Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find a replacement for my cleaner...

116 replies

Newbie408 · 03/11/2021 15:29

... after finding out that she isn't vaccinated against COVID?

Just that really.

She mentioned this in passing when she was here today - this is not due to being vulnerable or anything, just that she "doesn't believe" in the vaccine. Her unvaccinated secondary school age children also live with her which makes me feel more uncomfortable.

To be clear, this isn't a choice based on discriminating against her for her beliefs, it's about a genuine fear of being more at risk from catching COVID from her and I don't know if I'm BU for feeling like this.

I know that looking for a replacement starts a slippery slope of discrimination against those who chose not to be vaccinated but I feel uncomfortable as I am home when she is here and I am quite heavily pregnant - this final factor being what is swaying me towards finding a replacement.

Am I being over the top? Do I just need to accept that COVID is part of our lives now and so is inevitably mixing with people that have chosen not to get the vaccine?

Sorry this is a bit stream of consciousness. Really appreciate any thoughts.

OP posts:
Newbie408 · 03/11/2021 19:11

*he there for (typo kind of ruined that, didn't it)

OP posts:
Newbie408 · 03/11/2021 19:10

[quote SpookyPumpkinPants]@Newbie408

It can be a great place, but it can also be bike, but don't ever be out off by that because there simply isn't no place like it when the chips are down. I hope you stay

As for your cleaner. Pregnant women & newborns are more susceptible to Covid and it's great you're double jabbed, but it's still wise to take as many precautions as you can.

There's no need to have an unvaccinated cleaner (with unvaccinated teens) when you could have a vaccinated one, so why take the extra risk. If she chooses 'not to believe' in the vaccine, that's her (stupid) choice, it's your choice to tell her you don't require her services any longer. You don't have to be honest about why if that makes you uncomfortable! (You can blame your DH saying he think we need to cut back now with the baby coming 🤣)

Best wishes with the birth![/quote]
Thank you! So excited :-)

Ha, I was totally already thinking about blaming DH, what else is here there for!

OP posts:
CombatBarbie · 03/11/2021 19:06

Doesn't alter my position either. But I'd judge any of my friends who sacked someone for not being vaccinated.

ilovesooty · 03/11/2021 19:03

@CombatBarbie

Oh well this is exactly what the anti vaxers said would happen. Discriminated for not having the vaccine..... A vaccine that doesn't stop transmission, only affecting the symptoms.

This then makes no sense to the preachers saying they have no time for selfish people putting others at risk. The only people they are putting at risk is themselves.

Are you going to ask all future cleaners for their covid and MMR proof seeings how we lost our measles free status 2years ago but Noone seems bothered about that!?

I already said it might be difficult to establish someone's vaccination status as one can't ask.

I said I wouldn't want someone in my house who said they were unvaccinated by choice. No amount of unpleasant sniping such as this is going to alter my position.

SpookyPumpkinPants · 03/11/2021 19:00

@Newbie408

It can be a great place, but it can also be bike, but don't ever be out off by that because there simply isn't no place like it when the chips are down. I hope you stay

As for your cleaner. Pregnant women & newborns are more susceptible to Covid and it's great you're double jabbed, but it's still wise to take as many precautions as you can.

There's no need to have an unvaccinated cleaner (with unvaccinated teens) when you could have a vaccinated one, so why take the extra risk. If she chooses 'not to believe' in the vaccine, that's her (stupid) choice, it's your choice to tell her you don't require her services any longer. You don't have to be honest about why if that makes you uncomfortable! (You can blame your DH saying he think we need to cut back now with the baby coming 🤣)

Best wishes with the birth!

CottonSock · 03/11/2021 18:48

I've changed hairdresser for the same reason.

Newbie408 · 03/11/2021 18:46

@WorriedGiraffe

YABU are you going to ask all the medical staff delivering your baby if they’ve had the vaccine too? It should be pretty easy to social distance from your cleaner (which would be sensible regardless of their vaccination status) and she’s cleaning the place so it’s unlikely she’s leaving germs on all the surfaces. You could struggle to replace her with a vaccinated cleaner, or you could hire a vaccinated cleaner that takes no other precautions and is more likely to catch covid as a result anyway. If you’ve other concerns about her work then I’d understand this being the final straw, but if she’s otherwise good I wouldn’t sack her.
No but I don't have a choice in who delivers my baby and it wouldn't be my place to ask them. I do have a choice in who cleans my house and comes into my home. Thank you for the other points, all very valid and helpful in making me see both sides.
OP posts:
Newbie408 · 03/11/2021 18:44

Thank you for all the responses so far (both telling me I'm BU and that I'm not). They've given me some good food for thought. As my first ever post on MN, I really appreciate this community!

OP posts:
Newbie408 · 03/11/2021 18:42

@XenoBitch

YABU

Why does the reason she is not vaccinated matter? If she had not had it due to allergies, would you still sack her?
Do you not trust the vaccines that you have had yourself?

I genuinely do not understand why my OP would lead to the question "Do you not trust the vaccines that you have had yourself?"

Of course I do. Which is why I am more wary around those who have not had it!

OP posts:
RockinHorseShit · 03/11/2021 18:39

This then makes no sense to the preachers saying they have no time for selfish people putting others at risk. The only people they are putting at risk is themselves.

Wrong

Some genuinely can't have the vaccine for medical reasons. I have 2 friends in this category who for the time being at least have to rely on others to protect them & still basically shielding. These people put those at risk

Our friend is double vaccinated, got Covid & was still very ill & is now going through heart tests as a result. Looking like he now has POTs to live with, which is a known complication of COVID. No vaccine he would have died for sure. With the vaccine he survived, but now with extra debilitating health issues

We also know someone who was vaccinated, caught it & died.

The vaccine improves chances & reduces transmission for sure, but it does not stop it spreading completely. The Unvaccinated deniers are the super spreaders & who the hell wants that in their own home

WorriedGiraffe · 03/11/2021 18:32

YABU are you going to ask all the medical staff delivering your baby if they’ve had the vaccine too? It should be pretty easy to social distance from your cleaner (which would be sensible regardless of their vaccination status) and she’s cleaning the place so it’s unlikely she’s leaving germs on all the surfaces. You could struggle to replace her with a vaccinated cleaner, or you could hire a vaccinated cleaner that takes no other precautions and is more likely to catch covid as a result anyway. If you’ve other concerns about her work then I’d understand this being the final straw, but if she’s otherwise good I wouldn’t sack her.

CombatBarbie · 03/11/2021 18:23

Oh well this is exactly what the anti vaxers said would happen. Discriminated for not having the vaccine..... A vaccine that doesn't stop transmission, only affecting the symptoms.

This then makes no sense to the preachers saying they have no time for selfish people putting others at risk. The only people they are putting at risk is themselves.

Are you going to ask all future cleaners for their covid and MMR proof seeings how we lost our measles free status 2years ago but Noone seems bothered about that!?

Patapouf · 03/11/2021 17:54

I don't have time for anti vaxxers and I wouldn't want to give one any of my money or let them into my home to touch my stuff.

ilovesooty · 03/11/2021 17:22

It would possibly be difficult to establish that any replacement is vaccinated but I wouldn't employ anyone in my house who had told me they were unvaccinated through choice, especially if they had unvaccinated school aged children.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 03/11/2021 17:18

Do you not trust the vaccines that you have had yourself?

The vaccine doesn’t necessarily stop you getting COVID, as everyone who hasn’t been living under a rock knows.

It just lessens the symptoms and impact.

Most of the people in hospital / ICU / dying are the unvaccinated.

XenoBitch · 03/11/2021 17:13

YABU

Why does the reason she is not vaccinated matter? If she had not had it due to allergies, would you still sack her?
Do you not trust the vaccines that you have had yourself?

Chasingaftermidnight · 03/11/2021 17:07

You’re not her employer - she’s presumably self-employed - so it’s just a question of who you want to provide services in your home. I think you’re perfectly within your rights not to want an unvaccinated person who has unvaccinated secondary age kids in your home, especially when you’re heavily pregnant - if you catch it (even if you’re asymptomatic), at the very best it would impact negatively on your antenatal care/care in labour.

Not quite the same thing but I am also pregnant and needed some refresher driving lessons and I asked the instructor if he was vaccinated before booking lessons. He was, and was taking various other Covid precautions, but if he hadn’t been I wouldn’t have taken lessons with him.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 03/11/2021 17:07

Of course you are not being unreasonable.

I don’t understand unvaccinated people getting the hump when vaccinated people don’t want to be in their company.

You make your bed, you lie in it. Unvaccinated people can surely just be happy in the knowledge that they’re ‘right’ (according to themselves).

In your circumstances, I’d definitely be finding a replacement.

RockinHorseShit · 03/11/2021 17:06

However, how will you be able to guarantee the replacement is vaccinated? You're not entitled to their medical records so you're only going by their word - I'm not even sure if you can legally ask a potential employee about it (although I may be wrong). There is also a chance they'll lie about being vaccinated if they want the job

That's the thing though, vaccinated people have nothing to hide & will be more than happy to offer proof or advertise themselves as vaccinated. DH is a tradesman as are several friends & they all flash their vaccination cards quite freely, as have trades we've had do work here. 🤷‍♀️

Lou98 · 03/11/2021 17:02

Don't think you are or aren't BU as it's everyone's preference on what they're happy with.

However, how will you be able to guarantee the replacement is vaccinated? You're not entitled to their medical records so you're only going by their word - I'm not even sure if you can legally ask a potential employee about it (although I may be wrong). There is also a chance they'll lie about being vaccinated if they want the job

2bazookas · 03/11/2021 16:50

It depends on how vulnerable you are.

People who are fully vaccinated, in good health, have none of the age/medical conditions/ factors that make people who catch covid less able to resist it, then even if you catch it you should just have a mild dose lasting a few days. Which would then help you develop more antibodies and improve your resistance to covid.

  OTOH if I was  80, obese, diabetic,  undergoing  chemotherapy  or had a poor immune system  I'd be very wary indeed of indoor home  contact with unvaccinated people . I'd swap an unvaccinated cleaner for a vaccinated one.
gamerchick · 03/11/2021 16:40

@Shitfuckcommaetc

Why not get her full vaccine record? Has she had the mmr? Meningitis b/c? Flu vaccine?

Or is covid the only risk to you and your baby?

No. This argument is void. It simply does not matter. The OP requires a vaccinated against covid cleaner and her cleaner isn't. Game over. There is no debate on it.
RockinHorseShit · 03/11/2021 16:37

YADNBU. Your cleaner can have her beliefs & principles anyway she likes... up until it puts you & your family at higher risk of covid, which it potentially does, then as her employer you have every right to re asses the risk & replace her. Your house, your rules, end of

hangrylady · 03/11/2021 16:34

I don't think YABU. It's her choice of course, but it's your choice whether to have an unvaccinated person in your house.

MrsWooster · 03/11/2021 16:30

She has a right to make her choice. And so do you.
Choices have consequences and it’s perfectly reasonable for you to take a view that you want to lessen chances of covid transmission around your new-born.