Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 05/11/2021 08:52

@Peanutbuttercupisyum

“We have 2 large engined petrol SUVs and an electric SUV. Of those vehicles the electric one is by far the least versatile. I try not to buy diesel vehicles where possible as a token effort to reduce particulate pollution.I use a non suv electric car as my daily drive.

We love to travel both long and short haul.

I never buy 'designer' labelled clothing.

I'm not in the least bit concerned about climate change. Part of that position comes from actually reading through these infernal climate change 'catastrophe' reports themselves and not the reporting on what they supposedly say.”

I have a massive distrust of the media but particularly the bbc when it comes to climate change...can you link me to the reports you’ve been reading please??

I have a massive distrust of the media but particularly the bbc when it comes to climate change...can you link me to the reports you’ve been reading please??

There is not really any point, the science on climate change has been settled for a decade or more, the BBC is a reliable source, as is the UN, the governments of nearly every Western economy, every university, NASA, etc. Even the Chinese agree that climate change is a major issue, they are just being slower about it than the West would like.

You have chosen to discount scientific evidence because it is convenient for you to be a denier (and/or you lack the capacity to understand it), regardless of any information we shared you would continue to deny it. To put that in perspective even Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping don't deny climate change, they just want to change on their terms not ours and they are hardly allies of the West.

anon12345678901 · 05/11/2021 08:52

@StevieNicksscarf

Christ so much bloody ableism on this thread.

"You would think no one was disabled before SUVs were invented."
Well yes they were but they probably couldn't get around so easily.

I have a larger diesel car than I would like- not even sure if it's classed as an SUV but having looked for electric or hybrid I couldn't find one that I could fit my mobility scooter in and that was affordable since the bastards at the DWP so kindly decided that I no longer qualified for motability and took away my car.

And no I can't get in and out of a Honda Jazz, and it doesn't fit my scooter in the back. HTH.

You don't need to justify this to anyone on this thread. I can bet they all do something that's bad for the environment.
TheFairyCaravan · 05/11/2021 08:51

you don't need an SUV because of mobility issues. For example, a Honda Jazz is easy to get in and out of and has great visibility when driving too. And very comfortable seats. But it doesn't have the status symbol factor...people think it's a granny car.

MIL has a Honda Jazz. It’s too low for me and because it’s so small the doors don’t open wide enough for me to get in and out independently. It would be impossible to get my mobility scooter or wheelchair in it either.

Gertrudetheadelie · 05/11/2021 08:51

I think part of the issue is that the car manufacturers now see the market for cars for people with mobility issues etc as fulfilled by the SUV selection so there's little financial incentive for them to offer alternatives. All I can say honestly is that we tried every different type of estate and a Honda jazz and a Ford BMaxx and Cmaxx (not worried about the keeping up with the Joneses aesthetic) and they weren't the right size and shape - I would have been elated if they were! I just hope that car manufacturers are incentivised to make better, lighter, more efficient, less resource wasteful versions of the existing SUVs for which there is clearly a wide market. I'm not sure I need a sensor, which uses precious raw materials, to tell me that I should check the back seats for a child, which is what they have in the new model fiestas.

I think even if ”most” people buy them for what you consider to be poor reasons, it isn't helpful to throw contempt at everyone assuming they are part of the ”most”.

StevieNicksscarf · 05/11/2021 08:49

Christ so much bloody ableism on this thread.

"You would think no one was disabled before SUVs were invented."
Well yes they were but they probably couldn't get around so easily.

I have a larger diesel car than I would like- not even sure if it's classed as an SUV but having looked for electric or hybrid I couldn't find one that I could fit my mobility scooter in and that was affordable since the bastards at the DWP so kindly decided that I no longer qualified for motability and took away my car.

And no I can't get in and out of a Honda Jazz, and it doesn't fit my scooter in the back. HTH.

