Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be reluctant to agree to an induction in these circumstances? WWYD?

108 replies

TinyCIanger · 04/11/2021 10:40

Am currently 36+1 weeks pg with DC2.

About a month ago at 31+4 I paid a visit to maternity triage on a Sunday evening because I’d been bleeding- not fresh blood but dark brown, but wanted to get it checked anyway. Whilst they were doing the speculum exam the midwife remarked that quite a lot of fluid was coming out- I mentioned that I’d been having the odd small trickle for a few days but not huge amounts, and I’d dismissed it as runny discharge (apologies if TMI).

Because of this the midwife concluded that my waters had gone early, and I was admitted for 48 hours as there was apparently a 60% chance that I would go into labour in that time. On my notes the volume of fluid that was lost was estimated to be 40-60 ml. I was given steroid shots to help boost baby’s lungs and put on a 10 day course of antibiotics.

Very early the next morning I was transferred to delivery as I’d been having tightenings, roughly 4 in 10 mins- by the time we actually got round to delivery it had settled down and in hindsight this was more than likely just BH. Otherwise it was an uneventful stay.

I had a scan later that day that showed there was still plenty of fluid around baby, and it’s looking to be a good size. Have been coming in to hospital for regular CTG checks which have all been fine, I’m taking my temperature twice a day which has never gone above 36.9°, bloods and urine have all been normal and baby is wriggling like an octopus so generally, everything seems to be going exactly as it should be.

However due to this suspected PROM (which I’m still dubious about) the “plan” is to induce labour at 37 weeks. The reason for this I’m told is because baby is considered full term at this point and the risk of developing an infection increases from 0.5% to 1-2%.

I really, really don’t want to be induced for several reasons.

I don’t want to force my body into labour, and force the baby out, before either of us are ready.

My birth with DS was rough- I tried for a water birth and was in the pool for a few hours (after waiting 12 very painful hours to progress from 3 to the all-important 4cms when they finally moved me to delivery), eventually after 21 hours of labour and at least 8 hours of agony I asked for an epidural but by that time I was fully dilated so it was no longer an option. 2 hours of pushing followed, but in the end DS was delivered by ventouse with me on my back, legs in stirrups and an episiotomy. Turns out he was back to back, which nobody realised until his head was out. So I was rather hoping for a slightly smoother experience this time around.

If it comes to needing the drip I know I’m going to need an epidural, so that again means no water birth, and an increased risk of birth injuries and instrumental delivery. I am preternaturally terrified of forceps so this prospect scares me shitless. Also increased risk of the whole thing ending in EMCS which means a longer, harder recovery and will impact more on my ability to take care of DS and baby.

DS (aged 2) will be staying with PILs when the time comes- inductions can take days and I really want to keep the time that I’m away from him to a minimum.

All these concerns aside- I just keep thinking this “PROM” happened a month ago and they’ve been happy to leave us be since then, and that aside everything seems to be progressing well. All the checks and tests and scans and whatnot have been fine, perfect in fact- and the amount of fluid lost seems so small, and the level of risk so low, that I’m wondering just how medically necessary an induction really is.

I’ve got a scan tomorrow and am meeting the obstetrician on Monday when the “plan” will be finalised, so I need to gather my thoughts around this- on one hand, I’m not a medical professional and part of me thinks I should just go along with whatever they say because obviously they know best, but then I keep thinking they’re suddenly leaping to being super cautious at 37 weeks after leaving us to it for a month and all these other doubts come into my head.

OP posts:
CrazyOldBagLady · 04/11/2021 23:00

The NHS want you to follow their procedure which is to induce you at 37 weeks. They don't seem to have any give in their procedure to personalise care based on your birth preferences. I was in a somewhat compatible situation to you, although much later down the line. I opted for monitoring as I didn't want to be induced without any medical need.

They can check you for infections, they can check how much water you have, they can monitor you and baby to see if you are both healthy. You can ask them to explore these options with you.

Also, you don't need to finalise any plans on Monday if you need more time to think or need more information or more test results. It's your care and you can decide what the plan is and when it will be made.

NameChange30 · 04/11/2021 22:57

@CoffeeRunner

In my experience (although my children are admittedly older), you do not get induced unless there's very good reason.

I had three inductions. 37 weeks (pre-eclampsia), 40+1 (given previous history of pre-eclampsia & rising BP) & 38+2 (rising BP & odd liver function blood results).

With DC3 I had been in hospital for 2 weeks prior to the induction. They wouldn't induce until absolutely necessary.

When did you give birth to your children?

There has been a big increase in inductions in the last 10 years.

"induced method of onset [increased] from 21 per cent to 33 per cent in the period 2009-10 to 2019-20."

Do you think it's "absolutely necessary" to induce 1 in 3 labours?

I don't think it is, but I'm open to being persuaded otherwise. Preferably with reliable data rather than anecdote.

To be reluctant to agree to an induction in these circumstances? WWYD?
Dazzledee · 04/11/2021 22:50

I was induced at 37 weeks (with my second) for different reasons so can't comment on your individual case. It wasn't my plan but I actually didn't have a plan, I always had the attitude that they knew more than me and I would have to trust them. They look me to labour suit and could already burst my waters. 2 hours after they burst them my baby was born. No drip, no epidural, no 16 hours in labour like first. I remember thinking if I ever did it again I would pick an induction over natural labour! So it's not always bad being induced!!

KateTheEighth · 04/11/2021 22:47

@wigglerose

I would go for an elective section. I don't know why hospitals are so keen on the rigmarole of induction. Quicker recovery my arse if you end up having an emergency section any way or forceps/ventouse/episiotomy.

Agree with this absolutely

My (42 week) induction was 3 days of hell and an em section at the end of it with exhaustion and distress added to the mix

CoffeeRunner · 04/11/2021 22:47

In my experience (although my children are admittedly older), you do not get induced unless there's very good reason.

I had three inductions. 37 weeks (pre-eclampsia), 40+1 (given previous history of pre-eclampsia & rising BP) & 38+2 (rising BP & odd liver function blood results).

With DC3 I had been in hospital for 2 weeks prior to the induction. They wouldn't induce until absolutely necessary.

NameChange30 · 04/11/2021 22:46

Also see this, it's very helpful
www.aims.org.uk/information/item/making-decisions

With my friend's recent experience, what I found striking was that all the doctors were going on about induction as if it was the only option. Actually there were two other options: doing nothing (apart from monitoring) or ELCS. It would have been far more helpful if they had discussed the pros and cons of each option, to allow her to make a fully informed decision.

I second the advice to ask to talk to the consultant midwife. You might get a slightly different perspective to the consultant obstetrician's.

NameChange30 · 04/11/2021 22:41

@whosaidtha

I'd also focus on why it is necessary. What are the risks of not having an induction on baby? On mother? How likely are these to happen? What would the risk factors be if we waited a week? Two weeks? Three weeks? How big is baby- how likely that they may need neo-natal care? How long would I need to stay in hospital post induction? What are the options for a c-section? What are the pros and cons of this? Don't focus too much on your fear of induction and forget to question why they are suggesting it in the first place. I hope baby comes safely.
Good questions and good advice.

You should also ask what staffing levels are like at the hospital and whether they've had to put inductions on hold at any point recently, whether they've had to redirect women in labour to different hospitals because the labour ward is at capacity, etc.

I know someone who was pressured into an induction at 37 weeks only to find that the antenatal ward was full of women who had been waiting days for their induction because of dangerously low staffing levels. Not exactly a calm reassuring environment to give birth. She ended up with an EMCS and a baby in NICU.

Obviously there are more positive stories on this thread. But try and find out the current situation in your maternity hospital before deciding. Maternity care is in crisis. I would never consent to an induction in the current situation. My preference would be to wait to go into labour naturally but if I decided the risks were too great i'd go for an ELCS.

NameChange30 · 04/11/2021 22:37

@User0ne

Drs and nurses calculate risk on a population level and base their recommendations on that. It doesn't consider what's best for you (or your baby) as an individual - you are the person who does that.

Maternity care is the same as all other medical care - you can decline it for whatever reason you want. It's perfectly legitimate to say that you don't think that induction is right for you at this point and that you'll let them know if you change your mind.

If you are happy to own your decisions then make them yourself. If you aren't let someone else do it for you. I've declined many things while pregnant/labouring (3dc) - it isn't always easy but they are your decisions to make.

This
Everydayimhuffling · 04/11/2021 22:25

Just to reassure you a bit in case you do end up with an induction: I had to be induced with DC2 at 37 weeks and it was great. They went step by step, breaking waters, waiting, then a low drip which kick-started labour for me. It wasn't ages of waiting for everything to progress and I didn't need an episiotomy like I did the first time. I didn't find the pain more unmanageable than when I went into labour naturally.

Incidentally this was also after failing to get my water birth the first time, and I've subsequently found out that that reduces skin elasticity and can raise the risk of an episiotomy.

wigglerose · 04/11/2021 21:35

I would go for an elective section. I don't know why hospitals are so keen on the rigmarole of induction. Quicker recovery my arse if you end up having an emergency section any way or forceps/ventouse/episiotomy.

whosaidtha · 04/11/2021 21:28

I'd also focus on why it is necessary. What are the risks of not having an induction on baby? On mother? How likely are these to happen? What would the risk factors be if we waited a week? Two weeks? Three weeks? How big is baby- how likely that they may need neo-natal care? How long would I need to stay in hospital post induction? What are the options for a c-section? What are the pros and cons of this? Don't focus too much on your fear of induction and forget to question why they are suggesting it in the first place.
I hope baby comes safely.

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 04/11/2021 21:25

I would ask for an appointment with the consultant midwife in your position.

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 04/11/2021 21:25

Your Bishop score is an assessment of how favourable your cervix is, taking into account position, thickness, dilatation and where baby’s head is; it is calculated after a vaginal examination so won’t be documented anywhere unless you’ve had a sweep or something like that

TinyCIanger · 04/11/2021 20:55

Thanks for all the responses.

This is going to sound daft, but it hadn’t actually occurred to me to request an ELCS as an alternative to being induced- I suppose because I’ve always thought of sections as being last resort EMCS or planned due to medical need, tokophobia etc. And at no point has any midwife or consultant suggested it to me as an option, even though I have discussed my concerns about induction more than once. But it is definitely something to consider.

I know my reasons for not wanting an induction are largely based around myself - it’s not that I’m not thinking of what’s best for baby, it’s more because the only medical reason for having an induction seems to be because the risk of infection at 37 weeks increases from really minuscule to ever so slightly less minuscule, and everything so far seems to indicate baby is perfectly happy in situ.

I’m trying to compile a list of questions I can ask the consultant on Monday. So far I’ve got:

  • How many inductions at this hospital, at this stage of gestation
a) end up needing the syntocinon drip? b) end in instrumental delivery? Forceps vs ventouse c) How many result in birth injuries to mother and/or baby? Instrumental vs non-instrumental, forceps vs ventouse d) end in EMCS? Awake vs under GA
  • What is my Bishop score? (Have looked through my notes, no mention of it anywhere so I don’t think this has actually been calculated)
  • Aside from losing 40-60ml of what may or may not have been amniotic fluid more than 5 weeks ago, is there anything else that would indicate that induction is necessary?

Can anyone think of anything else I might want to ask or discuss?

OP posts:
AHobbyaweek · 04/11/2021 18:35

Why don't you try speaking to AIMS to get all the facts and risks of each side so you can make your own decision. They can also let you know all of your rights and choices you can make.

They will point you to all the research/guidance and balance which might help.

www.aims.org.uk/

Sciurus83 · 04/11/2021 18:27

I would also go ELCS in your position. Having said that a friend just had a successful pretty straightforward induction at 37. Personally if a medical professional tells me the baby needs to come out due to infection risk I wouldn't be pushing back in that.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/11/2021 18:26

Just to reassure though, I had two inductions at 38 and 40 weeks- no drugs, no intervention. So it’s not all bad.

They were going to let men have a water birth the second time, as first time had gone so well, but the heating/ hot water went off in the hospital (in February!)

Was quite nice for me as I got really hot both times giving birth but not ideal.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/11/2021 18:22

I agree with those who say err on the side of caution in terms of dates. The main thing is to make sure the baby is born safely, and avoid an emergency situation.

I would also think you have the right to ask for an elective section (well, you always do) and that it might be the best option in this case.

TheOriginalEmu · 04/11/2021 18:16

I dunno wtf happened there…‘start induction it gets harder to stop it escalating to more intervention’ is what I was going for..

TheOriginalEmu · 04/11/2021 18:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DuggeeHugs · 04/11/2021 18:06

There's no way I'd agree to an induction - I foolishly agreed to one before and it failed. It would have to be ELCS or wait for things to begin naturally.

User0ne · 04/11/2021 18:02

Drs and nurses calculate risk on a population level and base their recommendations on that. It doesn't consider what's best for you (or your baby) as an individual - you are the person who does that.

Maternity care is the same as all other medical care - you can decline it for whatever reason you want. It's perfectly legitimate to say that you don't think that induction is right for you at this point and that you'll let them know if you change your mind.

If you are happy to own your decisions then make them yourself. If you aren't let someone else do it for you. I've declined many things while pregnant/labouring (3dc) - it isn't always easy but they are your decisions to make.

Merryoldgoat · 04/11/2021 17:32

Having had the induction when I wasn’t ready which was an abject waste of 5 days I’d look at this:

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bishop_score

Find out what yours is before agreeing. Mine was 1. If I’d known beforehand I’d never have agreed.

ELCS is much better than an EMCS after a failed lengthy induction where risk of haemorrhage increases.

HeyFloof · 04/11/2021 17:23

@nodogz

Ask for an elective section. If medical advice is to get the baby out then get it out in the least distressing and predictable way.
This.