Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools worth it?

219 replies

Anon2136 · 03/11/2021 14:20

I’m really torn on whether to put my DD in private school. She’s in year 2 and the private’s near us start from year 3. We can afford it, We’re not super rich but both working and in good enough jobs although we will have to cut back on some things but money wise yes it’s doable. Also I will have to keep working I enjoy working but sometimes I wish I could cut my hours and be at home more. I’m really torn on what to do. Im going around in circles I keep convincing myself that her primary is good enough but then something happens then I think private might be worth it. I’m not sure what to compare it with but for example she very rarely has her homework marked by teacher and it’s frustrating as we spend all weekend doing the homework.

Please be kind and obviously give me differing views but no attacking. I actually asked same question couple of years back but got attacked by people being really nasty and done comments were awful that in end I just didn’t read anymore. I’m hoping this time I can get some useful advice. Any cons to private you can think of please tell me.

Thanks in advance for any useful advice I get.

OP posts:
Incognito22333 · 05/11/2021 08:57

For me, independent is largely about extra curricular opportunities at secondary level if the independent school fully supports your child’s talents. On academics alone, if you have an academic child, grammar all the way or great comprehensive that streams well.

But if you have an academic child who also really needs their extra curricular talent supported fully in school eg music, a particular sport, art, particular strong drama then it can be worth it but you have to really question in detail the provision the independent actually provide.
At primary, a good independent will introduce to a wide range of extra curricular activities but let’s say you have a talented dancer, unlikely to be supported fully.
One of mine had anxiety in large lovely primary so went independent from year 3. It was worth it for him because they had that extra time for him to build his confidence, nurture his musical talent, encourage drama, actually were able to get him to do sport. But my two confident all rounders who push themselves- state absolutely fine and I don’t expect academic outcome to be any different anyway.

Bunnycat101 · 05/11/2021 07:58

I am currently doing some open days to consider year 3 entry. I’d ideally not go private yet for financial reasons but fully intending to for secondary. The biggest differences as far as I can tell

  • much better music provision, opportunities for orchestras etc
  • sport at our state school is good but would be better at the private as can access so many facilities
  • smaller class sizes
  • less behavioural issues.

It is the latter that will swing it for us tbh. I’m keeping an eye over year 1 but there are a number of aggressive boys in my daughter’s class and I feel like if it’s bad when they’re 5 I’m worried it will get worse as they age.

shallIswim · 05/11/2021 07:54

@Anon2136

The other thing I am considering is once she’s older we have lots of grammar schools in area so that’s a possibility. I have no idea where to see their data as they don’t publish it.

One negative adjective if grammar I feel is the single sex education. I don’t really want DD to have any issues going to single sex school. Maybe I’m not thinking clearly but I feel single sex education has more cons than pros.

I agree - another can of worms entirely!

I do want you to bear in mind generally that home remains the biggest influence on a child's educational outcomes. So if you are motivated your child will be. Conversely if you're not and perhaps feel you lack educationally your child may benefit from an uplift elsewhere. There were lots of kids at my DC's comp who would have done far better if their parents had been able to afford private. For mine I think it would have made no difference grades wise (since they literally aced everything that was put in front of them). But perhaps it would have given them extra confidence and would definitely have given them better contacts. Also we found that Oxbridge prep was non existent at DC's (now failing) comp. DS had to muddle through all by himself.

DublinDoris2000 · 05/11/2021 07:41

Our boy is on private primary school, as it suits us best for a lot of reasons
-Mixed and non religious (rare in South dublin)
-No uniform
-Sports every day
-Small classes
I'd think I out what individual schools offer rather than just thinking private/public. I know a Eton style public school wouldn't be for us.

Anon2136 · 05/11/2021 03:48

The other thing I am considering is once she’s older we have lots of grammar schools in area so that’s a possibility. I have no idea where to see their data as they don’t publish it.

One negative adjective if grammar I feel is the single sex education. I don’t really want DD to have any issues going to single sex school. Maybe I’m not thinking clearly but I feel single sex education has more cons than pros.

OP posts:
Anon2136 · 05/11/2021 03:45

Apologies for all typos. * do = so

OP posts:
Anon2136 · 05/11/2021 03:44

@Hosum I’m still here! Sorry it’s just a lot to read and consider do I haven’t responded to any recent posts. Im definitely reading everyone’s opinions and taking on all the advice. Thank you everyone for your input, I am still 50% 50% about my decision do this is really helping.

Yes we’re in Redbridge but problem is the state primaries that are amazing and outstanding are over subscribed and impossible to get into. My DH Went state and his primary is amazing but we will never get in as out if catchment and numbers are ridiculous e.g. over hundred on waiting list!

DD is in a fairly new primary but as it’s a religious based school the catchment is wider hence we got in. The state primary that are in our catchment are awful - the KS2 results are horrendous and data shows below and we’ll below average.

The primary she’s in is also oversubscribed mainly due to being a religious school. I’m not bothered about the religious aspect, only sent her here as our local one has awful ks2 results.

OP posts:
Ticksallboxes · 05/11/2021 00:43

Hmmm...I do tend to agree with @WombatChocolate and @MojoMoon.

My son left a state junior for a year to attend private school but, at that particular one anyway, it was very much a self-made new money environment. I met a lot of hairdressers anyway!

He eventually returned to his original state school as we were convinced he was actually mixing with more intelligent children there. But he became incredibly confident which has lasted and this thread has got me thinking.

I grew up with a lot of privately educated people and, regardless of grades, almost all started their own, successful businesses. I think that's what a private education gives you - confidence.

notsureconfused · 04/11/2021 23:34

What has my grammar got to do with this thread at all? How can you base your judgement on my ability to help my child with their homework on a hastily tapped out reply on my phone? I was trying to help the op by sharing my experience. What are you doing?

thepeopleversuswork · 04/11/2021 23:08

@Andante57

But I still at some level find it nauseating

Peopleversuswork if that’s how you feel, plus the fact you don’t approve of private education, then why on earth are you considering it for your dc?
You sound like a massive hypocrite.

I am. That's why I said I was in my post. Grin

It's having a bit of self awareness.

uneffingbelievable · 04/11/2021 23:00

I send my child to a private school- because they are happy, not being bullied and the school is delivering me a happy thriving child who is growing into a lovely adult. The school suits my child.

I do not need a financial return on "my investment" and to be honest I find those comments offensive.

I was state and always said no to private, until my child was having the crpa being bullied out of them and the teachers did not have the time to give a shit about yet another child. Had not noticed in the melee of the class that they were struggling to read, was dropping far behind and did not have the resources to help.

Horses for courses - would have stayed state if it had fitted but it did not. An unhappy crying failing child is a disaster and if you have the resource to fix it, then why the hell wouldn't you. What they do in the long term is to be honest irrelevant - a happy content child at whatever level they end up at is more important.

( I am the high achieving 3 degree adult - it suits me but not everyone)

Heiferr · 04/11/2021 23:00

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

This isn't correct though. State Schools absolutely do pick up the slack in this respect

This has not been my personal experience in life. I have a lot of friends and have been to uni and worked in offices etc and anecdotally the people who were privately educated are always far more polite. That’s just my personal experience and I’m willing to accept that there will be an element of bias there too but I’m just saying.

I too have friends, I too went to uni, I too work. At no point has it ever occurred to me to correlate somebody's manners and politeness with their educational background. I could also counteract your anecdote with the amount of people I've worked with that have been privately educated and been utterly appalling in their attitudes including my current boss but in my view that's down to them as individuals rather than the school they went to 20 years ago!

I will always object to the idea that state school = poor manners. For a start, schools get judged on it by ofsted. They simply aren't "allowed" to ignore poor behaviour. I've been doing the rounds on open evenings this year while I look for a school for my daughter, every single one talks about high expectations where manners are concerned. Another anecdote, some of the loveliest and most polite children I've worked with have had some of the worst parents 🤷‍♀️

Hosum · 04/11/2021 22:10

I imagine the OP may have left ages ago but if Woodford is where you are aiming - I'm assuming the other Redbridge schools plus the local independents - Bancrofts, forest, Chigwell. All are completely accessible from a state primary into 11+ - it is just the toss up of time - prep will prepare them within school - non prep you'll need to either do it yourself or get a tutor -even just timed exam practice is needed for the brightest and it isn't covered at state. So it depends - enter at 7 save the stress cost 30k or enter at 11 but accept you need to have 6 months continual drip feed prep on top of school (unless a feeder independent).

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 04/11/2021 22:07

@Andante57

I still think that people need to admit that a lot of these schools have entrance exams so less able dc just can’t get in hence their better results

Lucentblade it’s hardly a secret that many private schools have entrance exams.

I agree to an extent, but you don't have to be a genius to pass the entrance exams for most private schools. Yes some are super selective but many are strapped for cash these days and need to fill their places.

Also, you don't see many under achieving private primary school children not make it into the associated senior schools or sixth forms.

BoardingSchoolMater · 04/11/2021 22:01

OP, my children have been right the way through independent schools, and it has nearly killed us financially - but it has been worth it. However, it was a no-brainer for us as everyone in my and XH's family went through the independent system, and I was quite happy to have a small house, not go on holiday, have one ancient rust-bucket family car etc. Only 9 more months to go until the final DC finishes...

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 04/11/2021 21:56

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

School is also more than just academic education and I think that private school is better all round, including for manners, etiquette, extra curricular and attention to the emotional needs of the children.

Conversely re SEN I’ve actually heard state schools are vastly superior in that field.

I disagree. It's not the 1920's! Children in state schools are likely to be equally polite!

I went to private school and the people I met we're no more polite or proper than the people I met in real life.

Many private schools have comparatively higher rates of drug use. Eating disorders can also be a massive issue.

I'm not against private school at all. I'm considering it for my own children. Not all private schools are posh and I can assure you that my teenage friends swore, smoked and had under age sex as much as the state school kids did!

Andante57 · 04/11/2021 20:59

But I still at some level find it nauseating

Peopleversuswork if that’s how you feel, plus the fact you don’t approve of private education, then why on earth are you considering it for your dc?
You sound like a massive hypocrite.

TatianaBis · 04/11/2021 20:56

Exactly, if the worst came to the worst, you can downsize.

The sibling I mentioned could have done that. They have 2 large houses, they just chose to keep them and move the kids’s schools rather than rather than sell. They were at boarding school though so we were talking 120k+ a year.

TSSDNCOP · 04/11/2021 20:53

Here for a flaming perhaps. Having sent DC to private primary and secondary I would say move at secondary, unless you have good grammars.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/11/2021 20:35

To be fair @TatianaBis we didn't send DS until we had 4 years' fees in the bank and were secure in the fact that we could flog the house and move 2 miles south of the school to free up enough capital to pay the rest of his and dd's. Never ever would we have expected wither of them to reverse back for the lack of funds. I had school friends who did. It didn't go well.

TatianaBis · 04/11/2021 19:47

DH’s NHS salary wouldn’t cover 3 sets of school fees after tax.

But that’s ok as we have my income and investments.

If everyone avoided private school for fear of redundancy no-one would go.

And having to move to as state school is not the worst thing that could happen. One of my siblings had to move their kids due to Covid’s impact on business and they’re all really happy. It’s a lot more laid back.

Indoctro · 04/11/2021 19:16

Comfortably affording it is being able to afford it and all your normal bills on one parents income

If you can't do it on one income you can't afford it.

Last thing you need is children at private then a redundancy happens and kids have to be removed from the school

If you can't afford it , tutoring is a good option.

thepeopleversuswork · 04/11/2021 19:10

@Evesgarden

I'm not sure where you think I was nasty? I've admitted I'm considering private for my own child.

I said and I stand by this that I think reasons people choose private (and I include myself in this analysis) are not entirely rational. And that the people who have the most to gain from private are generally the ones who have the least chance of getting into them. That's not nasty!

I'm having a grown up discussion like lots of other people on here so please don't tell me which threads to post on!

Evesgarden · 04/11/2021 19:01

[quote lousanne]@notsureconfused 'would have been worth it'.

@Evesgarden 'you're too late', not 'your'.

Grammar is usually irrelevant but I find it amusing on here - you are parents who clearly care about education, yet don't know simple grammar? What if your child asks you for help with their homework?[/quote]
When you start picking grammar to prove a point you really are scrapping the barrel @thepeopleversuswork. I don't understand why people get so nasty when discussing private schools, maybe you should avoid these threads if it stirs negative feelings within you.

I was eating my dinner when I typed that so wasn't that invested tbh meh ..

Now - if your asking about superlative adjectives then you've got me! That shit just goes right over my head! Grin

rrhuth · 04/11/2021 18:55

@Andante57

State schools, to me, are better because they have all the families in who choose state schools

Rrhuth so you’re saying all parents at state schools could have sent their children to private schools but they chose state schools?
Are you sure about that?

No, of course not, but obviously everyone who chose state school is in state school, that is pretty obvious! There are five groups of people:

Those who can afford private and choose private
Those who can afford private and choose state
Those who can not afford private but would choose private
Those who can not afford private but would choose state
Those who don't give a shit!

I sent my children to the school where I thought the best peer group and the best opportunities would be. State school.

The idea that we would all choose private if only we could is nonsense. I chose freely - state school.