Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider breaking up over where to raise our (future) kids?

86 replies

babayagoo · 03/11/2021 14:32

Kids are still a long way off for us, but we’ve discussed where we’d like to raise them and it’s caused more than a few rows!

When do have LOs, we each, selfishly, want to raise them near our own families, who live 4.5 hours apart.

We’ve considered a “compromise” of living halfway between the two families, but even that feels a bit pants. We want the LOs to have the kind of close relationships we had with our own families growing up, and we know that’s hard to pull off if kids don’t see people regularly. Plus we know it’s so much easier with nearby family support (both of ours would be great for this).

What makes it even harder is that none of the areas in between our respective hometowns have good job particularly good prospects, so we’d have to rely on decent WFH jobs. Which probs isn’t that unlikely tbf.

Honestly this is starting to give me a bit of a wobble. I love my SO to pieces, but I love my family too and the idea of raising my own family far from them makes me feel so sad. I know it’s the same for my SO.

We’re kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place.

It’s hard to know if I’m just being melodramatic, or if this is a valid thing to consider breaking up over. The problem is, the idea of breaking up makes me feel just as sad as raising kids away from my family.

Some perspective from people a bit further on in life would be good! I’m only in my late 20s and it’s hard to know which I’ll regret less in the future — ending things with a SO I love, or raising kids at least a 2hr drive from my parents, who I’m v close to.

AIBU? Loads of people raise kids away from their families and seem fine, so idk why I’m getting so worked up about it!!!

OP posts:
ThePoisonousMushroom · 04/11/2021 08:55

Where do you live in relation to your families now?

grapewine · 04/11/2021 08:54

@Chikapu

Yes, you're being melodramatic to consider breaking up with someone you love to pieces for the sake of hypothetical children.
I'm sorry, but I agree with this.
SoupDragon · 04/11/2021 08:54

Don't most people just stay where they are already when they have children?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 04/11/2021 08:50

I think you're over thinking this.

Mumsnet often has posts from people who have moved to be close to one set of parents who promised childcare. This then doesnt materialise because the GP aren't as interested as they thought they would be, or they develop health issues, or they move away themselves. Unless you have siblings who have kids, you dont know exactly how they will be with kids. It would be a massive gamble to move towards one set of GP.

I'd say have kids where you live now or in the middle. See how you get on. See how the GP get on. I know some GP who have moved closer to their grandkids.

Hankunamatata · 04/11/2021 08:45

I get it OP. My parents were a lot older then dp parents so I made the sacrifice and moved near dp family but we made sure we had a house big enough so my parents could stay comfortably with us. Its worked out well. Inlaws are amazing on childcare front and mucking in. Mun and dad come and stay for a couple weeks a time.

Nanny0gg · 04/11/2021 08:40

@Chikapu

Yes, you're being melodramatic to consider breaking up with someone you love to pieces for the sake of hypothetical children.
^^This.

You're either the most important thing in each others' lives or your not. Grandparents and help should come way down the list

Couldhavebeenme3 · 04/11/2021 08:08

I met and married my ex in his home town, my family lived 3-4 hours away.

My kids saw more of my parents than his (who literally lived 5 mins away) because his parents really didn't give a toss about their grandkids, 'DIDN'T DO BABYSITTING' and were the typical hands-off grandparents from day 1. My expectations were low enough by the time dc1 was born, but their absence was a contributing factor to my pnd. My ex was also very hands-off, and this was the major reason behind our divorce. He resented my parents visiting to support but refused to step up to any parenting himself.

I would do as pp said, move closer to your own parents now, leaving him if he's not on board. I moved when dc were young, and the kids have very little contact with him now.

Haggisfish3 · 04/11/2021 07:18

Both sets of our parents moved to be closer to us when we had dc.

WaterBottle123 · 04/11/2021 07:16

You both sound unusually emotionally dependent on your families, this should reset when you make a family of your own. So no, don't break up over this, madness!

VeganCheesePlease · 03/11/2021 21:58

My mum's advice to me about relationships when I was a teenager (and it's solid advice) was there are two foundations you need to agree on for a relationship to work, and that's whether or not you want children, and where you want to live, and if either of those things you struggle to agree on, it won't work out long term.
In saying that, I know that when we hopefully one day get our rainbow baby, I know that his family are much better to live closer to because they are much more hands on than my family. They might drive us crazy but they play a very active part in their children's and grandchildrens lives, so it makes sense.
Compromising and living two hours away from both families will make help with childcare, and even just regular visiting really difficult

TheWayTheLightFalls · 03/11/2021 19:41

I wouldn’t break up over a two hour drive, and I think even a 4.5h one is surmountable once a month or so (maybe I just like driving?), but broadly YANBU. My husband is desperate to move home. To Moscow. With our three kids. I’m never going to agree. It’s not a great setup to be in. So while I’d never caution anyone against what (to me) seems a surmountable distance, I’d warn them against marrying someone Japanese or Australian or Canadian.

readwhatiactuallysay · 03/11/2021 19:33

I would never have raised a child away from my mum, but then we were close and always lived relatively close to eachother by an hour or so.

So for me it would be a dealbreaker.

BunNcheese · 03/11/2021 19:30

@TremoloGreen

How committed are you to this person? Maybe you should break up, you both sound bonkers and unable to compromise.
Quite Grin
BunNcheese · 03/11/2021 19:28

I think this is a bit odd OP. I don't get it tbh.

Unless you are worried you wouldn't cope with motherhood and your mum wanted to do XYZ amount of childcare then that would be different.

There's no guarantees in life and I think you have over thought this. Are both sets of parents retired? Realistically how much input would you like from your parents...

Once you have your own kids you become your own little family.

SeagullSong · 03/11/2021 19:23

I sympathise as I never saw myself living and raising children away from my family but moved to DH's home country before having kids. DS obviously sees my in-laws more often, but has spent some lovely quality time with my family on visits and seems equally close to both sides. I do have some regrets especially on birthdays, Christmas etc, but on balance, life would be way more stressful in the expensive little corner of England I am from. Do consider the reality of how your day to day life would be but ywnbu if you decide being close to your family is the most important thing to you. I hope you and your partner can work something out that you are both happy with.

BreakfastClub80 · 03/11/2021 19:19

Lots of good replies, one other question is why did you move away from your parents in the first place? That goes for your dp too?

maudmadrigal · 03/11/2021 18:50

If this is all a way off yet, then unless it's an absolute deal breaker for you, I'd stay together (assuming all is basically well otherwise) and keep talking.

Also, remember that the other people involved have agency, and conversely, no one knows what is around the corner.

When DH and I were about your age we had a lot of conversations about if we'd ultimately want to stay where we were (London) or move nearer to either set of parents - both at different points of a triangle and some 7-8 hours from each other. But my parents moved overseas around when my first child was born. (We ended up moving near to in-laws a few years later.)

I'd say the kids, teens now, have pretty good relationships with all the grandparents, but aren't noticeably closer to the ones around the corner. Same with cousins - one set a stone's throw away, others a six-hour drive - but the relationships are actually not dissimilar.

RedWingBoots · 03/11/2021 18:28

There are always posters on MN saying how they have no one near them, no family support, no one to look after the kids in an emergency and how hard it is.

Over the years I've known plenty of people who have no family to look after their kids in an emergency - guess what? They make friends with people they meet whether neighbours, colleagues, people they meet by chance, people from a group of some sort and they end up with someone who will and actually does look after their kids in an emergency.

SausageSizzle · 03/11/2021 17:01

Living on my PILs' doorstep would be far more of a deal-breaker for me than living away from my parents.

Fortunately, my DH thinks the same (and feels the same about my parents) so we've agreed to maintain a minimum 2 hour distance from both sets of parents.

I imagine our parents are quite relieved too as they still get to see DS frequently but there's no chance or expectation of them being pressed into service as unpaid babysitters.

Personally for me, 2 hours from each sounds like the dream and not a compromise, apart from the job situation.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 03/11/2021 16:54

Why wouldn't you raise your children where you live now?

thecatsthecats · 03/11/2021 16:51

Living somewhere in the middle is pointless, but a sensible choice that's not smack on one doorstep or the other can make a big difference. For example we're planning to move back to where I'm from, but half an hour south of my ideal location, trimming the journey for visitors (and also £££ cheaper).

I'm also planning to stick to WFH roles whilst building consultancy work, and we're buying a house big enough for guests to stay in a semi-annexe.

Another important factor is age - my parents are a decade plus older than my husband's, and we'll likely be retired when his parents are older. We also live near the in laws now, so we want to live in my location for a while.

But the real clinching factor is that where I'm from is a much, MUCH better place to raise kids. The city we live in will be a great place to bring our kids for long weekend/HT type visits to do all the things you can't do in my area.

Be smart about this and you don't have to see it as one choice or the other.

Gosports · 03/11/2021 16:48

Although you’re between a rock and a hard place, I don’t think breaking up would even be an option.

Assuming you want to live near your parents, you’d have to move back there asap in order to find someone. And anyone you did find would probably never match up to your current guy given you’re still in love with him. For what it’s worth, I lived 500 miles away from both sets of my grandparents and loved them all to bits.

billy1966 · 03/11/2021 16:34

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

Most married couples don't move to be nearer relatives just because they have children.

I’ve found the opposite. Lots of people do move nearer their families what you when they have children.

I think this is very true for a lot of people.

OP,

Only you can decide if this is a deal breaker for you.

What I wouldn't do is go ahead and have children when you are not happy with the decision and hope it works out.

A lot of resentment happens from that.

In a similar situation the person giving birth to the children gets to choose but with the provisio that the other family can visit very regularly.

Will both parents be working?
Who will be doing the likely lions share of childcare and mental load.

Don't expect to eventually get over being 4.5 hours away from family and friends if that is really what you want.

A cool head is needed.Flowers

Flouts1 · 03/11/2021 16:30

I think if you are going to be a SAHM then I would push for being close to your parents if they are the sort to be helpful with children
My parents were amazing with my kids growing up
I live 10 mins walk from my mum & dad who have now passed away but it was hugely helpful to be that close the last few years
My sister and nieces are a 10 min drive away as well
I’m lucky that my DH dosent bother much with his family and gets on fine with mine 😂

TremoloGreen · 03/11/2021 16:25

How committed are you to this person? Maybe you should break up, you both sound bonkers and unable to compromise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread