Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU with street begging?

152 replies

2389Champ · 04/11/2021 14:16

Walking around our town yesterday, I was asked by three different people sitting on the pavement, for spare change. All without exception young and as far as I could see - although I could be wrong - pretty healthy looking and clean. Not the usual haggard, worn look of the homeless.

There were also quite a few shops/cafes with notices asking for staff. Maybe just seasonal, but still work.
I was very tempted to go back to these youngsters and point out nicely there were employment opportunities and had they seen them? Not from an outrage point of view but as a genuine suggestion. DH talked me out of it and said I was in danger of turning into a DM reader and that it would be construed as interference or being a busy body.

Generally, I buy a sandwich for the homeless rather than give money as it often gets spent on alcohol and I’d rather they at least had something to eat.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nosafeguardingadults · 08/11/2021 14:18

And some of them are vile. They intimidate, sit in groups drinking and swearing and deliberately block access to shops. They think it’s ok to piss in the corner of a public walkway when free public toilets are 100 metres away.

Another naive thing is people that thinking domestic violence is just phone call needed to be safe and thinking victims will be safe if they leave. Is not safe always cos support and housing is postcode lottery. After refuge is either no housing help at all cos lots councils break law or is dangerous housing with the scary people you speaking about.

The scary people you saying about that I copied pasted. They have problems and need help but they is what you say scary. Some are just out of prison including for violence offences including domestic violence.

These is same people sometimes who victims of domestic violence are put with in hostels and other homeless housing. Even when own bathroom and kitchen is not safe and is scary being in same housing block or building as them. Is not safer than domestic violence even if risk of murder high risk domestic violence.

Is also why the homeless people who are not like that don't sometimes wanting stay in homeless shelters cos is with the scary not nice ones cos all dumped in together. Is violence and rapes in these places. Is why some homeless is on streets and people say they refused accommodation but is cos very dangerous accommodation.

2389Champ · 08/11/2021 12:39

Right.
I wasn’t going to come back to my OP as I asked for your views, I got them and I felt the subject had run its course.

However, I have read every response and found it very enlightening.

Two main observations; street begging and homelessness aren’t the same thing. Not all homeless beg, not all beggars are homeless.

As with every level of society, there’s the genuine people and there’s the opportunists. How we’re are supposed to tell the difference - who knows and I defy anyone to truly know that difference. Some of the street people around my area are absolutely fine and pleasant - we have a regular Big Issue seller who intervened when my DH was having hassle from some characters and is always fantastic company. He’s very open and honest about his past demons too.

And some of them are vile. They intimidate, sit in groups drinking and swearing and deliberately block access to shops. They think it’s ok to piss in the corner of a public walkway when free public toilets are 100 metres away.

If anyone is naive, it’s those that assume every person living on the street is an angel in disguise and automatically a victim when there are all types and all personalities out there.

OP posts:
Wife2b · 07/11/2021 16:59

With all respect OP you sound very naive. They are probably tidy looking because there are plenty of homeless shelters that allow opportunity to shower etc.

Thadhiya · 07/11/2021 16:52

Homeless charities are pretty clear that you shouldn't give money to street beggars. They're the ones who've already rejected the help on offer. I'd sooner listen to the charities. Especially as the ones around here are very aggressive and start swearing at you when you walk past, so I've lost any sympathy really. My children don't need to hear me being called "a stupid fucking whore".

Vates · 07/11/2021 14:28

I have given money in the past but very rarely have it on me anymore. The last woman I gave it to was very strung out but obviously desperate, sitting out for money wouldn't be good time. If I have change on me and give it away then there are no strings attached.

The only thing that sticks out here is the use of homeless; people with a roof over their head can still be classed as homeless. Sofa surfers, people living hostels, dry houses, people who are living in overcrowded homes, etc (none of these positions are great living conditions, I know but they're not sleeping literally on the streets). It is usually rough sleepers who are actually sleeping on the streets, car parks and at the mercy of the weather and people who want to do the harm simply for being a rough sleeper. I have addiction issues with alcohol and could easily imagine myself being in their position.

