Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why schools do this!!?

405 replies

FedUpOfYetAnotherCold · 03/11/2021 18:44

AIBU to wonder why children in primary school are taught 'head, shoulders, knees and toes' in French, can tell the difference between metamorphic, sedimentary and ignious rocks, can trace a stone age picture, can create great models of the tower of London, and learn (and promptly forget) all about the Victorians, Romans etc... but...

Quite a few can't swim 25m by end of primary (a skill which could save their life), many barely know what the term 'mental health' means - let alone know how to manage their own or support others with MH difficulties. Most state primary kids are not given access to decent sports provision to support future athletic dreams, better manage in-school behaviour, and promote healthy lifestyle and reduce obesity, and very few kids are supported to learn key life skills. (I'm focussing on primary here - but we also need more life skills like MH and budgeting and cooking etc... taught in secondary)..

Surely we need more teaching in schools on mental health, life skills and better access to sports and teaching which will lead to physically and mentally healthy adults of the future.

When my children finish primary I'd like them to be able to read, write and do basic maths. But in terms of the rest of the teaching - surely we now need to re-evaluate how much emphasis we place on teaching less vital skills such as French (if a language is deemed important why not Chinese, Spanish or Arabic, or something more useful in this current global village) which could be learnt later if desired?

AIBU?

OP posts:
Cuck00soup · 03/11/2021 20:05

Would your offenders be offenders if they can/can't swim 25 metres?

I happen to agree with you that sports & swimming are important - personally, I wish children were taught to run, not set off on cross country to divide the cans and can'ts - but honestly, offenders tend to come from complex families and no curriculum is going to change that. Helping them to read and write might.

user452369 · 03/11/2021 20:05

@echt

Yet, there is no learning of Civics in the UK - kids leave education with a vote but zero education about how the political or financial system of their own country works, basic finance etc

So what is PSHE about then?

IME it wasn't the political or financial system of the UK. It was soft social right-on subjects as well as important stuff like sexual health, race etc.
user452369 · 03/11/2021 20:03

Tories sold off school playing fields and barely any new swimming pools have been built for years. Under previous labour governments joint school and community sports and community facilities were built. Now it is all private leisure companies only - they keep on with creaking decaying sports facilities and swimming pools with zero investment.

This is what you get for voting Tory.

echt · 03/11/2021 20:03

Yet, there is no learning of Civics in the UK - kids leave education with a vote but zero education about how the political or financial system of their own country works, basic finance etc

So what is PSHE about then?

echt · 03/11/2021 20:01

Why who's kids are you raising and what does it have to do with this thread

If you've read the thread, you'll know that many posters believe many of the skills found wanting by the OP (who hasn't been back much), are correctly the domain of the parent, not the school.

That's why they wrote what they wrote.

user452369 · 03/11/2021 20:01

OP you are right. At the root is the early age of starting proper education in the UK - 4. Other countries might not start until 7, but have a vast kindergarten system involving outdoor learning with light academic touch.

Our kids are mentally destroyed by the exam system in the UK. Secondary school is worse.

Yet, there is no learning of Civics in the UK - kids leave education with a vote but zero education about how the political or financial system of their own country works, basic finance etc.

God help them if the tories get their way with A** at A levels. Just fund more top uni places instead of trying to make it harder to get in.

motherrunner · 03/11/2021 20:00

@Evesgarden Well if teachers were doing all the things the OP wants we would be taking the role of parents. M children can swim, they can cook, they have good mental health because I’m making sure they have those life skills. I don’t expect their teachers to parent them.

Unihorn · 03/11/2021 19:58

There's a new curriculum here in Wales, not sure if anyone on the thread is knowledgeable on it, but my very limited understanding is that they are (theoretically) moving towards a more rounded approach.

The primary schools around here only teach Welsh, I didn't realise primaries in England taught European languages but I'd never given it much thought before! We only got exposed to European languages form Year 7 onwards.

Calvinlookingforhobbes · 03/11/2021 19:56

You’d like schools to parent your children?

Morgoth · 03/11/2021 19:55

@Starpleck

Teach what about mental health? If anything it should be taught that sometimes feeling anxious is fine, feeling down sometimes is normal too, and we don't need a label for everything. The amount of people who now proclaim they have anxiety, for example, because they feel anxious before a big event or whatever is annoying as it minimises it.
@Starpleck I could not agree with you more. These are just normal emotions on the human spectrum. It’s healthy to experience nerves or failure or shame or guilt or humiliation or unpleasantness. These are normal healthy self-correctors of human behaviour. It’s how people develop a conscience, a moral compass and resilience. Shielding kids from experiencing these normal ups and downs does them no favours. It produces adults that will either be quivering wrecks at everything or psychopaths that have never had to face the consequences of their behaviour. This over-indulgence and over-introspection over absolutely nothing is doing so much harm.
Abraxan · 03/11/2021 19:55

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

Surely some of the onus is on the parents? We have the ability to teach our own kids to swim, pay for lessons etc.

I get that, but many kids don't not have parents able to teach these things or provide lessons etc...

I think, as a pp said, we need a conversation about the role of schools and how we can support ALL kids (not just those privileged enough to have parents able to teach them) to keep mentally and physically healthy and manage to live in society in a compassionate way, able to stay on the right side of the law, and able to live happily and comfortably

So, rather than trying to cram even more into a school curriculum, we should be investing in supporting those parents better. And maybe holding parents responsible for how they parent their children. Lay out an expectation, and help parents without the skills to learn though skills and be able to pass it on.
Evesgarden · 03/11/2021 19:55

@motherrunner

I want to teach the pupils in front of me the subject I qualified in.

I want to parent my own children.

I do not want to raise anyone else’s.

Why who's kids are you raising and what does it have to do with this thread Confused
motherrunner · 03/11/2021 19:51

I want to teach the pupils in front of me the subject I qualified in.

I want to parent my own children.

I do not want to raise anyone else’s.

EdenFlower · 03/11/2021 19:51

Education up to year 8 or 9 is about giving children a broad base of knowledge and a taste of everything so that they can discover where their real interests lie for further studies. Even GCSEs are fairly limited in what they teach. History, for example, focuses fairly narrowly on British History in the main, because after all that is our own History, and there just isn't time to teach world history in detail. Education doesn't stop when you leave school- it's not really about what children learn that is important, it's about sowing the seeds of interest, that learning is good and about learning how to learn so that they can go forth to be life-long learners.

When they touch on the Romans in primary school most might not remember it, but a few will take it forward to develop a real interest in History from that small snippet.

I think it's not that relevant what exactly we teach them in primary school (other than to read, write and develop their maths skills), but it's important that we teach them they can learn.

Inertia · 03/11/2021 19:51

@FedUpOfYetAnotherCold

Still confused about the cookie! I work with offenders, many of whom can't read and write, have extremely poor mental health and none were taught mental health, life skills or given access to ways to manage these things in school.

This is something I'm genuinely passionate about. I really think alongside reading, writing and maths - we need to support our kids to come out of primary school with good mental and physical health and knowing how to manage basic living skills, stay away from substances etc...

You work with offenders who can’t read and write.

I’ve taught in both primary and secondary schools. I’ve seen how children and teenagers who lack basic literacy skills may become school refusers, or get into trouble as a way of getting out of lessons they cannot access.

Government funding cuts mean that schools have spent the last 5 years cutting staffing to the bare minimum. Children who need support with basic numeracy and literacy for whatever reason are getting a tiny share of a class teacher’s time, with no other adult support. We are desperate for proper funding for primary schools, to ensure all children are supported to reach functional levels of reading, writing and maths.

It’s typical of this short-sighted government. Adequate school funding early on to support all children is key.

Abraxan · 03/11/2021 19:51

Swimming and sports facilities

Many, if not most, primaries do not have their own swimming pools and large sports halls, or have them walking distance. Many don't have sports fields at all - the Governments sold them off!
Which means accessing them costs money - money to hire facilities, money to hire trainers, money to hire buses to get pupils there and back. Travelling distances to different places eats into the time. As it happens we do take out Y2 children swimming, but a quick 30 min lesson actually eats up much of the morning - by the time the children are taken there, get changed, get into pool, have lesson, get dried and dressed again and then returned to school - you've lost most of your morning to one short lesson. Same with other sports facilities.

Fwiw we do do a lot of sport, but within the constraints we have regarding time and budgets. We do things like the Daily Mile which gets children active every day. We have installed climbing equipment in the playground for daily activity at playtime. We have a sports group who come in and take specific and specialised sports lessons weekly for reception, and half a year each for key stage 1. We spend our sports premium money effectively to teach what we can to the best of our abilities.

