Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rafiq racism at Yorkshire CC

82 replies

peoniesarejustperfect · 03/11/2021 19:23

Posting here for traffic as just so upset and disgusted to read about what has been happening at Yorkshire CC. The initial abuse and then it seems a cover up. Not sure if the whole story is out, but it just seems so shocking that a young, talented man would be subject to such horrible abuse by another young, talented man. Then for it to be dismissed by an inquiry. There's nothing to explain or justify it apart from pure nastiness. I am so pleased the sponsors are pulling out.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brefugee · 17/06/2022 09:15

there are many many tales of families racing back to the county to give birth in case it was a boy and could then play cricket for Yorkshire. They were the last county to give up that stipulation when taking on players, and frankly i think it's a bit of a shame that counties don't do that, but the modern game requires modern player policies.

But this case is shocking - and any woman who has been subject to sexual harassment that gets written off as "bantz" must surely feel solidarity here (unless they're a racist in which case "fuck you"). The reaction by Yorkshire CC is appalling and embarassing and it would be great if Yorkshire folk would write to them to let them know (I will be sending them an actual letter in an envelope).

The Zimbo thing is - well, i don't know. How did the Zimbabwe player really feel about that? did he feel that he had to put up with it or be ostracised or subject to worse? or did he genuinely not mind? it's difficult to answer that (sorry if the information is already out there)

What a fucking mess.

Meraas · 17/06/2022 08:39

Bumtum126 · 16/06/2022 08:49

They have been, 6 of the 7 aren't involved in the playing or coaching side of the game. The ECB can't do much with them. Probably give them a telling off. They have charged Yorkshire but again all those that let this go on have left so not sure what the point of any punishment will be.

I see, thanks Bumtum,

CherryReid · 16/06/2022 09:02

I think what contributes is the old fashioned, accepted racism.
I was brought up in the 50s 60s and racism was the norm- not deliberate cruelty but a basic acceptance of our superiority -after all they wanted to come here, so it must be better.
Yorkshire had a large influx of Asians with very different cultures and what got ingrained then was still in place today. Somehow YCC has not moved from those old attitudes.
But that is inexcusable. A few prison sentences will sharpen minds - and a some Asian players should improve the games.

Bumtum126 · 16/06/2022 08:49

They have been, 6 of the 7 aren't involved in the playing or coaching side of the game. The ECB can't do much with them. Probably give them a telling off. They have charged Yorkshire but again all those that let this go on have left so not sure what the point of any punishment will be.

Meraas · 16/06/2022 07:44

This is good news, but why aren’t the individuals named?

name and shame them.

balalake · 16/06/2022 07:37

I hope that belatedly Azeem Rafiq and others who have been treated disgracefully by Yorkshire CCC can finally get something approaching justice.

nettie434 · 16/06/2022 06:52

I think it's incredibly serious that the ECB are charging Yorkshire CCC as well as various individuals (names not confirmed yet) with bringing the game into disrepute. The whole way the club handled the situation is shocking. The cricket establishment is also at fault for not questioning why a county with so many local cricket teams has had so few Yorkshire born Asians in the first team.

We all know about the racist abuse that players receive from spectators but Azeem Rafiq's experiences, and the example of the sacked Crawley Town manager in football, show that racism exists at multiple levels in sport.

Reading your post, kd44, reminded me of an excellent article by the (now) Real Madrid player, Toni Rudiger:

www.theplayerstribune.com/posts/antonio-ruediger-champions-league-soccer-racism-chelsea

It's easy to condemn racism when it is committed by others but when it reflects on our own community or workplace, it's harder for some people to acknowledge.

Kd44 · 16/06/2022 05:28

It feels.like a lot of white MNers love a racism thread because they can all hug and comfort each other as they are so disgusted and distressed by it. Then an actual brown person posts about their perceived discrimination and the self same people gang up and use terms like playing the racist card.

Sparro · 15/06/2022 19:09

www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/61808315

Planned by who?

depremesnil · 22/11/2021 12:21

@LegBreakGoogly

I'm a big cricket fan and like both *@Otherpeoplesteens and @Libertaire* had heard nothing within the game about Ballance being a dickhead; pretty much the opposite really.

Not to diminish the suffering that Azeem Rafiq has clearly experienced, but I can easily believe that an 18 year old separated from his family could have gone to Yorkshire and become racist, either consciously to fit in or possibly without even realising it - i.e. institutionalised. In other circumstances we might call the same thing radicalisation.

This is a club where virtually everyone is accused of being one, where racist behaviours were so normalised that no-one in the team thought to speak out and say it was wrong, and literally no-one in the entire club appears to have noticed that an Asian player was becoming suicidal because of it. Even Joe Root seems to have not noticed any racism at Yorks; this is the same Joe Root who called out homophobia on the pitch in a Test against West Indies, the Joe Root who would have been put through all the E&D stuff at the ECB as part of his England role.

I have no interest in apologising for a racist, but I am concerned that focusing on the perpetrator and throwing him under the bus is a bit too convenient when there is clearly an institutional issue at play here.

The Harry analogy is spot on because by all accounts the Army is the same. Similarly, I doubt most MPs go into Parliament to become corrupt or to fiddle their expenses, but they all seem to end up doing it and not finding it wrong.

You can't call someone the P word and not be a dickhead.

And I'm still appalled by the comment that Ballance has a good reason to be racist because his parents come from Zimbabwe.

LegBreakGoogly · 22/11/2021 12:19

I'm a big cricket fan and like both @Otherpeoplesteens and @Libertaire had heard nothing within the game about Ballance being a dickhead; pretty much the opposite really.

Not to diminish the suffering that Azeem Rafiq has clearly experienced, but I can easily believe that an 18 year old separated from his family could have gone to Yorkshire and become racist, either consciously to fit in or possibly without even realising it - i.e. institutionalised. In other circumstances we might call the same thing radicalisation.

This is a club where virtually everyone is accused of being one, where racist behaviours were so normalised that no-one in the team thought to speak out and say it was wrong, and literally no-one in the entire club appears to have noticed that an Asian player was becoming suicidal because of it. Even Joe Root seems to have not noticed any racism at Yorks; this is the same Joe Root who called out homophobia on the pitch in a Test against West Indies, the Joe Root who would have been put through all the E&D stuff at the ECB as part of his England role.

I have no interest in apologising for a racist, but I am concerned that focusing on the perpetrator and throwing him under the bus is a bit too convenient when there is clearly an institutional issue at play here.

The Harry analogy is spot on because by all accounts the Army is the same. Similarly, I doubt most MPs go into Parliament to become corrupt or to fiddle their expenses, but they all seem to end up doing it and not finding it wrong.

depremesnil · 21/11/2021 15:07

@Otherpeoplesteens

This particular dynamic obviously has still to reveal its secrets, but I happen to know Gary's family near Harare and I can tell you that the idea he is racist is inconceivable.

'He would constantly talk down to me and make racist jokes, designed to undermine me and make me feel small, like coming up and interrupting when I was talking to girls in a club, saying 'don't talk to him, he's a P*'.

Both of these statements can't be true.

danzig · 17/11/2021 20:07

@Otherpeoplesteens

"Shafiq?" Rafiq. Fucking autocorrect!

The border between Lincolnshire and Yorkshire has moved around a bit over the years: it is possible that the place of your birth has been both in Yorkshire and outside it over the years. If they are prepared to discriminate against you on the basis of a line on a map within sight of the Humber River, it's hardly surprising that they might discriminate against someone brown born in Karachi, even if that individual was British enough to captain England at age-group level.

It's unfortunate that Gary Ballance's involvement as the 'senior player' involved in the use of the "P-word" has become public tonight, particularly as he is clearly the individual on the receiving end of the "Zimbo" comments. This particular dynamic obviously has still to reveal its secrets, but I happen to know Gary's family near Harare and I can tell you that the idea he is racist is inconceivable. Nothing has been said of the more junior players who were apparently also involved.

All the same, Yorkshire is not going to emerge from this with much credit - no matter how much they say they will - and their refusal to release the full unredacted reports is even more baffling. Several more sponsors have withdrawn their support today.

