Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how drivers of massive SUVs square it with themselves in terms of climate change?

735 replies

Bleepingtons · 04/11/2021 16:27

Same goes for those who go long haul on the regular? Buy loads of cheap, disposable fashion? Etc etc? Do you just not worry about climate change?

I know I sound sanctimonious but I am genuinely baffled by people driving massive diesel SUVs like there isn't a major issue.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
peaceanddove · 10/11/2021 18:11

@TizerorFizz

Research assumes we all eat meat fed on plant based food from forest areas. That’s not the case for everyone in the uk. It’s all about making individual choices and lots of the people who lecture make dubious choices in other ways. Just look at Meghan and Harry and using private jets. Plus every other lecturing celeb or Royalty!

Same goes for cars. I can use a variety of cars. One is used mostly on electric because it’s for short journeys. I can afford this car and if makes me “green” and certainly I hardly use any petrol! However I’ve 3 other cars that are not so green. However I also have air source heat pumps. So big tick for the heat pumps but black mark for our old Merc sports car! So everyone can do something but continuous virtue signalling and calling people out won’t help. Most households do a mix!

Quite. I might drive a monster, gas guzzling Range Rover Sport. However, I rarely eat red meat but when I do buy it it is organic, and locally reared and slaughtered. I rarely drink alcohol, probably once a month at most. And I reckon that 90% of my clothes are sourced from Vinted or eBay Smile
Newgirls · 10/11/2021 17:26

Agree royals and politicians flying around is appalling. Let’s be better than that

Newgirls · 10/11/2021 17:25

We have a climate crisis so looks like we do need to call people out. We could all do better - whether it’s travel, food, clothes etc

If people on here with SUVs make a difference choice next time, use it less, car share etc then that’s worthwhile.

If people choose more veggie meals each week that adds up.

If people make their own sandwich rather than buying one in a packet, it adds up.

60 million of us eating fewer animals and driving less would be massive

TizerorFizz · 10/11/2021 17:19

Research assumes we all eat meat fed on plant based food from forest areas. That’s not the case for everyone in the uk. It’s all about making individual choices and lots of the people who lecture make dubious choices in other ways. Just look at Meghan and Harry and using private jets. Plus every other lecturing celeb or Royalty!

Same goes for cars. I can use a variety of cars. One is used mostly on electric because it’s for short journeys. I can afford this car and if makes me “green” and certainly I hardly use any petrol! However I’ve 3 other cars that are not so green. However I also have air source heat pumps. So big tick for the heat pumps but black mark for our old Merc sports car! So everyone can do something but continuous virtue signalling and calling people out won’t help. Most households do a mix!

Newgirls · 10/11/2021 17:16

British meat is being transported to mainland Europe at the moment due to lack of workers so the eco argument doesn’t hold at the moment. Refrigerated lorries there and back etc

Newgirls · 10/11/2021 16:56

[quote TizerorFizz]@Newgirls
Oh yes I do agree. Eating British meat isn’t a solution. But it’s better than importing. It’s also expensive and I get that too! However we should embrace British farming and nit keep saying all meat is bad. It’s not. If all vegetarians grew their own veg it would help![/quote]
If meat eaters grew their own veg too surely?

I don’t get this anti vegan thing. All the research shows plant based is better for the planet. And I say that as someone who isn’t vegan! Almond milk etc gets a bad PR but it is not in the same league as factory chicken from the UK and all the feed, antibiotics,
processing and transport that goes into that. That is sold with a British flag on it and it is an awful ‘product’ used in chicken shops, burgers, sandwiches, nuggets, dippers etc

I’d eat tofu over cheap chicken any day!

Ariela · 10/11/2021 16:37

@JennyDune

My current mild hybrid suv does 35-38 mpg in real life, my car 10 years ago, an old small Polo did 30 mpg.
That's not actually very good for a hybrid unless you live in a very hilly area. I drive our Shogun and aim for 27mpg (urban) & 33 mpg (motorway), it's not hybrid just plain LWB diesel! Admittedly towing I have to aim for anything over 20mpg depending what's being towed. I suggest adapt your driving for economy.
TizerorFizz · 10/11/2021 16:12

@Newgirls
Oh yes I do agree. Eating British meat isn’t a solution. But it’s better than importing. It’s also expensive and I get that too! However we should embrace British farming and nit keep saying all meat is bad. It’s not. If all vegetarians grew their own veg it would help!

Theline · 10/11/2021 16:09

I guess that very few people chose the ideal option environmentally in absolutely everything - look at the whole lifestyle before judging too much...

I have a large diesel SUV - use it mainly weekend walks and camping and occasionally as the second car when it is needed. We are considering getting a twin axle caravan.

DH works from home.
I work within walking distance of work, although sometimes I take the small car.
Our other car is a small electric car - this is the car that we take out most of the time
We rarely fly (last time for me was 10 yrs ago I think) or travel further away than 2 hrs by car and will take the train if that is convenient.
We live within easy walking distance of the town centre and usually walk there
We have one child (that won't change)
We don't eat much meat or dairy products - I rarely do and DH has cut down a lot.
We aren't massively into clothes and wear the same capsule wardrobe until it wears out usually.

Newgirls · 10/11/2021 15:53

[quote TizerorFizz]@Bythemillpond
I think you will now find that, with the growth of vegan/vegetarian diets, there is a great deal of land being cleared for these crops.Land is not solely cleared for beef feed. Palm oil bring one such crop but there are others.

It’s much easier to buy British reared meat than it is to buy British grown and harvested vegan food. However price is a determining factor for poorer families. But vegetarians and vegans don’t get a free pass on this.[/quote]
It’s too easy to say ‘buy British meat’. There are 60 million in the UK. We import half of our food inc meat and meat eg prawns, cod, chorizo, tuna and loads of other things we don’t have here. It’s far too easy to blame vegans when that is a vanishingly small amount of the food products sold.

The Uk eats vast quantities of animal protein compared to tofu, soy bean and quorn.

The National Food Strategy has done the research into this and compared water usage, feed etc and pulses and plants still comes out far more eco than meat (as it takes so long to grow, feed etc)

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 10/11/2021 13:06

We drive a fairly big SUV purely because we own a large twin axle touring caravan that we use for hlidays. We take the caravan over to France or Spain by ferry and tow it all over the UK. So no flights for us but we do need a decent tow car to haul the caravan.

TizerorFizz · 10/11/2021 13:01

Yes. Raising animals takes farmers, butchers and all the people in between. I want to see British farming go from strength to strength. I don’t want to see farm animals die out.

Lots of converts to being vegan don’t give a XXXX where their food is grown. Especially recent “converts” who virtue signal but still fly all over the globe! Most don’t grow their own food and rely on mass produced products from factories where lots of the raw ingredients are flown in from abroad. It’s utterly hypocritical.

Quite a few people who can afford a new Range Rover can also afford an electric run around. Large cars also are not environment friendly if they are old diesels. Modern diesels are very different, and SUVs in the EU6 category are pretty good when compared to an older diesel small car. However if it’s war on people with bigger cars, that’s completely different but some are electric or hybrid. The truth is that richer people will covert to electric first! They can afford it!

Bythemillpond · 10/11/2021 10:46

TizerorFizz

But would a committed vegan actually eat the type of processed food palm oil was in. A lot of the stuff palm oil is used in isn’t vegan anyway.

Whether it is British meat or meat that has been imported it all involves raising an animal and that takes an awful lot of resources.

Even animals that would normally rely on grazing get fed extra by the farmer.

Mintine · 10/11/2021 10:29

I totally agree with you, I wouldn’t drive one, but nor am I perfect.
I rarely fly either, but I do eat meat.
But as far as I’m aware, the farming in the UK is sustainable, if cattle are fed on grass, it actually helps to keep carbon captured in the earth.
It’s when cattle are fed on other types of feed that you get the problems, environment wise.

TizerorFizz · 10/11/2021 10:25

@Bythemillpond
I think you will now find that, with the growth of vegan/vegetarian diets, there is a great deal of land being cleared for these crops.Land is not solely cleared for beef feed. Palm oil bring one such crop but there are others.

It’s much easier to buy British reared meat than it is to buy British grown and harvested vegan food. However price is a determining factor for poorer families. But vegetarians and vegans don’t get a free pass on this.

Bythemillpond · 10/11/2021 10:13

TizerorFizz

How many people eat vegetarian and vegan ingredients grown here? It’s nearly all imported. Lots of forests being felled to grow it

I think you will find the majority of food grown on these sites is for animal feed that will end up on the plate of meat eaters.

HarrietsChariot · 10/11/2021 09:59

The truth is that no individual's actions make a difference to climate change. I could live perfectly and everyone else could pollute to their heart's content, the world would be fucked. Everyone else could be perfect and I keep a coal fire burning 24/7 and my hobby is revving my diesel SUV whilst stationary, the world will be fine.

People know that alone they can't make a difference. It doesn't matter that they do what they want, combatting climate change relies on everyone else doing the right thing.

Also, people tend to target the behaviours others do but they don't. It's easy to complain about SUV drivers and people who fly around the world when you don't drive and haven't left the country in fifteen years. But the same people have other problematic behaviours, be it buying Chinese products, using Netflix or drinking almond milk, all of which cause climate change too. (China because they use so much coal, streaming services because they use an inordinate amount of energy for the data centres to keep them going, and almond milk because of how much water is wasted.)

Newgirls · 10/11/2021 09:48

@TizerorFizz

How many people eat vegetarian and vegan ingredients grown here? It’s nearly all imported. Lots of forests being felled to grow it!

Until China and the USA get emissions under control, little uk is pissing in the wind. I have an electric suv, heat pumps and I’ve not flown for 2 years. Is that ok? Copt26 and people who like lecturing,such as M&H, use private jets when they feel like it. Which is quite often. Let’s cull them for a start! The jets and the people who use them!

50% of uk food is imported. Meat eaters buy imported food too - bananas, chocolate, coffee, tea, rice… list goes on!
JennyDune · 10/11/2021 01:28

My current mild hybrid suv does 35-38 mpg in real life, my car 10 years ago, an old small Polo did 30 mpg.

TizerorFizz · 10/11/2021 00:37

How many people eat vegetarian and vegan ingredients grown here? It’s nearly all imported. Lots of forests being felled to grow it!

Until China and the USA get emissions under control, little uk is pissing in the wind. I have an electric suv, heat pumps and I’ve not flown for 2 years. Is that ok? Copt26 and people who like lecturing,such as M&H, use private jets when they feel like it. Which is quite often. Let’s cull them for a start! The jets and the people who use them!

Figmentofmyimagination · 09/11/2021 23:52

This is interesting.
www.bbc.co.uk/food/articles/carbon_cost_food

KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 20:58

I'd imagine fat people are also bad for the environment as they over consume.

JassyRadlett · 09/11/2021 20:30

(For the record - I come from a cattle farming family. I’m also not going on anything I’ve ‘read in the media’. Figures I’ve quoted are from primary sources, some from the NFU, others from Defra, others from independent research.

JassyRadlett · 09/11/2021 20:28

I mean, I did very specifically say that ruminants are not the only meat, and that lowering consumption to more expensively reared, lower-carbon meat would probably benefit UK producer over cheaper imports that are more intensively farmed.

That said, not all beef farming systems are as local as yours and more intensive systems in particular use imports. We import billions of pounds worth of feed every year.

I will reiterate however what I’ve already said about chickens and pork.

It’s a weird misdirection that when we talk about the footprint of the ag sector it always gets diverted to ruminants only fed on locally grown feeds and reared on land unsuitable for crops?

We import lots of meat, mostly reared less sustainably than here. We also feed vast quantities of foreign-grown soy to chickens and pigs (and some cattle and sheep.)

Still hard to argue that the land used to grow the feed for those cattle couldn’t feed a lot more humans than the beef does. I’m not anti-cattle farming personally but we need to be honest that eating meat does have a greater footprint than eating plants.

But I’ll shout it again: ruminants are not the only meat. Why suggest that I focused on cattle by singling me out here, when I was very clear in pointing out that chicken and pork are the two biggest issues for soy - and we consume more chicken than anything else.

Chicken chicken chicken. Why do we never talk about chicken?

KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 20:16

Another thing that makes lorries seem so close is the sheer size of them and the way they look over you. Even if no closer than most cars they will often seem closer.