Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable to think they should correct this mistake?

134 replies

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 00:15

A friend is a representative for a well-known cosmetics firm. I recently made an order for items worth nearly £80 which arrived a couple of weeks later.

I was pleased with most of the items I received, but was disappointed to find that one item was not only the wrong colour, but it was also a slightly different and completely unsuitable product for me. As I can't use it, it's completely useless to me.

I let my friend know that same day and she said she would order the right one straight away and collect the wrong one the next time we meet. That was just over a month ago and I had heard nothing since.

This week, I've been thinking about ordering some more things from this company for myself and for Christmas presents, but was reluctant to do so until the mistake with my last order was rectified.

I sent a message to my friend asking when I could expect to receive the correct product and she told me that I had misunderstood her and that she would not order the correct product (which I have paid for) until I return the one sent to me in error.

Am I being unreasonable to think I shouldn't have to return an item I didn't order or want before I receive the item I have already paid for? I have seen the order my friend sent to the company. The mistake was definitely the company's and not hers.

I'm left feeling very let-down and disinclined to order anything else from this company.

OP posts:
WTF475878237NC · 03/11/2021 03:36

If it's their error different rules apply and they are at fault and need to send the correct item. If it's your error, you are under obligation to return it in order to receive the replacement.

Werehamster · 03/11/2021 03:36

It sounds like a miscommunication, but, yes, when you want to exchange a product, you give them the product and then they give you the correct product. You don't go into a shop and they give you the replacement and then you bring in the wrong product several days later.

I think you are being weird about this.

Saoirse82 · 03/11/2021 02:51

I'm assuming you don't do much online shopping? You need to return the item they sent you in error to get the replacement. I do almost all my shopping online and this is standard. It's a real PITA especially when it's their mistake but that's just the way it works unfortunately.

LanisHouseLot · 03/11/2021 02:24

I'm actually a bit surprised by some of the replies as my experience of online shopping has been that if the mistake belongs to the seller then they fix it without waiting for you to send back the thing. Many times they've even said to keep the thing they sent in error (sometimes because it arrived broken, but still). Obviously if I order the wrong size etc that that's my error and the onus is on me to return it.

With your friend changing her story, maybe the company wouldn't let her just order the replacement without her paying for it herself, so she ended up pretending you misunderstood. Maybe. Might make sense if she's skint, which is often the case with MLMs.

YukoandHiro · 03/11/2021 02:22

Of course you should return it if you want a swap.

KosherDill · 03/11/2021 02:20

I think the saleswoman should make the effort to collect it rather than putting the client to that trouble.

Djifunrsn · 03/11/2021 01:26

Yanbu

She said she’d order the right one straight away.
And that you could give her back the other one when you met.
And now she’s saying something different.

Regardless I’d avoid the company. 2 weeks for an order to arrive is just shit in the first place and MLMs are just wrong.

CatNameChange101 · 03/11/2021 01:22

So if you don’t trust the company why did you buy from them? MLM (which I think it is) of not, you simply don’t get a new product without returning the wrong one.

If it’s MLM like I think it sounds like you want your friend out of pocket to replace the product. Still YABU.

Basic rule - if it isn’t right return it so you get what’s right.

TheWestIsTheBest · 03/11/2021 01:16

But they are going to replace it once you return the incorrect item? I'm failing to see your problem here!

BananaPB · 03/11/2021 01:15

Have you ever shopped online? You send back the wrong item then they send you the right one.

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 01:15

@Fefifobum

Are you as dolly as your user name? Send the product back to the friend she’ll order the new product, that’s how online shopping works. Your friend isn’t a high street store?

It’s taken you a month to get back to her about it, maybe your hoping that it’ll do someone’s Christmas it they don’t ask for it back and you get a new one too...

Some classic projection going on there. Presumably that's what you would do...
OP posts:
AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 01:12

I trust my friend. I don't trust the company. I have offered to send the item to her, because for various reasons we haven't had the opportunity to meet up recently, but I am surprised and disappointed that a big - supposedly reputable - company cannot be more accomodating.

This was their mistake. Not mine. Not my friends. I don't usually buy products in this way and I have certainly never known a shop that expected a customer to return a faulty item and receive nothing in return. I have always received a replacement item or refund in such circumstances.

Still, live and learn, I suppose. It's a shame though, because the products they got right are lovely. Maybe that's why they get away with treating their customers and representatives like sh*t. 😪

OP posts:
CatNameChange101 · 03/11/2021 01:06

You understand how life works right?

Fefifobum · 03/11/2021 01:05

Are you as dolly as your user name?
Send the product back to the friend she’ll order the new product, that’s how online shopping works.
Your friend isn’t a high street store?

It’s taken you a month to get back to her about it, maybe your hoping that it’ll do someone’s Christmas it they don’t ask for it back and you get a new one too...

iwishiwasafish · 03/11/2021 00:57

Have you never shopped online before?

This is pretty standard!

elenacampana · 03/11/2021 00:56

Oh just give it back so she can swap them over. You’re making an issue out of nothing at all.

GiltEdges · 03/11/2021 00:55

Do you not trust your friend or something? Because it’s as if you feel the need to hold the current item as collateral until you get the one you ordered… which is frankly just bizarre Confused

Just tell your friend she can collect the item and she’s already told you she’ll then sort the replacement. Problem solved.

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 00:55

@HeddaGarbled

How odd of you. Of course you return the incorrect item in order to receive the correct one. Think of it like taking something back to a shop to get a replacement. You wouldn’t expect to get a replacement from the shop without taking the original item back, would you?
Of course I wouldn't, but neither would I expect to take an item back to the shop and receive nothing in return. I would expect the shop to replace it with the correct item.
OP posts:
araiwa · 03/11/2021 00:52

So give it back to her so she can exchange it? Confused

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 00:50

As I said in my original post, my friend said she would order the correct product (which I have paid for) and I could exchange it for the one sent in error (which I don't want and didn't order).

OP posts:
AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 00:45

I have every intention of returning the unwanted product. It is sitting safe and unused in a drawer. It is of no use to me.

My issue is that I have not received the product I paid for and I was given to understand that I could exchange the unwanted product with the one I ordered.

A month later, I am being told that they won't send the item I have paid for until I return the one I didn't order and don't want.

OP posts:
SpookyPumpkinPants · 03/11/2021 00:28

^^ what most everyone said

MrsBungle · 03/11/2021 00:26

Why on Earth wouldn’t you return the item you can’t use? It’s a mistake. Return the wrong item and receive the correct one. Confused

daisyroses · 03/11/2021 00:25

I think you should return it, but I read it as your friend said not to return until you saw each other but she'd sort it in the meantime and hasn't, which is unreasonable of her. I'd now return it to her so you get the correct product and use a different company/representative next time.

HeddaGarbled · 03/11/2021 00:23

How odd of you. Of course you return the incorrect item in order to receive the correct one. Think of it like taking something back to a shop to get a replacement. You wouldn’t expect to get a replacement from the shop without taking the original item back, would you?