Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
woodhill · 05/11/2021 15:43

@thelegohooverer

I think if people focused their righteous anger at the multi billion dollar industries behind those consumer choices, instead of at individuals we might affect real change.

But instead environmentalism is the new religion, and like all religions the purpose is to feel sanctimonious and look down on others.

In fact, the rhetoric of this new religion is as worrying as Isis, the Spanish Inquisition and witch hunting. We’re constantly hearing about over population which undermines the sanctity of life and is a short step from promoting genocide in some form.

Fair point
mewkins · 05/11/2021 15:43

People have them because they can. Until big charges are imposed on them they will continue. I don't get it either. It is partly a status thing I guess.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 05/11/2021 15:43

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

Who on this thread has no SUV but 2 cars?!
That's a very specific question. We have a pickup truck and 2 cars. Should we be summarily executed? :-)

The pickup is not used regularly - it's just an old spare we have for managing the acre of woodland we have, doing dump runs, home construction, etc. My neighbour borrows it pretty regularly. It probably does about 2000 miles per year.

The 2 cars are shared by 5 drivers.

julieca · 05/11/2021 15:36

So in the UK the move from pigs kept in fields to being kept inside is awful and should be banned.

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 15:34

[quote Monsteres]@JassyRadlett, no I am aware of pork and chicken, but unfortunately until people go for higher welfare meat not much can be done, intensive farming was brought in after WW1 to stop people from starving to death and it unfortunately had a purpose then. The UK is far ahead of other countries when it comes to Agricultural emissions. And I think that until countries like the USA and China change their way of doing things what we do here in the UK is just a drop in the ocean[/quote]
Totally disagree with you there. There is lots that can be done - perhaps not by individual consumers but the supply chains absolutely can and must get deforestation and conversion out of their supply chains. We need to be honest about the true footprint of UK agriculture, including feed imports.

And honestly, we’re all probably going to need to reduce the amount of animal products we consume, regardless of where they come from. Part of that will be due to more expensive meat because the most carbon-heavy production (often the cheapest) is removed - such as the £5 chicken that is 90% Cerrado soy.

This should actually be a relative benefit to systems like the U.K. where much of the meat we produce is lower in emissions than the meat we import, but those emissions are still problematic even if they’re lower than other places. But ultimately there is a lot of land globally dedicated to growing protein for animals; the emissions reduction (including LUC) of that land instead growing protein or other crops for humans rather than animals is really significant.

For the UK, it’s 10% of our production emissions. We do need to sort out our own sector, no matter how much we feel others are worse.

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/11/2021 15:29

And I think that until countries like the USA and China change their way of doing things what we do here in the UK is just a drop in the ocean.

I’m sure this has already been pointed out earlier on the thread, but the problem with focusing on China as the greatest producer of emissions is that one of the reasons for that is because they make so much of the stuff the entire world wants to buy. So people in the UK (and other wealthy countries) changing our ways of doing things would be more than a drop in the ocean in reducing emissions, overall.

Monsteres · 05/11/2021 15:23

@JassyRadlett, no I am aware of pork and chicken, but unfortunately until people go for higher welfare meat not much can be done, intensive farming was brought in after WW1 to stop people from starving to death and it unfortunately had a purpose then. The UK is far ahead of other countries when it comes to Agricultural emissions. And I think that until countries like the USA and China change their way of doing things what we do here in the UK is just a drop in the ocean

Rummikub · 05/11/2021 15:14

[quote julieca]@Rummikub in Britain we are ditching traditional farming and moving to larger-scale intensive farming that absolutely is a problem. And the government is encouraging this by giving older farmers big payoffs to retire.[/quote]
Yeah that’s not good.
In terms of scale though (amount of land) it’s still USA cattle farms that are bigger problem

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 15:11

@ExConstance

I have just bought a medium sized petrol SUV, changing up from what most people would regard as a city car. I got the new car because I want to go camping, take the (large) dog with us and transport our bikes. The new car is petrol, it has the same sized engine as the old baby car and returns better fuel economy. Lot of the medium sized cars now have small turbo charged engines with better performance and enhanced fuel economy. I don't think I have anything to concern myself about.
I mean people will still call you anyway because they’ve decided they hate all SUV drivers and they’re short on critical thinking skills and the ability to look at evidence.

Something tells me they’re not bitching anywhere near as much about a bloke in an Audi A8, of the person driving the high-mode Ford Focus Estate which has higher emissions than the Kuga.

ExConstance · 05/11/2021 15:03

I have just bought a medium sized petrol SUV, changing up from what most people would regard as a city car. I got the new car because I want to go camping, take the (large) dog with us and transport our bikes. The new car is petrol, it has the same sized engine as the old baby car and returns better fuel economy. Lot of the medium sized cars now have small turbo charged engines with better performance and enhanced fuel economy. I don't think I have anything to concern myself about.

ChrissyPlummer · 05/11/2021 14:59

It’s like @CokeZeroAddiction said. We went to Hong Kong a couple of years ago. Every day in the hotel, new glasses wrapped in new plastic, new plastic toothbrush wrapped in plastic, plastic bottles of water (didn’t see any refilling places for reusables) from shops, new disposable razors wrapped in plastic. I went to a shop that sold items of a character that I collect; everything and I mean everything I bought (and it was a lot) even things like pens/key rings/small figurines was individually wrapped in plastic then put in a shopping bag!

I don’t even have a “massive SUV” but we were two people in one hotel room in one place for a week. The amount of single use plastic multiplied across the whole region must be astronomical, the car I drive will make not a jot of difference.

halloweenqwueeeen · 05/11/2021 14:56

I think it’s safer in a big car and would fare a lot better if I was in a crash in my SUV than the mini I used to drive. I need my DD to be as safe as possible.

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 14:50

@JassyRadlett the majority of soy used for animal feed is the waste product as I've said earlier only 30% of soy is able to be used for human consumption the other 70% is waste, so it's used as a feed for animals.

That’s probably nearly correct for UK-grown soy but it’s flat out untrue globally - human food demand is nowhere near the demand for soy for animal feed.

I don’t disagree with you on agriculture overall though I don’t think you’re being quite honest about some of the challenges - UK agriculture is far from being a net good currently and the NFU net zero plans are too over reliant on future technology for my tastes; I think the CCC pathway here is about right.

Also massively in favour of ELM payments being solely for farming and land management for environmental good.

However both the pro- and anti-farming lobby focus way too much on ruminants in all of this. Understandable as they’re the ‘easy’ emissions to quantify, but the reality is that in the UK we eat more chicken overall now than any other meat, and the true carbon footprint of chicken production is not shown in the UK GHG inventory as much is foreign deforestation and conversion. Pig meat is another major issue when it comes to soy.

Ruminants are not the only meat!

MatildaIThink · 05/11/2021 14:43

@julieca

Yes burning wood is worse than gas or oil for heating. Sorry didn't realise you transported it a long way. We cut it down in our wood and transported it a few miles.
That depends on what wood. If you have your own woodland grow, cut, season and burn your own on a cycle then burning wood is carbon neutral, although does contribute to particulate pollution. Gas and oil are both net CO2 contributors, oil more than gas. Gas burns cleaner and does not add to particulates, oil tends to contain an element of sulphur which it adds to the atmosphere, although for home oil that should be very low.
JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 14:43

The majority of cattle feed is waste products that are either inedible for people

Huge amounts globally are grown specifically for animal feed - it’s a huge market. And a lot if grown by destroying forests.

Almost all our soy imports (both meal and bean) are used for animal feed; the majority comes from South America (which will increase with Brexit as EU soy will be less affordable.)

Those deforestation emissions aren’t captured in our agricultural footprint but they arguably should be as a key part of British agriculture.

Monsteres · 05/11/2021 14:43

@JassyRadlett the majority of soy used for animal feed is the waste product as I've said earlier only 30% of soy is able to be used for human consumption the other 70% is waste, so it's used as a feed for animals. Same as a lot of other waste products from food production including beer, confectionery, and the obvious fruit and veg that's supermarkets deem to be 'imperfect' all that waste gets used for animal feed,.what would happen if they weren't there to ' tidy' that up? Arable farming waste is your oat milk that you drink instead of dairy has the waste product of straw which is used for animal bedding. Agriculture is working on lowering they're emissions more but until people realise that agriculture is being used as the scapegoat here so that travel and fossil fuel companies can just plant some trees instead of actually changing anything they do nothing will change!

HappyWinter · 05/11/2021 14:42

Here are the bigger impacts on carbon footprints, it's interesting that recycling is pretty low on the list. Having children is very high. It's too late for many of us on that count Grin. I do try but I'm definitely not perfect. I have a diesel car, it is rarely used and would probably be worse for the environment to replace it with an electric one unless it dies. I'm trying to focus on the biggest savings (drive less, fly less, renewable energy supplier, eat less meat and dairy, buy less stuff) rather than things like zero waste which take up all your time and don't make as much difference.

