Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rafiq racism at Yorkshire CC

82 replies

peoniesarejustperfect · 03/11/2021 19:23

Posting here for traffic as just so upset and disgusted to read about what has been happening at Yorkshire CC. The initial abuse and then it seems a cover up. Not sure if the whole story is out, but it just seems so shocking that a young, talented man would be subject to such horrible abuse by another young, talented man. Then for it to be dismissed by an inquiry. There's nothing to explain or justify it apart from pure nastiness. I am so pleased the sponsors are pulling out.

OP posts:
HarrietsChariot · 17/11/2021 09:15

I don't necessarily condone it but I think cricket (and many sports) have a culture where it is acceptable to use terms of abuse to others. Often to opponents but also to "motivate" your team.

Cricket is notorious for "sledging" - a euphemism for abusing your opponent. Sometimes it puts the opponent off, other times they just deal with it. (E.g. when the Australians were playing England, one of them asked Ian Botham "How's your wife and my kid?" Botham replied, "My wife is fine, the kid is retarded.")

You only have to look at football to see how prevalent abuse is there - whole crowds of Neanderthal scum making abusive chants to their opponents.

People think racism is the problem, but they are missing the point. It shouldn't be the case that it's fine to be abusive just so long as it's not racist. Abusive language and behaviour should not be tolerated at all. It doesn't matter whether Rafiq was called a p-word or a b_n bastard or a cunt, it's the abuse that should be stamped out.

It's not a problem with Yorkshire CC, or English cricket, or cricket as a whole - it's a problem with almost all sport.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 17/11/2021 09:03

@Anordinarymum

There is more to this story than meets the eye. It's not just about racism. It's political and has been planned.
I hate posts like this - vague and pointless
wtaf37 · 17/11/2021 08:42

@Snoozer11

Reading Gary Ballance's statement it seems a shame it's come to this.

He says they were best friends at the time, very young and would go drinking with each other and the remarks were made in that context.

I can see how this is the case and I used to know people in similar situations.

Using that logic, it's therefore acceptable to call a colleague/teammate/friend a 'fattie' or 'Dumbo' or 'sheep sha££er' because they are overweight, have big ears or are from the country? "But we're having a drink and a larf..."
VladmirsPoutine · 16/11/2021 17:29

The thing is it's just so heartbreaking but I am not even a little bit shocked. This is the reality for a lot of ethnic minorities esp institutionally.

TomPinch · 16/11/2021 17:17

@araiwa

It really seems daft as fuck considering Yorkshire has a huge Asian population that tends to love cricket
And with hugely talented players too, and yet hardly any of them ever played for YCCC. Well now we know why.
Pohtaytoes · 16/11/2021 17:08

I feel disgusted at hearing what Rafiq has had to put up with, "bants"? Piss off its racism.

Was a Michael Vaughn fan too, I'm horrified at what's been going on.

Rafiq is a brave man, seen much abuse at him today on social media alone. Sad

mediciempire · 16/11/2021 16:47

@Otherpeoplesteens

"Shafiq?" Rafiq. Fucking autocorrect!

The border between Lincolnshire and Yorkshire has moved around a bit over the years: it is possible that the place of your birth has been both in Yorkshire and outside it over the years. If they are prepared to discriminate against you on the basis of a line on a map within sight of the Humber River, it's hardly surprising that they might discriminate against someone brown born in Karachi, even if that individual was British enough to captain England at age-group level.

It's unfortunate that Gary Ballance's involvement as the 'senior player' involved in the use of the "P-word" has become public tonight, particularly as he is clearly the individual on the receiving end of the "Zimbo" comments. This particular dynamic obviously has still to reveal its secrets, but I happen to know Gary's family near Harare and I can tell you that the idea he is racist is inconceivable. Nothing has been said of the more junior players who were apparently also involved.

All the same, Yorkshire is not going to emerge from this with much credit - no matter how much they say they will - and their refusal to release the full unredacted reports is even more baffling. Several more sponsors have withdrawn their support today.

I'll watch with interest, but I can't imaging wanting to pay to go into Headingley again.

well he was racist. he was brutally racist. some of the comments he has made are despicable and he had his drug use covered up by the clubs. he has admitted using racist language. it is funnily enough absolutely conceivable that gary ballance is racist.
CricketCat · 06/11/2021 15:20

@phishy “I’m Asian and how would have reacted to being called a Paki at 17 is very different to how I would have reacted now, 20 years later.”

Me too. I’ve been following this since last year and tbh not shocked at how little publicity it received. But I’m really happy with how this is going now. It feels like a win for every time I was ever called a paki or a curry muncher.
The fact Azeem Rafiq did this alone, I can only take my hat off to him.

burblish · 06/11/2021 14:43

@phishy “I’m Asian and how would have reacted to being called a Paki at 17 is very different to how I would have reacted now, 20 years later.”

Same here. It was so degrading to feel so powerless when it happened back then.

burblish · 06/11/2021 14:39

Not surprising to hear that other Asian players are now reporting they encountered similar things to Azeem Rafiq at Yorkshire.

phishy · 06/11/2021 09:51

I agree it’s systemic racism.

As to the ‘banter’ defence, Azeem joined YCCC at the age of 17, the culture of white vs Asian would have been inculcated into him, like a slowly boiling frog. Others have reported that in the breaks from cricket, football matches were played white vs Asian, and that comments were made that ‘too many Pakis’ were getting through to the club.

I’m Asian and how would have reacted to being called a Paki at 17 is very different to how I would have reacted now, 20 years later.

Etinoxaurus · 06/11/2021 07:26

My take on it is that it’s systemic. The personal relationships are a distracting side show. And by systemic I mean racism is in the bones of the club, sport and bloody Yorkshire. So many horrible situations enabled up by the system Yorkshire ripper, Holbrook, Jimmy Saville, Rotherham girls, Yorkshire police, even the phrase God’s own Country. Angry

BaconMassive · 05/11/2021 11:54

@Libertaire

That’s an interesting statement by Ballance. He has been careful to avoid using the word ‘banter’, while making it very clear that, in his view, that is exactly what his verbal exchanges with Rafiq were. He also insists that the pair were close friends at the time. It will be equally interesting to hear Rafiq’s side of the story, of course.

As a big cricket fan, I have not heard any rumours about Ballance being a dickhead. You would think the fact that he is also good friends with Joe Root would tell you all you need to know about him, which makes these allegations all the more surprising.

The whole thing has been handled incredibly badly by Yorkshire and those responsible for this fiasco need to resign.

Rafiq - Ballance - Root. The England Test Captain.
BlackAndGreen · 05/11/2021 11:40

Oh, and a rule which forbids Board members from commenting in public about Club goings on, on pain of being thrown out of the Club.
Very Stalinist.

BlackAndGreen · 05/11/2021 11:38

I've just had a look at their club rules.

Section 8 deals with Misconduct.
" Bringing the game into disrepute" appears to apply to members, as well as players ,racially abusing players. And usual rules provision for hearings, listening to evidence , sanctions etc

Nowhere do I see a clause saying, "this section does not apply if you are a players grandad".

It could have been dealt with. They chose not to.

( A hollow laugh from me, regarding section 4. Objects of the Club and their commitment to coaching and encouraging diversity)

logsonlogsoff · 05/11/2021 11:15

My 12 year old is in a cricket team with half a dozen non white players and I can’t imagine a world in which those boys would either think it’s okay to use that language against anyone, let alone a friend and team mate, or have to put up with being on the recipe ing end of it.

logsonlogsoff · 05/11/2021 11:11

The racism is appalling enough, but the handling of it even worse. Yorkshire are screwed, as they should be. The ECB are coming down like a ton of bricks, Nike have pulled their kit sponsorship, the Headingly sponsor Emerald have said they want their name off the ground ASAP.
Unfortunately it takes money, or the loss of it to make some institutions sit up and listen. And as for the ‘bants’ argument - oh please do fuck off. Even as a child 40 years ago the P word wasn’t consider okay to use.
And as for Michael Vaughan - deny it all you want, mate. You’re in that report for a reason.
I hope Rafiq standing up encourages other players to come forward about similar abuse. Everyone knows it goes on in cricket.

Otherpeoplesteens · 05/11/2021 10:59

I wonder if there is a structural issue with the way cricket is run here.

The ECB is controlled by the 18 counties who all act in their own self interest rather than the interest of the game at large or even the national teams.

Yorkshire CCC, like the other 17 counties, is a members' organisation so the first duty of its board is to the membership. I imagine it must be virtually unmanageable.

One of the complaints that Rafiq made is that during match he received racial abuse from a spectator. He reported it to the club which did nothing, although it also resulted in separate ECB and police investigations which found that... the spectator was the grandfather of one of the other players (and, presumably a member in his own right.) Of course nothing was done by Yorkshire.

BlackAndGreen · 05/11/2021 10:31

He was only there about 18 months wasn't he?
Quite a damning statement from him, and his request for help from ECB ignored, allegedly.

www.yorkshirepost.co.uk/news/politics/yorkshire-ccc-chairman-roger-hutton-resigns-over-azeem-rafiq-racism-scandal-3445976

.....a constant unwillingness from the executive members of the Board and senior management at the Club to apologise, and to accept that there was racism

The executive members of the board include chief executive Mark Arthur and director of cricket Martyn Moxon. While not directly named in the statement, he said they should resign.

burblish · 05/11/2021 09:42

I see Roger Hutton (chairman of the YCCC board) has resigned, as apparently have a number of non-exec directors. The club’s handling of this whole affair has been disgraceful.

robertcatesbynight · 04/11/2021 20:11

I think it was only because Azeem Rafiq has been invited to the House of Commons to give evidence and could name under parliamentary privilege that any statement was made on behalf of Gary Ballance. To me the cover-up for a long time is the worst thing about all this.

LizzieSiddal · 04/11/2021 18:20

It’s been announced by the EXB that Yorkshire have been banned from hosting International and major matches.

Great news!

BlackAndGreen · 04/11/2021 17:58

Geoff Boycott indeed. Don't mention women or colour to him, and definitely not at the same time, or he'll self combust.
He seems to be keeping a low profile on Twitter on this occasion. Sticking to supporting Yorkshire Air Ambulance when I last looked.

Bideshi · 04/11/2021 17:22

Well it is the county that spawned Geoff Boycott. It's got previous....

Porfre · 04/11/2021 17:14

[quote BlackAndGreen]twitter.com/AzeemRafiq30/status/1456169816050618375?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw[/quote]
There it is.

By making one person the fall guy, it isnt going get to the root of the problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread