Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rafiq racism at Yorkshire CC

82 replies

peoniesarejustperfect · 03/11/2021 19:23

Posting here for traffic as just so upset and disgusted to read about what has been happening at Yorkshire CC. The initial abuse and then it seems a cover up. Not sure if the whole story is out, but it just seems so shocking that a young, talented man would be subject to such horrible abuse by another young, talented man. Then for it to be dismissed by an inquiry. There's nothing to explain or justify it apart from pure nastiness. I am so pleased the sponsors are pulling out.

OP posts:
alexdgr8 · 04/11/2021 16:16

let's put andrew jennings on to the case, now that seppblatter and platini have been hoiked, at long last.
maybe he can winkle out what's going on, if anyone can.

Otherpeoplesteens · 04/11/2021 10:53

@araiwa

It really seems daft as fuck considering Yorkshire has a huge Asian population that tends to love cricket
Yorkshire CCC have such form on refusing recognition of Asian clubs that many of them formed their own tournament years ago and operate almost completely separately. This morning's article by Mihir Bose in the Guardian is a depressing read:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/nov/04/yorkshire-cricket-race-row-sport-azeem-rafiq

Otherpeoplesteens · 04/11/2021 10:50

@Libertaire

That’s an interesting statement by Ballance. He has been careful to avoid using the word ‘banter’, while making it very clear that, in his view, that is exactly what his verbal exchanges with Rafiq were. He also insists that the pair were close friends at the time. It will be equally interesting to hear Rafiq’s side of the story, of course.

As a big cricket fan, I have not heard any rumours about Ballance being a dickhead. You would think the fact that he is also good friends with Joe Root would tell you all you need to know about him, which makes these allegations all the more surprising.

The whole thing has been handled incredibly badly by Yorkshire and those responsible for this fiasco need to resign.

On the last England tour to Australia, with Ben Stokes sitting out because of his criminal charges and Jos Buttler not selected, there was a dearth of leadership in the touring party. Jimmy Anderson ended up as the designated Vice Captain even though he has never set a field in his life, never mind led a side. It's fairly widely acknowledged that Gary Ballance was in the touring party - at Joe Root's insistence - for the leadership, stability and example he brought to the squad, even though his selection was nowhere near justified on cricketing grounds and he was never likely to actually make it on to the field. Indeed, after the Jonny Bairstow headbutting incident Ballance's name featured regularly in the aftermath as someone trying to keep heads cool, limit damage, and prevent similar things happening again.

I don't want to deify someone who is frank about his use of racist language in this situation, but Ballance's role is what makes everything so puzzling. Ballance and Rafiq were by all accounts very close friends, close enough that Ballance invited Rafiq and his bowling coach to his parents' home in Zimbabwe. It doesn't add up. I don't know if Ballance is a closet racist, but that fits with nothing I do know about him.

I also don't know whether Ballance is being lined up as a fall guy, but the peak of his career is probably behind him, he's not a true Yorkshireman either, and it's a theory that happens to fit what we do know and might reasonably infer from what's been revealed so far.

Nobody in or near cricket seems to think Yorkshire doesn't have a serious problem with race, or internal management and governance. It will be interesting to see what comes out.

It's also worth noting that cricket is one sport which is becoming distinctly less representative over the years. Asians make up nearly 40% of recreational players but just 4% of professional players. In the Eighties and Nineties black English cricketers were, if not common, at least not unusual, but the number of black professionals in the sport has fallen by 75% in 30 years. It is now also very unusual for anyone who is not from an already cricketing family or a Public School to go anywhere near the club system which feeds the counties. The game is virtually extinct in state schools.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 04/11/2021 10:34

I think there is a clear distinction between name calling between teams of the "whinging poms" v "bloody convicts" type (both of which I have heard at Ashes matches) and team members singling out an individual with pejorative comments based on his race.

Targeting an individual for racist abuse is never banter.

araiwa · 04/11/2021 10:22

It really seems daft as fuck considering Yorkshire has a huge Asian population that tends to love cricket

siestalady · 04/11/2021 10:08

@HarrietsChariot

Name-calling has always been a part of cricket, especially between teams (some of the "sledging" used by Australia is appalling) but also between team-mates. It's just part of the game, like football fans chanting "you're going home in a fucking ambulance" or similar.

As with anything, times change and what was acceptable before may not be acceptable now. But until the culture within the game changes, one kind of offensive behaviour will just be replaced by another.

I'm pretty sure that calling anyone a "paki" has never been acceptable.

Sick of the "name calling has always been part of cricket" gaslighting bollocks that both Yorkshire and the ECB have continually tried to hide behind.

HarrietsChariot · 04/11/2021 09:52

Name-calling has always been a part of cricket, especially between teams (some of the "sledging" used by Australia is appalling) but also between team-mates. It's just part of the game, like football fans chanting "you're going home in a fucking ambulance" or similar.

As with anything, times change and what was acceptable before may not be acceptable now. But until the culture within the game changes, one kind of offensive behaviour will just be replaced by another.

BlackAndGreen · 04/11/2021 09:44

@Extraonions

Cricket Fan here …. I can remember going to watch Lancs v York’s late 80s / Early 90s, and the Yorkshire fans singing “we’re all white”, in relation to thier thinly veiled racist policy of “only people born in Yorkshire” can play for us. It was grim
Yes, same. The likes of Yorkshire Tea pulling out, speaks volumes to me and others on the outside looking in.

The Yorkshire person who was at our District level club a while back was at pains to blame it all on Aseem Rafiq.

"Awkward character, couldn't take a joke" and so on. When I said I'd heard that kind of smear campaign many times before, re racism, away he ran.

ECB are bringing in a QC, but I'm not sure who.

We are conscious about the length of time that Azeem has waited for resolution and the toll that must be taking on his wellbeing and that of his family. We are sorry that, as a sport, this has not yet been resolved

They've tried to wear him down in my view. But this isn't going to go away.

Summerofcontent · 04/11/2021 09:03

@LizzieSiddal

I’m glad the sponsors are pulling out, also I think Rafic is due to give evidence in front of an MP committee. Those two things should be the final nail in the coffin for whoever is on the board of Yorkshire Cricket. It’s sounds an appalling, racist, toxic place and they should all go!
The ECB are also investigating
Squeezita · 04/11/2021 07:57

DH is from Bradford and says in the late 90s, people would chant at Bradford City stadium:

“stand up if you hate P***”

And the whole stadium would stand up Sad

And at Leeds Utd, a section would start chanting (in relation to the 2 fans stabbed in Istanbul):

“I’d rather be a P than a Turk”

And the whole stadium would chant it too.

It feels like things have barely changed.

LizzieSiddal · 04/11/2021 07:09

I’m glad the sponsors are pulling out, also I think Rafic is due to give evidence in front of an MP committee. Those two things should be the final nail in the coffin for whoever is on the board of Yorkshire Cricket. It’s sounds an appalling, racist, toxic place and they should all go!

Simonjt · 04/11/2021 07:00

Sadly those comments are essentially a weekly occurence if you’re Pakistani or even just South Asian. Sadly there are still too many people out there that are so racist that they choose to blame victims of racism for the racism they are exposed to, or they choose to pretend racism doesn’t exist and the victim is making it up.

There are people out there who will do anything to excuse racism, as their own racism means we aren’t really seen as people, or we’re seen as not being trustworthy etc.

Extraonions · 04/11/2021 06:47

Cricket Fan here …. I can remember going to watch Lancs v York’s late 80s / Early 90s, and the Yorkshire fans singing “we’re all white”, in relation to thier thinly veiled racist policy of “only people born in Yorkshire” can play for us. It was grim

Squeezita · 04/11/2021 03:30

*Azeem Rafiq

Squeezita · 04/11/2021 03:29

@Boobicoosg

I would not be surprised if the management was racist to the core. Keen to keep most ‘forriners’ out whilst sipping their ‘Yorkshire’ tea so proudly 😆

And if someone tells you they’ve been racislly abused, believe it. The ‘oh are you sure, I have a cousin of a friend of his dog’s that says he just wouldn’t do that’… is bloody tiresome.

Disgrace.

