Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Health visitors, WIBU to opt out?

65 replies

Alldayallnight · 04/11/2021 10:34

I know you can opt out I'm just wondering how many do, and how that is perceived?

It's my third baby so I know the ropes, I don't feel as though I need any particular advice and should I ever have a health concern my first port of call would be the GP. I have support, a DH and family. I'll take baby to clinic to be weighed occasionally however he's making fab progress according to the midwife.

I was told somebody from the HV team would be round this morning at 9.30 so I was up and rushing about, doing dishes and hoovering despite very little sleep, because despite what people say they do take notice to an extent.

They then called at 9.30 and said they had to reschedule for tomorrow which was annoying.

It got me to thinking how unnessecary it all feels and how I don't really want them coming round anyway. I'd prefer to opt out.

AIBU?

OP posts:
furbabymama87 · 04/11/2021 12:53

Oh yeah I agree the parenting courses are useless. I think it's just a box ticking thing for them.

godmum56 · 04/11/2021 12:52

Not HV's but DN's. I did have problems with them when my late husband was ill and they would either TELL me when they were coming or arrive without notice. There was no reason for them to do either and I know this because I used to manage that service before I retired. Once they had clocked it was me they were much more amenable and the culprits were not sent again. YANBU definitely

PeacefulDreams · 04/11/2021 12:47

I opted out with my first and second babies and now pregnant again and will opt out with this one too. They pushed abit more to have contact with my first but after a couple of firm no's they have left me alone.

WarmWinterSun · 04/11/2021 12:46

Hi OP, I opted out with my second child. There were no repercussions whatsoever. I find it highly disturbing that people agree to having HVs visit out of fear. We live in a free society, not a totalitarian state.

QueenOfCatan · 04/11/2021 12:46

@furbabymama87

I wouldn't opt out. I've had kids with global delay and eye problems and the health visitors are always the ones who have referred them for investigation, so have proved useful. I think you're drawing attention to yourself and making it look likes there's a problem if you don't see them. They can give advice you think is irrelevant but you can disregard if you know better.
You can still contact them for this kind of thing even if you opt out. I opted out but contacted them for help with my daughter who is likely adhd. They are bloody useless though and keep telling me to do parenting courses, the content of which doesn't work because my kid has adhd Hmm
PlasticCupPolitics · 04/11/2021 12:43

I work in HVing, we (or at least the area I work in) would much rather you opted out if you didn’t want to see us, it frees up time to see families that maybe have more complex needs.

Nobody will flag it up if you decline visits, unless of course there has been previous concern or social services involvement.

I know it’s habit that you clean your house before a visit but I promise that unless you live in an actual hovel, we (the majority!) don’t care.

If you find that you do want to access the service at any point before your child starts school, you can still call your team if needed.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 04/11/2021 12:41

I'd opt out if I was you. I doubt you need them for anything.

I'm expecting my second in a few months and am quite worried about their visits as my new house is a complete state and needs a full renovation. We've moved county and they made a huge fuss about seeing my older daughter when we moved here so I feel like I have to have them in with the second. The lady who came to see my daughter was lovely and I would happily have her in, but if it's someone else I can see how the current state of the house could give them worries for a new baby.

Starlight86 · 04/11/2021 12:37

I opted out for few reasons.

  1. was my 3rd child so i felt like a knew the ropes.
  2. middle of the pandemic
  3. I know how overstretched they are (family member is one) so want them to use their resources on someone who needed it.
  4. I have an excellent GP that i can go to with any concerns.
  5. We are an out and about family therefor them booking in on a tuesday without giving a time didnt suit me.

So i just opted out, said i knew where they were and would call if i needed them and use my GP also for any concerns.

Thebig3 · 04/11/2021 12:34

It is a voluntary service, you will under no circumstances be put on any 'watch list' because you opt out of seeing them. Absolutely ridiculous that anyone would think this!

If you don't want to see them just say you don't feel it's necessary. It's exactly what I did with my 3rd. The HV said 'no problem, you know where we are if you need us'.

To be honest they are probably so busy they'd be grateful for one less person to see!!

furbabymama87 · 04/11/2021 12:32

And you can ask to see them. My youngest is 4 so not sure if anything has changed in that time.

furbabymama87 · 04/11/2021 12:30

@SickAndTiredAgain

I've had kids with global delay and eye problems and the health visitors are always the ones who have referred them for investigation

When? I didn’t turn down a single appointment with DD, they just only made one and then disappeared off the face of the earth. Unless DD had a global delay that was noticeable at 10 days old, the HV wouldn’t have seen it.

They do development routine checks at 2 years and again at 3 ( I think). They can be involved up to when they start school, then they're under the school nurse.
TheOrigRights · 04/11/2021 12:25

The HV for my second child was lovely. My Mum had just been diagnosed with terminal cancer, I was in an emotionally abusive marriage (though hadn't acknowledged that myself at this stage) and looking back now (12 years later) I can see that she went out of her way to be a consistent, caring person.
She was in my life for about 5 months I think, showing me baby massage and having a chat.

I didn't open up to her - again I see now that I was using my own (unhealthy) coping mechanisms - but she was doing her job really well and would have spotted signs of me being overwhelmed.

MarmaladeToastAndAMarmaladeCat · 04/11/2021 12:17

Yanbu I am expecting my third and I will be opting out. My health visitor with my first baby berated me for formula feeding and told me I’d let my baby down (despite not being able to for medical reasons!) My second one gave me a stern talking to because she thought my age gap between my children was too small. I told her how well my eldest was doing and how much he loved the baby and she just found ways to make everything negative and said how much they would both suffer Sad it left me feeling really shit. Cannot be bothered with the negativity this time.

Stef92 · 04/11/2021 12:09

I would look up to see if clinics aren't running. Due to Covid everything has been appointment to my house and my son is now 8 months old and they're no closer to restarting clinics in my area

SickAndTiredAgain · 04/11/2021 11:55

I've had kids with global delay and eye problems and the health visitors are always the ones who have referred them for investigation

When? I didn’t turn down a single appointment with DD, they just only made one and then disappeared off the face of the earth. Unless DD had a global delay that was noticeable at 10 days old, the HV wouldn’t have seen it.

furbabymama87 · 04/11/2021 11:51

I wouldn't opt out. I've had kids with global delay and eye problems and the health visitors are always the ones who have referred them for investigation, so have proved useful. I think you're drawing attention to yourself and making it look likes there's a problem if you don't see them. They can give advice you think is irrelevant but you can disregard if you know better.

EgSk · 04/11/2021 11:47

YANBU to feel this way but it’s probably easier to let her do her checks since the appointment is already made !

My health visitor has ignored me for the past year. I called to make appointments for my 2 year olds review and my 11 month olds review . I was asked if I had any concerns and when I said no they told me no need for an appointment. I also didn’t do a single weigh in with my second born except for his 8 week one ( and his 5 day old one ). He will be one on Sunday . I weigh him on my scale at home and although it’s not as accurate as a doctors baby scale , I can see he’s gaining weight very well. He loves the boob and his food and I have no concerns with his weight .

3scape · 04/11/2021 11:43

When I had my third she only came round for a cup of tea because there was a first just around the corner. We spent more time talking about choosing secondary schools for our older daughters (same one as it turned out). But then if you're too busy just cancel in the moment, I don't think they'd be overly concerned.

SickAndTiredAgain · 04/11/2021 11:41

I’m pregnant with my second and would be opting out if I thought it would make a difference. With my first we had one 10 min visit where she handed me a list of the HV clinics for weighing etc and pointed out the vaccine record in the red book and asked if we were vaccinating. Never heard from them again. Would probably be more hassle to cancel it.

The reason I’d be wanting to opt out is because I did ring them once when DD was a few months old, very upset, I was suicidal with PND, and thought they’d be able to signpost some help. They told me to call back in a few days when the “phase has passed.” I hung up thinking that I might actually not have a few days. So I have no interest in them, and their “help”.

Cosmois · 04/11/2021 11:40

Just opt out. I have opted out with all my children and no repercussions.

CherryHug · 04/11/2021 11:33

wish i had opted out especially with my third, she was a right patronising cow.

Walks in and says "I know this is your third but I am going to just talk to you like you have never had a baby before" any attempts at me replying were sharply spoken over.

I have never felt so insulted and unheard in my entire life. I declined all future appointments after that.

Aderyn21 · 04/11/2021 11:20

My last one was awful - insisted on meeting all my DC, as of I was keeping them in a dungeon or something Hmm
I felt judged and uncomfortable and I'm not a shrinking violet type - I'm very good at advocating for myself, but she caught me when I was hormonal and made me feel 100x worse. She was so clunky in her approach. On the basis of that experience I'd never have a HV in my house again.

I also think it's incredibly rude when they turn up without prior agreement. I understand why they do it and in theory I do believe that if they save one child from harm then it's obviously worth putting up with their clunky approach. But on a personal level I feel they often do more harm than good and can tip women, at their most vulnerable time, into PND.

I think the whole service needs remodeling because I'm not convinced it's fit for purpose.

Clovacloud · 04/11/2021 11:20

My HV showed up once, called to reschedule her second appointment as she had to collect her kids and was then never seen again. I don’t feel like I massively missed out.

You have three kids, you know what you’re doing. I wouldn’t worry about it.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 04/11/2021 11:12

I agree with @EllieSattler - one visit and get them out of your life. I found the service useless, can’t understand people apparently like me who rave about the HV support they got.

Rosebel · 04/11/2021 11:12

But if you don't want to use the HV just call them and say that.