I'll watch with interest, but I can't imaging wanting to pay to go into Headingley again.

You seem determined to apologise for a racist.
caketiger · 17/11/2021 17:43

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

givethatbabyaname · 17/11/2021 15:00

but nobody seriously suggested that Harry is a card-carrying bona fide racist then, or now.

I don’t want to make this not about the YCCC, but this does go to the point about banter. Comments like this refer to the sliding scale of racism, from KKK/lynching level racism to overhearing someone call you a P* on the bus. @Otherpeoplesteens, you’re effectively saying ‘at least this wasn’t KKK-level’ racism. It wasn’t. And?

GBH isn’t as bad as murder. And?

Groping on the dance floor isn’t as bad as sexual assault at knifepoint. And?

Why should someone be allowed to make another suffer, however much or little, because they’re having fun, or are ignorant, or just want to?

Racism is such a complex thing. There are few clear boundaries EXCEPT that it’s unacceptable in all forms, at all times. There’s no excuse for it. Plenty of meaningless explanations, but no excuses.

There was also never any excuse for it decades ago. It’s absolute bullshit people saying some things were acceptable decades ago and should be judged in their historical context. Acceptable for the perpetrators’ consciences maybe, but it was NEVER okay to the victims or to those who fought against it. Further, anti-racism isn’t a modern invention. People have been anti-racist since the beginning of people, they just have a louder voice at this moment in time.

Racism in Zimbabwe and Zambia are multi-fold more complex than in the U.K., given the massively different historical context. Still, there is no excuse for it. Period.

It’s never okay to sexually abuse someone just a little bit, or not too badly, or as a joke. Equally, it’s never okay to racially abuse someone just a little bit, or not too badly, or as a joke. Coming from a ‘good family’ changes nothing. Being friends changes nothing (look up statistics on marital rape). There’s a single hard line, and it’s NO. NEVER. IT’S NEVER OKAY.

shylatte · 17/11/2021 14:12

I'm glad this has come to light and hopefully people can be held accountable. The 'banter' card is so old, I'm flummoxed that this was upheld.

C8H10N4O2 · 17/11/2021 14:05

We can sit here and say it's wrong all we like, but young men of all backgrounds easily morph into products of the environments around them - in this case, toxic ones

So that's ok?

Its bigotry not the weather.

depremesnil · 17/11/2021 13:06

@Otherpeoplesteens

What's inconceivable about a man who uses racial slurs being racist?

Why am I not surprised that there are people on MN defending these racist scumbags?

Simon Ballance, Gary's father, was one of the very few white farmers to have survived Mugabe's 'land reforms' with both his livelihood and his life intact. Many of their friends were murdered by stooges of the ruling party, Zanu-PF, simply for being white. You'd think they have better reason than most to be racist but in my experience most the overwhelming majority of white Zimbabweans are just not like that and everything I know about the Ballances suggests the same. Most regard themselves as African first and foremost; black employees on the farms are viewed as analogous to extended families and many white farmers were killed protecting their staff.

Prince Harry was filmed in 2009 calling an army colleague "our little Paki friend" and saying "fuck me, you look like a raghead" to someone in a camouflage veil. He apologised at the time it was revealed by the News of the Screws and it was widely condemned at the time - rightly so - but nobody seriously suggested that Harry is a card-carrying bona fide racist then, or now. Nobody has so far rebutted Gary Ballance's claim that he and Rafiq regarded themselves as good friends for a significant amount of time.

We can sit here and say it's wrong all we like, but young men of all backgrounds easily morph into products of the environments around them - in this case, toxic ones.

You'd think they have better reason than most to be racist

There's no good or better reason for being racist.

You can make up all the excuses you want, someone who uses racist slurs and insults is racist.

Nobody has so far rebutted Gary Ballance's claim that he and Rafiq regarded themselves as good friends for a significant amount of time.

So it's okay to be racist to someone if you regard them as a friend?

Otherpeoplesteens · 17/11/2021 12:46

What's inconceivable about a man who uses racial slurs being racist?

Why am I not surprised that there are people on MN defending these racist scumbags?

