Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To try to find out how my uncle died?

136 replies

Keke94LND · 04/11/2021 10:05

So 18 years ago, my uncle died, I was 9 at the time.

I don't remember a lot about my uncle, he was very quiet, quite reclusive, he lived with my Nan pretty much until he died (he was in his 40s) I know he had mental health problems and possibly some drug addictions.

Since his death, no one in my family has ever really talked about him, I think it's mainly because they don't want to bring him up around my Nan, although in recent years my Nan has talked about him a few times. But every time she has I've been sort of shocked just because he is never spoken about. It's like him and his death is some sort of family secret or topic that we don't speak about, for some reason.

I have spoken to my mum about him and his death before, but she has no idea how he died, no one does, except for my Nan. and for some reason even though they are incredibly close, my mum has never/won't ask her.

I have always been curious of what happened, especially because it's a secret, WIBU to try and find out what happened? I am considering trying to find/buy his death certificate as surely that will state cause of death, the only thing stopping me is, is the next of kin ever notified if someone orders a death certificate? (I.e will my Nan find out I have ordered it? I wouldn't want to upset her

OP posts:
twentnine · 04/11/2021 11:10

If one of my siblings died in their forties I would definitely ask what happened. I'm surprised your Mum didn't, or maybe she did and doesn't want to talk about it. If you want to take it further, order the death certificate. This is your family. You are not being morbid.

JudgeJ · 04/11/2021 11:08

@BingBongToTheMoon

No, no one will know or be told. Anyone can order certificates.
Can they? I seem to recall that the last time I ordered certificates I had to state the relationship to the person, this didn't use to be the case. Maybe I've remembered it incorrectly.
TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/11/2021 11:07

Well, people who are guarding family secrets are often doing so because of perceived shame

The same is true of rape, child abuse etc. Would you decide to drag these issues out and shine a light on them so the person affected can be forced to rid themselves of any feelings of shame?

Or would you let them be the judge of what they want to expose and discuss?

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 04/11/2021 11:02

Verfremdungseffekt

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate
Lots of crossed posts there. I’m not saying she should raise the topic with her family and force a discussion, to be clear. I’m saying there’s nothing morally wrong about looking into it quietly.

But you say that 'family secrets cause a lot of pain' in what way will the OP relieving her curiosity about the death of a family member she barely knew and who died possibly by suicide -- when she was a small child, alleviate that pain?

Well, people who are guarding family secrets are often doing so because of perceived shame — whether about suicide or mental illness or illegitimacy or homosexuality or something else. It can frequently mean that they are inadvertently perpetuating a view of something as shameful that really needn’t be, trapped by worry about protecting the dead person somehow. The white lies and distress that hang around that kind of secret can often drive a wedge into relationships with living family members.

It’s understandable that it happens but it can be a huge help to just quietly let some light into things, so that younger relatives can understand and be aware without needing to confront anyone.

It isn’t only the directly bereaved person who experiences pain in situations like this, it often ripples out. Nobody should feel judged for wanting to know their own family stories.

Keke94LND · 04/11/2021 10:58

@Mrsjayy

What will you do with the information? Once you know then what your curiosity is settled and you will be in the know will you tell your mum other family members or just keep it to yourself . This isn't your business I honestly think you should let it lie .
I kind of disagree it's not my business though, he was my mums brother, my uncle, when I say I don't remember much about him, I don't mean I remember nothing. A lot of my memories from before I was 9, he was always there, he just wasn't a 'life and soul of the party' type, he didn't speak that much.. but he was there, in the background of a lot of my memories, and I still loved him, he wasn't just nothing to me
OP posts:
knittingaddict · 04/11/2021 10:58

Why isn't it the op's business. It's her family too.

I do family history. You could say that none of that is my business either, but it's fascinating and in a way, it brings the dead back to life and honours them.

Obviously recent history requires more tack and empathy, but in op's shoes I would want to know too. Once you know there's a mystery in your family it's hard to let it go. It's how you deal with the information that really matters and I hope the op will be careful.

