Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughter refusing to wear most of the clothing she owns

216 replies

Pinklilly123 · 04/11/2021 07:54

Is this normal?

She’s 7. Won’t wear jeans (mostly as they aren’t comfortable which I understand), won’t wear anything too girly or flowery, no dresses or skirts. She puts them on and changes her mind. It’s honestly infuriating me! She begs me to buy things in shops which I will because I just want her to wear something that isn’t a holey pair of leggings in black or grey and a grey or black hoody. She won’t wear anything but this even to parties. I buy stuff they she removes the tags and never wears it. We try it on first if we can before buying but some changing rooms remain closed so that’s not easy. I replace leggings often but realistically they get worn a few times and they end up with holes or stains even m&s or gap ones. Her much loved hoody’s are so worn they make her look unkempt. Am I being unreasonable? Is this normal for a 7 yo? My friends girls are into pretty dresses still and will wear anything. Her style is so particularly it’s driving me around the twist not to mention all the wasted money and bags of practically brand new clothes I’ve given away to friends and charity shops

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 04/11/2021 09:34

@Bear2014

My 7 year old DD is fussy too. She won't wear jeans and will take against things for no real reason sometimes. I buy her big bundles of good quality second hand things from Ebay etc and the bits that she likes go into rotation - the bits she doesn't go in the charity/hand me down pile. It is really annoying, we're already on our second attempt this month at a winter coat that she will wear. I do think she's particularly sensitive to collars, seams, hard-feeling things etc.
A quick comment on coats - DS has significant sensory processing issues and DD has, I suspect, some very very mild ones. Coats are a huge issue because they're so restrictive. This is especially true for sensory children who are a little on the larger side (which is common, for reasons I've never understood).

DD has had a series of Michael Kohrs coats, purchased cheaply from TK MAXX as they offer her far more moveabiility. For DS, I've bought those puffer-style coats from Mountain Warehouse or Trespass and sometimes they do a hardier coat that's still very soft. Trespass this year less good than Mountain Warehouse (or at least, in our local store) so it's worth checking both. We've got one of those two-in-one fleece/rain coats from Mountain Warehouse this year which will be fine except for the absolute depth of winter, when he'll revert to his Trespass coat from last year which still fits.

These adjustments have completely changed the coat buying and wearing experience for us.

Triffid1 · 04/11/2021 09:30

DS was a lot like this and if I'm understanding correctly, your frustration is that sometimes she wants you to buy something that when you do she then subsequently refuses to wear it? We had that a little, but I started being quite strict in that I'd take him shopping and tell him that he could choose things, but then he had to wear them. And I'd insist he tried them on in the shop before I purchased!

I also limited what I bought in that he tended to prefer to simply rewear the same few things over and over again.

The good news is that as he's got older, his ability to manage the sensory issues is significantly improved. We bought jeans for the first time this weekend, which is a major breakthrough for us.

Bear2014 · 04/11/2021 09:28

My 7 year old DD is fussy too. She won't wear jeans and will take against things for no real reason sometimes. I buy her big bundles of good quality second hand things from Ebay etc and the bits that she likes go into rotation - the bits she doesn't go in the charity/hand me down pile. It is really annoying, we're already on our second attempt this month at a winter coat that she will wear. I do think she's particularly sensitive to collars, seams, hard-feeling things etc.

BelleOfTheProvince · 04/11/2021 09:26

I think if you examine this you'll find it stems from your stereotypical ideas of what a girl should do. Unless you were posting about getting your son's to wear starchy shirts for smartness at the same age you should consider whether it's coming from a gender bias.

Absolutely nothing wrong with her wearing leggings and hoodies. This was what I wore as a child along with cycling shorts in summer and ripped jeans (not artfully ripped, I climbed up a tree ripped)

If you wouldn't try and wrestle ypur boys into uncomfortable clothing for no reason you shouldn't with girls.
No wonder so many girls are rejecting their femaleness at the moment when people seems to think being a girl is synonymous with having uncomfortable, impractical clothing you can't do anything in.

Leggings are great for being active imo, even better than jeans. Have lots from the girls section for Ds as they are often softer and brighter colours.

naomi81 · 04/11/2021 09:26

My little girl is only 2 and is very fussy about clothes, will only wear leggings also, I find next to have the thickest ones that actually last. She won't let me wash or brush her hair 🤪 and don't think it's a padding phase unfortunately!

Kotatsu · 04/11/2021 09:25

My 8 year old likes leggings (ideally black), tshirts (these he's open to some kind of design), and hoodies (ideally black).

I get supermarket leggings - especially the thick ones that are out now it's winter, which cost about 3 quid, and either patch or replace them as he wears them out. Same with hoodies.

I don't worry about it - at some point he'll change his fashion choices, and until then at least it's easy shopping.

ThursdayLastWeek · 04/11/2021 09:23

I think she’s old enough to be told no the next time she nags you for stuff. And have the reasoning explained to her.

MintJulia · 04/11/2021 09:23

Stop taking her shopping. Listen to what she likes and will practically wear. Leggings and hoodies in subdued colours, fine.
For winter just make sure she has a warmer version (ski pants?' And a heavier fleece in the same colours.
If she wants to choose for herself, point her at the H&M website or whichever.

redtshirt50 · 04/11/2021 09:23

This sounds kind of like me, I always buy things I 'love' then never wear them Blush

I also love a baggy hoody, although I don't mind a bit of color.

LittleMysSister · 04/11/2021 09:20

Tbh I was very much like this myself, except I'd only wear jeans! I never ever wore dresses or skirts until I was about 17. Had a favourite few bits that I wore all the time.

I wouldn't worry about it too much, as long as she has some smarter stuff she can wear when actually needed.

RubyTuesday70 · 04/11/2021 09:20

That's girls for you.

My youngest was and still is horrendous about feel, texture and look. She buys loads online and sends it all back again..........

DH is exactly the same, and has an almost empty wardrobe as things have to "feel" right. Which is very very little. I could say it drives me mad but I get to use the space Grin

DietCokeChipsAndMayo · 04/11/2021 09:17

My eldest daughter always preferred leggings too, now at 10 we have also ventured to the dizzy heights of jeggings and cycling shorts too 🙌🏼
Leggings/tracksuits/hoodies/longline t-shirt’s are all in fashion now and you can get slightly smarter ones
This isn’t a hill I ever chose to die on

Member984815 · 04/11/2021 09:16

My daughter is the same so I only shop with her and let her pick stuff , still sometimes we end up with new stuff just grown out of without her wearing it . She has no sensory issues or sen that's just her style . She likes being comfy and to be honest I can't blame her

murcimari · 04/11/2021 09:16

Have you considered that she may have sensory issues? I'd definitely do some investigations. Especially if you notice that she prefers baggier, second hand clothing as it's not touching her skin and feels softer. Also, when next out shopping, see if she gravitates towards fluffy tops/jumpers. Does she even like wearing jumpers? My sensory sensitive child prefers cardigans because she can keep it open at the front. Tbh, when I read your post I immediately thought of my DD who started behaving very similarly around about 7 yrs of age, she's now 10. She always was a little different as a small child.

noscoobydoodle · 04/11/2021 09:15

Yes my DD is just like this (age 8 but a longstanding thing!). She is particular about materials and shapes and hates labels. It's been years since she wore a dress or skirt. She likes clothes from gap, who do a nice soft boxy t-shirt range which is not quite cropped but similar style, have no labels at the neck and come in a variety of colours and patterns. Also a good selection of leggings and hoodies. She picks online and send anything back she doesn't like. We don't often shop in person as she needs plenty of time to try on and think about it!

FatAnkles · 04/11/2021 09:14

DD was a bit like this. She's rejected structured fitted clothing for tracksuits, leggings and t-shirts. She often shopped (and still does!) in the boys section because she said the clothes were more comfy. She was out of "girly, sparkling" stuff by 8 years old. Her secondary school uniform is quite fitted so it's heaven to her putting on comfy relaxed clothes after she comes home. My daughter loves oversized baggy jumpers!

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/11/2021 09:13

My dd was the same. So many unworn clothes throughout the years. She went through a stage at about 6 of only wanting to wear one dress at home and one particularly washed out school blouse and two washed out school skirts. I managed to get a size up in the skirts and washed them to death before swapping them over but the size up in blouses was slightly different. So many issues with school uniform in primary.

Her sensory issues have improved a lot now at 13. Then there was the stage maybe in yr6 she wanted all new clothes - a different style and no dresses, which she’d practically lived in until then so I bought a whole new wardrobe eg a bunch of leggings, 3 jumpers and she only ever wore one jumper, had a favourite a couple of pairs of the leggings etc. And some were not right as no one else had them etc. So an element of trying to fit in.

Don’t listen to suggestions of not buying your dd clothes and chucking out those with holes in them. It will cause her massive distress. With my dd, I would insist she wore nicer clothes if we were going somewhere special. But she liked party dresses, possibly as they were pretty, soft and silky.

If I could do my time again, I would not buy as many things. The problem was, like you, we would get things home, take the tags out and she’d find something wrong with them (itchy) or just say she’d changed her mind. She still does it now. But now it’s for fashion reasons, to fit in, as she has now the ability to know when something isn’t comfortable.

I get it. It’s really really frustrating and wasteful. Charity shops had a field day.

Athrawes · 04/11/2021 09:13

My son has no desire to wear impractical dresses and uncomfortable fabrics. He prefers joggers and t shirts and hoodies. Preferably well washed and soft.
So why would a girl be any different?

Xmassprout · 04/11/2021 09:12

Stop buying the girly clothes and skirts. Just replace the leggings and hoodies when needed

astoundedgoat · 04/11/2021 09:10

Stop trying to dress her in the clothes you think she ought to wear, and listen to her - she wants to wear leggings and hoodies, so.... let her? It's not like she's trying to wear something mad or impractical.

H&M have leggings that are kind of thicker and almost fleecy on the inside, and they're nice and warm and don't get holes in the knee or crotch so quickly. Long hoodie that keeps her bum warm and you're grand.

My younger dd has always hated the way jeans feel behind her knees and refuses to wear them, although soft jeggings will pass if they're REALLY soft.

She's 7 and doesn't need to be smart, just clean.

WingingItSince1973 · 04/11/2021 09:09

Mum of 3 daughters. They all went through this. Honestly its normal and my girls would wear some bizarre combinations but I've always been of the mind that they wear what they feel comfortable and confident in. Two of my daughters have sensory issues so jeans were ruled out for many years but I'm the same too. She may want you to buy the dresses etc as she might be feeling she should be wearing them and then regrets it when she actually has to wear them. Maybe buy some smart casual clothes for her when you go somewhere special but just let her wear what she's comfortable in. As long as she's clean and happy I would just go with the flow. Xxx

Etonmessisyum · 04/11/2021 09:08

Sounds like she enjoys being comfy and perhaps with 3 brothers she wants to wear similar to them? Or that’s just her style. I have 4 boys so no experience of dressing a girl but if she’s not interested in pink/dresses then that’s fine not all women wear skirts and dresses etc.
M
Bonus it must be quite cheap to dress her but I would say no to the stuff she points out and never wears. My son has additional needs and wears jogging bottoms every single day they are comfy he has lovely soft t shirts no tags etc. He’s quite happy. I get him patterned joggies for weekends so they aren’t all ‘school’ uniform bottoms but def helps as these are easy items to pick up in town and cheap.

ginnybag · 04/11/2021 09:02

Move towards good quality jumper dresses and leggings as a 'smarter' compromise.

If you can add a pair of knee or ankle boots, or even ballet flats, you'll get your 'smart' look, without making her wear clothes she doesn't like.

My DD lives in leggings - always has; she hates all other forms of pants and hates having bare legs - and whilst she can and has worn 'frilly' dresses for some properly 'posh' occasions (where the adults were in Black Tie), we've done meals out, theatres, parties and all sorts on a variation of the leggings/top/skirt or leggings/jumper dress/even leggings under summer dress plus boots/flats/sandals.

The right combination of leggings/boots (particularly if you can find knee boots) etc can actually look very chic and stylish, if a little alternative in a young child.

defnotadomesticgoddess · 04/11/2021 09:01

My dd has been like this since she was tiny. Now she’s older (early 20s) she chooses mostly to wear leggings with T-shirt’s. Occasionally will wear jeans and dresses depending on the occasion. She def has had sensory issues so can only wear certain fabrics that are the right texture. She chooses her own clothes as I had a long while if buying things I thought she could bear the texture of but she couldn’t wear them. Alongside sensory issues other things that have affected clothes wearing for her have been low self esteem, body dysmphoria and I think undiagnosed autism. I wouldn’t make it into an issue let her wear what she’s ok with. If there are events she needs to dress up for let her choose something she can wear comfortably, There is no point trying to force a child with sensory issues into wearing particular clothes. They end up with increased anxiety about it and bigger problems to unravel. 💐

Idony · 04/11/2021 08:59

She's only 7. Stop giving her so much control. Don't take her to shops and let her convince you to buy things. She's probably overwhelmed. Plenty of adults buy shit in shops they don't want.

Get her a 3 pack of basics in the black and grey she likes, then don't engage in any fights about clothes (that's attention seeking) and make it all very boring, rather than such a big issue. Get dressed or lose privileges, just keep it simple and don't engage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread