Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Suspiciousmind20 · 09/11/2021 20:11

How much meat consumed in the UK is reared in the UK though?

Monsteres · 09/11/2021 20:04

@JassyRadlett amd@GaryLurcher19 here's what UK cattles the ones I know of are fed;
We hear so much in the media that “the rainforest is destroyed by people growing soy to feed cattle” and that the animals are fed food which is soya based and imported. Especially with COP26 being all over the news and allegations being thrown round that all cattle are fed soya.

We’d like to set the story straight. Like most UK farmers our animals live most of the year on grazing. This is mostly grass but also herbs and broadleaf plants which grow in the pasture.

We only give hard feed at certain times – over winter, pregnant and nursing cows and if course – the bulls get hard feed as they work hard.

We use a UK company called Manor Farm Feeds who are based near Oakham. We feed a basic finisher feed and most of the contents of this feed are supplied from within the UK with not a sniff of Soya

🌾 Barley – Local Farmers, generally customers within 30 miles

🌾 Wheatfeed – Flourmills mainly in the East Midlands and East Anglia

🍚 Sugar Beet – British Sugar Beet Factories, mainly Newark and Bury

🍺 Malt Nuts – Breweries, mainly Coors @ Burton-on-Trent and others in East Midlands and East Anglia

🌿 Cane Molasses – Sourced globally and delivered from Liverpool, mainly South Africa. This is often a byproduct of sugar manufacturing.

🌱 Rapemeal – From Oilseed Rape grown domestically, pelletised with additional ingredients in the Midlands.

The fats and oils, maize and sunflower extract are all present in the same pellet as the rapemeal and the vitimins and minerals are all sourced from @trownutritionGB in Ashbourne, Derbyshire.

Over winter, grass has very little nutritional value so the cattle are fed hay which is grass that has been cut, dried and baled in summer before being stored.

This is the truth of what UK farmers are feeding cattle - not necessarily what you read in the media.

LivesinLondon2000 · 09/11/2021 16:38

@Bythemillpond
Totally agree. I use the M3, M4 and M25 most regularly and large chunks seem to constantly have speed limits between 40 and 60mph. Rare to get an unrestricted section where you can do 70mph

Bythemillpond · 09/11/2021 14:54

But there are so many speed restrictions in place that to do a journey on a motorway without speed restrictions is the exception rather than the norm

Yesterday I got on M25 to signs of 30mph. It then went up and down between 40-60mph. I was about 45 minutes on the motorway and only the last 3-4 miles didn’t have a speed restriction.

Apparently there was an obstruction
Never did work out where the obstruction was. The only obstruction appeared to be the speed restrictions that changed randomly to catch people out.

Definitely not talking about dual carriageways.
I can’t remember the last time I did a journey where I got on the motorway and actually did 70mph all the way.

takenforgrantednana · 09/11/2021 03:10

@Bythemillpond

KayKayWat

I do drive dhs hatchback occasionally and I find it incredibly scary how close some lorries get to the back of these little cars

To be fair, 99% of lorries are restricted to 56mph so you may be driving too slow on the motorway if they're right up your bumper.

As they're prohibited from using the fast lane to overtake, a lorry up your arse is usually a hint to stop hogging the middle lane and pull over so they can get past

It isn’t just me. I have watched where small cars are being tailgated by huge lorries.
I go at the speed limit but when the speed limit is 30, 40 or 50 which seems to be most of the motorways I use then how are you supposed to get away or drive faster. Even if the limit is 70mph it is usually so busy that you haven’t space to start accelerating away.

@ Bythemillpond there are no "motorways" that you drive at 30,40 or 50 mph unless it has a speed restriction in place due to an accident or roadworks! i think you are mis using the term motorway when your talking about a dual carriageway.
Bythemillpond · 09/11/2021 00:43

KayKayWat

I do drive dhs hatchback occasionally and I find it incredibly scary how close some lorries get to the back of these little cars

To be fair, 99% of lorries are restricted to 56mph so you may be driving too slow on the motorway if they're right up your bumper.

As they're prohibited from using the fast lane to overtake, a lorry up your arse is usually a hint to stop hogging the middle lane and pull over so they can get past

It isn’t just me. I have watched where small cars are being tailgated by huge lorries.
I go at the speed limit but when the speed limit is 30, 40 or 50 which seems to be most of the motorways I use then how are you supposed to get away or drive faster. Even if the limit is 70mph it is usually so busy that you haven’t space to start accelerating away.

georgarina · 07/11/2021 22:47

And when they do know something is bad it's in a breezy 'oh I know it's terrible isn't it' way, in the way you'd say 'oh I know I really shouldn't eat this dessert.'

georgarina · 07/11/2021 22:46

I think a lot of people just don't think about it. I cringe at some of the habits of my friends and family - constantly buying disposable plastic toys, water bottles etc, driving everywhere, wasting resources - and I think they 1 don't know how bad these things are and 2 don't think about the environment in anything other than an abstract way. Educated people, but just totally out of sync with the climate and good habits.

Neveragain990 · 07/11/2021 22:10

I agree OP. Why do people drive massive gas guzzlers? They want to be ‘superior’.

KayKayWat · 07/11/2021 21:34

@Dojacatpaws

Kaykay, yeah lorries never go over that speed limit and never go in the fast lane
Unless they’re euro trucks they literally can’t go faster than that. You’ll almost never see lorries in the fast lane of a proper motorway.
Dojacatpaws · 07/11/2021 21:30

Kaykay, yeah lorries never go over that speed limit and never go in the fast lane

lljkk · 07/11/2021 21:26

I spend a lot of time in tiny villages & hamlets. Too small for a shop.

Fiat500s are quite popular in the wee villages; sensible choice when the roads are so narrow and we don't have too many hills to deal with.

KayKayWat · 07/11/2021 18:38

I do drive dhs hatchback occasionally and I find it incredibly scary how close some lorries get to the back of these little cars.

To be fair, 99% of lorries are restricted to 56mph so you may be driving too slow on the motorway if they're right up your bumper.

As they're prohibited from using the fast lane to overtake, a lorry up your arse is usually a hint to stop hogging the middle lane and pull over so they can get past.

julieca · 07/11/2021 18:30

@Suspiciousmind20

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-59157836

This is interesting. Very shocking graphs about the emissions the top richest 1% emit. I was also surprised by how little you need to earn to be in the top 1%. In pounds it’s around £127,000 I think. So it isn’t just the millionaires and billionaires (although their emissions are likely to be the highest).

The next highest emissions are in the group earning over £42,000 (top 10%). My memory isn’t great so so fact check but it’s around that) and translating dollars into £ I haven’t quoted the exact amount.

I know lots of people that would fall into those two categories but wouldn’t imagine that they would be in the top 1% or 10% richest people in the world.

The injustice that the richest 11% of the worlds population are causing most of the problem but those who have the least will be most effected is depressing.

Thanks for sharing that. I think a lot of well off people simply do not realise how rich they are on an international scale.
Mirw · 07/11/2021 18:23

YABU. As much as I don't understand why people who live in the town need any type of 4b4, since cars are not banned, it is their personal choice.

What I find annoying is couples with more than one child telling me that the way I live is not sustainable. Well, it is to me.

May be take your anger out on the USA, Qatar, China, India... Who are polluting at a great rate of knots and leave your fellow Brits alone as we are not the worst in the world.

Gagagardener · 07/11/2021 18:10

I noticed in Italy a about 3 years ago, when we were staying in a small hill town near Naples, that locals drove small cars that cd manoeuvre the narrow streets. What a clever idea that was, I often think, as I press myself into a hedge in a narrow country lane so as to make way for the much wider cars driven over here. Or try to get into my car when the owners of great bug

Suspiciousmind20 · 07/11/2021 18:03

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-59157836

This is interesting. Very shocking graphs about the emissions the top richest 1% emit. I was also surprised by how little you need to earn to be in the top 1%. In pounds it’s around £127,000 I think. So it isn’t just the millionaires and billionaires (although their emissions are likely to be the highest).

The next highest emissions are in the group earning over £42,000 (top 10%). My memory isn’t great so so fact check but it’s around that) and translating dollars into £ I haven’t quoted the exact amount.

I know lots of people that would fall into those two categories but wouldn’t imagine that they would be in the top 1% or 10% richest people in the world.

The injustice that the richest 11% of the worlds population are causing most of the problem but those who have the least will be most effected is depressing.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 07/11/2021 17:57

@Shade17

Living in Maine, where a huge number of personal vehicles are SUVs or large pickup trucks, I can confirm that they provide very little extra protection when hit by a truck.

In the UK there have been no fatalities in a Volvo XC90 so clearly there is something to be said for a safe SUV.

Ahh we should all get one then. I quite like them.
Suspiciousmind20 · 07/11/2021 17:53

CrankyFrankie

To quote someone else
The world doesn’t need a handful of people doing climate conscious perfectly; it needs millions of people doing it imperfectly.

I like this quote. We don’t all need to be vegan, wear hair shirts and live in mud huts powered by solar. We just all need to do what we can. Start with the bits that feel easiest.

TheFairyCaravan · 07/11/2021 17:36

@ColinTheKoala

Try being riddled with arthritis, having metal plates in your back and pelvis and see if you can get into a low down car and I think you’ll find you can’t

I don't but my mum does have metal in her back and she has a Honda Jazz which she is very happy with.

And most people who drive SUVs are not disabled and do not live rurally. They drive them as status symbols (and park them on pavements with the engine running).

Good for your mum. I take it she doesn’t have a mobility scooter to transport and neither does she have arthritis in almost every joint in her body?

Why can’t people accept we’re not all the same so we don’t have the same requirements?

Shade17 · 07/11/2021 16:09

Living in Maine, where a huge number of personal vehicles are SUVs or large pickup trucks, I can confirm that they provide very little extra protection when hit by a truck.

In the UK there have been no fatalities in a Volvo XC90 so clearly there is something to be said for a safe SUV.

UsedUpUsername · 07/11/2021 16:02

LOL it's not a paternalistic idea - it is a fact!

Lol no.

Emissions are driven by domestic needs—the construction industry emissions exceeds that of the export-led manufacturing sector, for example. IIRC foreign exports make up less than 15 percent of their total emissions.

So maybe stop thinking the UK has any levers to control what China does. Those days are long over!

Duchess379 · 07/11/2021 15:04

@Fizzbangwallop

I’m another one who drives an SUV due to using a mobility scooter or wheelchair due to disability (hi to *@TheFairyCaravan and @Duchess379* Smile ) Most normal cars can’t fit a mobility scooter. I’ve also found I can’t get in or out of most ‘standard’ cars in a safe way as they are too low down. Public transport isn’t an option as my local station doesn’t have step free access. My SUV is a hybrid which seems like a reasonable compromise.
😊👍🏼
ColinTheKoala · 07/11/2021 14:50

Try being riddled with arthritis, having metal plates in your back and pelvis and see if you can get into a low down car and I think you’ll find you can’t

I don't but my mum does have metal in her back and she has a Honda Jazz which she is very happy with.

And most people who drive SUVs are not disabled and do not live rurally. They drive them as status symbols (and park them on pavements with the engine running).

daffodils123 · 07/11/2021 14:20

@UsedUpUsername

Jassy

I’m pushing back on this paternalistic idea that Chinese emissions are based on Western demand, as if China would go back to its low-carbon, impoverished lifestyles absent this demand.

So the overall point is that carbon emissions are driven more by local needs rather than by manufactured goods bound for Western markets.

LOL it's not a paternalistic idea - it is a fact!