Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can you predict if you will like being a parent?

80 replies

KarmaElBanana · 04/11/2021 09:53

Do you think there are any predictors of whether someone will take to having kids or not? I see a lot of those threads on here where people ask who regrets having kids, and the general proportion is 2/3 don’t regret it, 1/3 do.

So what characteristics / circumstances / etc. do you think are predictors of whether someone will take to being a parent or regret their decision? Is there any basis you can use to judge how likely it is to be the path for you? Eg different personality traits / types of temperament / circumstantial aspects of their life?

OP posts:
peppersauce1984 · 04/11/2021 11:10

I think it helps if you have some experience of being around babies and have realistic expectations about what parenting will involve.

Chunkymenrock · 04/11/2021 10:58

Do you find children overrated and irritating? If yes, then I'm afraid you won't change, no matter how much you tell yourself it'll be different with your own. (You can find other redeeming features, but I think this is pretty much the bottom line.)

AlbusDumbledore2234 · 04/11/2021 10:54

Do you love you partner? Is he a nice man, a good man, a decent person with values similar to yours? Will he be a positive role model to your children, and show them what a good man looks like? Will he stick around to help you raise your child, will he contribute financially and be an emotional support to you all?
Even if your relationship doesn't work out in the end, would you be able to co-parent and be on good friendly terms until your children reach adulthood, until with all the financial, physical and emotional support that will be needed to get your children through to adulthood happy and healthy?

Your choice of Father will determine whether you enjoy parenting, it will also determine your relationship with your children and could potentially cause a lot of negative emotions such as resentment and frustration with them but a lot of people will never ever admit to that.

This also works the other way round, absolutely, so men, beware pick the Mother of your children very very carefully.

Be careful who you chose to have a child with.

FigureofEight · 04/11/2021 10:53

I'd also say when both parents have the experience I've mentioned so much the better.

FigureofEight · 04/11/2021 10:53

Your own upbringing is a big predictor.

While of course there are exceptions I'm sure. Generally parents who struggle did not have a great experience growing up / ongoing support system. Not even one providing childcare but being there as extended family.

Honestly. I see this over and over. Those from happy solid families are happy solid adults who make happy solid marriages and brilliant parents. Because they had a good model and support.

There are exceptions and I much admire those who pull it off have historical relational trauma , abuse and more. Wish I was one of them....

Vbree · 04/11/2021 10:49

@RealMermaid

Do you like spending time around kids? Seems wildly obvious but I'm often surprised that prior who don't like kids or have spent very little time around them are then very shocked that they don't love parenting...
I don't particularly like other people's children. Love my own!
whosaidtha · 04/11/2021 10:49

I agree with lots of this. Partner pulling their weight is essential.
I think temperament of the child plays a massive part.
Also if you are a perfectionist or put pressure on yourself. You can't do that as a parent because you can't be perfect all the time. No one is.

MareofBeasttown · 04/11/2021 10:45

@RealMermaid

Do you like spending time around kids? Seems wildly obvious but I'm often surprised that prior who don't like kids or have spent very little time around them are then very shocked that they don't love parenting...
I don't like other people's kids. I like my own.
RealMermaid · 04/11/2021 10:39

Do you like spending time around kids? Seems wildly obvious but I'm often surprised that prior who don't like kids or have spent very little time around them are then very shocked that they don't love parenting...

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/11/2021 10:34

I don’t think you can because there are so, so many variables. There are a few factors that people have mentioned that make it more likely you’ll enjoy it (patience, money, time, a partner who pulls his weight, etc). But they aren’t guarantees.

Also, parenthood is an ever-changing journey. I hated being the parent of a newborn. I mostly love being the parent of a toddler, although I didn’t like it that much at 5.15 this morning. Will I enjoy being the parent of a pre-schooler, primary-age child, tween, teenager, young adult? I honestly don’t know because I have no idea what challenges those stages are going to hold.

DeepaBeesKit · 04/11/2021 10:27

Selflessness is key imho
Generally the people i know who are happiest with kids are the ones who were ready & willing to put children's needs ahead of their own preferences for a few years, and were prepared for having far less time & money for their own hobbies etc.

Seeline · 04/11/2021 10:24

[quote MareofBeasttown]@HugeAckmansWife I love " keep all your fucks in a closely guarded bucket":) I am trying to do that. But as a parent of 2 young adults, the thing I find most difficult is that I can no longer fix their problems instantly with an icecream or a trip to the park. Now they have big, massive problems that I can't fix easily. Depression. Heartbreak. Uni problems. Collapsing economy. I found it so much easier when they were little, even with the lack of sleep.

Sorry to whinge so much; am having a v hard day and overposting on AIBU. Will go away now.[/quote]
I think this is very important. Parenting is a lifetime commitment.

Your child(ren)'s needs change daily, monthly, yearly. Your ability to provide for those needs will change too. THat can have a massive impact on whether you 'like' being a parent.

Mine are late teens/ early 20s now. I found the early years so much easier as a parent.

Hardbackwriter · 04/11/2021 10:23

@HugeAckmansWife

But the money and partner things can change in an instant can't they, so it has also have something to do with resilience, calm and being able to put or keep things in perspective. If you catastrophise and overly fret about all aspects of life / parenting / screen time / diet / school reading level / role in the nativity it makes for a high stress environment. If you can generally keep most of your fucks in a closely guarded bucket and only let one go in serious circumstances it does help.
I really agree with this but I also think it's such an easy trap to fall into. I just posted on a thread about anxiety saying that I have had my (once clinical and severe) anxiety really well managed for years now but I sometimes find it hard that worry is so valorised as a part of motherhood. It's really pushed in many ways that how much you worry about your children is a mark of how much you love them (I find MN particularly bad for this) and that objectively excessive anxiety is 'good mothering'. I have to work hard and draw on my CBT to remind myself that actually worry achieves nothing and that not freaking out about every tiny thing is healthy not a sign I don't care.
MareofBeasttown · 04/11/2021 10:17

@HugeAckmansWife I love " keep all your fucks in a closely guarded bucket":) I am trying to do that. But as a parent of 2 young adults, the thing I find most difficult is that I can no longer fix their problems instantly with an icecream or a trip to the park. Now they have big, massive problems that I can't fix easily. Depression. Heartbreak. Uni problems. Collapsing economy. I found it so much easier when they were little, even with the lack of sleep.

Sorry to whinge so much; am having a v hard day and overposting on AIBU. Will go away now.

Hardbackwriter · 04/11/2021 10:16

Being a parent is a million times easier if you have a partner who genuinely does half - I see some of the posts here where people talk about not being able to have a night out for years/never having a lie in/ having no time to themselves/etc and I find it quite hard to fathom how this can be the case with two parents.

People on MN are very insistent that there's no way of knowing of your partner will be shit prior to having children but that isn't my real-life experience - I could have told you very accurately which of my friends or even colleagues it would be who ended up not even being able to have a cup of coffee without bringing all their children because 'Mike works six days a week and then cycles on Sunday' or 'Dave couldn't cope with them both alone, hahaha!'

HugeAckmansWife · 04/11/2021 10:13

But the money and partner things can change in an instant can't they, so it has also have something to do with resilience, calm and being able to put or keep things in perspective. If you catastrophise and overly fret about all aspects of life / parenting / screen time / diet / school reading level / role in the nativity it makes for a high stress environment. If you can generally keep most of your fucks in a closely guarded bucket and only let one go in serious circumstances it does help.

MareofBeasttown · 04/11/2021 10:13

Oh also I did not predict a global pandemic, and neither did many of my friends, who are also finding it hard to parent right now, despite advantages.

MareofBeasttown · 04/11/2021 10:08

I mostly did not regret being a parent until the last 3 years when DD has developed crippling depression and anxiety. She has had every advantage mentioned here, as have had I. No money worries, plenty of help etc etc.

You can't predict. Sadly. Nobody else in the family has depression so I did not foresee it.

Briezey · 04/11/2021 10:07

I think it real helps if:

  • you have a realistic idea about what it involves, e.g. you have been closely involved with children before.
  • you genuinely like children/find them interesting/enjoy seeing them develop.
  • you are a reflective and self-aware person.
  • obviously, you have enough money and support and a decent partner. These are basics imo.
rrhuth · 04/11/2021 10:07

Disagree utterly about introverts, I'm one and am a very happy parent.

The main things that cause problems are, IMO:

  • selfishness
  • lack of flexibility
  • fixed ideas of how it will be
  • dislike of mess/chaos

But I don't know if you can know, it hits some people hard.

Vbree · 04/11/2021 10:05

Worried I would not enjoy it I mean!

Vbree · 04/11/2021 10:05

I worried I would enjoy being a parent as I'm quite an introvert and not the most patient person but I love it and can't imagine not being a parent now. Probably helps that my son is quite happy and easy going though.

Aria2015 · 04/11/2021 10:05

A couple of friends and myself were all pretty unsure about having kids. Tended to focus on the perceived negatives rather than positives and strangely we've all taken to it much better than we thought. On the other hand I have a few friends who were desperate to have kids and were a bit 'rainbows and sunshine' about it all and they were the ones who struggled with it. I've sometimes wondered if it's been about expectations going in? If they're too high or you're only anticipating the good bits, does that make it more likely you'll struggle? Maybe? But that can't account for the long term I wouldn't think as surely people just adjust? I've added more questions to you question haven't I!? Sorry! The answer is, I don't know! 🤣

whereisthekey · 04/11/2021 10:03

oh main one I forgot, having a partner who genuinely helps out 50/50 with life!

AMistakePlusKeleven · 04/11/2021 10:03

I don’t think you can. I had such a dysfunctional family, a terrible childhood. I’m inpatient, I have mental health problems and on paper I’d make a terrible parent but I love it. Every part of it fills me with joy and I actively enjoy it. I’m not perfect but I try my hardest and I have given them a completely different childhood than I had. My siblings who may have been more suited to children on paper have unfortunately repeated the cycle of being a parent that doesn’t enjoy parenting or life with children.