Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools worth it?

219 replies

Anon2136 · 03/11/2021 14:20

I’m really torn on whether to put my DD in private school. She’s in year 2 and the private’s near us start from year 3. We can afford it, We’re not super rich but both working and in good enough jobs although we will have to cut back on some things but money wise yes it’s doable. Also I will have to keep working I enjoy working but sometimes I wish I could cut my hours and be at home more. I’m really torn on what to do. Im going around in circles I keep convincing myself that her primary is good enough but then something happens then I think private might be worth it. I’m not sure what to compare it with but for example she very rarely has her homework marked by teacher and it’s frustrating as we spend all weekend doing the homework.

Please be kind and obviously give me differing views but no attacking. I actually asked same question couple of years back but got attacked by people being really nasty and done comments were awful that in end I just didn’t read anymore. I’m hoping this time I can get some useful advice. Any cons to private you can think of please tell me.

Thanks in advance for any useful advice I get.

OP posts:
Blueuggboots · 04/11/2021 14:00

We've put my son through private primary.
He's high functioning ASD and ridiculously bright but struggled in larger groups of children when younger due to social issues.
He's really excelled at the private primary - not just academically, but socially too.
We did not put him into private primary to gain a place at the private secondary - we did it because at the time, it was the best fit for him.
He's now in a class of 25 (year 6) and much better equipped to deal with it.
We're considering the private school his primary feeds into and a state school for next year.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 04/11/2021 13:31

@rrhuth

Lol!

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/11/2021 13:30

*dire!

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/11/2021 13:30

@Merryhobnobs

I think education should be equal and therefore would never place my children in private schools. Having said this we have decent schools as our catchment and have the opportunity as parents to get involved if there were things we wanted changed/involved in. My husband is a lecturer at a very good university and the private school children are often very academically excellent but don't always have a wider idea of how most people live, can be entitled and it's just not the ethos we want for our children.
You can’t really claim to stand by your principles - unless the state schools around you are sure and you still send your kids to them with no extra tutoring or anything else.
queenofarles · 04/11/2021 13:29

the private school kids are more likely to get hired. Partly because their rich school friends daddy owns the company don’t be daft,

There was a thread recently "if you went to private school what do you do for a living" or something close , the majority are working standard jobs .
Some become high earners some don’t.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/11/2021 13:22

@honkytonkheroe

I've had 2 daughters go to Russell Group unis. Both A/A*s at GCSE & A level. Both at uni with many private school kids and both have always wondered why people privately educate when you can end up at the same place without it.
Because there are too many variables affecting achievement and as the excellent @WombatChocolate pointed out what’s right for one family may not be for another.

Around here parents pay through the nose to get into the catchment area of the very good state schools, club together to pay for activities. It’s a state school in name but the demographics of the catchment area have made it such that you’re not going to find many (or even any) disruptive children as parents are quite involved.

Meanwhile in a ‘mixed’ area of London the state schools were dire, lots of teachers’ time spent on handling disruptive students/discipline rather than actually teaching. Lessons catered to the slowest (many were so behind) that the bright ones got bored.

Finally a lot of private schools offer things like good wraparound care which make financial sense for working parents.

A lot to consider and very very individual. And as mentioned some state schools can be as ‘exclusive’ as private school. So no moral superiority there.

Merryhobnobs · 04/11/2021 13:18

I think education should be equal and therefore would never place my children in private schools. Having said this we have decent schools as our catchment and have the opportunity as parents to get involved if there were things we wanted changed/involved in. My husband is a lecturer at a very good university and the private school children are often very academically excellent but don't always have a wider idea of how most people live, can be entitled and it's just not the ethos we want for our children.

lousanne · 04/11/2021 13:10

@notsureconfused 'would have been worth it'.

@Evesgarden 'you're too late', not 'your'.

Grammar is usually irrelevant but I find it amusing on here - you are parents who clearly care about education, yet don't know simple grammar? What if your child asks you for help with their homework?

lousanne · 04/11/2021 13:04

@charliesbookmarker it's 'hear, hear!'. As in: 'listen to what this person is saying', so you're agreeing with them.

rrhuth · 04/11/2021 12:43

@Evesgarden

These threads are bonkers. Every single thread turns in a 'State schools are better'

But honestly every one knows they are not. Its bizarre. State schools are in a shocking state.

Its exactly the same as private health care. Yes you get the same NHS doctors (sometimes) but you get much better standard of care.

State schools, to me, are better because they have all the families in who choose state schools.