Simon Ballance, Gary's father, was one of the very few white farmers to have survived Mugabe's 'land reforms' with both his livelihood and his life intact. Many of their friends were murdered by stooges of the ruling party, Zanu-PF, simply for being white. You'd think they have better reason than most to be racist but in my experience most the overwhelming majority of white Zimbabweans are just not like that and everything I know about the Ballances suggests the same. Most regard themselves as African first and foremost; black employees on the farms are viewed as analogous to extended families and many white farmers were killed protecting their staff.

Prince Harry was filmed in 2009 calling an army colleague "our little Paki friend" and saying "fuck me, you look like a raghead" to someone in a camouflage veil. He apologised at the time it was revealed by the News of the Screws and it was widely condemned at the time - rightly so - but nobody seriously suggested that Harry is a card-carrying bona fide racist then, or now. Nobody has so far rebutted Gary Ballance's claim that he and Rafiq regarded themselves as good friends for a significant amount of time.

We can sit here and say it's wrong all we like, but young men of all backgrounds easily morph into products of the environments around them - in this case, toxic ones.

depremesnil · 17/11/2021 11:38

She also said it doesn't matter that it was specifically racist abuse. It does.

buffyajp · 17/11/2021 11:36

Can’t argue with that

buffyajp · 17/11/2021 11:36

@depremesnil

People think racism is the problem, but they are missing the point. It shouldn't be the case that it's fine to be abusive just so long as it's not racist. Abusive language and behaviour should not be tolerated at all. It doesn't matter whether Rafiq was called a p-word or a b_n bastard or a cunt, it's the abuse that should be stamped out.

If definitely matters. Don't act like racism isn't a problem here.

She isn’t. She’s saying all forms of abuse are wrong. Surely you can argue with that?
depremesnil · 17/11/2021 11:36

@Otherpeoplesteens

"Shafiq?" Rafiq. Fucking autocorrect!

The border between Lincolnshire and Yorkshire has moved around a bit over the years: it is possible that the place of your birth has been both in Yorkshire and outside it over the years. If they are prepared to discriminate against you on the basis of a line on a map within sight of the Humber River, it's hardly surprising that they might discriminate against someone brown born in Karachi, even if that individual was British enough to captain England at age-group level.

It's unfortunate that Gary Ballance's involvement as the 'senior player' involved in the use of the "P-word" has become public tonight, particularly as he is clearly the individual on the receiving end of the "Zimbo" comments. This particular dynamic obviously has still to reveal its secrets, but I happen to know Gary's family near Harare and I can tell you that the idea he is racist is inconceivable. Nothing has been said of the more junior players who were apparently also involved.

All the same, Yorkshire is not going to emerge from this with much credit - no matter how much they say they will - and their refusal to release the full unredacted reports is even more baffling. Several more sponsors have withdrawn their support today.

I'll watch with interest, but I can't imaging wanting to pay to go into Headingley again.

What's inconceivable about a man who uses racial slurs being racist?

Why am I not surprised that there are people on MN defending these racist scumbags?

depremesnil · 17/11/2021 11:28

People think racism is the problem, but they are missing the point. It shouldn't be the case that it's fine to be abusive just so long as it's not racist. Abusive language and behaviour should not be tolerated at all. It doesn't matter whether Rafiq was called a p-word or a b_n bastard or a cunt, it's the abuse that should be stamped out.

If definitely matters. Don't act like racism isn't a problem here.

TomPinch · 17/11/2021 09:22

Political?

Either this kind of thing was happening or it wasn't. From the Guardian:

Rafiq, who is Muslim, said he started drinking “to fit in” at Yorkshire, something he has “come to regret”. When asked by Knight if he was ever forced to drink under the age of 18, Rafiq said he was pinned down while a player for his local cricket club in his mid‑teens and had red wine poured down his throat. He said someone who played for Yorkshire and Hampshire was involved. In his witness statement to the employment tribunal, Rafiq added: “At YCCC, it was never forced, but there was an entrenched drinking culture which had the effect of isolating Muslim Asian players: if you didn’t drink, you didn’t fit in.

Disgusting. Disgusting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread