Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
Gertrudetheadelie · 05/11/2021 07:37

@SnackSizeRaisin

Estates honestly weren't big enough on the cabin space for us because we tried (hoping it would be easier to park and not look so conspicuous!). I totally agree about the parking though and urban driving but it is difficult if you have made the choice to only have one car because you can't justify having a runaround as well. Ours is the smallest as and most economical SUV we could find but I am very conscious of not making life harder for other drivers and pedestrians so we walk everywhere within about 3 miles with my toddler in tow and I don't think I've parked anywhere but a designated bay!

SnackSizeRaisin · 05/11/2021 07:37

I am being totally honest. I don't care about it, I just find it yet another tiresome thing that people grab to make themselves look like good people. I really don't think about it ever and couldn't care less.

Fair enough at least you are honest!

SnackSizeRaisin · 05/11/2021 07:36

People who have had children are hypocrites though if they judge people for things that aren't environmentally friendly,

I really don't think that's a good argument. Fair enough bring red meat and long haul flights into it (still whataboutery though) but reproduction is a basic human behaviour. Society wouldn't function without children being added to it. You speak as though a personal choice not to have children is an excuse to do exactly what you want as, if it were up to you, there'd be no people in 100 years anyway. Have you thought about who is going to grow your food, deliver your shopping, provide your healthcare etc after retirement? Or do you just expect to die at 65? (If so who will bury you)

stereeotype · 05/11/2021 07:36

How do you feel about driving at all? About eating meat, about using your washing machine, about going on holiday, I guess that makes you just as guilty as us SUV drivers 🙄

Draggondragon · 05/11/2021 07:34

We have 2 and also a Camero. We fly a fair amount first or business only.

I am being totally honest. I don't care about it, I just find it yet another tiresome thing that people grab to make themselves look like good people. I really don't think about it ever and couldn't care less.

TheFairyCaravan · 05/11/2021 07:34

I’ve got an SUV because I need one.

Every single one of you who judges someone driving an SUV is an utter dick. Try getting a mobility scooter, or wheelchair, and hoist in a small hatchback and i think you’ll find it won’t fit. Try being riddled with arthritis, having metal plates in your back and pelvis and see if you can get into a low down car and I think you’ll find you can’t.

For some of us the choice of what we drive is very limited. We can’t just hop on public transport, get on a bike or walk to the shops. I’d much rather have a small electric hatchback than a life of severe pain and immobility if I had the option.

SnackSizeRaisin · 05/11/2021 07:31

SUVs aren't great for the environment but it's probably still better to have a 15 year old SUV that you rarely use instead of a more economical car used for every short journey or a brand new efficient cat every 3 years.

My main problem with SUVs is the safety (much worse if you hit a pedestrian or cyclist) and the fact that all these huge cars makes it more difficult to cross roads, they often need to be parked on pavements to avoid blocking the road, etc.

Fair enough if you own one for occasional use but people using them daily for school runs and urban driving (and there are an awful lot that do) really should think again. I am certain that almost all could manage perfectly well with an ordinary family car. SUVs often don't even have good cabin space. You need an estate for that.

anon12345678901 · 05/11/2021 07:30

@Chasingaftermidnight

Truthfully I don't really care. I can't have children so don't have the 'what about my kids' argument. Plus those that do have children have a far worse carbon footprint than I do with my car.

There have been quite a few of these types of comments in the thread - either ‘I don’t have kids so I don’t care’ or ‘I don’t have kids so I’ve done my bit’.

There’s an irony to it - [some] people who don’t have kids don’t care because they don’t see themselves as having a stake in the future and/or think they’ve already made their sacrifices, while [some] people with children care a lot but only because of their children’s welfare. And people who have had kids apparently (according to some on this thread) aren’t allowed to care about climate change because they’ve created new carbon generators so they’ll always be hypocrites.

(That said, some of the childfree people I know are also among the most committed environmentalists I know!)

People who have had children are hypocrites though if they judge people for things that aren't environmentally friendly, such as SUVs when they had me created an even bigger carbon footprint bringing in another person. If you weren't worried about the environment when you had your kid, don't act high and mighty around others due to their choices.
LivesinLondon2000 · 05/11/2021 07:25

@SisforSoppy
Yes totally agree - we need the Government to impose large taxes on things that aren’t environmentally friendly as that’s the only way to make most people change.

More and more people are switching to electric cars but we need to get away from this culture that new is best and the idea that changing your car every couple of years is a good thing.
Also manufacturers need to make cars that last - yes this will make them more expensive but there should be large taxes/restrictions imposed on using cheap materials that don’t wear well or can’t be repaired.

Re long haul flights when celebrities and other people of influence stop using private jets and making them seem glamorous and desirable - that would be a big help. I think many people feel a little disgruntled that they’re discouraged from a once yearly yearly holiday flying in economy class when people like the Beckhams, Clooneys etc fly here, there and everywhere on private jets. They should be banned quite frankly.

Isitsixoclockalready · 05/11/2021 07:23

What bugs me more really is the amount of people that I see sitting with their engines idling whilst waiting for people. That's not good - especially around schools.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 05/11/2021 07:11

Why do people buy Chelsea tractors?

Because they like them? There aren’t that many cars with 7 seats

GobletofFiyah · 05/11/2021 07:04

Well I have a Dacia duster because where we live gets snow a lot and it also rains a lot, if I don't have access to a car when it's snowing the children I work with won't be able to have chemo at home.

However my car is a 1.2 engine and very efficient.

