Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU To keep back half of my son's PIP payment?

231 replies

Whiskyinajar · 04/11/2021 14:55

DS is 18 and autistic, he attends a college for people with learning disabilities and needs a lot of support both there and at home with anxiety, interpreting life and his emotions etc.

At 16 we had to apply for PIP which he was awarded but with me as the responsible person for using it in his best interests,

Now PIP has been really helpful for him, when he has need of counselling etc we can pay for it privately to help him. We put it towards seam free socks etc and the rest of it bar £150 goes in the pot towards household bills.

I'm interpreting the "in his best interests" part as keeping me at home so that if he has a crisis (not infrequently) I can get to him and help. The issues he has mean it isn't easy for me to take on work alth9ugh we have tried.

Initially I transferred a very small amount a month to him as pocket money etc . When he hit 18 he wanted to get a mobile phone which is okay as hisnold one was falling apart and very old. He didn't go for anything fancy and pays £15 a month .

Then he started asking about having more of his PIP money and I agreed to give him £150 a month but told him he needed to budget for his phone out of that. A phone is pretty necessary for him so I thought it would be an easy thing to budget for.

However he's not managing this and every month I end up putting the money over for his phone the day before it comes out. Because he's autistic I don't want him having phone issues so the bill has to be paid.

Financially it's a struggle every single month because we rely on a mix of UC and also what my husband earns form his job. This was severely affected in lockdown but is gradually recovering,

So to the current issue. DS is (I know) feeling resentful that I don't hand over all the PIP payment to him . We've spoken openly about it but he still wants more than the £150 I give him.

DS has no real interests apart from gaming as he finds socialising very difficult. A SW has said to me that it's okay for him to spend the PIP on gaming as that's how he socialises and I get this but it doesn't feel right

He's just been to me and asked again if he can have all his PIP.
It went into my account two days ago and I gave him the usual £150.

He asked about the rest and I pointed out I'd had to put petrol in the car, pay towards a trip for college and buy him some new clothes he needed. I have £45 left until Carers Allowance goes in (about 10 days time).

In the meantime that £45 will be petrol costs and anything he needs for college, husband will deal with food bills.

DS is so resentful though .

I've got the offer of a job at £10 hr from January...it's just 10 hrs a week but will make us better off and I can work from home . This means he could have all his PIP money then but I also know he won't manage it.

Don't know what to do tbh.

SW suggested I transfer all the PIP to him and let him cope with the mistakes he makes. I know absolutely he will blow it all within a few days on gaming and I'm not comfortable about that...even if it is his way of socialising.

Should I continue digging my heels in . I have already said that PIP is not really to be used for gaming.

OP posts:
hatgirl · 04/11/2021 21:09

I'm a social worker who works with people with autism and learning disabilities.

This is a common conundrum faced by families and one unfortunately that does end up as a financial abuse 'safeguarding concern' far more often than it should because families haven't been supported very well through this transition stage.

Not saying this is you OP but we regularly have to deal with issues where someone decides at e.g. age 25 -30 that they want to move out of the family home and try supported living with their mates from college/day services/ football but the parents can't afford for their PIP etc to be taken out of the family pot and are actively mum supportive of the move for mostly financial reasons.

There's a balance to be had here, if it was me coming into your family home and advising you I would be saying yes, the money is his now he's an adult, but he absolutely needs to be understanding that he needs to contribute or a problem with sitting down with him on his 'pay day' and asking for his contribution to the household / phone etc first before he gets to do what he likes with the rest.

That's what would happen if he was in supported living and that's what you can do at home.

Do whatever you can to get to a point where if he's ready to move on for the family home in the next few years that it's a wonderful milestone for him and not something that's going to cause you significant financial hardship.

Ultimately though if he turns round and demands the whole lot there's not much you can legally/morally do as his DWP appointee to stop him unless you have a capacity assessment showing he is incapacitated and a subsequent successful deputyship application at the court of protection,

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 21:08

@Bonsaibreaker

Do you think child benefit and UC will cover her being out of work plus her son's counselling, college trips, petrol, clothes, shoes, food, phone bill etc?

The OP has already said she pays for his phone, petrol, college, counselling and clothing from his PIP. She doesn't use UC for that. She keeps the UC she gets for him for the household and uses the majority of his PIP payment for the household too.

I am in noway saying this is easy but what I am saying is that the OP is so reliant on the majority of his PIP paying for the household its not right or sustainable.

Yes. But if she gives him all of his PIP to do with what he wants like people (and a SW) are suggesting then what? Who is paying for all that if he doesn't?
Bonsaibreaker · 04/11/2021 21:00

Do you think child benefit and UC will cover her being out of work plus her son's counselling, college trips, petrol, clothes, shoes, food, phone bill etc?

The OP has already said she pays for his phone, petrol, college, counselling and clothing from his PIP. She doesn't use UC for that. She keeps the UC she gets for him for the household and uses the majority of his PIP payment for the household too.

I am in noway saying this is easy but what I am saying is that the OP is so reliant on the majority of his PIP paying for the household its not right or sustainable.

Bonsaibreaker · 04/11/2021 20:55

Because CN, child element of UC and caters allowance does not equal a wage.

If DS is her only child OP recieves

£80 pm CB
£289 pm child element
£128 pm mimium disability premium but this could be as much as £402.
That's £500 ball park basic
Plus £268 CA ( this is painfully inadequate I know it sickens me)
So that's £750 just in the child element.
Then they will have the couples element
£509 pm

Then housing element if any.

The family will not be ben capped but will be subject to the work allowance/taper but they still have DHs wages on top of any UC award.

While I agree living off UC is far from easy infact it's virtually impossible relying on the majority of their sons PIP payment is not sustainable either.

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:54

@Bonsaibreaker

If the OP was disabled and unable to work would you think it was ok for her husband to struggle to pay for everything himself so she could keep her £800 a month PIP to herself to spend on Candy Crush?

The OP unless her husband earned a decent amount would be entitled to claim UC for living costs. The OP is already reciving living costs for her son via child benefit and UC child element.

Nobody is pretending benefits are great and pay enough but it sounds like the OP is taking the majority of her sons disability payment while still claiming other benefits she also keeps.

She says her son doesn't socialise so spends it all on gaming. Maybe hire a support worker/companion for a few hours a week to support him to do activities outside of the home?
I used to manage a service that provided this so it is possible.

I dont think the OP I'd being abusive but I do think as a parents they need to stop being financially reliant on their disabled sons PIP.

Do you think child benefit and UC will cover her being out of work plus her son's counselling, college trips, petrol, clothes, shoes, food, phone bill etc? Because who do you think will have to pay for all that when he blows it all on gaming because "it's his money".
alreadytaken · 04/11/2021 20:47

Give him all his pip but tell him he has to pay rent as he wants to be an adult. Sit him down and go through what he would have to pay to live independently and then take some money from him that is less than that.

itsgettingwierd · 04/11/2021 20:45

@Bonsaibreaker

*It is a good idea helping him for the future. You aren't holding it back you're managing it by saving for him.*

Emerald the OP isn't saving anything for his future. She is giving him £150 pm £15 of which is for his phone, then the the rest of his PIP money is for petrol and some clothes the rest goes in the family pot.
The OP is already receiving CB and child element of UC plus disability premium as part of her UC award so why does his PIP have to go in the household pot too?
I could understand if she was saving for his future but she's not.

Because CN, child element of UC and caters allowance does not equal a wage.

If you can't work because you are caring for someone disabled then the pip helps cover this.

I agree with above poster that some people have no idea.

I'm flabbagasted people think PIP should be used for gaming and not for petrol, phone and clothing etc.

Bonsaibreaker · 04/11/2021 20:43

If the OP was disabled and unable to work would you think it was ok for her husband to struggle to pay for everything himself so she could keep her £800 a month PIP to herself to spend on Candy Crush?

The OP unless her husband earned a decent amount would be entitled to claim UC for living costs. The OP is already reciving living costs for her son via child benefit and UC child element.

Nobody is pretending benefits are great and pay enough but it sounds like the OP is taking the majority of her sons disability payment while still claiming other benefits she also keeps.

She says her son doesn't socialise so spends it all on gaming. Maybe hire a support worker/companion for a few hours a week to support him to do activities outside of the home?
I used to manage a service that provided this so it is possible.

I dont think the OP I'd being abusive but I do think as a parents they need to stop being financially reliant on their disabled sons PIP.

Clymene · 04/11/2021 20:41

Things my child's DLA pays for:
Super fast broadband
Petrol because he can't take public transport
Clothes because he will only wear very expensive socks and ruins quite a lot of things through chewing/tearing at them
Specific kinds of branded foods
Cables and chargers because they get broken monthly
Furniture which he breaks

Off the top of my head.

OP - I think you'd be better off posting in SN children. AIBU is full of twats who have no idea about raising disabled children

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:34

If the OP was disabled and unable to work would you think it was ok for her husband to struggle to pay for everything himself so she could keep her £800 a month PIP to herself to spend on Candy Crush?