Having one fewer child - 58.6 tonnes of CO2 saved
Not having a car - 2.4 tonnes of CO2 saved
Avoiding one long-distance flight (6 hours+) - 1.6 tonnes of CO2 saved
Buying energy from renewable sources only - 1.5 tonnes of CO2 saved
Eating a plant based diet - 0.8 tonnes of CO2 saved
Recycling as much as possible - 0.2 tonnes of CO2 saved
Not using a tumble dryer - 0.2 tonnes of CO2 saved
Replacing traditional lightbulbs with low energy or LED - 0.1 tonnes of CO2 saved

There's a survey on the PDF link below where most people get the rankings on the highest carbon emitters in lifestyle wrong, recycling is seen as being very important and having children is way down the list.

Article: www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/05/climate-action-change-behaviour-impact-survey/

PDF with the above statistics and interesting survey results: www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/news/documents/2021-04/Environmental%20Perils%20of%20Perception%202021_0.pdf

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/11/2021 14:40

@Blinkingbatshit

If burning wood is so bad why have the govt been incentivising people to fit biomass boilers (fed by wood pellets that get shipped from as far away as South America!) for the past 15years ish?! Burning wood for heat is only a major pollution issue if you live in a built up area - if you live rurally and are using locally sourced wood then you’re doing fine.
I’ve no idea what the current view on biomass is because I bought my boiler in 2011 and scientific consensus may have changed since. But back then it was considered environmentally friendly because the very low-moisture wood fuel is burned under very high heat and pressure to release its gas, and then it’s the gas that is burned to create the actual heat for central heating and hot water. A well functioning biomass boiler doesn’t create very much smoke or particulate at all. But open fires and log stoves, particularly when people burn “locally sourced” wood which they don’t season properly (hardwood for biomass typically has to be seasoned for at least three years to be below the required 15% moisture), are awful for air pollution.
LimitIsUp · 05/11/2021 14:37

@thefamous5

I have a large diesel car.

I have four kids; I needed a car to fit them in.

I couldn't do electric car even if I could afford one because we wouldn't have the facilities to charge it.

We only ever holiday in U.K.

What facilities do you imagine you need for charging an electric vehicle? You just need to get an EV charging point fitted which is possible as long as you have your own driveway
Monsteres · 05/11/2021 14:32

@GaryLurcher19 wrong I'm afraid only 30% of soy is actually used for human consumption so that 70% of waste is what is fed to the cows. The majority of cattle feed is waste products that are either inedible for people or supermarkets deem not up to standard or wonky veg. Maybe you should try talking to people who work with cattle rather then reading a one sided view all the time?

JassyRadlett · 05/11/2021 14:31

@Rummikub

It’s not British farming that’s the big issue. It’s the cattle ranches in USA. Intensive farming.
That’s (a bit) true for ruminants, but the third largest agricultural sector in England is poultry; it’s hard to say they’re not farmed intensively - or often fed on environmentally catastrophic commodities, as are pigs. Nearly 900g of every kilo of chicken produced is soy feed.

Agriculture is 10% of our domestic emissions; if we’re worried about aviation and shipping we should also be looking at how to cut emissions from ag and use agricultural land as carbon sinks.

Blinkingbatshit · 05/11/2021 14:31

And for those on their high horse why don’t you try to stop buying or consuming anything that contains palm oil - do that for a month and I’ll give you some respect for your ‘green’ credentials!

LimitIsUp · 05/11/2021 14:30

I've ordered an Audi E-tron, a fully electric SUV, so my choice of vehicle is probably more environmentally sound than 95% of posters in this thread. Hth

Monsteres · 05/11/2021 14:29

@juliaca what do you think will happen to all that land that uses to be used for farming when they all retire? It won't be turned into a nature reserve they'll build on it, love to see what the carbon footprint of that is?! I would ask yourself why a load of high up people in government and business who hold shares In development companies by the way, want all food production to be shipped in from abroad, I can guarantee you that, that won't lower.carbon emissions it will lost definitely increase them and heaven forbid there ends up being another world war and as an island imports and exports get cut off, wonder what you'll all do for food then?.......

Blinkingbatshit · 05/11/2021 14:29

If burning wood is so bad why have the govt been incentivising people to fit biomass boilers (fed by wood pellets that get shipped from as far away as South America!) for the past 15years ish?! Burning wood for heat is only a major pollution issue if you live in a built up area - if you live rurally and are using locally sourced wood then you’re doing fine.