Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at ASD assessment

63 replies

TEH82 · 03/11/2021 19:02

So DS 7 was diagnosed with ASD a few months ago and it takes a few weeks for it to come through. It has come today and in 2 separate places it refers to him as ‘odd’ in the context of ‘child’s eye contact and interaction is extremely odd’
I work in health with children and would never dream of writing this about a child let alone in a report that will follow him for years- but not sure if I am being precious?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TableFlowerss · 06/11/2021 14:18

[quote PixieLaLa]@TableFlowerss You do realise atypical means ‘not typical’ which means unusual, which means different, which means odd.[/quote]
If you genuinely can’t understand why the OP would be miffed then there’s no point in me explaining, there’s no hope.

HeidiHaus · 06/11/2021 09:43

I would say inappropriate language, yes. Who diagnosed him, OP?

Watchingyouwazowski · 06/11/2021 08:24

@LennyMurdoch

ASD has been rebranded to ASC these days,

According to who?

My local health authority, I’m now assuming. I was surprised to see everyone referring to ASD in this post. Where I live it’s been called ASC for well over 18 months and I assumed that was what it was now called everywhere. I must be wrong! Never assume, eh?
ToastieSnowy · 04/11/2021 07:21

The Camhs woman who assessed my DS for ASD used the term “odd” to describe his behaviour in the assessment then used it in her diagnosis report. Yes he was diagnosed with ASD, yes her use of odd still irritates me 10 years later.

Vanishun · 04/11/2021 07:18

I was diagnosed autistic as an adult, and would describe myself as odd. I am. So this wouldn't bother me whatsoever.

Its got me wondering if this is something that almost autistic people wouldn't think twice on, but clearly relatives would be super-upset for some reason?

Or is it just me and most people would be hugely offended, and I've misunderstood how massive an insult this is in the neurotypical world?

TEH82 · 04/11/2021 07:13

They detailed further on (next paragraph) he made next to no eye contact and when he did it was an intense stare with a blank facial expression but that was only momentarily.
It’s not ODD as in the defiance disorder as that is not how he manages his behaviour- he tends to withdraw rather than act out

OP posts:
Londonwriter · 04/11/2021 01:25

The main problem with ‘odd’ is that it’s highly subjective because it’s so non-specific.

‘Child’s interaction is extremely odd’ - I mean, that could mean anything from ‘child has limited eye contact’ to ‘child licked my face and his head spun around 360 degrees when I asked if he wanted a biscuit’.

The lack of specifics means it feels a bit, ‘why is my child odd to you, exactly? Because I may disagree’. I speak as the mum of an autistic boy who I did not know was autistic until he had problems in school.

lawofdistraction · 04/11/2021 00:36

DD is currently on the autism pathway and it wouldn't upset me if her mannerisms were described as odd - I know they are.

It's not as if they said he was odd himself, they were describing a behaviour and it's just a synonym for unusual.

User310 · 04/11/2021 00:34

As a parent I think I would prefer the word atypical but actually looking at the dictionary, the word odd means ‘ differing in nature from what is ordinary, usual, or expected’.

I hope you and your son are doing well.

PixieLaLa · 04/11/2021 00:30

@TableFlowerss You do realise atypical means ‘not typical’ which means unusual, which means different, which means odd.

verymiddleaged · 04/11/2021 00:26

Professionally I would think odd but write atypical.
I would mean odd in something that jarred a little and wasn't expected in standard behavioral responses.
It isn't professional language to use.

Personally Neither ds or I are NT and we would both happily admit to being a bit odd so I wouldn't worry too much about reading it in a report about either of us.

StartSelect · 04/11/2021 00:17

I think they write these reports so parents can easily understand them, thats the feeling I got from my sons reports for both asd and for adhd. Odd doesn’t bother me personally, I probably described some of my ds’ behaviours to the professionals as odd myself

GazeboLantern · 04/11/2021 00:15

My dc have been described as 'quirky' in various assessments. I read that as a euphemism for odd or weird. I didn't care for it at first, it felt judgemental. But the truth is that, compared to their peers, they are quirky, they are odd, and sometimes they even are weird.

So what? As ds says "If I wasn't weird I wouldn't fit in so well with my family. People who aren't weird are boring."

TableFlowerss · 04/11/2021 00:02

@PixieLaLa

Odd, unusual, different, atypical all fundamentally mean the same thing. I don’t really see why it matters in the scheme of things.
Really? They might mean the sane things but being described as odd isn’t something most people would be happy about. It’s not a positive word.

Atypical is much more neutral, as in it’s not offensive

TableFlowerss · 04/11/2021 00:01

nothing odd about him I mean

TableFlowerss · 04/11/2021 00:00

Bless him, no wonder your mad, I would be too. He’s your little boy and there’s nothing off about him from your pint of view I’m sure.

Atypical gets to the point without being derogatory.

They’re bludy odd for using that terminology!

PixieLaLa · 03/11/2021 23:54

Odd, unusual, different, atypical all fundamentally mean the same thing. I don’t really see why it matters in the scheme of things.

RAOK · 03/11/2021 22:36

You should query it and give your feedback. It could be ODD acronym in that context though as others have said.

stingofthebutterfly · 03/11/2021 22:31

Odd is subjective though. They should have been more specific. What about his eye contact was odd? Was it non-existent, only in response to certain situations or what? I wouldn't be happy with that description at all and I'd be asking them to clarify and rewrite it.

connffussed · 03/11/2021 22:14

My child has asd, I would be insulted and angry to read that.

There are more appropriate words.
Unusual. Atypical. For example.

People with asd have a hard enough time trying to find their place in the world without the people who are supposed to help end support them using language like that.

Rosesareyellow · 03/11/2021 22:10

I agree it’s inappropriate. But doctors for all their knowledge aren’t always the most articulate people on paper nor the most emotionally intelligent.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 03/11/2021 22:07

I sometimes have to write reports of a similar type. We referred to eye contact as “atypical”. Odd is more perojrative so I wouldn’t use it. I imagine it is probably intended to simply convey how it relates to their diagnosis of autism, but you should definitely feed back how you received that word. If a parent said they didn’t like our wording we would definitely review it.

Somuddled · 03/11/2021 22:02

I would be OK with it for myself. I don't consider it to be offensive or derogatory, just 'different to the expected norm' but if you aren't happy ask them to change it to a synonym such as atypical or anomalous.

LennyMurdoch · 03/11/2021 21:50

ASD has been rebranded to ASC these days,

According to who?

Watchingyouwazowski · 03/11/2021 21:49

@VillKrill

YANBU at all. It's the kind of language we'll look back on in years to come and wonder how the fuck it was ever deemed acceptable. I personally also have an issue with the term Autism Spectrum Disorder for the same reason - I genuinely don't understand why labelling autistic people as "disordered" isn't considered deeply problematic.
ASD has been rebranded to ASC these days, with the C referring to ‘condition’. My children don’t really care either way. Different labels, same impact on their life.