Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable to think they should correct this mistake?

134 replies

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 00:15

A friend is a representative for a well-known cosmetics firm. I recently made an order for items worth nearly £80 which arrived a couple of weeks later.

I was pleased with most of the items I received, but was disappointed to find that one item was not only the wrong colour, but it was also a slightly different and completely unsuitable product for me. As I can't use it, it's completely useless to me.

I let my friend know that same day and she said she would order the right one straight away and collect the wrong one the next time we meet. That was just over a month ago and I had heard nothing since.

This week, I've been thinking about ordering some more things from this company for myself and for Christmas presents, but was reluctant to do so until the mistake with my last order was rectified.

I sent a message to my friend asking when I could expect to receive the correct product and she told me that I had misunderstood her and that she would not order the correct product (which I have paid for) until I return the one sent to me in error.

Am I being unreasonable to think I shouldn't have to return an item I didn't order or want before I receive the item I have already paid for? I have seen the order my friend sent to the company. The mistake was definitely the company's and not hers.

I'm left feeling very let-down and disinclined to order anything else from this company.

OP posts:
WTF475878237NC · 03/11/2021 08:42

Cannot understand how people are criticising you OP. The company made a mistake not you.

Laiste · 03/11/2021 08:39

OP - I don't know what an MSM is, but it certainly isn't the sort of organisation I would want to use if they behave this way.

OP MLM stands for Multi Level Marketing. Basically a business has representatives (your friend) to promote and sell the company's products to customers, while also recruiting those customers to become representatives themselves.

Often the rep (your friend) is under stress to make enough commission of orders to justify the workload of collecting/delivering/handling returns and mistakes.

Your friend has tried to make the mistake sound easy to rectify but has misled you by letting you think you'll receive a replacement product BEFORE returning the original.

Just return the original product and let her get on with a swap!

hibye123 · 03/11/2021 08:30

Of course I wouldn't, but neither would I expect to take an item back to the shop and receive nothing in return. I would expect the shop to replace it with the correct item

This is exact same thing as if you ordered items from a company online and for whatever reason they had sent you an incorrect item. In order to receive the correct item, you have to send the incorrect item back first.

Even though the company is at fault, they don't know if you'll send the incorrect item back once you've received the correct one. What your friend (& the company) is asking for is nothing out of the norm from any other company tbh

butterpuffed · 03/11/2021 08:29

Of course you have to return an item for exchange. The Company need to know that you're not going to keep it as well as a replacement, otherwise everyone would be doing it .

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 08:28

Thank you for your responses. Clearly the verdict is that I am unreasonable and as I asked the question, I accept that.

I would point out (if it's not clear in my first post) that I was not aware I had to return the unwanted item before the new one arrived. I was only told that yesterday. I was not 'withholding' it, neither was I intending to keep it as a Christmas present for someone else. It is of no use to me. There is nothing I can do with it apart from exchange it for the item I ordered and paid for, or throw it out.

This item is not something I ordered and didn't like or changed my mind. Neither is it a similar replacement for an out of stock item. It is a different product.

My friend originally said she would order the right one and we could do an exchange. That seemed perfectly reasonable to me. She has done everything right. It's the company that made a mistake.

I don't know what an MSM is, but it certainly isn't the sort of organisation I would want to use if they behave this way. I thought my friend's company was reputable.

OP posts:
Namechangehereandnow · 03/11/2021 08:27

terry … it really doesn’t matter - it’s very easily solved, instead of OP creating a massive drama 🙄

It would be very different if friend had said, no sorry nothing I can do. But friend has told OP what to do and how it will be fixed. Simple.

terrywynne · 03/11/2021 08:24

But who has delivered the wrong item to who? Rep to op. Company to rep. Or company to op.

Namechangehereandnow · 03/11/2021 08:23

Blimey OP. You may not agree with the practise but you have to follow their rules - just send the item back and you’ll get your replacement 🙄
Your friend has notified you of the incorrect communication originally, so now just follow the rules 🙄
You’ll get your product, why be an arse about it??

I’ve had incorrect items delivered online - I’ve had to return the incorrect item THEN I get the correct item sent out. It’s standard practise. Similarly, if I return an item to a store as there’s a fault or quickly developed a fault, I have to hand the item back first before getting a replacement - even to the point of having to wait if said item is out of stock and has to be ordered in - SHOCK HORROR, I have to go home empty handed and wait for my replacement to arrive 😱
Really, OP just get a grip, and do what’s required.

bedbathandbeyond · 03/11/2021 08:23

Your first mistake was buying from a MLM. The rest was bound to go down the toilet from there.