MissMaple82 · 07/11/2021 14:27

Get off your high horse

ChargingBuck · 07/11/2021 14:23

I wonder how many job interviews you have attended as a person of no fixed abode OP?
Or how you think potential employers usually respond when told by an applicant that they have no address, so cannot supply it for the standard checks?

Elleherd · 07/11/2021 14:17

In order to be homeless you have to have upset every single friend, relative and family member to the point where they would rather see you sleep rough than temporarily house you

Sometimes people have left a situation grim enough that even though horrible things happen to them, rough sleeping reduces the amount of things happening and is generally massively safer and far less distressing.

Don't assume people start out in life having family and friends to alienate. Many don't.

You can start out in life with nothing, and still have all of it later on!

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 07/11/2021 13:34

I give change wherever I have some. It's less now, because I pay mostly with contactless and doubt usually have change on me. I don't care or judge what they buy. There for the grace of God and so on.

We also have a direct debit for Shelter, but every homeless person feels safe in a shelter, and not every homeless person wants to go there or sometimes they can't because they have dogs.

I don't give to professional beggars or tissue beggars though. They are easy enough to spot.

EmeraldShamrock · 07/11/2021 13:30

@skybluee its hopeless.
There are so many young people on the street there's no housing available for working families never mind the poor homeless.

Volunteer charities were supplying soup sandwiches, unfortunately one of the main leaders was sexually abusing clients, now soup runs are being halted.
These people are very vulnerable.
Lots undiagnosed with non NT illnesse and left to suffer.

Opal93 · 07/11/2021 13:29

I wouldn’t do this because I don’t know their story or circumstances. They’re may be many reasons that could be preventing them from getting employment. They may have criminal records or addiction issues which may harm their chances of getting a job. I hope this doesn’t sound judgemental, I know this is not true for all of them but I just wouldn’t approach them assuming that getting a job is an option for them

Bassetlover · 07/11/2021 13:26

Jesus! Compassion bypass alert!

skybluee · 07/11/2021 13:22

@EmeraldShamrock

Our homeless local lad definitely sleeps in a doorway every night. Someone told me his DM left when he was 17 with a new man from a private rented address, he had to leave. He has no-one he is 22 addicted to crack, there is none or minimal help in Ireland for addicts. The placements that are available thresholds are impossible for an addict to reach alone. I think they've to be down to a certain amount of the medical heroin substitute before they'll get on a list.
That shouldn't be the case - talk about setting people up to fail. I think people need housing first and then focus on the other things. How are you meant to sort the other things out when you're sleeping in a doorway? So hard. It's silly as well bc why should it matter if someone was on 100ml of methadone or 30ml in terms of a tenancy?
skybluee · 07/11/2021 13:20

One of my friends who was street homeless hated ham sandwiches. Every day, people would literally buy him ham sandwiches, sometimes 5 of them, and he would have to throw them away or give them away... he always used to say he wished someone would buy tuna. Maybe it sounds picky but think of something you hate eating, and imagine being pissed off, cold and outside and someone buying that/spending money on it. He would keep telling people not to buy ham sandiwches but I'm sure they saw him as ungrateful.

I think ham was bought as it was the cheapest one in the shop he was by.

Some of the comments on this thread are orientated around getting a job. Loads of people in this situ have been thru so much they aren't going to be able to hold a job immediately in a million years.

Personally I think the focus should be on setting someone up in a place where their rent is covered and paid directly. It's a lot to ask someone to manage all of that when they haven't for a long time, to budget and so on.

Maybe somewhere where all bills are included. Somewhere stable.

And to claim benefits for the timebeing to give them months breathing space to try to sort everything out. Not forever, but to give someone a chance to get better.

I wish there were no homeless people in this country.

It is an area very close to my heart. It really upsets me when I see people criticising or making assumptions. As someone else on this thread posted, sometimes people have no idea what other people have been through.

EmeraldShamrock · 07/11/2021 13:17

Our homeless local lad definitely sleeps in a doorway every night.
Someone told me his DM left when he was 17 with a new man from a private rented address, he had to leave.
He has no-one he is 22 addicted to crack, there is none or minimal help in Ireland for addicts.
The placements that are available thresholds are impossible for an addict to reach alone.
I think they've to be down to a certain amount of the medical heroin substitute before they'll get on a list.

skybluee · 07/11/2021 13:12

@Squeezita

In order to be homeless you have to have upset every single friend, relative and family member to the point where they would rather see you sleep rough than temporarily house you whilst your find a new job.