HollowTalk · 04/11/2021 10:57

Was he your mum's brother? How could she not know how he died?

Mrsjayy · 04/11/2021 10:55

The only reason not to pry would be if the OP were doing it for morbid

Well it is for morbid reasons what else can it be this isn't ancestry research this is recent times people the uncles mother is still alive and to be nosing into a death is morbid curiosity.

Mrsjayy · 04/11/2021 10:52

What will you do with the information? Once you know then what your curiosity is settled and you will be in the know will you tell your mum other family members or just keep it to yourself . This isn't your business I honestly think you should let it lie .

HarrietsChariot · 04/11/2021 10:48

@TheYearOfSmallThings

I would probably not pry into this. It sounds as if he lived rather a sad life and died rather a sad death. If your grandmother wants to speak about him, by all means listen and allow him to do so, but don't dig around to satisfy your curiosity.
I might be the only person, but I actually find that quite offensive although you almost certainly don't mean it to be.

Someone having a sad life and a sad death doesn't mean that their life wasn't valid or worthwhile. Almost everyone will have had some positive impact on someone else at some point. Vincent van Gogh for instance had a rather pathetic existence and a slow, lingering suicide. That doesn't make his life irrelevant nor mean people shouldn't try to understand him or what made him work.

The only reason not to pry would be if the OP were doing it for morbid reasons, or to gloat over the person's failures, which there is no suggestion they are doing.

knittingaddict · 04/11/2021 10:46

[quote Keke94LND]@Verfremdungseffekt mum definitely doesn't know, my Nan is a really private person (often because she is protective), whereas my mum is a super open person. When I discussed it with her before, she said that she didn't know how he died and she can't ask about it and that she probably won't know until my Nan is gone, she was definitely telling the truth, I think she does wonder about it too, but yeah there may be a part of her that doesn't want to find out if it is something horrible [/quote]
I have to say that I do find a lack of curiousity about this sort of thing really hard to understand. By curiousity I don't mean nosiness, but just the need to find out why a brother had died. I know it does happen, but it definitely wouldn't in ours.

Marylou2 · 04/11/2021 10:46

I understand why you want to know. It natural to be curious about such a close family member. My brother took his own life and there was an inquest etc so could your Nan really have kept that secret from you all? I'd order a copy of the death certificate. Almost every family has hidden sadnesses.

knittingaddict · 04/11/2021 10:43

@GoodnightGrandma

We were told that my great grandad was lost at sea, when I found out that he actually died in a sailor’s hospital in Australia. And my great grandma continued to have babies after he was ‘lost’, and she gave them his surname !!!
My great great grandparents had 7 children and never married.

I was told that my great grandfather from this same family fell off a roof and died. I have the newspaper report of his death. He died in his bed of heart failure. I'm sure if any falls from roofs were involved they would have mentioned it. Death certificate confirmed heart failure with no dramatic falls.

As far as I'm concerned family stories might as well be a game of Chinese whispers. They can't be relied on.

Keke94LND · 04/11/2021 10:40

@Verfremdungseffekt mum definitely doesn't know, my Nan is a really private person (often because she is protective), whereas my mum is a super open person. When I discussed it with her before, she said that she didn't know how he died and she can't ask about it and that she probably won't know until my Nan is gone, she was definitely telling the truth, I think she does wonder about it too, but yeah there may be a part of her that doesn't want to find out if it is something horrible

OP posts:
GoodnightGrandma · 04/11/2021 10:37

We were told that my great grandad was lost at sea, when I found out that he actually died in a sailor’s hospital in Australia. And my great grandma continued to have babies after he was ‘lost’, and she gave them his surname !!!

Verfremdungseffekt · 04/11/2021 10:33

@LemonJuiceFromConcentrate

Lots of crossed posts there. I’m not saying she should raise the topic with her family and force a discussion, to be clear. I’m saying there’s nothing morally wrong about looking into it quietly.
But you say that 'family secrets cause a lot of pain' in what way will the OP relieving her curiosity about the death of a family member she barely knew and who died possibly by suicide -- when she was a small child, alleviate that pain?

