Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you ever really come back from having huge fights with in laws ?

143 replies

nubbie · 03/11/2021 11:36

To cut a long story short, I think there's a big personality clash between my in laws and I.

I don't think they're bad people. I don't think they generally mean harm. But it's just a bad fit.

We've had various big fights over the years.

I think eventually both sides will just give up and we will stop seeing each other socially. I would never stop them from seeing the grand children. But I just wouldn't spend time socially with them.

I think the narratives between us are so deeply engrained on each side, that there's always going to be friction.

It's always the same, they say something upsetting. I either let it go or I tell them please not to say or do whatever it is. They say I'm sensitive and shouldn't be upset and that they only ever mean good.

I understand it takes two sides to have a fight. But they never take any blame at all and basically attack my character. Saying I have a chip on my shoulder, a horrible mind and that I twist what they do.

They don't apologise for upsetting me. I end up apologising to them for making them aware of having upset me. Because I genuinely am sorry about it, because they just don't understand it. It's a character clash.

Anyway, it's just not healthy for anyone. Has anyone ever come back from a situation like this ?

And before everyone tells me that I'm the issue, I do think about this a lot and I analyse myself and I really really try to let as much stuff as possible go. But sometimes it just gets too much and I have to say something to stand up for myself.

As I said, it's not black and white. I understand sometimes I need to let things go/ not take things to heart and just brush stuff off. I try to do it as much as possible. But I acknowledge this to them as well and I apologise.

They don't seem to see any error in their ways and always put the blame on me having a strange personality and I just can't accept that's the only reason there's a problem.

It's a clash, which I'm happy to acknowledge, but they do not. They say it's me only.

Any advice ?

OP posts:
nubbie · 03/11/2021 17:06

But you all know how it will go if I stay distant. They'll again, blame me for wanting that.

They'll blame my unreasonableness and sick mind.

I have to live with that, I guess.

OP posts:
mygenericusername · 03/11/2021 17:01

No. You learn to tolerate them for the sake of your husband but I’d gladly push him under a bus if I could get away with it

RockinHorseShit · 03/11/2021 16:58

They sound very toxic & abusive. I'd definitely limit contact & id do the same with the DCs too. If they bitch about your family in front of you, then you can guarantee that they will do the same about you in front of your DC which would be damaging to your DCs as will undermining your parenting as they are already doing... avoid!

Avarua · 03/11/2021 16:50

Hey, you know your MIL is awful. Accept it. Laugh about it (in time). Just don’t spend any time with her. Let your DH go whenever he wants of course and you turn up dutifully for major events but stick to chat about the weather and go to bed early.

This is word for word what I do with my in laws. I like my FIL but MIL is toxic so I do the bare minimum. They don't like me anyway so why should I press my presence on them?

Pumpkinsonparade · 03/11/2021 16:39

I never gave my ils my mobile number.. Made for a quieter life. Maybe your phone is due an accident op? Block them. Say it must be a glitch.

Notonthestairs · 03/11/2021 16:36

@nubbie

Another one:

' no mum didn't undermine you when she kept saying you're holding your own baby wrong. She just means well. You're so sensitive. You take everything personal. '

Their starting point is that sensitive is bad.

I have a very sensitive friend (a worrier is probably more accurate) whereas I am quite slapdash. I adapt myself a bit around her because I know I can set her worrying and because I think she's lovely and an asset in my life I don't want that to happen!

So ask them - if you know I'm sensitive why would you want to upset me? Do you enjoy it?

But in this instance you'd be better off going low contact.
I'm really cross on your behalf.

ElsieMc · 03/11/2021 16:30

I took a decision not to see my PILs ever again after one final argument after I had dd2. They made a huge fuss about seeing the kids regularly but showed not one jot of interest in dd2 and only ever asked to see dd1. My children came as a pair and by allowing them to take one only, it was damaging to dd2 and was manipulative and cruel. It was a repeat of the behaviour with me.

An example of differing attitudes was when my dh was out of work for 4 months and we had a new baby. My parents wanted to give us some money to help out by we didnt want to take it. So my dad asked my dh to undertake some building and decorating work so he could "pay" him. We were all happy with this.

FIL told me in front of the family that I was a terrible person for "taking" money off my parents - he meant I had effectively charged them for decorating. This has always stayed with me.

I can see now he was trying to cut off lines of support and kindness from my family.

Put distance between you and them. Just stop seeing them. Believe me, you wont miss each other.

LilianRose · 03/11/2021 16:24

They sound awful.

Mine are just odd introverted people. DH is an only child and it’s so weirdly intense. They will barely even make eye contact with me or acknowledge me. MIL once patted me on the head and said ‘pat the dog’. No joke.

It’s a strange dynamic especially when you have children. My children are their life and they have nothing else going on.

You’re not being unreasonable here. I think it’s okay to not get on with in laws, let the relationship be with Dh and children. It can be quite sad when you have friends or family who have lovely in law relationships but it just isn’t going to be the case with everyone.

mbosnz · 03/11/2021 16:19

Do they also deploy that immortal line, 'Oh that's just how she is, she's never going to change, you've just got to learn to live with it'?

665TheNeighbourOfTheBeast · 03/11/2021 16:10

This sort of behaviour causes me to channel my long deceased grannie who would undoubtedly have said something along the lines of
"Aw get to fuck with you, always finding something to nasty to be saying, go have a rummage around my kitchen then see if you can find some filth in there to make you happy, and mind you dont come back without a nice hot cup of tea for us all, go on then away wit cha"
Just because someone else starts the row doesn't mean you have to finish it. Or care. Or lose.

Sciurus83 · 03/11/2021 16:08

You do spend a lot of time hand wringing and questioning yourself though hey? You know you're right. She sounds awful, I think you give this too much headspace and worrying about other people's feelings and analysing things when it's actually quite simple. She's rude and awful, tell her she is rude, yoy can do it withba smile so they're not quite sure you're serious. When other people tell you you're too sensitive say they're welcome to their own opinion but you don't agree. I mean it would be glorious if you could start referring to her and the other ILs as the "extended family", make it very clear that you are the family. But honestly stop seeing them so much, you don't have to have this in your life. Just why are you seeing them so much that you're having this many conversations with her and then the dissections from the other family members, cut them off! Let DH take the kids and do it significantly less than before. It's fine to do that this all sounds like a big old waste of energy. I mean you could just blow it all open and call her a vile b and to back off, I can't imagine ever actually doing that in real life or that you would from your posts but it would stop all this agonising once and for all!

nubbie · 03/11/2021 15:54

Another one:

' no mum didn't undermine you when she kept saying you're holding your own baby wrong. She just means well. You're so sensitive. You take everything personal. '

OP posts:
nubbie · 03/11/2021 15:53

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

Having read your updates, It's not you being over sensitive It's not clashing personality types It's not different family dynamics They are deliberately trying to wind you up. Repeatedly telling someone their bum looks big is bad enough but not acknowledging that not everyone would appreciate this is mental. There is literally nothing you could do to deal with behaviour like this other than just let them help you which obviously isn't viable. They won't admit they made a mistake they won't compromise and they won't acknowledge their part in the argument. So I think you've got two options. Ignore them or insult back. Mil: your bum looks so big! You: yes it's got bigger but still not as big as yours eg, ha ha Mil: that's so rude, how dare you You: it was a joke, you are so over sensitive!

I would honestly consider whether you want your children to be around people like this. Even if they don't do it to them (unlikely) they just sound nasty, and it's not good for them if you are there to see their mum being insulted

Yes this is accurate. But also she has her defence lawyers ( FIL and SIL ) who agree and ridicule me every time she brings this up during an argument.

They'll take her side on anything and always go into huge explanations..

' mum really didn't mean it like that. You always take everything personal. When mum was pregnant she wasn't offended when people told her she'd gained weight '.

' she was just having a laugh ' etc..

This is probably the worst part. Other family members defending her and each other when I point something out that's upset me.

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 03/11/2021 15:16

Having read your updates,
It's not you being over sensitive
It's not clashing personality types
It's not different family dynamics
They are deliberately trying to wind you up. Repeatedly telling someone their bum looks big is bad enough but not acknowledging that not everyone would appreciate this is mental.
There is literally nothing you could do to deal with behaviour like this other than just let them help you which obviously isn't viable. They won't admit they made a mistake they won't compromise and they won't acknowledge their part in the argument.
So I think you've got two options. Ignore them or insult back.
Mil: your bum looks so big!
You: yes it's got bigger but still not as big as yours eg, ha ha
Mil: that's so rude, how dare you
You: it was a joke, you are so over sensitive!

I would honestly consider whether you want your children to be around people like this. Even if they don't do it to them (unlikely) they just sound nasty, and it's not good for them if you are there to see their mum being insulted

diddl · 03/11/2021 15:15

@Blackmagicqueen

I think it depends if its just too much hard work tp maintain a relationship that possible is bringing absolutely no positivity to tour life. Sometimes blood really isn't thicker than water and estrangement is kinder all around.
Yup.

I mean they are deliberately nasty to Op & their own son.

How soon before they start on the kids.

And if adults can't deal with it...

There's no shame in thinking sod it they're not worth it.

paisley256 · 03/11/2021 15:13

They sound absolutely awful. No matter what you say or do it will always be wrong, they've already decided that. I'd have nothing more to do with them and as a PP said I'd keep my kids away from them as they'll be trying to poison their minds against you, their mother. All the best Flowers

thing47 · 03/11/2021 15:12

As Pallisers says, I'd be able to laugh off the 'big bum' comment, probably just say "well yes, I'm pregnant remember?".

But comments about my style of parenting? Nope, noppity nope. To that I would respond quite bluntly along the lines of not needing any parenting advice. If MIL carried on after that and was determined to get a response, the response she would get is 'fuck off.'

zoemum2006 · 03/11/2021 15:12

Your in-laws sound awful and I’d develop a very superficial relationship with them (and certainly not socialise with them).

I think it’s worth having very firm boundaries. I’d laugh if someone told me how to parent and maybe say “awww bless you” and leave it at that.

If they’re rude then laugh at them “omg what are you lot like, you crack me up with the things you say”. Just act like you think they are joking.

Keep as much distance as you can and emotional distance if you have to see them.

TheGirlCat · 03/11/2021 15:00

[quote nubbie]@blubberball he thinks it's totally unfair that the narrative is always me being the issue and that they can't see they genuinely upset me a lot.

I think it's pretty toxic for my health to be honest.

But if he stands up for me they tell him he's a traitor to his family. It's just a mess. And I feel for him because it really can't be easy.

It's not easy for in laws either. I also feel for them. But I just can't take it anymore and I think my life would be easier if I limited contact. Like I said, I want them in my children's lives. But do I really need to have dinners and christmases with them. I don't know, it's tough when there's such a clash. [/quote]
But if he stands up for me they tell him he's a traitor to his family. It's just a mess. And I feel for him because it really can't be easy.

He's not a traitor to family, as YOU are his family! When a man leaves his childhood home and enters into a marriage and new family with his wife, SHE becomes his family. He would be a traitor to his family if he didn't have his wife's back. His wife IS his family. Maybe they should be told that.

Blackmagicqueen · 03/11/2021 14:37

to possibly your*

Blackmagicqueen · 03/11/2021 14:36

I think it depends if its just too much hard work tp maintain a relationship that possible is bringing absolutely no positivity to tour life. Sometimes blood really isn't thicker than water and estrangement is kinder all around.

Jonnylovesjazz · 03/11/2021 14:33

They sound like my own parents. I’ve not seen them for over 15 years. They are horrible people.

Cheerbear23 · 03/11/2021 14:18

I honestly think killing with kindness won’t work with these people, they want to be able to to insult you with impunity and not be called out on it. They want to get away with it.
Sod that, you sound like have more self esteem than to let them get away with it- good for you!

nubbie · 03/11/2021 14:09

@Lollypop701

Stay away in general but if you must visit kill them with kindness (and consequences) Your bum is big- response I know, I love my bum as does dh(sly smirk) You should let your kids play in mud - ok mil, then let them tramp mud through house and smile at mil and say your idea was fabulous, they look so happy (same applies to chocolate hands on furniture) Your kitchen is dirty .. thank you I’d love some help, kids can be overwhelming, here’s a mop Your sil does x better… tell sil mil has offered her services to do x because you know, she is so amazing at it.. when can she do x

Or tell them to go to hell… personally I’m petty so would at least try killing with kindness 😂

Haha I've done this. Aw DC looks tired, shall we put her down for a nap? At 5:30 pm.... ' oh OK, so you want to stay up with her until 11 pm then ? ' smile Smile
OP posts:
Helloise · 03/11/2021 14:08

I've never had a huge fight with any other adult, I suppose the closest I came was the serious breakdown of a business-partner relationship but even that was dealt with through legal channels and any time we had to speak to each other it was civil, if strained. This isn't because I don't know any toxic people, I do, including my partner's father, but we deal with that by supporting each other, agreeing how we would deal with him together so we would present a united front, clearly setting boundaries, and then quietly but firmly ending conversations/leaving situations when those boundaries were crossed. it isn't easy, but it is simple - as long as your co-parent is willing to 100% support you (and vice versa) and that you present that united front. It's when partners get wishy-washy about that united front and leave you twisting in the wind with their toxic family that things really fall apart.