Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider breaking up over where to raise our (future) kids?

86 replies

babayagoo · 03/11/2021 14:32

Kids are still a long way off for us, but we’ve discussed where we’d like to raise them and it’s caused more than a few rows!

When do have LOs, we each, selfishly, want to raise them near our own families, who live 4.5 hours apart.

We’ve considered a “compromise” of living halfway between the two families, but even that feels a bit pants. We want the LOs to have the kind of close relationships we had with our own families growing up, and we know that’s hard to pull off if kids don’t see people regularly. Plus we know it’s so much easier with nearby family support (both of ours would be great for this).

What makes it even harder is that none of the areas in between our respective hometowns have good job particularly good prospects, so we’d have to rely on decent WFH jobs. Which probs isn’t that unlikely tbf.

Honestly this is starting to give me a bit of a wobble. I love my SO to pieces, but I love my family too and the idea of raising my own family far from them makes me feel so sad. I know it’s the same for my SO.

We’re kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place.

It’s hard to know if I’m just being melodramatic, or if this is a valid thing to consider breaking up over. The problem is, the idea of breaking up makes me feel just as sad as raising kids away from my family.

Some perspective from people a bit further on in life would be good! I’m only in my late 20s and it’s hard to know which I’ll regret less in the future — ending things with a SO I love, or raising kids at least a 2hr drive from my parents, who I’m v close to.

AIBU? Loads of people raise kids away from their families and seem fine, so idk why I’m getting so worked up about it!!!

OP posts:
Fink · 03/11/2021 15:50

I'm really close to my family and my ex-husband was not particularly close to his (although they get on fine, he's just not a very family person). We lived in a few different places at varying distances from family. It didn't work because he just wasn't that in to family so he didn't like spending time with mine anymore than he did with his. So be careful before you break up this relationship thinking that a future partner might be happier closer to your family and not bother so much about his ... realistically there are a lot of ways that this wouldn't work. If you really are set on bringing up children close to your family, probably the only option is to move close to your family and find a partner who already lives locally. It may or may not be as good a relationship as you have with your current partner. It depends how desperate you are to be close to your family and whether that outweighs the relationship you have already.

Theuniverseandeverything · 03/11/2021 15:48

Is the age and health of your respective parents relevant? What about how willing or available they would be to help out? They might not be as keen as you think.

My parents were brilliant grandparents to my dc but have suffered ill health in recent years and haven’t looked after any of their grandchildren for a long time. Exh’s parents are fitter and younger but not interested.

Cameleongirl · 03/11/2021 15:48

@DaisyDozyDee

We never really had the option of living neither any of our parents without lifestyle compromises we weren’t prepared to make. My parents lived in different rural areas with very limited job options. My husband grew up in a council flat in an area where private ownership is completely unaffordable. Sometimes you just have to compromise. We can’t live near either family, so we live somewhere that’s good for us in other ways (better for jobs, better house prices, nearer the coast, better transport links, good school options etc).
We've had a similar experience to @DaisyDozyDee. We had to move for job opportunities, we didn't want to be far away from both sides of the family, but being able to be financially self-sufficient was also important. My DH received a good job offer in our current location and tbh, I was initially annoyed that he wanted to accept it, but everything's worked out long term. You make new friends and do the best you can to see family.

If we'd stayed in our old area, I think we'd be more financially strapped than we are now, and that causes another set of problems.

LobsterNapkin · 03/11/2021 15:48

I think there are many really really good reasons to be close to family when you have kids.

I also think one of the big things that can create a successful marriage is wanting to live the same, or at least a similar, lifestyle.

It seems like you both value the same things in this, so that is something! I guess the question is, if it comes down to it, can you find a way to compromise? Is it likely that there will be changes in the parents situation - how old will they be? Might some of them be in a home, or be looking to move closer to where their grandkids are? (I have a friend who moved close to his wife's family - his mum and dad, who were divorced, both moved there too over the course of a few years.) Where is it more plausible for you to work? What about schools, other lifestyle issues?

Some of these things might clear themselves up over the years and make one choice obvious.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 03/11/2021 15:43

If this is a deal breaker for you, then I agree that you should break up now, and move back to your home town NOW. There's no guarantee that the next person you meet is going to be any more amenable to moving halfway across the country for you either.

Personally, I think you'd be mad to give up a great relationship over this, but obviously everyones priorities are different.

ColinTheKoala · 03/11/2021 15:42

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Most married couples don't move to be nearer relatives just because they have children.

I’ve found the opposite. Lots of people do move nearer their families what you when they have children.

Yes I agree - they move once they want kids because they think the grandparents will provide free childcare.
Xenia · 03/11/2021 15:41

Go by where the best work it. Our parents expected us to leave for university and then settle elsewhere (as they did in the 1940s and 50s by the way). In fact my mother found her own mother so difficult I think she tried to minimise visits and that was about 40 mins drive away! So it probably just depends on family culture.

We used to take our children to Yorkshire and Newcastle (from London) about 3 times a year to see the 2 sets of grandparents and it worked out fine. sometimes the grandparents came down - may be twice a year on average.

Bananarice · 03/11/2021 15:37

My compromise would be living near an excellent school and have lots of extra curriculum activities available for dc. You don't need to take them everywhere, but it is nice to be able to take them to dance, karate, swimming class if they show interest.

Either way, we live in a globalised world. People move everyday out of the country. Are you certain people on either side are planning on staying long term where they are? What would happen if your dm got headhuntered and asked to relocate? Or your parents retire? Or his parents develop caring needs but refuse help from others, except family (my grandmother did this)?

I would choose place close to work and beat place to raise dc I could afford.

ladycarlotta · 03/11/2021 15:32

I really do mean this as kindly as possible, but if you're considering breaking up over how close the children you aren't yet ready to have will be to their grandparents, there might be other issues in your relationship. You seem very wedded to a picture in your head and neither of you are willing to be flexible about it: if it isn't achievable it doesn't mean the entire relationship is worthless.

I really do understand wanting to be near family, and wanting your children to have a great relationship with them. I think everyone with a vaguely functional family wants this. But as others have made clear, there are so many ways to foster that relationship besides being on the doorstep.

There's also the fact that your parents' lives aren't static either. I've got many friends whose parents saw retirement as an opportunity to move somewhere new, and so were very far away from their grandkids rather than just down the road; others choose move nearer once the babies are born. You don't know what their plans are; given that you don't know when your kids will arrive, you can't guess what needs and wants your parents might have at that time, either as people getting older or people living their best life after raising their own family and working a career.

I just think all you can do is live life your own way, in a place you want to be rather than somewhere diplomatically half-way from everything. Most of all I think you need to trust that everyone involved will be keen to facilitate the grandparent/grandchild relationship, so wherever you go it will be OK.

DaisyDozyDee · 03/11/2021 15:31

‘Living near’ not ‘neither’.

DaisyDozyDee · 03/11/2021 15:30

We never really had the option of living neither any of our parents without lifestyle compromises we weren’t prepared to make. My parents lived in different rural areas with very limited job options. My husband grew up in a council flat in an area where private ownership is completely unaffordable.
Sometimes you just have to compromise. We can’t live near either family, so we live somewhere that’s good for us in other ways (better for jobs, better house prices, nearer the coast, better transport links, good school options etc).

Blueskiesoutthere · 03/11/2021 15:29

Don't think you should break up, but I would say it would be more sensible to move nearer your family as when you have a baby it is probably your mother that you will want the support of. I would hope DP would see the logic in this!

However, lots of people don't live close to family and everyone survives so in reality just cross that bridge when it comes! You might find that PIL decide to move nearer to you!

ittakes2 · 03/11/2021 15:20

I think if you have to ask that question you already have your answer. I am very close to my mum and three sisters...my mum still at the age of 70 plus is very active in helping my sister's young family.
When I met my husband I accepted that my family lived 24hrs flight time away and 20 plus years later I don't regret my decision. You are already worrying about a few hours drive. I don't think this man is the one if you are even questioning whether you should split up over this. It looks like maybe he is not right for you.

lochmaree · 03/11/2021 15:19

we grew up living about a 6.5hr drive from both sets of grandparents (they lived very close together) and it was fine, mum's mum used to come and stay when my dad was off on detachment (military) and we used to visit them in the holidays.

We now have one DS and live 600 miles from my family and 200 miles from my DHs family. visiting my family is either a domestic flight with an hours drive either side or 12 hours driving time. DS is 2 soon and seems to be gaining more recognition of both sets of families. we'd like to live closer to my family but my DHs family are difficult and even DH doesn't want to live close to them so it makes that decision easier.

Triffid1 · 03/11/2021 15:19

While many of these posters are showing that living near family is not absolutely necessarily for a close relationship, I personally think that if this is a deal breaker for you and/or you OH then yes, you may have to consider breaking up. if you can't even imagine not being close by to your parents when you have your own children, then you are going to resent your OH massively.