Mental Health

This is a huge thing in most primary schools I know, and has become increasingly so over the last 5 or 6 years. There are many initiates and training out there. We teach about mental health through rshe lessons, but also every day - though systems we have in place such as zones of regulation, trauma informed schools programmes, ACE (adverse childhood experiences) training systems and much much more.
We focus on addressing their own mental health. I personally thing at primary level, and my school is only infants, they need to focus on that rather than how to support others with their own. We do touch on it through generalised teaching such as being a good friend, how to help,others feel happy, etc.

But the bottom line is that there are only so many hours in the day, so many days in a week. And there's only so much money in the budgets, and only so many staff available to do this. We can't teach children everything and I'm afraid much of these extra things should be being taught by parents. It's part of their role, not something that they should be expecting others to teach their children.

AliasGrape · 03/11/2021 19:51

@EdenFlower

In my experience schools are forever addressing mental health- to the point that by the time they are half way through secondary school they are all convinced they have mental health problems!
I do think this is an issue around the overall discussion of mental health, not just in schools.

I don’t really know how to phrase what I want to say because I’m not saying there should be less discussion, and I do think it’s important to promote openness and remove stigma. But I also think a lot of the way it’s framed is a bit off somehow - I’d like to see more emphasis on the ‘health’ bit of mental health, on wellness and resilience rather than constantly telling ourselves we are anxious/ depressed/ can’t do x y or z etc. Definitely in schools I’d like to see this be the focus where possible.

Evesgarden · 03/11/2021 19:46

@NeedAHoliday2021

I’ve no idea what you’re talking about. My primary dc can swim 25m (quite a few schools have their own 25 m pools round here) and they definitely know about mental health although they seem to think than being anxious means they have anxiety and being angry equals anger issues rather than seeing these as normal emotions that we all feel but have to control.
You must not live in the U.k then or live in a very influential area because it IS NOT the norm for state schools to have swimming pools - they cost an absolute fortune to run!
Sowhatifiam · 03/11/2021 19:45

if a language is deemed important why not Chinese, Spanish or Arabic, or something more useful in this current global village)

Because there is a shortage of language teachers in this country, less and less people are studying languages and university departments are closing. Because the number of people who speak these languages well enough to teach is small and increasingly, linguists can earn more than they can in a classroom.

French, by the way, is spoken on all continents, is very much the language of diplomacy and internationalism the world over. Your ignorance is astounding.

How to care for yourself, mental health, swimming etc etc are all important but parents need to take some responsibility here. We have a major problem in so many hours in a day. There is only so much they can do.

Whattodonowill · 03/11/2021 19:45

Some of these 'jobs' are down to the parents. School never taught me to swim.

Time and money is also the big issue.

Evesgarden · 03/11/2021 19:44

I agree OP especially with the swimming - but MN is notoriously harsh on school swimming lessons. It IS an important life skill and saves lives and many parents can not afford it.

Many many kids can't even read before they leave state primary school and their family lives are shocking so yes I absolute agree much could be done to help these kids learn valuable life skills.

MN is weird because apparently every one hates private schools as state schools are better. Yet if you raise swimming lessons/dance, any of the arts which actually do enhance children's lives then you are lambasted for taking up precious funds from underfunded schools that are already struggling.

And I do not understand the hatred for school swimming lessons ( I spent many years as a school swimming teacher so know how valuable they are to poorer families)

NeedAHoliday2021 · 03/11/2021 19:43

I’ve no idea what you’re talking about. My primary dc can swim 25m (quite a few schools have their own 25 m pools round here) and they definitely know about mental health although they seem to think than being anxious means they have anxiety and being angry equals anger issues rather than seeing these as normal emotions that we all feel but have to control.

TabithaTiger · 03/11/2021 19:42

I can still remember being taught all about the Victorians, Romans, Stone Age, etc. I found it fascinating and it sparked a life long love of history.

My DC had swimming lessons at school, although my view is that this is a life skill parents should take responsibility for. They had cookery lessons at school but there weren't particularly interested. However now they're older, they regularly cook at home (they use the internet and follow recipes).

I believe things like healthy eating, being kind, etc are taught in primaries aren't they?

Abraxan · 03/11/2021 19:40

Why do schools do this?

Schools, in general, follow a national curriculum determined by our Governments. They have little choice. You are aiming much if your annoyance at the wrong people.

Starpleck · 03/11/2021 19:40

Teach what about mental health? If anything it should be taught that sometimes feeling anxious is fine, feeling down sometimes is normal too, and we don't need a label for everything. The amount of people who now proclaim they have anxiety, for example, because they feel anxious before a big event or whatever is annoying as it minimises it.