Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
ThePoisonousMushroom · 05/11/2021 09:34

@Seasonschange

I wish you needed an additional license to drive an SUV. So many people wouldn’t bother because it’s an extra step but those who needed it would. I wouldn’t want them gone entirely because obviously there are cases where they are needed. But our roads are just not built for them.

I drive a bit rurally. I have a small 1.2l car, it wouldn’t be safe to drive in deep snow or really bad ice or be suitable for people who tow things but day to day rural driving it’s absolutely fine. I once got caught out and drove through fast falling bad snow and seen two suvs in a ditch on my way , over confidence I assume. It’s so much better when a small car is behind me at night because their headlights aren’t directly beaming into my car. And on single tracks when you have an suv coming the other way they NEVER reverse , if they had a normal car there is so much more space to pass as well. Similar situation for cars parked on roads. The highest percentage of ownership of SUVs isn’t rural locations it’s wealthy urban areas.

Would your small car safely fit 3 children in car seats across the back? Thats why a drive a large SUV.
Seasonschange · 05/11/2021 09:32

I wish you needed an additional license to drive an SUV. So many people wouldn’t bother because it’s an extra step but those who needed it would. I wouldn’t want them gone entirely because obviously there are cases where they are needed. But our roads are just not built for them.

I drive a bit rurally. I have a small 1.2l car, it wouldn’t be safe to drive in deep snow or really bad ice or be suitable for people who tow things but day to day rural driving it’s absolutely fine. I once got caught out and drove through fast falling bad snow and seen two suvs in a ditch on my way , over confidence I assume. It’s so much better when a small car is behind me at night because their headlights aren’t directly beaming into my car. And on single tracks when you have an suv coming the other way they NEVER reverse , if they had a normal car there is so much more space to pass as well. Similar situation for cars parked on roads. The highest percentage of ownership of SUVs isn’t rural locations it’s wealthy urban areas.

EvilPea · 05/11/2021 09:32

which fit my 3 young children in car seats

This and the better driver visibility is the reason they’ve become so popular.

EvilPea · 05/11/2021 09:30

Most SUV’s are or were built on shared platforms. So the under pinnings, size, engine etc are the same as a normal hatchback or estate. E.g x5 was a 5 series with nicked Land Rover technology for the 4wd, the q3 an A3 (which you could get as 4wd). Very few were proper designed from the ground up SUVs. Even the earlier evoques were 2wd transit engined cars.

The newer ones are ground up designed as our preference for them has changed and they don’t bother with the hatch or estate version. But the likes of a juke, t-cross are essentially the hatchback or estate of the past.

I do draw the line at the Q8, that’s so fucking wide and pointless for our roads.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 05/11/2021 09:30

Oh yeah and we bought ours when we were told Diesel was better for the environment. We will run it to the ground, which I’m sure is better than buying a new one when it’s not needed.

PoppityPop · 05/11/2021 09:27

@Bleepingtons
You haven’t answered how you define a massive SUV. I have an SUV, Vauxhall, and it’s a 1.0 litre engine. My best mate has a 2.0 litre Golf - how much small car but with a bigger engine. The size of the car can be misleading.

talkaboutgoady · 05/11/2021 09:27

Focus your energy on governments and corporations rather than judging individuals for purchasing items that you personally have decided are evil. You're not the judge and jury - if items are for sale then we can buy them, based on our own needs and priorities.

Many of us driving older diesel SUVs will be doing so because we were told diesel was BETTER for the environment. Too late now if that's not right, we've got cars worth less than £5k so not able to replace with a new eco friendly model, and since they're still running so why would we replace?

ThePoisonousMushroom · 05/11/2021 09:27

My choice of car was based on what I could afford and which fit my 3 young children in car seats across the back. That’s all there is to it.
I’ll buy an electric car when they’re more affordable and there are more charging points available. I live in the sticks and our nearest public charging point is about 8 miles away.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/11/2021 09:25

Towing our caravan with a Jazz or hybrid Corolla would be interesting (unsafe and illegal). Do we have to scrap the caravan and the SUV?