MatildaIThink · 05/11/2021 08:47

@Bleepingtons

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

They don't square it, they just don't care, the same with the large, loud engine AMG Mercs, BMW M series cars etc. The same as people discount their own flying, or their large meat consumption, their multiple fashion purchases, the pointless tat they buy, the things they do not recycle because it is too much hassle to rinse something out etc., they do not need to mentally "square it", they just don't care.
ArcheryAnnie · 05/11/2021 08:46

Why should I live a little miserly life

Firstly, most people who don't own SUVs don't lead "miserly little lives", probably because they don't base their self worth on status symbols.

Secondly - why? Because your life, and everyone else's life, will get "miserly" and "little" when crops fail and resource wars kick in. Its basic self-preservation to push for change, and to embody it.

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 05/11/2021 08:46

“We have 2 large engined petrol SUVs and an electric SUV. Of those vehicles the electric one is by far the least versatile. I try not to buy diesel vehicles where possible as a token effort to reduce particulate pollution.I use a non suv electric car as my daily drive.

We love to travel both long and short haul.

I never buy 'designer' labelled clothing.

I'm not in the least bit concerned about climate change. Part of that position comes from actually reading through these infernal climate change 'catastrophe' reports themselves and not the reporting on what they supposedly say.”

I have a massive distrust of the media but particularly the bbc when it comes to climate change...can you link me to the reports you’ve been reading please??

4thtimethecharm · 05/11/2021 08:46

I am a bit confused about people saying “But what about the big corporations? Surely, they are the biggest culprits.”

These corporations only exist because they meet a demand for products that we, as society, provide. If we stop consuming their products (or lessen our consumption), it would be less of an issue.

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:43

You would think no one was ever disabled before SUVs were invented. In reality people have always bought some cars that are much easier to get in and out of.

VanGoghsDog · 05/11/2021 08:41

@GaryLurcher19

"I weep every time I see an avocado or bunch of asparagus in a trolley. 😭"

Why asparagus? Genuine question. Is it usually imported? Because it grows perfectly well in the UK. I've grown it for years.

Asparagus has a very short season, basically May/June. So if you're buying outside those months it's imported.
Often from outside Europe too.

Non UK asparagus isn't very nice anyway, so personally I only buy it in season from the UK, preferably locally at farms etc.

But I'm not sure why it's such a focus of climate issues, green beans always seem to be imported, and pineapples, etc

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:41

@ColinTheKoala yep agree you don't need an SUV in the country. I drove an ancient ford escort around fields, often carrying lambs. It was fine. SUVs are a status symbol, nothing more.

ColinTheKoala · 05/11/2021 08:41

So when you are hoisting your judgy knickers be aware there are many permutations as to why someone arrived at that decision

you don't need an SUV because of mobility issues. For example, a Honda Jazz is easy to get in and out of and has great visibility when driving too. And very comfortable seats. But it doesn't have the status symbol factor...people think it's a granny car.

Climate change is down to capitalism, posts about SUVs and long haul flights just perpetuate the idea that it’s down to the individual to prevent the incoming climate catastrophe

It's not just about climate change though, it's about local air pollution. And that's where individuals can make a difference.

userg5647 · 05/11/2021 08:41

So when you are hoisting your judgy knickers be aware there are many permutations as to why someone arrived at that decision

Na come on, most people get one because it's the done thing, I really don't think many people much thought into it until challenged and all of sudden it's their icy back road, safety etc etc. Not saying that's the case for you, but most.

Thatsthewaytis · 05/11/2021 08:39

@Bleepingtons are your children also vegan? Or do they eat meat and dairy? Do you source all their clothes and toys from the U.K. and ensure they are plastic free and sustainable produced - or are you buying plastic toys and clothes from China/Bangladesh - major contributors to climate change. What about your household goods? Where are they all purchased from?

I find posters like you zone in on things like ‘owning a SUV’ ignoring the massive contributions you’re making to climate change in your own life. It’s so hypocritical.

ColinTheKoala · 05/11/2021 08:39

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue

Not RTFT because I know there were be loads of posts from people saying they live rurally down a country track (we're not talking about you) and from people saying "but we need that size car to fit in all the car seats and the dog" (you don't, and we are talking about you).

Unless it's an electric SUV they pump out massive emissions (especially when parent is sat outside school waiting for offspring for 45 minutes before pick-up with the engine running Angry. But it's not just that, they also cause more congestion. As an example, if I come to the end of a road and want to turn left, if there's eg a Fiesta waiting to run right, I can squeeze past them and go. If it's a gas guzzling SUV, I can't. So they are emitting more pollution and causing other cars to, as well (admittedly I have a hybrid so it often cuts out the petrol engine when waiting at junctions).

Also take up too much room in car parks (which isn't an eco thing, but is still annoying).

If you can afford an SUV you can afford something like a hybrid Corolla. Or an electric car. When you next replace your car, please make one of those your status symbol, instead.

Summerfun54321 · 05/11/2021 08:34

Decades of consumerist propaganda has programmed us not to.

^ this 100%.

Gothisway · 05/11/2021 08:30

Can’t beat them so might as well join them I say.
Why should I live a little miserly life when there’s people out there contributing 100x more to climate change than I do and they won’t stop. I don’t have children which is the biggest contributor.

dresstokillmytime · 05/11/2021 08:28

@FinallyFluid

I damn near died six years ago, won't bore you with the back story but I was in bed for six months, my muscles wasted, I have some sort of normality now, but I can not get in and out of normal cars without being either very determined, or helped. I am 57 FFS Angry

We were due a car change anyway ( we run them into the ground and only replace when absolutely required) #green and bought a midrange SUV, we already have plans to buy another one (petrol) before this model disappears into a fug of hybrids.

So when you are hoisting your judgy knickers be aware there are many permutations as to why someone arrived at that decision.

Any reason why you don't want a hybrid?
Lucycantdance · 05/11/2021 08:23

FFS threads like this do my head in. Climate change is down to capitalism, posts about SUVs and long haul flights just perpetuate the idea that it’s down to the individual to prevent the incoming climate catastrophe. Look up the stats on who is responsible for the majority of global emissions then start posting about what major corporations and billionaires are going to do to prevent this crisis getting worse.

FinallyFluid · 05/11/2021 08:23

I damn near died six years ago, won't bore you with the back story but I was in bed for six months, my muscles wasted, I have some sort of normality now, but I can not get in and out of normal cars without being either very determined, or helped. I am 57 FFS Angry

We were due a car change anyway ( we run them into the ground and only replace when absolutely required) #green and bought a midrange SUV, we already have plans to buy another one (petrol) before this model disappears into a fug of hybrids.

So when you are hoisting your judgy knickers be aware there are many permutations as to why someone arrived at that decision.

ArcheryAnnie · 05/11/2021 08:21

I don't see why I should make loads of changes to my lifestyle when billionaires are jetting off into space on jaunts , have huge mansions and private jets!!

"I am not going to try and bail out this sinking lifeboat because that rich person sitting in the prow is busy pissing into the bilges." Yeah, well, I still don't want to drown, so while you sit there being petty, I'm still going to get busy with a bucket.

Honestly, the short-sightedness of some people on this thread is astonishing.

etulosba · 05/11/2021 08:18

The media could help by refusing to glamourise long haul flights, new cars, fast fashion, avocados 😂 etc and the Government need to impose taxes/restrictions on all of the above.

Taxing or restricting children might be a tad controversial.

Backtomyoldname · 05/11/2021 08:17

We have what some might consider a large car.

But it’s got a couple of beds in it, cooker, fridge, pull out toilet, lift up roof. It celebrates its 12th birthday soon. Not used that much in winter.

Despite its apparent size its smaller, lighter and uses less fuel than many SUVs available on the market today.

The growth in the size of some types of car is unjustifiable.

I’m sure there’s a connection between the size of car and the dourness on the face of the driver.

teenytinydoor · 05/11/2021 08:13

@julieca I was actually thinking of the farmers I live next to and the game shoot the other side! They've been here decades as a family and all have the dirtiest 4x4 going. Some cars admittedly look like they've driven straight out the 80's Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread