Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
verymiddleaged · 05/11/2021 13:23

SUV's do have a higher center of gravity, which makes them more likely to roll.
DH's car is more stable with it much lower center of gravity.
But when we get lots of snow his car just gets grounded and my suv doesn't.
The snow setting doesn't give my SUV magical powers anymore than the increases ground clearance does but driven sensibly I can get myself out of more situations than DH can in his much lower slung car.

The same applies with the significant amounts of standing water we had recently.

I don't think SUV's are the only cars you can drive in bad weather, other cars have different advantages as has been pointed out.
I don't think that they are a green choice.
But they can be a practical and helpful choice for the person driving them.
( although DH's car is much more luxurious than mine which is just a fairly basic Ford)

The OP's question was why to do people drive these cars with mental equanimity and I was giving her my answer.

Moulesvinrouge1 · 05/11/2021 13:13

@Watchingyou2sleezes

We have 2 large engined petrol SUVs and an electric SUV. Of those vehicles the electric one is by far the least versatile. I try not to buy diesel vehicles where possible as a token effort to reduce particulate pollution.I use a non suv electric car as my daily drive.

We love to travel both long and short haul.

I never buy 'designer' labelled clothing.

I'm not in the least bit concerned about climate change. Part of that position comes from actually reading through these infernal climate change 'catastrophe' reports themselves and not the reporting on what they supposedly say.

Are we reading the same reports?! I read scientific peer reviewed reports on the likely outcomes of climate change, and they are terrifying. Can you please link to the reports that paint a rosy picture?
julieca · 05/11/2021 13:09

SUVs are worse for snow and mud than cars with a lower centre of gravity. Yes they are more comfortable, most luxury things with higher carbon footprints are. But you are more likely to lose control in an SUV than a car lower to the ground.

Blinkingbatshit · 05/11/2021 13:06

Oooo, late to the party but I’ll bite too😆. We have 2 suvs - 1 large, 1 medium. We live rurally and I do 30k miles a year - a lot with a good few children in tow. The safety, comfort and ability to get through snow & the odd flood, road covered by mud etc is too important to me currently to swap. When there’s a capable off road safe electric car I’ll get one. On the flip side I fly rarely (last trip short haul 8 years ago), planted 60 new trees last year, the kids & I wear a lot of hand me down clothes, we avoid single use plastic and we don’t use chemicals on our land. What measure are you going to use to see if that makes you better or worse than me?!

WakeUpLockie · 05/11/2021 13:04

We have a diesel (not SUV) because it had the best eco rating of all the cars we looked at and could afford.

Overall, climate change needs to be tackled by countries and corporations. I as an individual and a tiny insignificant dot. We ummed and ahhed for 3 years about going for longed-for baby 3, because of climate reasons, and am very happily and guiltlessly now pregnant. My third kid won’t cause the end of the world and we have an aging population. So you have to look at things overall.

bordermidgebite · 05/11/2021 13:03

Helpful: reduce your footprint , act as a role model , push government and business for real change

Unhelpful : pointing fingers , playing blame game, refusing to take action unless someone else goes first

WeevilStepmother · 05/11/2021 13:00

I have a looooong commute. Bought a bigger car for comfort after driving last one til it dropped, and it's a diesel for fuel economy because I spend a fortune getting to work. There is no public transport alternative for me.

The commute allows me to earn more than I could locally (not to mention do a far more interesting job!), a wage which will hopefully soon enable me to afford an Electric Car with an acceptable range... but my workplace needs to install charging points too.

So I'm working towards a more climate friendly option but I don't beat myself up daily in the mean time, I'm afraid.

julieca · 05/11/2021 12:54

@bordermidgebite

Having an suv does not mean that person automatically has a higher carbon footprint than you

Instead of criticism and buck passing look at your own footprint , put your own house in order and then talk about in in such a way as people see your life style as aspirational rather than sanctimonious

No not automatic. But everyone I has ever known with an SUV has a higher than average carbon footprint. Because generally it means they have money. So more flights, more consumption and bigger houses than average. Sometimes a holiday home too.
bordermidgebite · 05/11/2021 12:52

Having an suv does not mean that person automatically has a higher carbon footprint than you

Instead of criticism and buck passing look at your own footprint , put your own house in order and then talk about in in such a way as people see your life style as aspirational rather than sanctimonious

liliainterfrutices · 05/11/2021 12:50

@Cocomarine

I think for a lot of people (me included, though I don’t have an SUV!) it comes down to, “it’s only one plastic bottle… said 10 million people.”

I’m intelligent, I am aware, and I care. But despite that, honestly the scale isn’t compelling. I look at my one thing (my many one things: the steak, the diesel car, the not turning back for my water bottle) and know I’m part of the problem - but don’t really feel that it makes that much difference.

Not sure if I’ll get my arse handed to me for that! I’m certainly not arguing that I’m right, just trying to give insight. I think it’s maybe 90% that I don’t really FEEL the urgency and impact of my one thing in the moment, and 10% that I’m selfish and want it anyway.

To be clear: I might be making 95% good choices. I’m not saying I’m a walking (driving?!) environmental disaster! But in my 5% of bad choices - it’s the 90% don’t feel it, 10% selfish moment.

Yes - this is me, pretty much. I think about the climate every day, and do make an effort, but probably not as much as I should. I drive - but am only one in my household who does, so that's one car between 4. I have cut down enormously on meat (but so still eat it sometimes, and I sometimes eat prawns, which apparently are terrible environmentally), don't buy many clothes at all (that's mostly because I hate my appearance and am a bit phobic though) and I am v frugal about heating (but bought a house with an oil tank).
julieca · 05/11/2021 12:44

@FanFckingTastic maybe you missed my point that I have repeated that I was not saying to buy a ford escort. There are plenty of tough cars around that can tow. Most people towing caravans in the past had ordinary cars with the power to do this.
And its easy to say everyone is to blame when it is the richest with the biggest carbon footprint.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 05/11/2021 12:42

I do just fine in Maine in a Kia Rio with snow tyres.

verymiddleaged · 05/11/2021 12:41

DH has a decent all wheel car, when we get either snow or flooding he needs the ground clearance of my SUV to get about. ( We aren't in the UK so get both of these a fair bit)

That said I drive the size up from a discovery SUV through choice and would consider downsizing to a discovery to be greener.

Berkeys · 05/11/2021 12:39

You’ll regret your YABUs when there’s no more wine left - or it costs £500 a bottle!
www.theguardian.com/food/2021/nov/05/warning-over-extremely-low-wine-production-in-europe-due-to-bad-weather

FanFckingTastic · 05/11/2021 12:33

julieca Fri 05-Nov-21 12:04:00
@FanFckingTastic I wish people would just own that they want one. My family live in the countryside have been farmers and labourers. We have driven around fields with lambs in the back of an old ford escort and even the odd sheep. A decent car is perfectly capable of doing what a SUV does in unmade tracks. Cars with a lower sense of gravity are less likely to skid so safer. The only advantage of a SUV is that you are less likely to damage the exhaust.
People don't need SUVs. They are choosing to have one.

Maybe you missed the part where I said I need my SUV to tow? I don't believe that the ford escort that you describe above would be able to do this safely so would not be an option in my situation. As I also said, I would love to have something else but there are many factors that don't make that possible, so I do what I can elsewhere. If it would make you feel better then I'm happy to 'own' my decision to drive one.

As a previous poster said, it's not one group of people that are to blame, we could all do more.

Amberflames · 05/11/2021 12:25

Making sure electric cars aren’t “disposable”. If after 5 years the batteries are fucked and you need a new one

As far as I know we are yet to find a solution as to how the batteries will be recycled.

BubbleCoffee · 05/11/2021 12:19

No point pinning it down on one group of people, we are all to blame. Everyone is a little bit of a hypocrite when it comes to going green

Hear hear.

julieca · 05/11/2021 12:17

@daimbarsatemydogsbone And I was not saying you needed a ford escort. I was saying a car can do everything you said you need an SUV for. You prefer an SUV, That is all.

julieca · 05/11/2021 12:16

@daimbarsatemydogsbone no you use a tractor to tow a trailer full of sheep.

groundcontroltomontydon · 05/11/2021 12:13

What do you consider to be a “massive SUV”?
They all seem massive when they're parked on the pavement and you're having to walk into the oncoming traffic to get round the bastard things.
Three things that people here aspire to: a plastic lawn, a hot tub and a white Discovery. No wonder the environment's screwed.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/11/2021 12:09

[quote julieca]@FanFckingTastic I wish people would just own that they want one. My family live in the countryside have been farmers and labourers. We have driven around fields with lambs in the back of an old ford escort and even the odd sheep. A decent car is perfectly capable of doing what a SUV does in unmade tracks. Cars with a lower sense of gravity are less likely to skid so safer. The only advantage of a SUV is that you are less likely to damage the exhaust.
People don't need SUVs. They are choosing to have one.[/quote]
I can't tow our caravan with an Escort - and I bet you can't tow a trailer full of sheep with one either.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/11/2021 12:08

My father used to tow a (smallish) caravan and managed without a SUV as they weren't around in the early 90s. However, I don't know the rules or laws around towing because I'd never do it. Camping isn't my thing!

And when I referred to a Honda Jazz it was in response to the claim that you needed an SUV for mobility issues. It wasn't about towing a caravan and it is very silly to take comments out of context.

It's not the first time I've been called very silly - are you usually so patronising?

My point was not everyone is going to be able to get by with Jazz or a Corolla hybrid - that's not "out of context". The context here is blind hatred for people who drive an SUV, without any consideration of the practical issues.

julieca · 05/11/2021 12:04

@FanFckingTastic I wish people would just own that they want one. My family live in the countryside have been farmers and labourers. We have driven around fields with lambs in the back of an old ford escort and even the odd sheep. A decent car is perfectly capable of doing what a SUV does in unmade tracks. Cars with a lower sense of gravity are less likely to skid so safer. The only advantage of a SUV is that you are less likely to damage the exhaust.
People don't need SUVs. They are choosing to have one.

EvilPea · 05/11/2021 11:51

@Newgirls

Wrapping food in plastic IS bad. It’s used to prolong the life of foods that are usually out of season and have been transported. Cucumbers for example shouldn’t be sold in Nov.
They wrap them all year round though.

What I’m trying to say about all these green initiatives It’s not cut and dried though, it helps protect food and prolong it meaning we need less resources to produce it, transport it and dispose of it, which is a good thing. The plastic is obviously not the good part, nor is air freighting any fruit and veg.

We need to find better ways like corn starch wrapping.
Making sure electric cars aren’t “disposable”. If after 5 years the batteries are fucked and you need a new one

Arguably, bigger picture and production resources would say that’s no better either

FanFckingTastic · 05/11/2021 11:51

Driver of a 'massive SUV' here. Car was bought (second hand, when Diesel was supposedly the better option) so that we could fit kids and animals in safely, drive across all terrain and because we need it to tow. It spends a lot of time going through fields / down un-made roads etc and is generally covered in mud. It's most definitely not a status symbol, it's a work-horse. Of course I'm aware that there are issues with these kind of cars and climate change, but until there is a better solution at a price that I can actually afford I don't particularly have much of a choice. So to answer your question OP, I square it with myself by doing what I can in other areas. It's very easy to pick on certain groups of people - evil SUV drivers, avacodo eaters, folk that go on holiday etc. but in reality the problem is bigger and far more complex unfortunately.

Swipe left for the next trending thread