I struggle to empathise with that because I don’t think that it’s possible to find yourself in this situation where you have irretrievably alienated everyone who cares about you, without you being partly responsible. Even if the rest of the circumstances you’re in are purely bad luck, you’d have to be a complete dick/addict for no one to help you.

This is a very simplistic and heartless view. What about mental health issues? Abusive parents? Sometimes people alienate themselves from others not because they’re a dick/addict but because they don’t feel they can talk about what they’re going through and it’s easier to just withdraw.

It’s a slippery slope that many people, good and bad, can fall down.

@Squeezita thank you for writing this.
skybluee · 07/11/2021 13:10

@SweetBabyCheeses99

I don’t think you’re BU. In order to not have a bank account nowadays you’d have to have never had one at all. It doesn’t get closed because you’re temporarily homeless. Do you need a fixed address to get a job? Yes theoretically, but I don’t see why as my employer have never posted me anything! Just use your last address.

In order to be homeless you have to have upset every single friend, relative and family member to the point where they would rather see you sleep rough than temporarily house you whilst your find a new job.

I struggle to empathise with that because I don’t think that it’s possible to find yourself in this situation where you have irretrievably alienated everyone who cares about you, without you being partly responsible. Even if the rest of the circumstances you’re in are purely bad luck, you’d have to be a complete dick/addict for no one to help you.

Regarding the family/friends thing - a lot of people in this situation don't have a network of family and friends, that's part of what has led to this situation.

For example, care leavers. They don't have a safety net after 18 unlike other people.

People with MH problems or physical health - I know speaking for myself I've lost about 80% of my friends because I don't go out any more because I cannot walk far without pain. It's not due to being a dick, it's due to things dramatically changing from when I used to go out to pubs, friends houses, shopping etc.

I feel like you missed the whole point.

Homelessness often doesn't happen as a snap thing. It's a slow deterioration of resources and so on.

A lot of people don't have friends like that. Or friend who have anywhere you can sleep. A lot of people in studio flats or HMOs, or places where you will lose your own tenanacy if you have someone else stay. Open your eyes.

shylatte · 07/11/2021 11:54

A young homeless woman in my town died, and there were lots of comments on the Facebook page saying "where are her family?!" etc. Her family then did a local news response, saying that she had a warm bed at home, they had begged her to come back etc but she made the choice to stay on the streets with her "community" (other addicts). A homeless charity spokesman said that many on the streets actually are not homeless, but leave their accommodation empty to join others on the streets as it allows them to access drugs more quickly due to people giving them money. It's a very complex issue that giving £2/a sandwich/stick of deodorant certainly isn't going to solve.

Thelnebriati · 07/11/2021 11:43

Is this a joke thread? Its hard to believe that there are still people that dont know care leavers dont get housing benefit, and homeless young people with no experience dont get offered jobs

MsTSwift · 07/11/2021 11:04

At a dinner I should have said

MsTSwift · 07/11/2021 11:04

We sat next to friends of friends who worked in this area that’s what they said too

WildBluebell · 07/11/2021 11:01

So many gullible and naive people in this thread. That's why there are so many beggars - because "bleeding hearts" give them money Grin
Help charities that help the homeless. Don't support professional beggars.

logsonlogsoff · 07/11/2021 10:36

I have a friend who used to work in Centrepoint and according to him almost all the kids they dealt with were either previously in care - which ends at 18 anyway and your on your own - , or had fled abusive homes.

logsonlogsoff · 07/11/2021 10:34

Centrepoint = young people

logsonlogsoff · 07/11/2021 10:33

OP -
If you are genuinely interested you have a couple of options. Talk to the person and ask them about their circumstances, have a chat. Or
Go to a charity website like Shelter or Centrepoint and read some of what they e written about homelessness and the people they support. Lots on there about why someone who is homeless might look ‘healthy’ or be clean. Or why they have a mobile phone.
Centrepoint supports going people who are homeless in particular, so they’d be good to talk to about why a teenager might be be begging in the street and why they aren’t just living with their lovely, generous nan or uncle or a family friend…