CatsArePeople · 05/11/2021 09:25

only buy secondhand

this i always find funny.
Second hand market only exists because there is a steady supply and demand of brand new.

RonSwansonsHair · 05/11/2021 09:22

Kind of a bit like if I started a thread titled "how do parents of children square it with themselves in regards to climate change?" because I didn't have any DC but later on in the thread you found out I drive around in a range rover and go on long haul flights regularly.

Mantlemoose · 05/11/2021 09:21

I don't feel the need to square it with anyone. I have a swb suv and when it dies and is no longer fixable I'm buying a lwb which is even bigger! If I was to attempt to square it with anyone I would probably offset the fact that a) I'll drive it into the ground which is much better than leasing it replacing just because it's old b) I didn't have children because they're a very large drain on the world c) I recycle everything I can d) I compost everything I can e) I grow bird/bee/butterfly friendly garden f) I make lard cakes for the birds to supplement winter feeds g) I have a garden pond for lots of lovely frogs and the like h) I have water saving devices in my cistern i) I water my garden with rain wate j) I have never gone on a long haul holiday k) I buy at local shops l) I buy british wherever I can m) I grow basic staple veg items like potatoes, carrots and onions n) shower instead of bath o) leave beach and woods as I find them and don't remove shells/pebbles/pinecones to take home etc. Can't think of anything else but I'm sure you get the drift. What I would say is I don't do any of these out of any interest in climate change I do them because I want to.

I'll be sure to wave at you all watering your grass via the garden tap after cutting it at the same time on a sunday morning every week in the summer whilst wearing your boden outfit whilst hubby and 2.4 kids wash and polish the electric car sitting outside your new build with 60 year build span when I'm passing in my SUV and again in my new to me bigger SUV.

julieca · 05/11/2021 09:15

@StevieNicksscarf PIp reviews are stressful and shit.
Maybe others cant, but I can see just in the way people walk how agile and easy it is for them to move. I can see when my DP is experiencing pain when walking, although he doesn't say so, just because he walks less carefreely. I see others walking easily with a kind of a hop in their step, you don't do that if you are in pain.

RonSwansonsHair · 05/11/2021 09:14

I am not absolving myself but I'm positing the theory that having children is a slightly bigger decision than driving a range rover.

Of course it's a bigger decision. But if you're starting a thread berating people for their choices with regards to the environment then obviously people are going to bring it up. It's a bigger decision, but its also worse for the environment.

And I have read your arguments, or justifications, which is exactly what other people are doing about their choices.

I don't go on long haul flights, I don't drive an SUV, but I'm not vegan, and I'm a bit hit and miss with my recycling, however I only have one child so can I be sanctimonious now or?

StevieNicksscarf · 05/11/2021 09:12

Yes @julieca - but that is my point. Someone may appear "agile" but at what cost. I don't want to get into an argument and I think that the people with disabilities who have SUVs are probably in the minority and that as pps have said, many owners probably don't know or care about the environmental impact.

Also in my defence, I'm in a foul mood this morning as had a telephone review with DWP for my PIP yesterday which is always stress inducing and has made me angry and anxious in equal measure so I apologise if I came on a bit strong.

Bleepingtons · 05/11/2021 09:10

@RonSwansonsHair

Ooo another "you're all terrible for X Y or Z, yes I chose to have two children which is also pretty rotten for the environment but that's okay because it's ME".
I wish you'd read my arguments properly because I really like your username.

I am not absolving myself but I'm positing the theory that having children is a slightly bigger decision than driving a range rover.

Also - it's a specious argument to say oh you have kids so there's no way you can be environmentally conscious or give a shit or have an opinion which may have some merit to it.

OP posts:
EmmaGrundyForPM · 05/11/2021 09:07

If you can afford an SUV you can afford something like a hybrid Corolla.

What a ridiculous comment. My 14 year old SUV is probably worth £1500 tops. I'm intending to keep it until it dies, in which case it will be worth nothing. I couldn't possibly afford an electric SUV. I could swap my SUV for an old hatchback I guess, but as we live in a lane which often floods, that would compromise is. And it would still mean my SUV was on the road, just being driven by someone else.