Viviennemary · 04/11/2021 20:34

Id say the PIP is for your sons extra expenses not as a general top up for household income.

Bonsaibreaker · 04/11/2021 20:32

It is a good idea helping him for the future.
You aren't holding it back you're managing it by saving for him.

Emerald the OP isn't saving anything for his future. She is giving him £150 pm £15 of which is for his phone, then the the rest of his PIP money is for petrol and some clothes the rest goes in the family pot.
The OP is already receiving CB and child element of UC plus disability premium as part of her UC award so why does his PIP have to go in the household pot too?
I could understand if she was saving for his future but she's not.

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:29

Because if he wasn't there the OP would be able to work and contribute towards the mortgage. Him being there and not contributing likely means they would struggle to pay the mortgage. 3 adults (1 with additional needs) supported by 1 income.

jamiejamiejamie · 04/11/2021 20:27

My DS17 is autistic and gets £625 a month Pip I am his appointee he is very vulnerable to financial abuse from others in his peer group trying to get him to buy alcohol and cigarettes he would be fleeced alive if he had this amount. We've just reached an agreement I pay his season ticket each month, college trips etc, a set amount for lunches and spending money when it's gone it's gone. I'm going to pay him weekly. I am also putting £200 aside per month for him to buy a car in due course. It's funny they don't become responsible/able to deal with finances just because they're over sixteen. I'm hoping this works it is a very difficult time.

Clementineapples · 04/11/2021 20:23

My point is specifically why his benefits should contribute towards a mortgage which would be the same regardless of whether he lives there or not?

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:22

@Clementineapples

You'd rather struggle to feed your child than use the money that is there to help them? Ok.

If I couldn’t make it work of course I’d dip in but I wouldn’t assume the money is there for me to use on household bills and stuff. I get carers etc and I make it work.

There you go then. You would spend it if needed. How to you know that's not what the OP is doing? Would her son not suffer without food or a car and petrol to transport him? I'm pretty sure he'd suffer more without those things than £800 on Playstation games.
julieca · 04/11/2021 20:22

@BadNomad OP is going to start working 10 hours a week in January. Something like that is a good start.

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:19

[quote julieca]@BadNomad you have to plan for it, its not that easy to move from not working for years to a full-time job.[/quote]
I know it's not. I'm in that position. How do I plan ahead for something that is not happening yet?

VividGemini · 04/11/2021 20:19

I’m genuinely surprised that you’re not expected to have the majority control over this money

He's 18 - do your parents get control over your money?

Clementineapples · 04/11/2021 20:15

You'd rather struggle to feed your child than use the money that is there to help them? Ok.

If I couldn’t make it work of course I’d dip in but I wouldn’t assume the money is there for me to use on household bills and stuff. I get carers etc and I make it work.

julieca · 04/11/2021 20:15

@BadNomad you have to plan for it, its not that easy to move from not working for years to a full-time job.

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:03

[quote julieca]@BadNomad yes that is true. But most teenagers who are disabled do move on to supported housing or semi-independent living at which point those benefits go with the disabled adult. So families have to plan for that.[/quote]
Yes. Then the OP can work full-time.

Crikeycroc · 04/11/2021 20:03

SW suggested I transfer all the PIP to him and let him cope with the mistakes he makes.

So using that logic you should get a full time job that makes you unavailable to assist your DS during business hours and let him cope with his mistakes… I’m genuinely surprised that you’re not expected to have the majority control over this money. Presumably if your son didn’t have a disability he would have a part time job to pay for his phone and clothes etc or at least he wouldn’t require all the extra time you currently spend on him to your financial detriment. Personally I would charge him board if he is going to be in control of the money.

BadNomad · 04/11/2021 20:03

@Clementineapples

*The OP has already said that she has not been able to work regularly because of her son. You know, like a lot of mothers who have children. Except her child will never grow up to be completely independant. So disability or not he does have an impact on family finances by living there and depending on his mother. Stop making out that she's being selfish.

You can really tell who the people are here who have never lost their life to caring.*

My son is severely autistic. I’m a single mum. I can’t work and I have had no job, no friends, no life for 11 years. He will be with me until I die. I would still not take his benefits to pay the mortgage. I chose to have him, he is my responsibility and that responsibility will unfortunately continue for my entire life, that however is not his fault. So if he wants a game or whatever that comes out of his dla while I’m struggling for a grocery shop, I will make it work.

You'd rather struggle to feed your child than use the money that is there to help them? Ok.
BunNcheese · 04/11/2021 19:58

Give him a weekly budget then if he spends it he will soon get the hang of budgeting OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread