Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why schools do this!!?

405 replies

FedUpOfYetAnotherCold · 03/11/2021 18:44

AIBU to wonder why children in primary school are taught 'head, shoulders, knees and toes' in French, can tell the difference between metamorphic, sedimentary and ignious rocks, can trace a stone age picture, can create great models of the tower of London, and learn (and promptly forget) all about the Victorians, Romans etc... but...

Quite a few can't swim 25m by end of primary (a skill which could save their life), many barely know what the term 'mental health' means - let alone know how to manage their own or support others with MH difficulties. Most state primary kids are not given access to decent sports provision to support future athletic dreams, better manage in-school behaviour, and promote healthy lifestyle and reduce obesity, and very few kids are supported to learn key life skills. (I'm focussing on primary here - but we also need more life skills like MH and budgeting and cooking etc... taught in secondary)..

Surely we need more teaching in schools on mental health, life skills and better access to sports and teaching which will lead to physically and mentally healthy adults of the future.

When my children finish primary I'd like them to be able to read, write and do basic maths. But in terms of the rest of the teaching - surely we now need to re-evaluate how much emphasis we place on teaching less vital skills such as French (if a language is deemed important why not Chinese, Spanish or Arabic, or something more useful in this current global village) which could be learnt later if desired?

AIBU?

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 03/11/2021 19:40

While schools dont direct teach children how to write CVs or fill in application forms, the skills needed to do both of these are taught in school.
If youve taken almost any test, you have been taught how to read and understand questions, and answer what is being asked...which is basically the premise of an application form.

Schools do teach different styles of writing (persuasive, factual etc) along with grammar and spelling...so all the person needs is a template which can easily be accessed online...which most school also have.

There are so many transferrable skills which are taught without spoonfeeding every eventuality.

Head, shoulders, knees and toes in French teaching coordination, multi-tasking and French... all three things can be used in other circumstances.
Learning the children of monarchs teaches memory and the ability to structure timelines in your mind.
I'm sure there are many more benefits but these are just what spring to mind

BananaPB · 03/11/2021 19:38

My experience as a parent is that the schools I chose wanted my kids to be happy so they had boundaries and expectations that mean my kids can bond well with their peers as well as staff. This goes a long way towards being happy.

This was balanced with a broad curriculum which helped them get ready for secondary. My children didn't pick art or dt for GCSE or above but some of the kids that made that model Anderson shelter did. Those kids are the future product designers and engineers that we need.

Porcupineintherough · 03/11/2021 19:38

@ancientgran

Having run a payroll for a large company I think it would be really helpful if children were taught about NI, income tax and pensions plus their rights to things like SSP.
It would only help if they were interested enough to listen in the first place and remember it later. Which is unlikely. Some things you just learn when you need them.
Morgoth · 03/11/2021 19:37

Why is it up to schools instead of parents to teach kids how to swim, look after their health, budget, cook, have confidence speaking on the phone, clean their own teeth etc. They are life skills you teach your own kids.

  1. You cannot and should not outsource the majority of your child’s pastoral and holistic upbringing to another agency. That’s your job as a parent. The state also has no interest in doing things that quite obviously fall comfortably in the realm of what the job of a parent is.

  2. Teachers are already working an average of 20 hours unpaid and uncontracted time a week. They barely have time to see their own kids let alone want to bring up other people’s kids regarding things that are outside their jurisdiction.

  3. How many billions and billions of pounds do you think schools have lying around to do tailored sports and music courses for each individual child, to do hours of lessons in life skills? Kids barely pay attention as it is. Why on Earth would they pay attention to lessons about mortgage rates, budgeting and studying utility bills? What would you take out of the timetable to fit it in? Maths? English? Science? Kids are already underachieving in these areas due to a prevalent culture of no work ethic, bad behaviour, anti-intellectualism sentiment and the country’s antagonism towards the value of education which you see in barely any other country.

Peoniesandpeaches · 03/11/2021 19:37

@MintJulia

Perhaps, OP, the answer is to support the parents instead.

Parenting classes, basic cooking classes etc.

Absolutely and in Glasgow anyone between 5 and 18 can swim for free in the council run swimming pools. Investment needs to go beyond the schools themselves.
Thissucksmonkeynuts · 03/11/2021 19:37

Did you forget music op? Why don't you care about the arts?

user1471443411 · 03/11/2021 19:36

Voted YABU as my experience of primary school (through my DDs) was far too much emphasis on mental health 'mindfulness' 'wellbeing days', health eating etc. Both daughters hated mindfulness, they must have been an anomaly as the headteacher claimed all other kids loved it.
As for languages, I don't see what's wrong with French in primary. Surely Chinese and Arabic would be too difficult to teach at primary level with having to learn a new alphabet/characters? Otherwise a massive portion of the teaching time would have to be given over to it. And we wouldn't have wanted extra hours adding to the school day, my daughters barely tolerated primary school as it was.

damnthisvirusandmarriage · 03/11/2021 19:36

Surely all that shit is what parents are for?! 🤔

RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 03/11/2021 19:36

Parents should just drop kids off at school on their 5th birthday and pick them up fully formed on their 11th birthday.

Spiceup · 03/11/2021 19:36

Maybe there's an assumption that parents will do some of the parenting?

Schools only actually have kid 6 hours a day for 195 days a year

WonderfulYou · 03/11/2021 19:36

Most state primary kids are not given access to decent sports provision to support future athletic dreams

Who is paying for this decent sports provision?
Yes they should play sports but if you want proper coaching then you’ll have to find and pay for it yourself.

Learning a second language is often more valuable than sports in terms of preparing for the future.

MasterGland · 03/11/2021 19:36

Schools should not have to teach kids to cook. Nor how to budget. This constant abdication of responsibility will lead to a spiral of increasingly deskilled parents, becoming ever reliant on the state.

Patapouf · 03/11/2021 19:35

OP Can you give a breakdown of what you think should be within the schools remit and what you think parents can be expected to teach their own kids?

And then tell us how that curriculum can be taught 9-3, days a week for only 38 weeks a year?

Lots of what is taught isn't really about the content it's about the skills it gives the children.

PearlAsylum · 03/11/2021 19:34

@minipie

I agree with you that the curriculum is ridiculously outdated for the modern world.

I don’t necessarily agree with you about what should be taught instead however. I wouldn’t focus on life skills but would have more on things like computing, how government works, basic level economics, design (I know they do a bit). History could have more modern events and less Bayeux Tapestry. Geography could have more about environment and less igneous rocks.

Still academic subjects rather than “life skills” but modernised content.

But all these things ARE in the curriculum! Computing, how the governement works, environment - all of it!
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/11/2021 19:34

I do agree with pps that it’s not the schools’ fault but the government who don’t fund them properly

But I agree there should be more provision for teaching swimming to kids whose parents can’t afford it. And children’s mental health is such a worry. There’s a lot of ot being taught at my children’s school though.

Puffalicious · 03/11/2021 19:34

@ancientgran

Having run a payroll for a large company I think it would be really helpful if children were taught about NI, income tax and pensions plus their rights to things like SSP.
Aye, it would be nice but we can't do EVERYTHING.
EdenFlower · 03/11/2021 19:34

In my experience schools are forever addressing mental health- to the point that by the time they are half way through secondary school they are all convinced they have mental health problems!

DaisyDozyDee · 03/11/2021 19:34

@Hellocatshome

Being able to swim 25m in a swimming pool in your swimming cossie and goggles will only save your life in a very limited number of circumstances.
Absolutely agree with this. 50% of people who drown can swim. We had a couple of close calls as children because the fact that we could swim very well in a pool meant our parents made some frankly reckless decisions about what was safe around open water.
BananaPB · 03/11/2021 19:33

many barely know what the term 'mental health' means - let alone know how to manage their own or support others with MH difficulties.

It's a bit much for primary school children who may not even know anyone with mental health issues.

Ime they teach stuff on bullying, how to be a good friend, my son learned a bit about his friend's autism (with permission from him and the family) , he had a diabetic classmate so learned a bit about that and they covered things like how to stay safe online...

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 03/11/2021 19:32

@RaininSummer

The time wasted after gcses are taken has always bugged me. It would be great if 4 to 6 weeks after the last exam were spent getting first aid skills, job application skills and useful stuff like cooking to a budget amongst other things. No doubt money is the block again as I expect the normal teachers are busy doing other things once exams are done. I do think all the history, language, science etc is important however or we really will produce a cohort of dullards with no sense of learning, what might interest them or ability to score points in quizzes.
That and the fact that the ones most in need of the additional repetition of things they didn't engage with first time round wouldn't turn up. First aid is in PSHEE, cooking in Food Tech if the school has a food tech area and a food tech teacher, job/college applications earlier in the year...oh, and it's a time used for extra work experience - as well as a lot of MC families' favourite time to go on holiday, going by the number every year who call wanting to know the earliest date they can take them away (and not liking the answer of the official school leaving date).
Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 03/11/2021 19:30

My children have lots of stuff about mental health and mindfulness and exercise 1k per day, bike safety , swimming etc… Wales!

ancientgran · 03/11/2021 19:30

Having run a payroll for a large company I think it would be really helpful if children were taught about NI, income tax and pensions plus their rights to things like SSP.

BoredZelda · 03/11/2021 19:30

Our school did loads about mindfulness and teaching the kids how to improve their mental health, particularly after they came back from lockdown.

They got PE twice a week with a PE teacher and did a separate yoga/dance session once a week with the teacher. There were after school groups for basketball, football, cross country running and a before school gymnastic club. They also had a glee club.

They learned French, Spanish and German and there were after school clubs which did other languages.

Seems like you maybe just picked a shit school for your child.

They learned

NoSquirrels · 03/11/2021 19:30

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

Surely some of the onus is on the parents? We have the ability to teach our own kids to swim, pay for lessons etc.

I get that, but many kids don't not have parents able to teach these things or provide lessons etc...

I think, as a pp said, we need a conversation about the role of schools and how we can support ALL kids (not just those privileged enough to have parents able to teach them) to keep mentally and physically healthy and manage to live in society in a compassionate way, able to stay on the right side of the law, and able to live happily and comfortably

Schools aren’t the issue.

Children living in poverty - which is exacerbated by poor education of their own parents - is the issue.

You need children to be enthused by the process of learning at primary school age.

So that when they get to secondary school age they still think learning is worthwhile, and improve their prospects by getting grades that open up opportunities to them.

Primary school learning should be broad and delivered creatively. Not about ‘learning to stay away from substances’ or ‘budgeting’ or the amorphous idea of ‘mental health’.

Focus your efforts on supporting parents of those kids who can’t access swimming lessons and can’t teach these life skills. Get funding for programmes to support them to support their children.

Porcupineintherough · 03/11/2021 19:29

@Ohdoleavemealone that would be an excellent idea if we expected everyone to leave school at 16 and take a minimum wage job. Anyone staying on, who wants to take an A level / degree in science, or computer science, or medicine, or geography, or engineering or mathematics or, actually, economics will need more maths then just how to add up and calculate compound interest.