Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider breaking up over where to raise our (future) kids?

86 replies

babayagoo · 03/11/2021 14:32

Kids are still a long way off for us, but we’ve discussed where we’d like to raise them and it’s caused more than a few rows!

When do have LOs, we each, selfishly, want to raise them near our own families, who live 4.5 hours apart.

We’ve considered a “compromise” of living halfway between the two families, but even that feels a bit pants. We want the LOs to have the kind of close relationships we had with our own families growing up, and we know that’s hard to pull off if kids don’t see people regularly. Plus we know it’s so much easier with nearby family support (both of ours would be great for this).

What makes it even harder is that none of the areas in between our respective hometowns have good job particularly good prospects, so we’d have to rely on decent WFH jobs. Which probs isn’t that unlikely tbf.

Honestly this is starting to give me a bit of a wobble. I love my SO to pieces, but I love my family too and the idea of raising my own family far from them makes me feel so sad. I know it’s the same for my SO.

We’re kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place.

It’s hard to know if I’m just being melodramatic, or if this is a valid thing to consider breaking up over. The problem is, the idea of breaking up makes me feel just as sad as raising kids away from my family.

Some perspective from people a bit further on in life would be good! I’m only in my late 20s and it’s hard to know which I’ll regret less in the future — ending things with a SO I love, or raising kids at least a 2hr drive from my parents, who I’m v close to.

AIBU? Loads of people raise kids away from their families and seem fine, so idk why I’m getting so worked up about it!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ledition · 05/11/2021 12:00

I personally think you're being quite wise to consider this beforehand - I didn't and it caused a LOT of issues. We ended up living in my husband's hometown (well home-mountain as it's the middle of nowhere with no actual town for quite a few miles) I massively regret not moving before they were born. His family are very nice but they aren't in a position to offer any help with childcare and my family are much more hands on and supportive so it would have been hugely more practical to move to where I'm from and much less isolating when I was a SAHM as there's lots more to do and it's just a nicer place. However, when I raised it when my DC were babies he point blank refused to move and at that stage I didn't have the economic means to go myself so was ultimately trapped. It was NOT a happy time as you can imagine.

If both families are likely to offer help then moving to some random spot in the middle would be cutting your nose off. You'd benefit much more being close to one of them. If you really can't reach a consensus then I don't think it's crazy to end it before you're in too deep as it's likely to remain a huge bone of contention and may ultimately be a thing that triggers separation in the future which would be much worse with DC - which is exactly what's happening in my life right now.

VestaTilley · 05/11/2021 11:50

If you’re in a loving relationship I think you’d be mad to throw that away over hypothetical DC who don’t even exist yet.

I’ve several female friends in their thirties who would love to have a nice partner; they’ve been single for years and can’t find one. Don’t assume if you break up you’ll find another.

If I were you, I’d base it on job prospects- better jobs mean more money to see family, more money to buy in childcare and it just makes your life easier.

Millions of families manage well with little to no family support. If your DPs are still youngish could they visit you a fair bit while any DC are small? If so then you may be able to manage fine without them living nearby.

I didn’t grow up living close to either set of GPs. We managed fine and I was still really attached to them.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 05/11/2021 11:25

What is roughly halfway? If it’s something like Birmingham where there are lots of jobs then I’d consider that first before splitting up.

Sandinmyknickers · 05/11/2021 11:07

Well everyone is different. You get people who would move to the other side of the world to be with the person they love..and then you get people like you who value their hometown and being close to family more.

Persoanlly I can't understand the logic of giving up the person I love and makes me happy for some hypothetical future where you meet someone equally great, makes you equally happy and who is willing to move to your hometown and have kids with you....but then I'm probably the type who would move across the world. Personal connections and genuine, non toxic relationships are precious and the most important to me. I'll always be close to and feel connected to my mum even if living far away.

userg5647 · 05/11/2021 07:46

I can see the predicament, but I can't imagine leaving my DH over this. We moved away from both our families as we needed to, we're a team and it worked out fine, both amour families are still able to support a lot. Where do you live now? I suppose the hard thing here is one of you will "win" so the other May end up resentful.

malificent7 · 05/11/2021 07:45

With all dues respect op i think you would ve bonkers to break uo with your dp over this ..have a very rareBiscuit from me.
You don't even have kids yet!

Topjoe19 · 05/11/2021 07:42

If you really love each other so much, it shouldn't matter where you live as long as it's together. If you're that committed you'll compromise as neither of you will be able to imagine living without the other.

Summerrain123 · 05/11/2021 07:25

We have raised our children away from our families and it was so hard. I was always envious of friends who had help on tap.

Now they are older and more independent, I am still sad as I'd love to spend more time with my family, popping in for a chat or going out together.

I am the main carer too, being part time. If I had my time again, I would want to stay closer to my family. Having said that, the opportunities around here are better for my children so not all bad.

Who is most likely to be the main carer? They should decide.

rivertoskateaway · 05/11/2021 07:05

A friend of mine broke up with her (at the time) great love, because she’s Irish and wanted to move back home to Ireland to raise her family. Her SO had initially agreed, but his parents were older and in the end he changed his mind because he didn’t want to move so far away from them (London). It was heartbreaking watching two people so in love break up, but they felt it was the only option.
She’s now back in Ireland with a husband two children, and he’s met someone else in the UK and settled down too.
For what it’s worth, my husband and I are a good 4/5 hour drive away from our families, and our kids have amazing relationships with their grandparents and aunts etc. As pp have said, there’s a lot more extended visits and quality time. But, it is hard not being able to pop round for dinner/a cup of tea. We are lucky to have built up a great support network where we are, but it took time.

Walkoflife · 05/11/2021 00:17

Aside from grandparents though what about your wider families?
Do you or OH have brothers or sisters in your hometown?
Would potential children have more aunties/uncles/cousins in one town over the other?
I think you should also look at which town would have more family support in general
xxx

FriedasCarLoad · 04/11/2021 23:53

You may find that children would be as close to the faraway family. That's because they'd see them for more intensive time.

So the closer relatives they might see for three hours a fortnight, but the more distant ones for all the waking hours of one weekend, once every two months. That's how it's worked with various families I know.

It requires the parent whose family are nearby to be committed to frequent visits to their in laws, including maybe every other Christmas and so on. And also an agreement on whether you'd move if the distant set of grandparents need help but the near ones were well. Plus a real confidence that the marriage will last.

Skysblue · 04/11/2021 23:44

The sad thing about this is it sounds like you have so much in common.

I think if you’re only willing to raise children near your family then you need to move back there and narrow your dating pool to local guys. If you break up with your current partner over this there is no guarantee that future partners will be keen to move house to your hometown on demand. Also there’s no guarantee of meeting a guy this good again. I broke up with my first boyfrind assuming that good guys grew on trees but it took 4 yrs (and a lot of misery/lonliness) for next good guy to appear.

Depnds a lot what your family is. Like if you only have elderly parents then it’s not rally worth moving to thm and they can probably move in woth or near to you at some ppont. But if yoh left behind a big clan of extended family that you long to be part of again then all I can do is suggest you rejoin it or say goodbye to thenidea of raising family in it.

5foot5 · 04/11/2021 23:22

:16WaterBottle123

You both sound unusually emotionally dependent on your families, this should reset when you make a family of your own. So no, don't break up over this, madness!

Absolutely this.

Also, and I hope this will not apply, but you don't even know if you can have kids yet.

If you have a DP who feels like the one, surely that is the main thing. What if you threw thatcaway and then DC never happened anyway?

DevilWaresPrada · 04/11/2021 23:09

Do you do jobs that you can WFH? Does one set of parents have spare rooms so you could stay with them for a week a month at least until the kids go to school?
Do you have lots of space for parents to come and stay?
Could you buy a house with an annexe (or two 😀)

bordermidgebite · 04/11/2021 12:09

Children can have really close relationships to grandparents even if they live miles away

It is different, rather than seeing each other every week, they might spend 2 weeks at a time living with them

Malacath · 04/11/2021 12:00

It's definitely a tough one. DH and I are from different countries and we knew we would be would only be able to live near one set of parents. Never would have occurred to either of us to split up over it though. We tried my country for a while but DH found it too hard to learn the language and felt isolated and depressed because we didn't live that close to any of my family. In the end we moved to his hometown and we have his mum who has been an absolute superstar in helping wherever possible and we get on incredibly well. My own mum's health has declined and she hasn't been able to travel much in the last 5 years. Despite that, when they were here 2 months ago both my DC were incredibly close to them and regularly mention them. I speak to my parents so much more on the phone. Obviously I wish we could be closer physically more often, but my point is that the DC are emotionally close to all available grandparents and we've all accepted the situation as it is - it can definitely work.

inferiorCatSlave · 04/11/2021 11:58

Mumsnet often has posts from people who have moved to be close to one set of parents who promised childcare. This then doesnt materialise because the GP aren't as interested as they thought they would be, or they develop health issues, or they move away themselves. Unless you have siblings who have kids, you dont know exactly how they will be with kids. It would be a massive gamble to move towards one set of GP.

This.

Life can throw really nasty surpises - someone I grew up with had set everything up early in life for children - house done near sibllings so cousin could grow uptogether - fertility problems were a nasty blow ffew years later they sold the house bought a project hosue changed careers and lifestyle.

Were we lived been dicated by work, house prices and later schools - sometimes that's put us close to family mostly not.

I think you might want to consider how parenting styles mesh as well as conflicts there can be difficult to resolve once children have arrived.

Feetupteashot · 04/11/2021 11:34

If you're not living near family now then I think you have to consider why. The reasons for being where you are now are probably valid and might be where you continue to live

There's no perfect time / person / place to have children with !

SaltySeaAir · 04/11/2021 11:31

Where do you live now? We live in Bristol (and did before kids) and both our families live in Cornwall - about 3hours away. My kids have a lovely relationship with their grandparents, they are all however quite young and visit us as often as we visit them. It can be hard not having family close by, but as long as you have a good support network of friends where you are it's all doable. When we do go down and see family it's lovely, feels like a holiday for the kids and they are properly spoilt 🙂 Seems a shame to break up an otherwise good relationship over this, I personally wouldn't do that. There must be a reason you live where you live now, I would stay where you are.

JumperandJacket · 04/11/2021 11:21

Sounds like you both need to be more flexible. Life isn’t predictable- say you met someone happy to live near your family and then they had to move for work or because their parent was ill, or what about if you moved close to your family and then your family had to move got some reason? All sorts of things might happen and you’ll just have to roll with it.

Bringing up children close to your family would be nice but it’s not vital. Ending a good relationship over it would be crazy.

Cameleongirl · 04/11/2021 11:17

Also bear in mind that GP’s don’t always behave the way you think they will! I thought DH’s parents would want to be very involved in our children’s lives, but it turns out that after raising four of their own ( vey well, they were great parents), they’re not especially interested in GC. They liked them as babies when they couldn’t talk, but once they turned three, we’ve hardly seen them! Perhaps some people can’t deal as well with children when they’re older- that’s my assumption with my IL’s anyway. They’ve behaved in the polar opposite way to what I’d assumed!

RowanAlong · 04/11/2021 09:21

Yes, pick one side, don’t move half way between.

I moved to be closer to my parents. It turns out that was the wrong move, as once I had children the emotional distance between my mum and me that had been lurking there, and the differences between how she and I parent, became massively apparent! Should have moved to be nearer my in-laws, who are much more easy-going people, and bring a sense of joy and fun to the project of child-rearing, and don’t criticise my parenting.

Think hard about how you want to parent, and what sort of grandparents you really need nearby. Who will offer practical, non-judgmental support when you are at your most vulnerable and knackered? Who offers more of a feeling of warmth, optimism, jollity, etc? And be honest about it if it’s not your side of the family!

AtLeastThreeDrinks · 04/11/2021 09:18

My parents were down the road when we had a baby and they were a godsend, I don’t know what we would have done without them. (Struggled!) Unless you’re especially close to you MIL I think it’s natural for a lot of women to want to be close to their mums when having their own babies if you have a good relationship. Would a compromise be moving closer to them for the baby/toddler years, and then moving to his parents’ at school age?

Have you spoken to both families to gauge their plans for retirement? You might find one set more interested in grandchildren than the other, or more hands-on. It’s impossible to know what the reality will be like so yes, I do think you’d be throwing away a good thing for a huge unknown if you were to break up. Dating when wanting to settle down and start a family can be hard and emotionally draining.

coogee · 04/11/2021 09:03

Don't most people just stay where they are already when they have children?

That’s what I thought.

ThePlantsitter · 04/11/2021 09:02

For me this isn't a question of where it's best to bring up your children, but how you make decisions as a couple when you want different things. If you can find a way to do that your relationship will strengthen massively. If you can't, then yes you may as well call it a day.

I know some people who make these decisions by each secretly ranking out of ten how important an aspect of the subject is to them, (e.g support immediately after birth; contact with siblings; whatever else you can think of) and then revealing your scores and talking about them. Sort of helps because you're breaking down the decision into its constituent parts.