Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH calls his mum first

234 replies

JSmithy438 · 03/11/2021 11:00

I know I probably need to get a grip but it is really p me off when ever something bad happens to DH or there is a crisis for him he calls his mum first to tell her and me second. If it is something that involves me or the kids then he will call me first and his mum second but still I'd like to think he would call me first all the time.

Yesterday he had a REALLY bad day at work and was super upset, he called his mum first then me second.

OP posts:
DysmalRadius · 03/11/2021 14:45

A very dear friend of mine once had a pretty severe mental health crisis. Of all the people she spoke to at that time, the person who she had dreaded speaking to most (interfering and self-centred aunt) had astonished by saying: 'Call anyone that makes you feel better. Don't worry about what anyone else thinks - you have to call the person that can help.' And she said it was so lovely because that was what she needed to do and it came from such an unexpected source that it really helped her focus. Perhaps this is just one of those things that you can't change - can you live with it?

larkle · 03/11/2021 14:44

I think it is a refusal by some posters and by society in general that men have a right to emotional support. Suicide rates for men are so much higher than for women. We recognise the part played by family and friends in supporting our well being but when it comes to men, some posters think that men should not be allowed contact with their birth families and with being allowed to maintain friendships.
I really, really hope that MN leads the way in changing this sexist and damaging culture.

merrygoround51 · 03/11/2021 14:37

@DuckAndPancakes It’s all part of the Mumsnet ‘just us’ nuclear family narrative. What these posters don’t get is that they will also get older and their children will learn by watching them and in turn will choose to ignore their parents as it’s all about the ‘just us’ family

DuckAndPancakes · 03/11/2021 14:34

Some wonderfully vile, sexist shit being spouted in here Hmm Why do some women seem to be so very against men having relationships with anyone else and seem to think they have ownership?

AryaStarkWolf · 03/11/2021 14:20

as a mother of 6 sons and a daughter so many of the responses are quite upsetting actually.
all our kids know they can always rely on me and their father too. for some things we are interchangeble, while I'm better at dealing with some things, while DH is better at others.
they ask whoever is better for the job.
if at some point it will be a best friend, a spouse, a teacher, a doctor, a postman.... I wouldn't give a shit!! I'd just be happy they get the help they need.
But if I'm the best to help I'd be incredibly upset if someone was begrudging that...just because he is a man!!

I have one son, he's 17 now, we're very close, this thread makes me sad at how mothers and sons relationships are "supposed" to end up when they get older and I hope that doesn't happen to my son and me. I also have a daughter and don't have that worry at all because us being close is "allowed" ............apparently.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 03/11/2021 14:14

@JSmithy438

There are some thought provoking replies thank you.

Maybe there is no right or wrong way but it's not right for me, I want to be the go to person.

@JSmithy438

but you aren't right now and might not ever be.
then what?

some men won't talk to anyone they bury it: go straight to the pub, the gym, go for a run, work extra hours, overeat etc.
some take it out on others: wives, kids, colleagues
some might even start doing dangerous stuff

yours have found a safe solution that works for him.
do you want to be better than 2nd best? then allow him to continue to get the support he needs instead of focusing on what you want.

chunkymonkey101 · 03/11/2021 14:07

I think yabu. My first call in any situation was always my Dad. I love my DH but my Dad was my person who was practical and gave me the best advice. It was not a snub to my DH who is great, its just my dad was also great.

Hollywolly1 · 03/11/2021 14:06

I don't think the op has a problem with her husband telling his mother problems, its the fact he goes to her first rather than his wife

larkle · 03/11/2021 14:04

I remember a guest post on here on Mothering Sunday by a woman who had lost her mother. She admitted that it was her mother who she turned to first in a crisis and who she told first when she was pregnant and talked to first about the sex of her unborn children. She found the loss of her mother very hard to bear.
She received nothing but kindness, support and sympathy from posters. Imagine if a male poster wrote a similar piece about the death of his mother. There would no doubt be abuse about him being a 'Mummy's boy'.
You are being very unreasonable OP

AuntMargo · 03/11/2021 14:02

If he gets more comfort from ringing his mum, why shouldn't he, age is material, she will always be his mother. You're just being jealous !

MRex · 03/11/2021 13:58

@JSmithy438

There are some thought provoking replies thank you.

Maybe there is no right or wrong way but it's not right for me, I want to be the go to person.

That's a very strong statement. If this is the hill you want your relationship to die on then so be it, but you are being unreasonable. Are you so fixed on your wants that there's no room for anyone else's needs in other aspects of life too? Maybe if you had an independent person to talk with it might help?
Sittingonabench · 03/11/2021 13:57

I think YABU. I will go to my mother first in many instances - probably from my DH’s perspective more than I go to him first. But it isn’t about him. I love my DH entirely but he can’t and shouldn’t be my entire world and my sole support network.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 03/11/2021 13:57

@Tillysfad

I suppose it depends on the kind of relationship you want. I would personally want to be intimate with someone who didn't always call someone else first. Others might not care.

I think it highly likely that, if he has to have crises and be making these SOS calls like this, and always to one person, he's dependent and they're enmeshed. I would wonder what happens if there's an marital argument. Does he call her then too. Does she encourage him to stand on his own feet or encourage him to see the world as victimising him. What happens when a decision needs to be made that will affect the op and is already been discussed with mum so if op has a different view he's 'caught in the middle'. What happens when a boundary is needed as they always, always are. Does he know how to assert himself. What happens when mum and Gran have different views on raising children. What happens if op tries to observe that he seems to make a lot of sos phone calls. Does he observe that and take an opportunity for personal growth? I doubt it because he's got a person to call already.

I feel this way too.

I'm pretty resourceful and self-reliant, I never (in the past, my parents are both dead, I have no siblings) called either parent about anything, certainly not a 'crisis'.

SpaceshiptoMars · 03/11/2021 13:52

Maybe it's a shame thing. He knows he turns a bit childish for half an hour when things don't go his way, so he turns to Mum. When he's morphed back into an adult, you're good to go.

She still sees him as that cute little boy she tucked into bed. You see him as that big hunk of male gorgeousness who makes you breathe a bit faster. He wants to keep it that way!

Verfremdungseffekt · 03/11/2021 13:49

@LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus

I would find this pretty unattractive. A grown adult running back to their mum instead of discussing primarily with their partner, seems as though they are a bit dependent on their mum's views and support.
Seems as though grown adults might maintain a close relationship with the person who gave birth to them and brought them up. Weird, huh? Hmm
girlmom21 · 03/11/2021 13:49

@LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus

I would find this pretty unattractive. A grown adult running back to their mum instead of discussing primarily with their partner, seems as though they are a bit dependent on their mum's views and support.
What about if he went to a friend rather than his mother? Or a sibling?
LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 03/11/2021 13:48

I would find this pretty unattractive. A grown adult running back to their mum instead of discussing primarily with their partner, seems as though they are a bit dependent on their mum's views and support.

1309username · 03/11/2021 13:45

I might be a bit upset/taken aback if he told me one week later or even longer. But if he tells you the same day, I don’t think it’s a big deal.

Motherland101 · 03/11/2021 13:43

Maybe there is no right or wrong way but it's not right for me, I want to be the go to person.

With kindness OP, this is entirely your issue, not your DH's.

diddl · 03/11/2021 13:33

It does sound as if she offers different support.

Maybe initially he does just want to vent & have sympathy given.

I find it odd, but hearing his Mum being angry at who upset him obviously seems to work for him.

bobsholi · 03/11/2021 13:31

I call my mum first when I'm having a bad day. She is much better at supporting me when I'm having a tough time and coming up with solutions. DH is always in the 'think positive, you'll be fine' camp, which just isn't helpful.

ivykaty44 · 03/11/2021 13:29

maybe you are right but it still makes me feel 2nd best.

we cant be everything to our partners, life isn't like that.

Children need friends, husbands and wife need friends and confidants, for your husband its his mum. For many men its a mate down the pub or at fishing, football or a best mate. For many woman its their mum, sister, best friend

If you make your family your world and don't have others in that inner circle - it can become suffocating.

Verfremdungseffekt · 03/11/2021 13:27

@JSmithy438

There are some thought provoking replies thank you.

Maybe there is no right or wrong way but it's not right for me, I want to be the go to person.

But can't you see it as a good thing that he isn't entirely emotionally-dependent on you?

I wouldn't start doing the 'pick me' dance with your MIL for a start, you can't offer the same thing she does. You are married to this man, you live and have children together, you have intertwined finances etc you have a vested interest in him continuing to have a job and to manage his MH while in that job that your MIL hasn't.

pregnantncnc · 03/11/2021 13:27

I always call my mum first because she knows exactly what to say. She doesn't always help as much as DH, and I'm really not a "mummy's girl" - but my mum KNOWS the innate child-like me that comes out when I'm angry, hurt or upset and can chat to me for 5 minutes and make me feel positive or heard about the situation. DH will fire straight into practical advice, which is great and he does also listen, but if I go directly to him without either giving myself time to process or calling my mum, I find it a bit overwhelming.

gannett · 03/11/2021 13:26

@JSmithy438

There are some thought provoking replies thank you.

Maybe there is no right or wrong way but it's not right for me, I want to be the go to person.

This might be why you're not.

When you're having a bit of a crisis and need support, the last thing you want to do is go to someone who thinks it's all about them.