My kids would have been private school kids if they'd gone to private school.

I wanted the best for my kids. They got the best.

usernamehell · 04/11/2021 12:28

@Flubbah

I am always surprised by the number of posters that feel only private secondary is worth it and primary is a waste of money I think it’s more to do with the fact that most people get richer as they get older, thus are more likely to afford private secondary school when they’re several years older and been promoted a couple of times. Also the kids who are going to be bad people haven’t reached that stage yet in primary school, they’re merely naughty and can be coped with. Whereas by secondary they’re likely to have become seriously problematic.
Affordability is not the same as value for money though. Completely agree that most people are more likely to have the funds as children are older but that does not make the early years less significant to spend on.

Don't agree with children being bad people - in my experience of private (acknowledge this may not be the case across the board), there is zero tolerance for disruption so being 'naughty' is not an option. (As a separate note, I don't believe children are inherently naughty - if NT, issues can be addressed with a supportive school and parents working together, ND issues are more complex to address but they are certainly not naughty either). If they have consistently been in this environment, they will know what is expected of them by the time they reach secondary

SqueakyPeaks · 04/11/2021 12:27

I absolutely agree with PP about academic outcomes being of minor importance to me. Independent school gives space and time to children.

Private school has given my DS the confidence to research and give an assembly (for example) to younger children, to perform in front of the school, to play instruments and in an ensemble. He is proud to do well and there's a culture of success and aspiration. Teachers are accessible. I email and they call me back at a time that's convenient to me.

In state school he couldn't access learning because there was so much disruption and chaos in a class of 30 high-need children. At his independent Primary there were 7 kids in his class and now at independent Secondary there are no more than 15, reducing to no more than 10 when he enters Senior school in year 9.

For DS, the experience has been richer, calmer and more exciting. He copes now. That's worth everything.

Evesgarden · 04/11/2021 12:10

These threads are bonkers. Every single thread turns in a 'State schools are better'

But honestly every one knows they are not. Its bizarre. State schools are in a shocking state.

Its exactly the same as private health care. Yes you get the same NHS doctors (sometimes) but you get much better standard of care.

secretbookcase · 04/11/2021 12:05

I'm always a bit puzzled by the parents who say 'my state-educated DC ended up at the same uni as private school DC so what was the point of private?' as if education is an end-game rather than a day-to-day experience.

My DC went private because I wanted them to be in an environment where it was cool to succeed. When DC got good marks they got the genuine respect of their peers. They weren't sneered at or bullied or ridiculed for being swotty or teachers' pets.

And FWIW when one was diagnosed with quite complex SEN he got outstanding support at no extra charge. At state school I was told perpetually he was lazy.

Lunificent · 04/11/2021 12:05

State primary. Start doing the grammar prep in year 5. You can do it at home if they’re biddable.

GnomeDePlume · 04/11/2021 11:57

If it is the extra curricular activities then it is worth looking at what is already available in the local area. Our county music service runs Saturday morning music schools which start from a very young age. There are also sports clubs, theatre groups etc.

It doesnt all have to be through school and in fact I think there is a distinct advantage in them not being through school as it gives a different friendship group. Small class sizes etc are lovely if everyone is getting on but rather less lovely if there are friendship problems.

Flubbah · 04/11/2021 11:29

I've had 2 daughters go to Russell Group unis. Both A/As at GCSE & A level. Both at uni with many private school kids and both have always wondered why people privately educate when you can end up at the same place without it.*
Because when they leave university and start applying for jobs, the private school kids are more likely to get hired. Partly because their rich school friends daddy owns the company.

Flubbah · 04/11/2021 11:25

I am always surprised by the number of posters that feel only private secondary is worth it and primary is a waste of money
I think it’s more to do with the fact that most people get richer as they get older, thus are more likely to afford private secondary school when they’re several years older and been promoted a couple of times. Also the kids who are going to be bad people haven’t reached that stage yet in primary school, they’re merely naughty and can be coped with. Whereas by secondary they’re likely to have become seriously problematic.

ferretface · 04/11/2021 10:55

I went to a GDST private school for secondary after going to an excellent local primary. For me private school was pretty life changing and opened up opportunities I could never have had in the state system - I was quite academically gifted as a teen and the private school arranged the lesson timetable (!) so I could do 5 A-levels, I also got a fully funded scholarship to study abroad for a year. There's no way I would have had access to those opportunities otherwise. BUT I know that some classmates hated school, particularly if you were dyslexic or dyspraxic the school really was not good at bringing the best out of these students. Basically if you were good at sport or academically talented the school gave you so much, if you struggled they were not good at supporting. Don't know how universal this is but i suspect in the private system with entrance exams etc there will always be an element of it.

Splatling · 04/11/2021 10:51

I think I cross-posted with @FiddleFigs, but precisely the same experience. Also in the local area.

I wanted to add that I really value being able to email their teachers now, even with simple queries - communication is really easy, both ways. Unlike the prior school, where it seemed to be a criminal offence to try and talk to the teachers about anything! The previous school had a headteacher that was very offstandish - not welcome to new ideas or suggestions.

Andante57 · 04/11/2021 10:50

I still think that people need to admit that a lot of these schools have entrance exams so less able dc just can’t get in hence their better results

Lucentblade it’s hardly a secret that many private schools have entrance exams.

Splatling · 04/11/2021 10:45

@Anon2136 We were in a similar boat last year, although ours were a little older - we already missed the start of Year 3, and had another in Year 5. Local state school started out great, it was a small community school, Outstanding ofsted, well-regarded in the local area.

Even before the pandemic, I thought the school were not really pushing my children enough, and during and after the pandemic, there was a real decline in the standard of education being provided. Even when they were back in class. Similar to what you say, teachers just didn't seem engaged in their development, no work being marked, etc.

I'm not blaming the teachers, I know how tough it's been. But at the end of the day, our children are put through the education system only once. They only get one shot at learning through each stage - so I looked around for prep school places, and we were very lucky to find a place for one child, followed by the other.

The difference in the attitude to learning is vast. There is such a positive atmosphere in the prep school, and my children are so much more engaged with their learning. They find learning fun now, whereas before they would constantly tell me about how disruptive the class was. They would have been happy to stay in the state school, but they didn't know any different.

It was a difficult decision to make, not just financially, but also concerns about if they didn't settle in the new school, especially for the older one. However I think once you start getting doubts in your mind about the current school, it's really difficult to ignore those niggling issues.

Whatever you decide, best of luck. However if you do decide to move, try for Year 3 - they work around a year ahead of state schools, as some prep schools do help prepare for independent secondary school entry (if they only go up to Year 6). There has been less focus on grammar school entry (different type of exam) as many parents stick with the private route. Also I was surprised to learn that many of the parents still pay for additional tuition - I don't think that's necessary, but each to their own.

FiddleFigs · 04/11/2021 10:34

We've recently moved DD from state primary to independent prep (St Aubyn's - which I think is in your neck of the woods, OP). She was at a local OFSTED outstanding primary, but she found school boring and noisy. She's a high achiever, and just wasn't being challenged (and I can completely understand the difficulty in doing this with a class of 35 kids).

It's only been a few weeks in private, but she has a completely different outlook. She loves that it's quiet, that everyone is interested in class, that she's given extra work when she finishes a task, that she gets to learn netball and has singing, music and art. It's a different world, and has made her love going to school again. So for her, it absolutely was the right choice.

Gwlondon · 04/11/2021 10:25

You never really know how much tutoring is going on state and private until you are in a school. Even then parents don't talk about it and you slowly realise how many people are doing it.

Also there are some academic private schools, some middling and they have a range of abilities.

LucentBlade · 04/11/2021 10:19

No one really knows till you get end product. I worked in academia for many years until I became ill. So dc had been filtered already. I still think that people need to admit that a lot of these schools have entrance exams so less able dc just can’t get in hence their better results.

We didn’t send DS to a private school, DH went to one of the best private schools in the country. I didn’t but we met whilst working at the same RG University. We knew we could actually tutor DS at home if required in a lot of subjects to beyond A level. So we just didn’t bother and he achieved three A levels at grade A. DS state school had dire results but we knew our child, it was a five minute walk. People ponder how clever their dc are and ask about stuff like the gifted and talented register on here. DS is naturally academic like his parents, DH is literally at genius levels brain wise and his research has helped save millions of lives.

Are you sending for results, for the alleged polish, for the contacts in the hope that it will lead to big money?

Best paid people we know personally are two of DH mates who ended up working as bankers in the city, both state educated but did read for their PhD’s at Cambridge where they met DH. Next level down are academics and Medics, mix of state and private.

Then there are some people who have never achieved a great wage and they are a mix of state and private. Then what of people on a personal level, their relationships both romantic and platonic. Again a mixture. Really clever dc will do well wherever you send them. My friend went to a really rough school where the police and social services rolled up all the time for awful reasons. She was taken on to the grad scheme at PWC.