OneTC · 03/11/2021 08:19

It's just one of those shit aspects of distance customer service

Customer: I want to hold an item as insurance against your delivery

Company: outrageous behaviour, how very dare you, take this to MN and they will all shout at you

-----

Customer: I'd like to return an item and get it replaced with a new one

Company: very well, we shall hold your item as insurance against your delivery of the incorrect item

MN: Bravo

Platax · 03/11/2021 08:19

I suspect people are getting confused about the legal position because they are confusing it with the right to return goods you've bought at a distance where you discover that they're the wrong size or you don't like them, or there's something wrong with them. In that situation they have delivered what was ordered. In this situation, they've delivered something that wasn't ordered.

Platax · 03/11/2021 08:17

@malmi

They are not unsolicited goods, that's something completely different.
Nope. They sent OP goods she didn't order. It's the same.
malmi · 03/11/2021 08:16

They are not unsolicited goods, that's something completely different.

terrywynne · 03/11/2021 08:12

@Platax

Typical unthinking MN pile-on. As matters stand, the company is in breach of contract because it has not supplied the product OP ordered and paid for. They must supply those goods, unconditionally. Technically they have sent her unsolicited goods. Therefore it is their responsibility both to fulfil their contractual obligations and to make arrangements to collect the unsolicited product at no expense to OP.
Except her friend is a rep which means it is an MLM who has persuaded OPs friend she isba business owner. So the person with the responsibility is the friend, who probably can't afford to do the returns out of pocket.

Such a crap business model for anyone but the parent company

Hankunamatata · 03/11/2021 08:12

Your friend would probably have to pay to order the replacment item if she didn't return the wrong one first

terrywynne · 03/11/2021 08:10

For everyone asking OP if she has ever shopped online before, this is clearly MLM shopping via a rep not directly online. One of the ways MLM reps sell their services is on the personal nature (they will deliver direct to you etc). Unfortunately, contrary to what MLM companies say, being a rep does not make most people money so they will probably be paying to do deliveries. The rep probably can't afford to order the new item as they promised or to drive over and collect the item or to pay for OP to post it to her.

The company doesn't care. The reason Body shop (which this may be) and some other normal companies have gone down the MLM route is because it is cheaper for them as they have pushed all the hassle and cost of customer returns onto their reps (along with ridding themselves of the need to pay NI, sick pay, pension etc and getting reps to pay for marketing).

OP you and your friend are in a crap place over this because of the MLM model. You are probably going to have to pay to return this item to get your refund. Next time go into a shop or order direct from the company website. Then they will have to deal with mistakes not your friend (and if no one buys from her she might realise it is crap and give up before she loses too much money).

Platax · 03/11/2021 08:08

Typical unthinking MN pile-on. As matters stand, the company is in breach of contract because it has not supplied the product OP ordered and paid for. They must supply those goods, unconditionally. Technically they have sent her unsolicited goods. Therefore it is their responsibility both to fulfil their contractual obligations and to make arrangements to collect the unsolicited product at no expense to OP.

PaintedDaisy · 03/11/2021 08:04

@GiltEdges

Do you not trust your friend or something? Because it’s as if you feel the need to hold the current item as collateral until you get the one you ordered… which is frankly just bizarre Confused

Just tell your friend she can collect the item and she’s already told you she’ll then sort the replacement. Problem solved.

I agree sounds like you don't trust her.

Give I back and she will organise the exchange. Like if you ordered something online and the wrong one arrived.

And if it's an MLM avoid it and stop buying stuff from them.

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 03/11/2021 07:59

It’s not a faulty item. It was sent in error and you’ve already been assured that you’ll get the correct item. But of course you need to return the original item before you get the replacement.

ImUninsultable · 03/11/2021 07:58

You need to return it first. That's how distance selling works.

They may be a massive company but at the end of the day, it is individual people packing things. People make mistakes. It's part of life. We dont throw a strop and hold things hostage until those mistakes are fixed. We send back the wrong thing and they send out the correct thing.

Stop making this more difficult than it needs to be. Ask your friend for a postage label, send it back with whatever details need to be sent with it so you dont need to wait until you see her and she can get the correct item.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 03/11/2021 07:57

I don’t understand you can’t use it so return it you can’t hold onto it until you get your replacement. If you went to a shop you’d exchange there wouldn’t you ? Online is different you return you get the replacement. Sometimes they will let you keep the wrong item and just send replacement but not always but you said yourself you can’t use it anyway . I’m not sure what the issue is tbh op just return it .

Sunshineandflipflops · 03/11/2021 07:57

Agree with most other people here - just send it back for a replacement. They can't replace something they don't have! As far as they are concerned you could just keep both items.

Derbee · 03/11/2021 07:49

You’re so outrageously unreasonable that it’s almost mind boggling. Send the original item back, and you’ll get the item you ordered. What’s so bloody hard to understand?

Why should a company be out of pocket by risking every customer that has a mistake on their order, keeping multiple items?

It’s not even difficult for you to return. Your friend will do it all. Unbelievable

Busybee5000 · 03/11/2021 07:48

it was a mistake and so part of the mistake being rectified is that one product gets returned and the other replaced. Return and replace.

BonesInTheOcean · 03/11/2021 07:43

Avon?