Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitors, WIBU to opt out?

65 replies

Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 10:34

I know you can opt out I'm just wondering how many do, and how that is perceived?

It's my third baby so I know the ropes, I don't feel as though I need any particular advice and should I ever have a health concern my first port of call would be the GP. I have support, a DH and family. I'll take baby to clinic to be weighed occasionally however he's making fab progress according to the midwife.

I was told somebody from the HV team would be round this morning at 9.30 so I was up and rushing about, doing dishes and hoovering despite very little sleep, because despite what people say they do take notice to an extent.

They then called at 9.30 and said they had to reschedule for tomorrow which was annoying.

It got me to thinking how unnessecary it all feels and how I don't really want them coming round anyway. I'd prefer to opt out.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Rosebel · 04/11/2021 11:11

My health visitor was awful when I had my first so I didn't use one second time around. Long time ago so decided to use HV for my son. It was a mistake. No contact for months on end. When they finally did see me she basically told me off for not being in touch earlier as my son was delayed.
This is despite the fact I had phoned several times and over the phone was told not to worry.
I didn't frantically clean the house so I expect I have a black mark against my name anyway

usernumberno46273 · 04/11/2021 11:07

They are a waste of time. Even when I had my first baby I felt like I gained nothing from their visits.

Saddlesore · 04/11/2021 11:06

I found them a complete waste of time. Questions like "What job do you do?" Why? I said that it wasn't relevant, although it was on the tip of my tongue to say "One in which I turn up at the time I say I will."

Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 11:05

@Dogscanteatonions

I'd let them do a couple of visits - they won't be very interested if it's not your first anyway. I had terrible one with my second ,- lost any respect I had when she told me I would damage my babies teeth when I informed her I intended to breastfeed past a year old
Bloody hell, yeah that would really get my back up too. The cheek Confused
OP posts:
Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 11:04

@Cocomarine

I’m curious that you’d consider running the risk of the perception (whatever that actually is!) of you opting out - yet are so concerned about the perception of them seeing unwashed dishes. You really don’t have to worry about that.
I probably don't, but I feel uncomfortable having visitors when the place isn't tidy so always tidy before visits. It's a longstanding habit that's hard to break especially when it's a professional coming.

I've also read a few posts on here over the years from people saying their home has been critiqued when HV's have been round, even one from a woman saying the health visitor wanted to have a look around the whole house (I know you can say no, it's just awkward)

OP posts:
Dogscanteatonions · 04/11/2021 10:49

I'd let them do a couple of visits - they won't be very interested if it's not your first anyway. I had terrible one with my second ,- lost any respect I had when she told me I would damage my babies teeth when I informed her I intended to breastfeed past a year old

Cocomarine · 04/11/2021 10:48

I’m curious that you’d consider running the risk of the perception (whatever that actually is!) of you opting out - yet are so concerned about the perception of them seeing unwashed dishes. You really don’t have to worry about that.

Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 10:47

@LolaSmiles

The only reason I continued to let them come round was because I couldn't be bothered with them red flagging us for opting out.

I felt we had a revolving door of health visitors and only one was compassionate and supportive. The worst one was patronising and I got the impression she spoke down to every mum and was on some sort of power trip. She completely ignored medical letters regarding DC and to be blunt she implied that DC medical issues would go away if I was a better mum. I was furious.

That would rile me, I'm sorry you had that experience.

The one we had with DC1 refused to acknowledge my concerns about autism despite it being blatantly obvious, I got the distinct impression she thought I was being ridiculous and PFB. Low and behold he was diagnosed at 2.10 years and 10 months after I bypassed her and went through our GP for a paediatrican referral.

OP posts:
LaikO · 04/11/2021 10:47

I think we've been lucky with our HV team, they've been brilliant and have helped a lot, but I understand wanting to opt out if yours haven't been helpful. YANBU for wanting to, I've heard they will sometimes flag it up to social services if you do, though. Although I'm guessing even if they did, apart from being a bit of extra hassle, they'll see nothing is wrong and that'll be it!

TurnUpTurnip · 04/11/2021 10:44

I’ve always opted out, it doesn’t bring any attention to you, it’s a voluntary service so I’m not sure what attention pp thinks it will bring, Ive opted out with all of my children and never heard anything again it will only bring “attention” to you if there are other concerns. I’ve never bothered with them after a bad experience with my first child.

Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 10:42

@GinIronic

Opt out so that they can waste other peoples time.
Grin
OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 04/11/2021 10:42

The only reason I continued to let them come round was because I couldn't be bothered with them red flagging us for opting out.

I felt we had a revolving door of health visitors and only one was compassionate and supportive. The worst one was patronising and I got the impression she spoke down to every mum and was on some sort of power trip. She completely ignored medical letters regarding DC and to be blunt she implied that DC medical issues would go away if I was a better mum. I was furious.

GinIronic · 04/11/2021 10:41

Opt out so that they can waste other peoples time.

Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 10:40

@EllieSattler

I got so little attention from my HVs, it seems to me that they'll visit once then ignore you, whereas if you opt out you'll be drawing attention to yourself and will have to spend more time justifying it than you would have tidying up for a tick-box visit and being forgotten.
Hmm, you raise a good point.

I saw them semi regularly with DC1 but only once or twice with DC2 and her most recent developmental review was done over the telephone.

Perhaps it would be better to get the first visit out of the way then hope they forget about us.

OP posts:
EllieSattler · 04/11/2021 10:37

I got so little attention from my HVs, it seems to me that they'll visit once then ignore you, whereas if you opt out you'll be drawing attention to yourself and will have to spend more time justifying it than you would have tidying up for a tick-box visit and being forgotten.