Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
gofg · 05/11/2021 02:37

Truthfully I don't really care. I can't have children so don't have the 'what about my kids' argument

Wow - beyond selfish! Just because you can't have children you don't care about anyone else's? I don't have children, but still worry about climate change - because it's not all about me.

Mummyrowland · 05/11/2021 02:25

Can I please point out that premium batteries need premium coke........ this is ONLY produced from oil refining!!!! Trust me I work in this field

Namechangedox · 05/11/2021 02:13

I have a city car we also have a saloon and a lotus Elise so not green , I travel long haul probably once or twice a year it's rainy here and I like to explore different countries and cultures. I crank the heating up high because I don't want to be cold. I recycle as much as I can, but I don't see why I should make loads of changes to my lifestyle when billionaires are jetting off into space on jaunts , have huge mansions and private jets!!

ArcheryAnnie · 05/11/2021 01:46

Truthfully I don't really care. I can't have children so don't have the 'what about my kids' argument

This is the logic of a sociopath. Other people have worth even when we don't have a direct genetic connection to them.

ArcheryAnnie · 05/11/2021 01:43

People always have excellent reasons and justifications for why they need all the things they have, and too many people are also addicted to convenience, and are useless at planning, which is why they are so helpless when they don't have access to a car, even for the shortest journeys.

I also think we are in a state of collective denial about just how awful our lives are going to be in a few years, as climate change destroys societies, increases migration and serious conflict, and reduces the food supply. With this state of denial, its easier to justify all the resources we waste, because we can't allow ourselves to really believe we will ever be presented with the bill for our environmental misdemeanours. (But we will get the bill, whether we like it or not.)

Devilrocknroller · 05/11/2021 01:32

Do you have any dogs OP? They're worse to own than most Range Rover SUVs, simply because of the meat they eat (and for the love of god please don't say yes I have a dog but it's vegetarian because that's just god awfully inhumane and cruel to an animal with a body and mind designed to eat meat)

Devilrocknroller · 05/11/2021 01:30

Most people also assume "massive SUVs" have large fuel gussling engines when that's not always the case (especially with the new cross over SUVs) but I just bought a 4 cylinder jeep - most people would assume as it looks like a "massive SUV" it's a fuel guzzler, when it isn't. Also, most electric cars are actually worse. The amount of earth drilling and shipping needed to make their batteries does massive damage to the environment. And hybrids often use more fuel to keep pace - going faster they use more fuel because they have to work harder

fournonblondes · 05/11/2021 00:31

I am glad for you OP. Wherever makes you happy but do not lecture others about it. People may have reasons for their choices or not. Shaming people that do not follow your lifestyle does not make you look like a very good person.

Rubyupbeat · 04/11/2021 23:03

My SUV is a hybrid, and very rarely nerd the petrol in it.
No it's not a status symbol, we have 2 large long haired, quite often muddy dogs that need room to travel comfortably.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 22:54

[quote DallasDerby]@daimbarsatemydogsbone no idea why you felt the need to defend the ‘baddies’ aka 4WDs then - but I’m sure they are glad of you understanding and support because you couldn’t possibly give a shot and be one of them.[/quote]
So anyone who drives an SUV automatically “doesn’t give a shit” is that your argument? Because if it is you have no argument at all. That’s just chanting.

uder12340865 · 04/11/2021 22:54

Truthfully I don't really care. I can't have children so don't have the 'what about my kids' argument. Plus those that do have children have a far worse carbon footprint than I do with my car. I could get an electric car but won't until they address the waste created by batteries that can't be disposed of.

Plus, to be frank, until countries like China sort their impact on the environment out, me swapping my pretty green SUV for an electric car will make very little difference

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 22:51

Plenty of people NOT in SUVs idle outside DS’ school. Is that ok because they aren’t in an SUV?!

RepentMotherfucker · 04/11/2021 22:51

@Pinkorchide

Bleepingtons For what it's worth, I'm vegan, drive an EV, don't fly, only buy secondhand etc but am not perfect. I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a Range Rover.

OP what about if your kids decide to drive a Range Rover when they’re free to make their own life choices?

Both of them.

And then they each have seven kids and they all get Range Rovers Grin

Like a kind of post apocalyptic 'As I was going to St Ives' in my SUV-

DallasDerby · 04/11/2021 22:50

@daimbarsatemydogsbone no idea why you felt the need to defend the ‘baddies’ aka 4WDs then - but I’m sure they are glad of you understanding and support because you couldn’t possibly give a shot and be one of them.

anon12345678901 · 04/11/2021 22:38

@WhoIsBernieBrown

This competitive environmentalism is so exhausting. What's the point in shaming someone because they drive an SUV? Everyone's circumstances are different - someone might drive an SUV but never fly. Someone else might have been vegan all their lives, but have more than 2 children. It should be a collective effort to learn and be better, rather than constantly shaming people for not being eco enough.
This.

People on here like to feel morally superior when in reality, they really aren't.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 22:34

[quote DallasDerby]@daimbarsatemydogsbone I don't give a shit what you do. I'm not your parent or your moral guardian - I expect you to own it - I expect you to attempt to be a responsible adult. You should give a shit what you do and you shouldn't justify your failure to do your very best by looking at your neighbours down the road who have emitted more carbon than you. Your off-spring will judge you (or maybe they won't give a shit either) they might be convinced by the argument that you did at least as well as your neighbours - will that make you proud? Don't answer I don't care...make your decisions and live with the consequences or rather let all our kids and their kids live with them.[/quote]
I really don’t know what you think you are talking about. I absolutely do “give a shit” about what I do and I haven’t said otherwise - you appear to have decided that on my behalf, and like everyone else on this thread who is only interested in making accusations about others and not having a debate, there’s no substance, logic or coherence to anything you say, just chanting nonsense.

Pinkorchide · 04/11/2021 22:31

Bleepingtons
For what it's worth, I'm vegan, drive an EV, don't fly, only buy secondhand etc but am not perfect. I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a Range Rover.

OP what about if your kids decide to drive a Range Rover when they’re free to make their own life choices?

DallasDerby · 04/11/2021 22:30

@daimbarsatemydogsbone I don't give a shit what you do. I'm not your parent or your moral guardian - I expect you to own it - I expect you to attempt to be a responsible adult. You should give a shit what you do and you shouldn't justify your failure to do your very best by looking at your neighbours down the road who have emitted more carbon than you. Your off-spring will judge you (or maybe they won't give a shit either) they might be convinced by the argument that you did at least as well as your neighbours - will that make you proud? Don't answer I don't care...make your decisions and live with the consequences or rather let all our kids and their kids live with them.

MsAdoraBelleDearheartVonLipwig · 04/11/2021 22:28

I’ve got a small SUV diesel because it’s a solid, safe car to do the fifty-odd miles a day school run across rural country roads. It’s a bit cheaper to tax because it’s got a newer, more efficient engine. I’ve had it for ages and when I bought it electric cars weren’t as much of an option. My previous car was a big petrol injection estate and cost twice as much to tax so must have been pumping out a lot more nasty emissions. My next car will be another SUV hopefully and I’ll try to buy electric if it’s feasible to do so.

Obviously not everyone can have an electric car because they have nowhere to charge at home. We’re lucky in that we have a huge driveway and garage so plenty of room to install power points. How people in cities in flats and terraced houses will get on I don’t know. They need the electric cars more than anyone, living in smoggy cities. There has been talk of self charging batteries but I don’t know if that’s a thing.

Pity the electric batteries rely on such heavily mined components. I don’t know if they’re recyclable either?

MurielSpriggs · 04/11/2021 22:24

I don't really think about it to be honest. It's certainly not the only thing I do which is both environmentally harmful and unnecessary.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 22:20

[quote DallasDerby]@daimbarsatemydogsbone why do you feel the need to justify yourself to me? I can't change you - no one can, you make your decisions, stop justifying them by suggesting you aren't the baddie = own your decisions, admit you don't give a shit - stop pretending by justifying your decisions and comparing yourself with others - it's just daft. We need to use less, we all do - it's not a debate, we all need to do our bit, some of us will do more than others - I'm not asking you to justify your decisions to me - you have your kids and your grandkids to convince on that score.[/quote]
Because it’s not a clear cut argument and you are apparently characterising me as someone who doesn’t give a shit which isn’t true. In my understanding, changing to a newer, smaller car (and getting rid of the caravan we could no longer use) may be no less damaging in terms of overall effect on the planet. As I said, it’s arguable that anything I have/do/use is selfish but it is much less clear how to qualify as “not selfish”. DD is 13 and enjoys Caravan holidays (I know!) - not sure if I should tell her we are evil planet destroyers and it’s got to stop. We aren’t fucking up the planet for fun, but I am struggling to see what I need to do to get my green badge that is actually greener.

JudgeJ · 04/11/2021 22:15

[quote elbea]@JudgeJ yes! It’s a 1950s Land Rover, still going strong.[/quote]
Wow, and I thought it was a typo! A looked after Land Rover is almost indestructible.

etulosba · 04/11/2021 22:15

Are electric cars so much better though?

Electric car footprint exposed: Volvo says emissions from making EVs can be 70% HIGHER than petrol models - but once they've done 70,000 miles they become greener

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/cars/article-10161697/Volvo-says-electric-car-making-emissions-70-HIGHER-petrol.html

DallasDerby · 04/11/2021 22:08

@daimbarsatemydogsbone why do you feel the need to justify yourself to me? I can't change you - no one can, you make your decisions, stop justifying them by suggesting you aren't the baddie = own your decisions, admit you don't give a shit - stop pretending by justifying your decisions and comparing yourself with others - it's just daft. We need to use less, we all do - it's not a debate, we all need to do our bit, some of us will do more than others - I'm not asking you to justify your decisions to me - you have your kids and your grandkids to convince on that score.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/11/2021 22:06

@VanGoghsDog

China only has factories spewing out emissions because they produce all the shit we buy. So it's actually our fault.
My giant SUV was made in England