Chasingaftermidnight · 05/11/2021 07:03

Truthfully I don't really care. I can't have children so don't have the 'what about my kids' argument. Plus those that do have children have a far worse carbon footprint than I do with my car.

There have been quite a few of these types of comments in the thread - either ‘I don’t have kids so I don’t care’ or ‘I don’t have kids so I’ve done my bit’.

There’s an irony to it - [some] people who don’t have kids don’t care because they don’t see themselves as having a stake in the future and/or think they’ve already made their sacrifices, while [some] people with children care a lot but only because of their children’s welfare. And people who have had kids apparently (according to some on this thread) aren’t allowed to care about climate change because they’ve created new carbon generators so they’ll always be hypocrites.

(That said, some of the childfree people I know are also among the most committed environmentalists I know!)

lljkk · 05/11/2021 06:56

My 79yo uncle has a very newly purchased electric SUV, mustang.
It's quite swish car. I was very impressed by the review (Youtube video).

He just doesn't need any sort of SUV to toodle around the streets of Santa Monica.

Mominatrix · 05/11/2021 06:34

You do know that there are hybrid and electric SUVs? In the early days of the technology, I had a hybrid SUV and I remember an ignorant woman who hit my car with her old estate car yelling at me regarding my "gas guzzler" and my chuckling at her ignorance. As soon as there was a good electric option, I switched to electric.

wingingit987 · 05/11/2021 06:14

I have a diesel suv we bought it as a family a car about 3 years ago. At the time we didn't even think of it although Now I would prefer to get a hybrid car rather than diesel next time.... I would change it now if someone would help me but one however there isn't lots of money in the bank so until I stop paying 85% of my wage on childcare and we stop scraping by I'm sticking with the bad for the environment suv.

DramaLlllama · 05/11/2021 06:07

I have an SUV, but it’s actually a small petite model. I actually do need one because where I live is very rural, remote and impossible to cross in a car when it snows. I live on a mountain for context

Just by some winter tyres for a ‘normal’ car. It will then happily go along on snow! You don’t need an SUV for winter conditions, just buy the right kind of tyres.

DramaLlllama · 05/11/2021 06:04

I agree. It’s consumerism at its worst. Change your car every 3 years. By a massive SUV that is big, takes lots of materials to make, is very heavy and therefore uses more fuel to lug around. All for ‘status’ and keeping up with the Jones.

I will continue to use my current small car until it is starts falling apart around me.

MaxNormal · 05/11/2021 05:37

Since we don't have children, about the worst thing you can do environmentally, I reckon we've done our bit.
Our diesel gets good mileage actually. It's the petrol Subaru that's the gas guzzler.

SisforSoppy · 05/11/2021 05:29

We have one. I like it. I’m not going to justify it. It’s like almost every other argument that could be had about living a greener life. Most people aren’t going to change until they are forced to, probably via tax. Nevermind electric cars, just introduce a rule that limits all new car engines to 1000cc, from now. Add a green tax to literally everything new. And I mean a serious tax (30-50%) that means that it pays to recycle/up cycle/mend and make do. Go to your local recycling centre and see what people throw out. Tax all bottled/canned/cartoned drinks (none of us need anything but water) and make refill taps compulsory everywhere. I could go on. Very few people are serious about making a measurable difference, and certainly no-one in any government.

GaryLurcher19 · 05/11/2021 05:29

Why do people buy Chelsea tractors? Quite apart from the environmental impact (manufacture is worse than running, so no, newer ones aren't somehow better) nearly none of these people can manoeuvre or park the bastards. They flail about and gesture apologetically to pedestrians and other drivers as they fail to adhere to the highway code, all because they bought a massively over-sized town car.

Unless you live in remote rural areas, you don't need these things. Even if you do, you have a proper landy, because - uncomfy as they may be - they're the only vehicles that reliably traverse rough terrain/icy conditions.

UsedUpUsername · 05/11/2021 04:10

@ArcheryAnnie

People always have excellent reasons and justifications for why they need all the things they have, and too many people are also addicted to convenience, and are useless at planning, which is why they are so helpless when they don't have access to a car, even for the shortest journeys.

I also think we are in a state of collective denial about just how awful our lives are going to be in a few years, as climate change destroys societies, increases migration and serious conflict, and reduces the food supply. With this state of denial, its easier to justify all the resources we waste, because we can't allow ourselves to really believe we will ever be presented with the bill for our environmental misdemeanours. (But we will get the bill, whether we like it or not.)

No we are in a state of collective denial about how good are lives are compared to literally any point in history; and how the comfort of our lives is due to the usage of fossil fuels.

Climate change is not going to ‘destroy our societies’ unless the moral panic over it leads us to dismantle our economies.

Rich countries are barely affected by natural disasters—flooding in China used to kill tens of thousands in the last century alone, now it kills hundreds.

You sound like those serious scientists of the 60s and 70s who predicted mass global famine that would kill untold millions starting in the 80s.

It never happened. It’s starting to sound like an apocalyptic cult frankly; with doomsday just around the corner and they’ve got the signs right this time!

Nat6999 · 05/11/2021 04:07

I have an SUV because I'm disabled & it suits my disabilities because it means I'm not at pavement level to struggle out & it has everything I need to allow me some independence.

beachtosunset · 05/11/2021 03:09

@Rummikub

US and China need to be on board otherwise we are fucked
yes and for most things really
DinosaurDuvet · 05/11/2021 02:39

I have an SUV, but it’s actually a small petite model. I actually do need one because where I live is very rural, remote and impossible to cross in a car when it snows. I live on a mountain for context