OP, I wouldn't necessarily be convinced your mother doesn't know how your uncle died. She may simply not want to talk about it. My grandfather was sectioned multiple times in a mental hospital in the 1940s and 50s and had electroshock therapy -- my mother prefers to behave as though that didn't happen because it's a source of intense shame for her.

GoodnightGrandma · 04/11/2021 10:28

Just order the death certificate. No one needs to know.

knittingaddict · 04/11/2021 10:28

If you do request the death certificate then I would strongly suggest keeping the info to yourself unless asked by another family member. They could have easily found out themselves if they wanted to know, so maybe they are content with their ignorance.

Member984815 · 04/11/2021 10:27

It'll be listed on his death cert , is it possible for you to get a copy?

LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 04/11/2021 10:27

Lots of crossed posts there. I’m not saying she should raise the topic with her family and force a discussion, to be clear. I’m saying there’s nothing morally wrong about looking into it quietly.

Keke94LND · 04/11/2021 10:27

@MrsTulipTattsyrup

I do a lot of family research both for work and my own interest, and I firmly believe that if your family doesn’t talk about something from the past, it’s because they don’t want to, and therefore if you love them you should respect that. You can cause a whole world of hurt to people if you ride roughshod over their wishes.

I had a situation in my family where my grandpa didn’t talk about his family, and so I never investigated during his lifetime. I waited until long after he was gone and then started my research, comfortable in the knowledge that anything I turned up couldn’t be hurtful to him.

Maybe the time for you to look into this is after your Nan can’t be hurt by your looking into it all.

Hmm this is true
OP posts:
girlmom21 · 04/11/2021 10:26

[quote TheUndeadLovelinessOfDemons]@girlmom21 I'm guessing because the OP doesn't want to upset her.[/quote]
If she brings him up fairly often there's a good chance she actually wants to speak about him.

I'm sure she'd rather be asked than find out people were pussyfooting around her and doing all kinds of backhanded things to find out.

She's a grown woman.

Keke94LND · 04/11/2021 10:26

@girlmom21

Why don't you ask your nan?
The main reason I don't want to ask my Nan is because if he took his own life, that would be hard for my Nan to say or discuss.. Obviously I don't know thats what happened, but it's definitely a possibility
OP posts:
LemonJuiceFromConcentrate · 04/11/2021 10:25

@TheYearOfSmallThings

I would probably not pry into this. It sounds as if he lived rather a sad life and died rather a sad death. If your grandmother wants to speak about him, by all means listen and allow him to do so, but don't dig around to satisfy your curiosity.
This seems a bit repressive to me. There is nothing wrong with being curious about something that happened in your own close family and taking discreet steps to find out. Family secrets often cause a lot of pain; a little light on them can be a very healthy thing as long as it’s handled gently.

Of course it wouldn’t be okay to pressure anyone to talk about something painful, but it doesn’t sound like the op plans to do that.

knittingaddict · 04/11/2021 10:24

[quote Evesgarden]I think you can find out here.

www.ancestry.co.uk/cs/us/uk-death-records?ancid=jwzsurnpn3&pgrid=86887096710&ptaid=kwd-931857975757&s_kwcid=how+to+%2bfind+%2bsomeone+who+%2bhas+%2bdied&gclid=CjwKCAjwiY6MBhBqEiwARFSCPi5ItDWsNGxf3ph76Ad4yft7x-9LWg5CwGAh5Evk7gytIehp1xVsdRoCcxoQAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds&o_xid=59287&o_lid=59287&o_sch=Paid+Search+Non+Brand[/quote]
I highly doubt that the record will be there as it depends on people doing research. It might link to a source for finding out, but that would be the death certificate and op can order one from here:

www.gov.uk/order-copy-birth-death-marriage-certificate

Swipe left for the next trending thread