Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is an unfair split of finances?

58 replies

troobleflooble · 03/11/2021 15:04

Bf and I are talking about moving in together, not quite yet but as some point in the near future.

He owns his house and I rent. He earns a lot more than me, I unfortunately am on a very low income at the moment (hoping to change this in the future!). He also has pets and a lot of extra expenses that I don't have (car/life/pet insurance, subscription services etc) plus his mortgage so his outgoings are a lot more than mine.

He suggested that when the time comes I just pay half of all the bills while he continues to pay the mortgage on his own. I'm a bit uncomfortable with this because I don't see it as a fair split, if I stay at my place I'd be continuing to pay rent which I'm saving by living with him.

Just to make it clear, I wouldn't ever expect to get a share of the sale of his house based on 'paying in' to his mortgage, I would purely consider it 'rent' that he could use to pay off his mortgage earlier or save as he deems fit.

However, since my income is so low, is this actually a fair split? I've never lived with a partner who's had a mortgage before so any other time it's always been either a 50/50 split on everything regardless of income or I've paid 100% of everything due to being the breadwinner. I have no idea what would be fair for both of us! Please advise wise MNetters 😁

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mrsm43s · 04/11/2021 10:17

@troobleflooble

I have no issues paying half the bills, although I don't know exactly how much they are in total for the month I know there are a lot more of them than I pay. No expensive gym memberships or anything like that but certainly pet/home/life insurance, utilities are much higher at his place as it's a bigger house and some of mine are included in my rent cost. I'd be happy to pay a share of anything 'household' so yes to home (contents) insurance because my belongings would be covered under that when I move in but no to 'personal' bills like phone etc. I'd expect to pay my own for stuff like that too.

It does look like we'd both be a little better off in my example but it just feels weird to me to not pay any rent! I've been doing it so long it seems wrong not to 😂

I think you should pay a token rent to cover the additional wear on tear on his house caused by you living there. He would be responsible for maintenance, but things like carpets and redecoration will need to be replaced more often with you living there too. So £1-200 per month as a token rent amount seems fair.

The really important thing is that you save the additional rent savings in an account in your name for your future security, rather than just spending them on treats and holidays. Living in his house as you suggest gives you no security whatsoever, and so you need to have something to fall back on should he ask you to leave (which he could do at a moment's notice)- money saved up for either a rental or mortgage deposit.

troobleflooble · 04/11/2021 09:36

I have no issues paying half the bills, although I don't know exactly how much they are in total for the month I know there are a lot more of them than I pay. No expensive gym memberships or anything like that but certainly pet/home/life insurance, utilities are much higher at his place as it's a bigger house and some of mine are included in my rent cost. I'd be happy to pay a share of anything 'household' so yes to home (contents) insurance because my belongings would be covered under that when I move in but no to 'personal' bills like phone etc. I'd expect to pay my own for stuff like that too.

It does look like we'd both be a little better off in my example but it just feels weird to me to not pay any rent! I've been doing it so long it seems wrong not to 😂

OP posts:
SweetBabyCheeses99 · 03/11/2021 19:33

This seems fair to me.

ChocolateLover2000 · 03/11/2021 19:12

When my bf (now husband) moved in with me I owned the property and he had previously rented. We took everything into account and he paid me an amount of money in rent such that we were equally better off from him moving in. I think it was
about £300/month, but this was in 2010. Would this sort of thing work do you think?

TangledUp789 · 03/11/2021 18:28

@Tee20x

Not sure if this is the done way of doing things but could you work out how much extra his bills increase by having you there and pay that rather than 50/50.

Never been in your position myself so just throwing it out there.

That wouldn’t be fair though. What about the TV license for example? It wouldn’t cost him any extra for her to watch the TV, so he’d have to pay the whole thing himself and she’d save herself £160 a year. Same for phone and broadband. Or council tax - she’d only have to pay 25% and he’d pay 75%.
DrManhattan · 03/11/2021 17:59

Why would you be paying his pet insurance and that?

Bonusjonas · 03/11/2021 17:37

I was in this situation and what worked for us was that I saved the equivalent of my rent money and then when we bought a house I had enough deposit to put into it. It was a good back up to have in case we didn’t buy together too. I paid half of household bills.

Tee20x · 03/11/2021 17:33

Not sure if this is the done way of doing things but could you work out how much extra his bills increase by having you there and pay that rather than 50/50.

Never been in your position myself so just throwing it out there.

butterpuffed · 03/11/2021 17:33

Surely you don't mean you'll be paying half of his personal payouts [car/life/pet ins.] , presumably just half of the utilities ,food and council tax ?

Pinkgorrilaz · 03/11/2021 17:31

I think you should work out what each of you is saving by living together and split it so that you benefit equally. Because his bills are so high, it ends up with him gaining more (£400) than you do (£150). That seems particularly unfair given that he earns more than you in the first place. You should each benefit by £275. There may need to be slight tweaks to this if his utility bills increase etc. But you can work that out over time.

steff13 · 03/11/2021 17:30

doesn't include, not don't include.

steff13 · 03/11/2021 17:29

I think what he's suggesting is more than fair, as long as what he's asking you to pay don't include his personal expenses, like phone contracts, life insurance premiums, etc.

moanymyrtle · 03/11/2021 17:26

Maybe he doesn’t want you paying rent or towards mortgage to make it clear you have no claim on property. I wouldn’t take rent and would make you sign something before you moved in.

Hont1986 · 03/11/2021 17:26

I've just noticed that his bills are really high compared to yours, so I think I will revise my advice a bit.

I think paying half of the bills is more than reasonable, BUT only if they are reasonable bills. I was assuming he has the standard water/gas/electricity/Lidl-for-big-shop-Waitrose-for-nice-bits kind of bills that I do.

Maybe offer to pay specific bills rather than all of them, so half the water, half the electricity, etc.

Reallybadidea · 03/11/2021 17:20

I think I explained that really badly, but using your figures, your rent and bills of £550 will disappear so I think you should pay him half that so that you both benefit equally. If his bills increase as a result of you living there (council tax, heating, water etc) then you should pay this increase.

mygenericusername · 03/11/2021 17:13

@Reallybadidea

Sorry really. I’ll slap my hand for not RTFT

AryaStarkWolf · 03/11/2021 17:13

Soz, I have the attention span of a gnat and memory of a goldfish! My bad

It's halfway to the weekend, don't despair Grin

femfemlicious · 03/11/2021 17:10

I would simply bite his hand off. Just move in, save what you are saving. Treat him to nice meals once in a while. Enjoy your relationship.

Also try to increase your earnings ASAP

Feelingofftoday · 03/11/2021 17:09

@AryaStarkWolf

And she also said she's currently working part time (not through choice)
Soz, I have the attention span of a gnat and memory of a goldfish! My bad
Reallybadidea · 03/11/2021 17:08

@troobleflooble

Yes exactly right *@Stompythedinosaur*, which is why we're going to wait a bit. I do trust him absolutely but I've been in a difficult position before where things went wrong and I had no where to go.

I'm using made up figures here but just as an example:

His income: 2000
His mortgage: 400
His bills: 800
Spare money: 800

My income: 800
My bills: 150
My rent: 400
Spare money: 250

If I move in it would be:

Him -
Mortgage: 400
Bills: 400
Spare money: 1200

Me -
Bills: 400
Spare money: 400

I could just save as much as possible and put it towards future big expenses like holidays etc. I would say we'd like to buy a place together at some point but my income and credit rating is so low it's unlikely I'd be eligible for a mortgage. This hopefully will change in the future but I think I should assume I can't for now to be on the safe side as I'd hate to let him down.

We are both mid 30's, no plans to have kids.

I'd be more than happy to do most of the household chores, especially since I'm only on part time hours at the moment (not out of choice!).

Based on this he will be saving a lot more than you will by living together. Maybe you should work out how much each of you is better off by living together and then work out how much you should pay based on you both benefitting equally?
AryaStarkWolf · 03/11/2021 17:03

And she also said she's currently working part time (not through choice)

Feelingofftoday · 03/11/2021 17:01

@mygenericusername

Do you work full time for that money op?

I don’t know how to say this without sounding like a knob so I’m just going to say it.

35 hours a week full time on £10 an hour is £1500 per tax per month.

I don’t know what you do but most jobs are paying at least this to recruit at the moment.

You sound like a lovely girl with lots of potential. Unless you are on some kind of training programme, update your cv and go and get yourself a salary increase somewhere.

Nobody should be earning so little and before you all jump on me I know it’s a huge problem in certain sectors.

If you are earning more your current dilemma would go away.

OP said they were example salaries to show the comparison not the actual numbers
mygenericusername · 03/11/2021 16:56

Do you work full time for that money op?

I don’t know how to say this without sounding like a knob so I’m just going to say it.

35 hours a week full time on £10 an hour is £1500 per tax per month.

I don’t know what you do but most jobs are paying at least this to recruit at the moment.

You sound like a lovely girl with lots of potential. Unless you are on some kind of training programme, update your cv and go and get yourself a salary increase somewhere.

Nobody should be earning so little and before you all jump on me I know it’s a huge problem in certain sectors.

If you are earning more your current dilemma would go away.

mewkins · 03/11/2021 16:51

@lunar1

You both come out of it a bit better off than you were separately, that seems fair enough when you aren't married and don't have children together.
I agree with this. You will both have some spare cash. I do think the bills seem quite high. Have you included food?

Don't fall into the trap of buying all the food (you will probably find he eats and drinks much more than you do) or doing more than your fair share of chores. This is a mutually beneficial arrangement, you shouldn't feel indebted to him.

girlmom21 · 03/11/2021 16:48

@RedskyThisNight water will only change if he's on a meter.
Electric won't change that much unless she's intending on working from home or he's never home in the evenings/weekends