Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why schools do this!!?

405 replies

FedUpOfYetAnotherCold · 03/11/2021 18:44

AIBU to wonder why children in primary school are taught 'head, shoulders, knees and toes' in French, can tell the difference between metamorphic, sedimentary and ignious rocks, can trace a stone age picture, can create great models of the tower of London, and learn (and promptly forget) all about the Victorians, Romans etc... but...

Quite a few can't swim 25m by end of primary (a skill which could save their life), many barely know what the term 'mental health' means - let alone know how to manage their own or support others with MH difficulties. Most state primary kids are not given access to decent sports provision to support future athletic dreams, better manage in-school behaviour, and promote healthy lifestyle and reduce obesity, and very few kids are supported to learn key life skills. (I'm focussing on primary here - but we also need more life skills like MH and budgeting and cooking etc... taught in secondary)..

Surely we need more teaching in schools on mental health, life skills and better access to sports and teaching which will lead to physically and mentally healthy adults of the future.

When my children finish primary I'd like them to be able to read, write and do basic maths. But in terms of the rest of the teaching - surely we now need to re-evaluate how much emphasis we place on teaching less vital skills such as French (if a language is deemed important why not Chinese, Spanish or Arabic, or something more useful in this current global village) which could be learnt later if desired?

AIBU?

OP posts:
nanbread · 04/11/2021 09:54

What would be better than teaching kids to manage anxiety, is to create a society and education system that doesn't make kids feel anxious.

At least 50% of kids with MH problems say school is the main factor.

Animood · 04/11/2021 09:39

I am biased because I liked French was good at it and did it at a level and a business course as part of my degree.

I worked in France three different times in three locations with the skills I learned. I would not have got those opportunities if I didn't know the language!

So for me learning French meant I was very successful in my alevels (French being my highest mark) and opened up working abroad to me.

I know this is very very far from the norm. Completely get that, but to say learning a language is pointless simply isn't true!!!

It has a point for some people and has no point for others, just like almost every subject at school! There are shed loads of things I have never used (Pythagorean theorem, algebra, most of maths in fact!)

LivingNextDoorToNorma · 04/11/2021 09:37

I'm not knocking French if you do it from choice in secondary school, but given the limited resources in primary schools, what is the point of this subject?

It’s not about the subject necessarily. It’s about breeding curiosity and a love of learning. The children who’s parents aren’t at least trying to equip them with the basic life skills you describe, are also unlikely to be providing additional learning opportunities. The kids aren’t going to ‘opt’ to study french at secondary, because no one has encouraged them to explore different topics in the past, nobody believed they were capable of anything more than the very basics. How can they believe in themselves? As a previously said, you’re risking these children basically being categorised as not worth an academic education.

ADreadedSunnyDay · 04/11/2021 09:35

Disagree fundamentally OP, think more emphasis needs to be given to the basics of reading, writing and maths / numbers. Too much time is given at my son's primary school for PSE, resilience, outdoor learning, gym at the expense of basic skills. Now in year 4 and more than a third of the class need support with reading - frankly it would have been to these kids benefit for this to be picked up much much earlier.

Animood · 04/11/2021 09:31

Head shoulders need and toes in French - French is a language spoken by millions and is one of our nearest neighbours and allies.

Rocks - lots of people use this information in their jobs - think surveyors, builders, architects etc.

Learning about our history is important. Teach kids the mistakes of the past so they don't repeat them in future.

Swimming- isn't it parents job to teach their kids to swim or take them to lessons? Why should this be funded by the taxpayer?

Agree that sports and cooking / healthy eating are important. Sports should be done more in school. I think cooking and healthy eating is something parents should encourage more tbh.

Idony · 04/11/2021 09:05

Teach your own kids swimming. Schools aren't substitute parents

Andwander · 04/11/2021 08:03

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

I'm sorry, I'm going to mention French again!! - honestly if people enjoy it and want to study it at secondary school that's great! However, I honestly can't understand why it's part of many primary schools curricula.

I learnt french as a compulsory subject from age 6 to 16. The only use it has ever been to me was to order some cider on holiday when I was a teen. If I add up all the hours I spent learning French I just see it as a complete waste! I would have benefitted much more form learning CBT skills, DBT skills, ways to manage emotions, anxiety management skills etc... in that time.

I'm not knocking French if you do it from choice in secondary school, but given the limited resources in primary schools, what is the point of this subject?

Maybe so that Brits abroad are not like total dicks in regards to at least make an efforf to speak french.
Sowhatifiam · 04/11/2021 07:29

I’m not knocking French if you do it from choice in secondary school, but given the limited resources in primary schools, what is the point of this subject?

Literacy. The discipline of rote learning. We live in a world where we would benefit from some kind of inter-cultural understanding? Communication skills. Speaking out confidence. Fitting language into the wider curriculum so it links with RS, history, geography, maths. Tolerance. Respect. Confused

gingerbiscuits · 04/11/2021 06:56

Speaking as a teacher in a Primary School, in a nutshell, it all comes down to horrific lack of funding & the ever changing, utterly ridiculous dictats made by the ignorant cockwombles who run the educational system in this country!

Tailendofsummer · 04/11/2021 06:49

Your OP should be "Why does the government do this?"

Tailendofsummer · 04/11/2021 06:48

"Why do schools do this?"
Schools don't set the overall curriculum, the government do.
Schools don't sell off playing fields or decide what site a school is built upon.
Schools don't set the budgets that mean swimming is only available for short bursts throughout their time at school.

category12 · 04/11/2021 06:42

Also, it gets harder to learn languages the older you get. When you're young, your brain is basically set up for it and if you don't continue to use it, you start losing it.

So starting pupils learning another language only at secondary sets them up to fail/not achieve as well.

Rugsofhonour · 04/11/2021 06:25

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Worldgonecrazy · 04/11/2021 06:20

Because if I was being cynical I would say that schools’ main reason for existing is childcare and teaching kids to pass exams. Education is down the list of priorities.

Hercisback · 04/11/2021 06:18

The immaturity in student stems from the government putting pressure on the wrong output. There's pressure on teachers to get exam results, teachers can (and do) lose their jobs if the results aren't good enough. This means teachers will spoon feed kids through a qualification to get SLT/Ofsted off their back. The government has taken away so much responsibility from individuals and put it on to schools and other services. This creates a culture of immature and spoon fed kids who struggle to think for themselves. Not all of them, but there is a definite shift in attitude.

Rugsofhonour · 04/11/2021 06:17

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

category12 · 04/11/2021 06:10

The answer to every social problem is not "teach it in schools!"

CliffsofMohair · 04/11/2021 06:07
  • society raises children
CliffsofMohair · 04/11/2021 06:07

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

Surely some of the onus is on the parents? We have the ability to teach our own kids to swim, pay for lessons etc.

I get that, but many kids don't not have parents able to teach these things or provide lessons etc...

I think, as a pp said, we need a conversation about the role of schools and how we can support ALL kids (not just those privileged enough to have parents able to teach them) to keep mentally and physically healthy and manage to live in society in a compassionate way, able to stay on the right side of the law, and able to live happily and comfortably

You’d need a far bigger overhaul of how specialty raises children to achieve these goals. Teaching ‘mental health’ awareness or whatever you’re advocating for here won’t mitigate against a life on the edges society, in care, dealing with substance abuse at home etc. Far wider systemic issues at play here. Schools aren’t the panacea for everything and everyone which is wrong in society.
Andwander · 04/11/2021 06:06

I completely agree with you.there is a massive denial by lots of people here.If you compare say an apprentice in this country and in germany,its a huge huge diference.it is the immaturity of older students that is so striking.glad I didnt had to educate my kids in british school system.

Hercisback · 04/11/2021 05:51

I would have benefitted much more form learning CBT skills, DBT skills, ways to manage emotions, anxiety management skills etc

It's really not appropriate for schools to be teaching CBT and DBT skills. Teachers aren't medical professionals.

To the PP who discussed using the time after exams are finished in year 11, we offered something similar. Had under 20 kids interested so didn't run the classes. At 16, most students don't want more school, however you dress it up.

Lockeddownagain · 04/11/2021 05:48

I wrote with primary school kids and the children that can't read and write are the ones who's caregivers never read ti them the kids that get bedtime stories and storyline can read and the children who can't I promise don't.

balloonsintrees · 04/11/2021 05:17

@RaininSummer

The time wasted after gcses are taken has always bugged me. It would be great if 4 to 6 weeks after the last exam were spent getting first aid skills, job application skills and useful stuff like cooking to a budget amongst other things. No doubt money is the block again as I expect the normal teachers are busy doing other things once exams are done. I do think all the history, language, science etc is important however or we really will produce a cohort of dullards with no sense of learning, what might interest them or ability to score points in quizzes.
My school offered a program like this after GCSEs and A-Levels last year...less than 30 kids across both cohorts signed up to any of the 22 different courses on offer.
balloonsintrees · 04/11/2021 05:11

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

Surely some of the onus is on the parents? We have the ability to teach our own kids to swim, pay for lessons etc.

I get that, but many kids don't not have parents able to teach these things or provide lessons etc...

I think, as a pp said, we need a conversation about the role of schools and how we can support ALL kids (not just those privileged enough to have parents able to teach them) to keep mentally and physically healthy and manage to live in society in a compassionate way, able to stay on the right side of the law, and able to live happily and comfortably

Oh ffs we do do this in schools, but to a large extent we are always fighting external influences...if a family considers that teachers are useless and have no authority then why would a child bother to engage at school? So they don't and no matter what we teach or how well we teach, we are always fighting a losing battle. This is the most heartbreaking thing about it, many times uniform strictures are about encouraging the idea of the social contract, every time a parent subverts it and allows their child to go against it with impunity they show that the wants of the individual are more important than the needs of society. (I know I am making major sweeping generalisations, but the point stands)
sashh · 04/11/2021 04:55

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

Surely some of the onus is on the parents? We have the ability to teach our own kids to swim, pay for lessons etc.

I get that, but many kids don't not have parents able to teach these things or provide lessons etc...

I think, as a pp said, we need a conversation about the role of schools and how we can support ALL kids (not just those privileged enough to have parents able to teach them) to keep mentally and physically healthy and manage to live in society in a compassionate way, able to stay on the right side of the law, and able to live happily and comfortably

If it were possible to teach all the things you want to teach you still have to get the child to attend regularly.

If you have a chaotic home life then that might be a problem.

Primary schools HAVE to teach a language, this was brought in before any primary teachers were trained to teach a language so it is normally which ever member of staff did A Level, or failing that GCSE.