Bleepingtons · 05/11/2021 09:07

@Pinkorchide

Bleepingtons For what it's worth, I'm vegan, drive an EV, don't fly, only buy secondhand etc but am not perfect. I DO have 2 kids which us obviously a shit decision in terms of carbon output but I'm not sure I'd equate that with driving a Range Rover.

OP what about if your kids decide to drive a Range Rover when they’re free to make their own life choices?

I honestly think by the time they're adults, they'll be astonished and appalled by the decisions we made and lifestyles we led. Mine included.

But if they grow up to drive SUVs then so be it, provided they can actually drive them...

OP posts:
RonSwansonsHair · 05/11/2021 09:05

Ooo another "you're all terrible for X Y or Z, yes I chose to have two children which is also pretty rotten for the environment but that's okay because it's ME".

julieca · 05/11/2021 09:04

@StevieNicksscarf the way people move when they get out of a car and walk somewhere.

Pain or fatigue cant be seen. Basic agility can be.
I am disabled you know. In the same way you can tell in photo adverts when an able-bodied model is sitting in a wheelchair as opposed to someone disabled.

4thtimethecharm · 05/11/2021 09:03

@FinallyFluid

I damn near died six years ago, won't bore you with the back story but I was in bed for six months, my muscles wasted, I have some sort of normality now, but I can not get in and out of normal cars without being either very determined, or helped. I am 57 FFS Angry

We were due a car change anyway ( we run them into the ground and only replace when absolutely required) #green and bought a midrange SUV, we already have plans to buy another one (petrol) before this model disappears into a fug of hybrids.

So when you are hoisting your judgy knickers be aware there are many permutations as to why someone arrived at that decision.

I appreciate that in cases like yours it is necessary. I don’t think anyone would begrudge you a car that allows you to maintain mobility.

I live in a 1980s housing estate, where in the past 5 years everyone (but us) has upgraded to at least 1 SUV per family. There is less space for on-road parking as the car sizes have increased. Passing on the high street has gotten more difficult, etc.

With the change in cars the attitude has changed. They treat me and my tiny 15-yr old run-around appallingly, taking right of way when it isn’t theirs. It 100% has become a “must-have” here.

StevieNicksscarf · 05/11/2021 09:01

How do you know they are agile? Do people with disabilities who are driving have a special "look" Hmm. Most people wouldn't judge me as having a disability as witnessed by some of the looks I get when I pull into a blue badge space. You have no idea how much pain or fatigue people are experiencing when they get in and out of a car. In theory I can just about get in and out of DH's car, with help. In reality it causes me significant discomfort and pain.

julieca · 05/11/2021 08:57

@Newgirls

On a positive note - car sales are down. Elec car sales tho are up.

Meat sales are down. Fast fashion sales are down. People are aware of the issues and changes are possible.

I think people bought suvs years ago and didn’t really know the issues. Will it be your next purchase? Will you replace your car so often? If you own a car can you use it less? Lift share? Cycle? Steps we can all take.

People cant get the new cars to buy. Some cars a year old are selling for more than new cars as a result.
julieca · 05/11/2021 08:56

@StevieNicksscarf yes people transporting mobility scooters need a larger car. But plenty of people are saying they need a SUV because they cant easily get into a normal car, when there have always been acrs that are easier to get into. Nothing to do with disablism. I used to transport my gran in her nineties in an ordinary car that was favoured by older people at the time as easier to get into.
When my FIL could not get into a car any longer he needed a minibus with a wheelchair lift. An SUV wasn't going to do it.
The people who actually need a much bigger car is a tiny group of people. Most people I see driving SUVs are much more agile than I am.

Newgirls · 05/11/2021 08:54

On a positive note - car sales are down. Elec car sales tho are up.

Meat sales are down. Fast fashion sales are down. People are aware of the issues and changes are possible.

I think people bought suvs years ago and didn’t really know the issues. Will it be your next purchase? Will you replace your car so often? If you own a car can you use it less? Lift share? Cycle? Steps we can all take.