The only thing I would say is think very carefully about whether your ideal of living close to your family and having a life like you had growing up is practical, even if your OH is willing to move. Consider whether your parents would like to be that close? Are you 100% sure that they don't have plans to move away when they retire? Obviously, be realistic - what happens if they die suddenly? If after you take all these things into consideration you still feel like moving to be closer to your OH's family is an unbearable thought and he feels the same way in reverse, then yes, you should break up.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 03/11/2021 15:18

Most married couples don't move to be nearer relatives just because they have children.

I’ve found the opposite. Lots of people do move nearer their families what you when they have children.

girlmom21 · 03/11/2021 15:18

What happens if you move to your family and your family move away?

We live a 5 min walk away from my in-laws which is great as they've been a massive help when we've needed them but they're moving 90 minutes away from us now.

My friends moved 2 hours away to be closer to both their families. Within months one set of parents moved 3 hours further away (they'd already planned this but not discussed it with their children).

Winter2020 · 03/11/2021 15:14

I wouldn’t go for living in the middle of the two sets of parents as when you have children in school you will always be torn which direction to visit in the limited holidays.

Live near one set - perhaps the ones that can help the most or the area you prefer and then when holiday times come the other set are your priority to visit.

ditalini · 03/11/2021 15:13

My brother's kids live in the same town as my parents and see them a lot (almost always for childcare reasons).

We live further away, so when we visit it's for a weekend or several days and sometimes my two stay with my parents on their own for a bit. We often go on holiday with them (brother's family tends to go away with SIL's family).

My brother's children love my parents, but I'd say that on balance mine are closer to them oddly.

WarmWinterSun · 03/11/2021 15:13

OP, I think it’s sensible to think about this now if it’s that important to you. If you are both fixed on this, then obviously compromise will be needed. My family is incredibly important to me but I compromised and we live near DH’s family. I made peace with this but it wasn’t easy. My parents are now moving to live nearby and I’m delighted. But I was willing to live further away from them even though it was a sacrifice. If you neither of you would be willing to make that type of a compromise, then maybe the relationship doesn’t have the depth and strength that is needed. If you feel you can walk away, he may not be the right person for you in the long run.

JudgementalCactus · 03/11/2021 15:11

What are the odds that you would be able to find someone who:

  1. Is as good a partner as your current one
  2. Lives in the limited area around your family you are willing to consider and is happy to stay there
  3. Is not incompatible with you in some other way
  4. Wants kids on your timeline

And find him before your fertile window closes?

Good men don't grow on trees.
And it takes a reasonable amount of time to know someone enough to committ to a baby with them, say 2 years?

You have time for a few failed relationships before your mid thirties, but it's all a gamble. And the more time passes the more desperate you're going to get. When was the last time you had to do the whole dating thing? It's a long and grueling process for most women.

Kids can be close to grandparents who live 2h away. We have cars and phones and videocalls. Maybe your parents can retire and move closer to you?

BridgeFarmKefir · 03/11/2021 15:09

We don't have this problem but that's because my husband's parents are dead...

FWIW we live 3 hours from my parents and my daughter still has a great relationship with them. I always knew I'd have to manage childcare on my own so it's never felt like an issue.

If you really love your SO this isn't worth breaking up over. You're going to have bigger challenges when kids do come along tbh.

Greentomatoes21 · 03/11/2021 15:08

I live near my family but my husband's family live a short flight away. His mum comes to visit roughly every 8 weeks. Our children adore her and have a very close relationship. I know it's easy for me to say because I'm the one near my family, but I wanted to point out that it is possible to have a very close relationship with family even if they're not on your doorstep.

MRex · 03/11/2021 15:06

live near DH's family and it's great; if we lived nearer my family then we'd see more of them, but DS loves them and knows they are his people. When you marry, you join each other's families; it was a revelation to me to find I had a new set of parents, I'm not sure why I hadn't expected it, but all being well you might change your own mind more than you think over time. You should both ideally want to spend time with both families to make this work.

A compromise could be that you decide you will live near one or the other family, with decent transport options to get to the other family, but you will pick the place together based on where will be the best home for you all. You'll live in your home and enjoy (or not) your jobs. In working out where to live, you should be considering work, house prices and schooling as well as who else lives nearby. Then also an agreed holiday time with the other family every year so you all have some quality time together. You can't rely on family childcare, not everyone is able or willing when the time comes, it doesn't mean they don't love you all and ideally don't make that a factor.

SVRT19674 · 03/11/2021 15:04

My parents are from different countries, and my maternal grandmother was one of the most important persons in my life and lived 2.5 hours on a plane away. It is the quality of the time they spend with you. We lived 6 hours by road from our nearest relative, and I have moved again and we are raising our child away from our respective home towns. You do it, full stop. This reminds me of a friend of mine who moved to be near her mother who has way too much social life to be with her grandkids very often, they were no better off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread