Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why schools do this!!?

405 replies

FedUpOfYetAnotherCold · 03/11/2021 18:44

AIBU to wonder why children in primary school are taught 'head, shoulders, knees and toes' in French, can tell the difference between metamorphic, sedimentary and ignious rocks, can trace a stone age picture, can create great models of the tower of London, and learn (and promptly forget) all about the Victorians, Romans etc... but...

Quite a few can't swim 25m by end of primary (a skill which could save their life), many barely know what the term 'mental health' means - let alone know how to manage their own or support others with MH difficulties. Most state primary kids are not given access to decent sports provision to support future athletic dreams, better manage in-school behaviour, and promote healthy lifestyle and reduce obesity, and very few kids are supported to learn key life skills. (I'm focussing on primary here - but we also need more life skills like MH and budgeting and cooking etc... taught in secondary)..

Surely we need more teaching in schools on mental health, life skills and better access to sports and teaching which will lead to physically and mentally healthy adults of the future.

When my children finish primary I'd like them to be able to read, write and do basic maths. But in terms of the rest of the teaching - surely we now need to re-evaluate how much emphasis we place on teaching less vital skills such as French (if a language is deemed important why not Chinese, Spanish or Arabic, or something more useful in this current global village) which could be learnt later if desired?

AIBU?

OP posts:
wherestheweightlosspill · 05/11/2021 15:24

I guess everyone has different priorities, I am also unhappy with some of the things taught in schools but not the same ones as you. I think there's too much focus on Sports/PE. For kids who are not into it, it's almost impossible to avoid. I only had 1 PE lesson a week when I was growing up. My kids have 3, plus compulsory sports events, including during lunchtimes! Similarly in secondary schools I think there's too much science. I dropped science at the end of yr 7 (not in this country) as I wasn't remotely interested and have never regretted it. My daughter has got to do 3 science subjects for GCSE whether she likes it or not. That's 30% of her GCSE subjects. Science (like art for example) is something that I think you need to be actually interested in, I know they want more girls in STEM but the ones who'll make strides in those industries are surely those who are actually interested! I find the lack of choice of GCSE subjects really depressing. They're being forced into a mold that the govt have chosen for them. www.theguardian.com/education/2021/jul/20/funding-cuts-to-go-ahead-for-university-arts-courses-in-england-despite-opposition

Rainbowsew · 05/11/2021 13:50

And yes to pp who say that throwing everything to be the responsibility of schools becomes a mask for other deficiencies in society, usually a lack of government funding or social support and a consequence of poverty and discrimination.

Whatever small amount can be achieved by school alongside a busy curriculum will always be eclipsed by those parents who can afford to outsource to other people if they aren't up to dealing with it themselves through their own education or support network 😟

logsonlogsoff · 05/11/2021 13:50

I don’t know which school your kids go to OP, but in my kids’ pretty average state primary school they have compulsory swim lessons in year 5 with the aim of all kids swimming 100m they have 3 PE session a week with 2 of those outdoors, have an endless choice of sports clubs, teach PHSE which includes mental health care, yoga and meditation and have a huge focus on healthy eating to the point of policing lunch boxes.
Have you checked the primary curriculum? Because all the stuff you say they aren’t being taught are part of the KS2 curriculum

Rainbowsew · 05/11/2021 13:44

School can't teach everything there is not the time, I'd rather a qualified teacher taught my children the complex academic stuff I can't do.

Most of the things you mention should be taught outside of school in my opinion. If you personally can't there are other options. You could ask friends, or family that are good cooks/sports people/arty/crafty to help.

Budgeting and how to manage adult life, bills, mental health, physical health etc is a job for parents and family imo.

Swimming lessons are available either privately or via council pools. Most schools don't have pools anymore and it's expensive and time-consuming to take classes out for swimming and the short course my children had whilst at primary school wouldn't have been enough to teach a quality technique that would save their life in an emergency, so there fire was pretty pointless imo.

lazylinguist · 05/11/2021 11:53

I'm assuming all the PPs saying that children should be taught to swim by their parents. That's fine if you can afford it but there will be so many parents who can barely feed their children let alone pay for swimming and lessons.

Schools cannot be responsible for all the many things that some parents cannot or will not do for their children as well as providing a foundation for their academic education. It's simply not feasible.

LolaSmiles · 05/11/2021 11:06

I'm assuming all the PPs saying that children should be taught to swim by their parents. That's fine if you can afford it but there will be so many parents who can barely feed their children let alone pay for swimming and lessons
My parents couldn't do swimming lessons for us. We had half a term of basic lessons during primary school (possibly year 5 or 6).
I'm more than supportive of all children having a basic level of water safety instruction and basic swimming techniques, but ultimately schools are not parents.

There seems to be a growing trend that anything and everything becomes the responsibility of schools. That's mainly because it allows the government to turn a blind eye to the real causes of the issues: usually linked to poverty, systemic social issues that the government doesn't want to spend money on, chronic underfunding of services.

Schools become responsible for swimming vs government properly funds local health and fitness opportunities including swimming pools so they are affordable and accessible

Schools become responsible for dealing with child mental health vs government properly funds a dedicated mental health offer so that all children get the correct level of mental health that they need (which in turn would reduce the likelihood of them needing more services in adulthood)

Schools to have parent and family support workers and huge pastoral teams picking some of what was done by children's centres and other services vs government properly funding wrap around services to support families

It's very convenient for the government (and others) to throw everything to schools to avoid discussing the real issues and then when school staff complain they can be painted as the workshy union types who don't care about children.

Howshouldibehave · 05/11/2021 10:33

@Summerrain123

I'm assuming all the PPs saying that children should be taught to swim by their parents. That's fine if you can afford it but there will be so many parents who can barely feed their children let alone pay for swimming and lessons.
Where does it stop though?
Summerrain123 · 05/11/2021 10:19

I'm assuming all the PPs saying that children should be taught to swim by their parents. That's fine if you can afford it but there will be so many parents who can barely feed their children let alone pay for swimming and lessons.

Summerrain123 · 05/11/2021 10:16

The Tories......

They have cut funding and increased content and difficulty ( the children DO NOT need to learn what a fronted adverbial is or the other stuff they never see again in secondary EVER) to an extremely stressful level. More funding and time for healthy activities would certainly go towards reducing MH issues for children. I HATE what the tories have done to education and I have been a teacher for over 20 yearsAngry

CornishGem1975 · 05/11/2021 10:12

My kids were taught to swim in school once a week from Reception until they left, as their school (bog-standard normal primary) had a pool however, I don't feel this is something that should be taught by schools really, I think the onus should be on parents to give them these skills.

I also don't believe that it's solely the school's responsibility to teach them to read and write. They give them the tools and methods, and parents should reinforce them at home.

They've also been taught about wellbeing and mental health all the way through. Light touch at primary, heavier focus at secondary.

I think parents put too much emphasis on wanting schools to cover all bases when we need to take responsibility for our children's development, wellbeing and education.

user1472151176 · 05/11/2021 10:06

I totally appreciate not every parent is able but I would say teaching children is largely up to parents/guardians/carers. Schools were to learn to read and write everything else was passed through generations. Our primary school does a lot of work with mental health and various other activities. I teach my children to cook and appreciate money and care for a household I wouldn't expect my primary school to teach my children that. Parents have to take responsibility for the upbringing of their children too (I realise this is not possible in every household)

BookishKitten · 05/11/2021 10:03

Educator here:

Attending and learning at school is no replacement for life experience and the role of parents and peers.

Learning to swim for example shouldn’t be taught at schools but children should use their after school time for a variety of activities, especially when they’re young and their ability to concentrate and absorb information and process it isn’t fully developed.
So, plenty of physical activity with their peers outside of school time, including swimming at the local council facilities; they can learn to cook with their family; and budgeting and learning about managing money should also be done in a family setting to start with.

Learning to read, write and learning mathematical skills is invaluable and will put them in a very solid path for a future education, be that academic or apprenticeship based

LolaSmiles · 05/11/2021 09:06

Howshouldibehave
You also need an insert any topic that was in the news because someone somewhere did a survey and a knee jerk response to put it into an already full PSHE Curriculum was made.

I'm quite concerned at the push from some to expect children and young people to learn how to support mental health. It annoys me even more than pushing it onto teachers. Being a nice person and being considerate is part of learning how to be a reasonable person. Responding to mental health issues, potential trauma that someone might not have disclosed, and so on is something that requires professional knowledge, training and expertise. Well intentioned but poor quality mental health support is far from supportive and potentially very damaging, but for some reason some people want to push this on children under the guise of be kind.

The reason for the big drive on mental health in schools is because it's taking attention away from the fact that children and young people are being systemically failed by the absence of consistent, high quality, professional support for those who need it.

lazylinguist · 05/11/2021 08:06

Honestly, the bollocks some people trot out on here about schools is unbelievable. Primary schools making kids rote-learn lists of kings and queens Hmm. I'm a teacher but I hid the MN education boards a while back for the sake of my blood pressure. The regular dimwitted and ignorant pronouncements about what teachers and schools should have been doing to deal with the pandemic were the final straw tbh.

Silverswirl · 05/11/2021 07:50

@Mischance

We all have different things that we believe to be important in education.

I think children should have lots of musical opportunities and absolutely all learn to read music - it is the only truly international language there is.

Absolutely 100% this. If I had my way every child would be able to read music and play an instrument by the end of secondary school. Reading and playing music aids so much other learning and can help with mental health and stress. However it’s sadly not practical because it takes individual teaching to play an instrument and regular practice
Howshouldibehave · 05/11/2021 07:49

Since qualifying as a teacher, I have read on here that teachers should be responsible for…

Teaching swimming
Teeth cleaning
Applying suncream daily or twice daily
Doing head lice checks
Toilet training (bearing in mind schools cannot refuse to accept children who are still in nappies, this does happen more than you’d think already).
Teaching whatever language/art/sports subject the poster has a degree in or is quite good at, and thinks primary schools should be doing more of.
Makaton

There are probably countless others!

If you want the curriculum changed to include these things-write to your MP.

Leedsfan247 · 05/11/2021 07:43

If you’re concerned about your children’s ability to swim why don’t you teach them?

Are schools supposed to do everything??

bluejuniper · 05/11/2021 07:37

YABU I think the other way around. We are lucky to have an education system in the U.K. and it's not all bad, parents should take some responsibility for their dc education too.

Swimming lessons don't have to be expensive and you can actually teach your dc yourself in a public pool very cheaply. My dad taught me to swim before I had school lessons and my dh taught my dc to swim. Parents shouldn't rely so much on things being given out to them imo.

Swimming lessons are very time consuming for schools, dc would be better off having a parent teach them swimming so as not to waste that time or expense at school, also the lessons that are at schools are often inadequate for actually learning to swim.

tootootaataa · 05/11/2021 06:02

@Helloise

When I used to teach, I worked in a middle school near to a k-6 Montessori school (this was America, 6th grade is 12-13 years old). About 20% of our 7th graders any given year came from the Montessori and we had a hell of a time getting them up to grade standard, especially in Mathematics. They were generally lovely and social kids though. I personally think Montessori is great up until about 6-7 years old, max.
Oh wow! That doesn't sound ideal and in exact contrast to what I have experienced. Would be interested if you could PM me the name of that school. We have the opposite problem here, the kids are way advanced of the local maths program.
pollymere · 04/11/2021 23:26

You seem to have poor knowledge about what is taught in primary schools. Swimming is mandatory in Y4 and any student who can't swim by the end has to repeat in Y5 and Y6. You clearly haven't seen the Wellbeing and SEMH elements of PHSCHE either

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 04/11/2021 23:09

@KingVoid

What does yabu and yanbu mean
Yabu- You Are Being Unreasonable. Yanbu- You Are Not Being Unreasonable.
Solo · 04/11/2021 23:03

@Helloise
I was making a point about concentrating on getting our English right before teaching or learning to speak Chinese (for example).

Bath can be said with a long or a short 'a' but isn't baff or barf.

Nc4post99 · 04/11/2021 22:50

Erm french is a global language! It’s also an ‘academic’ language. Plus it uses the Latin alphabet unlike mandarin or Arabic. It’s quite unrealistic to expect primary school teachers to be able to read and write arabic or mandarin. You ever tried to learn Arabic OP? As someone who has let me tell you, It’s bloody hard

rachelvbwho · 04/11/2021 22:34

Why is the responsibility for all these things on the school? Surely the parents should be having input into a lot of these things?

Swimming (particularly as a large school group) costs a lot of money and not all schools have the budget to cover that.

Mental health is covered as far as I am aware, just often through different terms that you are used to. My DD did a huge amount of work in school on "growth mindset" and talking openly about emotions and feelings. A perfect introduction at age 4-5 IMO.

French is a widely spoken language and France are our closest neighbours so it makes sense. Yes, Arabic/Spanish/Mandarin may be more "useful" but good luck finding primary school teachers who are experienced in that! Learning any language is good and once you have learnt one it is MUCH easier to learn another.

SOME schools don't have good sports facilities. Others do. Not everyone wants to be an athlete nor should they. However, ALL schools do offer outdoor play and have PE lessons.

You have an odd bee in your bonnet and I am not sure what you expect in our overstretched and under Funded schools.

ChattyCathy25 · 04/11/2021 22:27

Just wondering what you plan on teaching your child OP? Or do you think it's just your job to keep them alive and school should do everything else?