Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this unbelievably discriminatory

90 replies

bagpuss90 · 03/11/2021 12:55

I belong to a small ladies club -there’s around 15 of us . We meet for drinks, socials and various other things It’s been decided that we should open a bank account and appoint a treasurer to deal with the money side of things - I might add that we are not talking huge sums here. One of the members said she was happy to be treasurer -she works in accounts. Two of the other members have says they are not happy with her dealing with the money because she lives in a council house, is probably not financially stable and might be “tempted”. Talk about stereo type . I’m pretty sure this hasn’t got back to the person in question. It’s made me so cross -I don’t actually think I want to be a part of it anymore. I haven’t had a chance to talk to anyone else to find out what they think about these comments .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
x2boys · 07/11/2021 14:58

@SheikhMaraca

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

This may blow your mind but in some parts of the country there is little discernible difference between private and social rent , And some housing association actually give preference to people that work.
iklboogiemaninthecloset · 07/11/2021 14:47

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

No. You really don't - despite what you believe in the Daily Fail.

Thedogscollar · 06/11/2021 00:12

@SheikhMaraca
Are you normally this rude, insulting and downright stupid?

LittleDandelionClock · 05/11/2021 23:32

@SheikhMaraca

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

Seriously, WTAF are you ON about? Confused

You are so unbelievably wrong about all this. Where are you getting this bullshit from?

LittleDandelionClock · 05/11/2021 23:30

@SheikhMaraca WTAF are you on about? Are you one of these clueless individuals that I mentioned earlier, who assumes everyone who lives in social housing is on benefits and gets the house for free?

As a number of posters have said, what a remarkably stupid and ignorant and ill-informed comment.

melj1213 · 05/11/2021 22:09

@SheikhMaraca

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

I occupy a Housing Association property via the council .... I did not have to be on benefits to qualify nor do I claim any benefits (beyond child related benefits that every parent is entitled to). I pay rent, council tax and all the bills just like any other rental, I just have a secured tenancy and more security than a private tenant.

Clearly you don't understand how council housing works ...

Blossomtoes · 05/11/2021 21:05

@SheikhMaraca

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

You’re really determined to show your ignorance. Yet more bollocks.
Mydogmylife · 05/11/2021 20:34

@SheikhMaraca
You sound absolutely awful

MushMonster · 05/11/2021 20:30

Not sure this of having a bank account will work here.
They are nasty.
I would stick to keep my money and pay for my own drinks and so on rather than sharing with them.

BackBackBack · 05/11/2021 20:28

@SheikhMaraca

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

It's s statement of bullshit love. Holding your views out as factual when they are easily disproved with a quick google makes you look incredibly silly.
titchy · 05/11/2021 20:24

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

Both statements are incorrect. Stop spouting shit you know nothing about. You just make yourself look stupid and bigoted. Or was that the look you were going for?

Newwifeatnumber10 · 05/11/2021 20:17

Disgusting, utterly disgusting behaviour. I could not be friends with these people.

IrishMumInLondon2020 · 05/11/2021 20:16

It’s not pleasant. Is she dodgy though? Surely there’s another reason for their hesitation.

tigger1001 · 05/11/2021 20:14

@SheikhMaraca

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

That's just ignorant.

There is no requirement to be on benefits to quality for a council house.

In some areas these on benefits may be higher up the list than others, but it is not a prerequisite. Many people in social housing are in work and do not receive benefits.

Maverickess · 05/11/2021 20:14

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

I'm in a HA property that used to be council (so the same thing but owned now by a non profit organisation instead of the council) I am not in receipt of benefits for myself because I work ft but earn nmw. That gives me a low income, not automatically from benefits from earned income
That's why I qualified.
You can be in private rented accommodation and be in receipt of benefits of in council/HA and be ft work with no benefits.

Garriet · 05/11/2021 20:12

@SheikhMaraca

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

Little bit confused that you think everyone in “council” / Housing Association properties are claiming benefits.

That’s why I said you’re ignorant. It’s demonstrably untrue.

Maverickess · 05/11/2021 20:09

If she were financially independent, then she wouldn’t be occupying a councIl property. To be doing so, she is demonstrably unable to support herself and I can understand why the others do not wish to have her managing their finances.

Why must people be judged on their income and assets and found wanting if they don't reach some imaginary standard instead of the actual person they are?
Being financially independent doesn't automatically mean you're of higher moral fibre, even if it were true that anyone in council or social housing isn't financially independent. It means they're paying lower rent, or more accurately fairer rent that matches their earned income (in an awful lot of cases) instead of inflated rents that outstrip the earning of lower income jobs. It has to be that way because many jobs aren't seen worthy enough to pay a wage you can live on and own your own home with.

SheikhMaraca · 05/11/2021 19:55

Little bit confused by the responses to my comment here.

If you occupy a council property, then by definition, you cannot afford to support yourself.

The council property itself is State benefit, and In order to qualify, the occupier also needs be in receipt of other benefits too.

If you’re on benefits of any form, you’re demonstrably unable to support yourself - It’s simply a statement of fact.

Garriet · 05/11/2021 18:07

If she were financially independent, then she wouldn’t be occupying a councIl property. To be doing so, she is demonstrably unable to support herself and I can understand why the others do not wish to have her managing their finances.

Astonishingly ignorant.

LittleDandelionClock · 05/11/2021 17:59

@bagpuss90 Is this for real? Shock

Mind you, the fact that some people are dense enough to believe that people in council houses get the house 'for free,' I can believe these people will be that ignorant or discriminatory.

Because like, NO-ONE with more money than they need ever steals do they? Hmm

BiscuitLover09876 · 05/11/2021 17:51

Who are these people? This is horrendous!

Blossomtoes · 05/11/2021 17:50

If she were financially independent, then she wouldn’t be occupying a councIl property. To be doing so, she is demonstrably unable to support herself and I can understand why the others do not wish to have her managing their finances.

What a load of utter bollocks. The vast majority of people living in social housing hold down jobs. Where does this nonsense come from?

Bettysnow · 05/11/2021 17:42

No i don't think you should leave if you enjoy the activities etc however i would not let this go unchallenged. You need to take this idiot down a peg or two and stand up for whats right.

TruJay · 05/11/2021 17:19

Wow!
I’m not surprised though, I remember being invited to a sleepover at my friend’s house, they lived in a big private house and I lived on the council estate.
The morning after at breakfast, her mum said to me “I must say TruJay, had I known where you came from I would never have let you in my house, never mind sleepover.” Shock she then went on to complement my behavior and manners and tell me how I was the most well behaved child they’d ever had stay over.
I thought it was a nice complement so took the silver candlesticks out of my bag before I went home Grin
Seriously though, I’ve had this discrimination my whole life, people with this view are disgusting. And in my experience whenever I went into town shopping with my friends (all from the massive houses in the private areas) it was always them shoplifting. My mum always warned me to immediately leave the shop if anyone I was with starting to steal as it would be me getting the blame, the ‘little council scruff’.

Did you call them out on their despicable view? I wouldn’t have been able to hold my tongue.

tigger1001 · 05/11/2021 16:53

I would say though that two signatories is always a good idea on group monies. It protects everyone, including the treasurer.