Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is an unfair split of finances?

58 replies

troobleflooble · 03/11/2021 15:04

Bf and I are talking about moving in together, not quite yet but as some point in the near future.

He owns his house and I rent. He earns a lot more than me, I unfortunately am on a very low income at the moment (hoping to change this in the future!). He also has pets and a lot of extra expenses that I don't have (car/life/pet insurance, subscription services etc) plus his mortgage so his outgoings are a lot more than mine.

He suggested that when the time comes I just pay half of all the bills while he continues to pay the mortgage on his own. I'm a bit uncomfortable with this because I don't see it as a fair split, if I stay at my place I'd be continuing to pay rent which I'm saving by living with him.

Just to make it clear, I wouldn't ever expect to get a share of the sale of his house based on 'paying in' to his mortgage, I would purely consider it 'rent' that he could use to pay off his mortgage earlier or save as he deems fit.

However, since my income is so low, is this actually a fair split? I've never lived with a partner who's had a mortgage before so any other time it's always been either a 50/50 split on everything regardless of income or I've paid 100% of everything due to being the breadwinner. I have no idea what would be fair for both of us! Please advise wise MNetters 😁

OP posts:
mrsm43s · 03/11/2021 15:45

I think you should pay half household bills, plus a token rent (say £1-200 per month), but he should pay the mortgage (obviously) and also he would pay for all household maintenance and repairs as its his house (hence why you should pay at least some "rent" to cover your wear and tear). This would be assuming that you accepted (and legally tied down) the fact that you have no claim on his property, and are just paying rent, not buying a share in his house. The rest of the savings that you make (i.e the difference between paying a full rent and a token rent) you should put into a long term savings account in your name alone, and that would form your "nest egg" should you need to move out in the future. This gives you some security of your own. Obviously, over time, your relationship may change and you may decide to buy into his property or buy a property together. Your nest egg would be your contribution for that too!

So basically, a token rent amount, and long term savings in your name.

troobleflooble · 03/11/2021 15:27

Yes exactly right @Stompythedinosaur, which is why we're going to wait a bit. I do trust him absolutely but I've been in a difficult position before where things went wrong and I had no where to go.

I'm using made up figures here but just as an example:

His income: 2000
His mortgage: 400
His bills: 800
Spare money: 800

My income: 800
My bills: 150
My rent: 400
Spare money: 250

If I move in it would be:

Him -
Mortgage: 400
Bills: 400
Spare money: 1200

Me -
Bills: 400
Spare money: 400

I could just save as much as possible and put it towards future big expenses like holidays etc. I would say we'd like to buy a place together at some point but my income and credit rating is so low it's unlikely I'd be eligible for a mortgage. This hopefully will change in the future but I think I should assume I can't for now to be on the safe side as I'd hate to let him down.

We are both mid 30's, no plans to have kids.

I'd be more than happy to do most of the household chores, especially since I'm only on part time hours at the moment (not out of choice!).

OP posts:
Triffid1 · 03/11/2021 15:23

I've commented on threads like this where the woman is the house owner. My opinion is the same either way - of COURSE you should pay rent. But you are a partnership, so it's perfectly reasonable for you to pay him rent at a lower level than you were paying before. In this way, you both win - he gets a contribution to his mortgage (ie saves money) and you are paying significantly less in rent than you would otherwise, allowing you to save and/or improve your quality of life.

Bills split equally (although spend time working out what those bills are - eg are you going to split the cost of the pet care?)

traintraveller · 03/11/2021 15:21

I'd suggest half all household bills and food shopping plus maybe a token "rent" of £100 or so.

Hont1986 · 03/11/2021 15:18

Depends on your incomes, really. 0% of mortgage and 50% of all other bills is a great deal for you. Take it for now and increase your share of the bills when your income is higher.

Clementineapples · 03/11/2021 15:15

He should be responsible for his personal outgoings and you should be for yours.
Household bills should be split according to salary. I personally think (although will be attacked for this) that the person contributing less financially should contribute more in the housework and cooking etc

girlmom21 · 03/11/2021 15:12

Why don't you propose that you save whatever you'd spend on rent in a fund for you both?

Or do all the food shopping.

Stompythedinosaur · 03/11/2021 15:08

Impossible to say without knowing your incomes and future plans.

On the face of things you're making the bigger saving, but you are also taking the risk as you could be left with no where to live.