Glad to see Yorkshire Tea have dumped the YCCC. Grin 🤣
Squeezita · 04/11/2021 03:29

@SoniaFouler

For the people less in the know, is there anything we can search or find online to find out what *@Anordinarymum* is talking about? I’m intrigued, but don’t know anything about cricket so I have no idea what is meant by those posts
I’m not in the know but it sounds like an attempt to discredit Azeri Rafiq by Anordinarymum

I’m ignoring and not intrigued. She says it’s one sided, maybe that’s because YCCC won’t publish their findings about the racism allegations.

Boobicoosg · 04/11/2021 03:21

I would not be surprised if the management was racist to the core. Keen to keep most ‘forriners’ out whilst sipping their ‘Yorkshire’ tea so proudly 😆

And if someone tells you they’ve been racislly abused, believe it. The ‘oh are you sure, I have a cousin of a friend of his dog’s that says he just wouldn’t do that’… is bloody tiresome.

Disgrace.

SoniaFouler · 04/11/2021 01:48

For the people less in the know, is there anything we can search or find online to find out what @Anordinarymum is talking about? I’m intrigued, but don’t know anything about cricket so I have no idea what is meant by those posts

Backstreetsbackalrightdadada · 04/11/2021 01:35

Definite resignation needed. It seems crazy to me that when cricket is trying to run a campaign of “we’re for everyone” and getting new talent they’d even allow this. What sort of culture is there in Yorkshire cricket?! Just god awful and puts you right off, and imagine WORSE that as a whistleblower you just get ignored. Too awful!!!! Surely sponsors should be thinking of moving their money elsewhere if action isn’t taken?

PrincessFiorimonde · 04/11/2021 01:09

The whole thing has been handled incredibly badly by Yorkshire and those responsible for this fiasco need to resign.

Agree.

Libertaire · 04/11/2021 00:45

That’s an interesting statement by Ballance. He has been careful to avoid using the word ‘banter’, while making it very clear that, in his view, that is exactly what his verbal exchanges with Rafiq were. He also insists that the pair were close friends at the time. It will be equally interesting to hear Rafiq’s side of the story, of course.

As a big cricket fan, I have not heard any rumours about Ballance being a dickhead. You would think the fact that he is also good friends with Joe Root would tell you all you need to know about him, which makes these allegations all the more surprising.

The whole thing has been handled incredibly badly by Yorkshire and those responsible for this fiasco need to resign.

BlackAndGreen · 04/11/2021 00:17

Thanks for that, my gut feeling too. The whole thing is shifty as hell.
Outside Yorkshire, and just getting half stories.

However, it seems that the whole club leadership is rotten to the core, not only systemically racist, but bent as hell in all manner of things.
Ballance sounds like the man being made to walk the plank.

Anordinarymum · 04/11/2021 00:06

@BlackAndGreen

committees.parliament.uk/committee/378/digital-culture-media-and-sport-committee/news/158502/announcement-dcms-committee-to-call-in-yorkshire-county-cricket-club-chair-on-azeem-rafiq-report/

There is something rotten going on at Yorkshire for sure, and has been for a very long time. I was fed a load of waffle from someone associated with the club, at a cricket function, based on the usual" can't take banter" line.

In fact, when pressed, the gentleman concerned, could not get away fast enough.

Otherpeoplesteens reading your posts, I'm prompted to ask, do you feel that Gary Ballance is going to be made some kind of fall guy here? A kind of attempted damage limitation before the DCMS committee meeting?

This is what it looks like to me
BlackAndGreen · 04/11/2021 00:04

committees.parliament.uk/committee/378/digital-culture-media-and-sport-committee/news/158502/announcement-dcms-committee-to-call-in-yorkshire-county-cricket-club-chair-on-azeem-rafiq-report/

There is something rotten going on at Yorkshire for sure, and has been for a very long time. I was fed a load of waffle from someone associated with the club, at a cricket function, based on the usual" can't take banter" line.

In fact, when pressed, the gentleman concerned, could not get away fast enough.

Otherpeoplesteens reading your posts, I'm prompted to ask, do you feel that Gary Ballance is going to be made some kind of fall guy here? A kind of attempted damage limitation before the DCMS committee meeting?

Swipe left for the next trending thread