Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to find 17c too cold at home?

330 replies

Coffeeandteevee · 02/11/2021 18:56

Apparently I'm crazy for finding 17c too cold.

I'm currently wearing a top, a hoodie and a big blanket/hoodie thing and I still have a cold nose.

Please tell me I'm not crazy and 17c is bloody cold to have it at home. What temp is your perfect temp at home in the evening?

OP posts:
CheesusTheSaviour · 04/11/2021 02:32

And this is why I'm happy to live in a hot country. We put the AC on at 24 for 10 minutes before bed just to take the edge off to fall asleep - it creeps up to I guess 28 in the night but still use a duvet. The thought of 17 makes me want to cry.

tomorrowalready · 04/11/2021 02:14

Otherspeoplesteens, thanks for replying to me about my father. He died in 1987 in a particulary cold spell but had lived his whole life like so many others in more or less permanent physical discomfort. As you mention I think our (as a country that is) attitude to warmth and comfort are still affected by Victorian attitudes and standards of cold being good for you and in addition to the modern puritanism of guilt at using the world's resources. I am over 60 now and it is only in the last few years I have realised how much I can do to make my life more comfortable - eg warmer bed covers ,dressing more warmly with hats and scarves outdoors, wearing more night clothes, socks in bed. Compared to many, I am an environmental saint but have had to consciously combat the residual guilt at not being miserably cold in my own home. There was another thread about someone's father regarding comfort seekers as soft or 'mardy' as I was regarded in my youth so I think it is still a strong undercurrent in British culture.

Otherpeoplesteens · 03/11/2021 23:39

@tomorrowalready

"The public health guidance is for a minimum indoor temperature of 18 degrees for healthy people suitably dressed but sedentary. It's at that level for a reason backed up by actual evidence: any less and you open yourself to increased risk of heart attack, stroke, flu and other respiratory diseases, and so on. Whilst it says lower indoor temperatures might be tolerable for healthy people who are active, it also suggests that anyone with COPD should spend at least nine hours a day at 21 degrees." This is quite depressing to read , Otherpeoplesteens, as it maybe contributed to my father's death as he had lived all his life in cold houses with just a coal fire in living room. All other rooms including the toilet and bathroom were like fridges and may as well have been outside. He had emphysema and 2 strokes when he died and that was in the coldest time of February 30 years ago. That's why I appreciate so much being warm now and having hot water for baths etc. and why I have a warm duvet and plenty of warm night clothes. All my memories of chidhood were of being bloody cold all the time. Great for those few hot weeks of summer to have a cool house but otherwise just miserable and, as you say, actually harmful to health.
Hi @tomorrowalready

I don't know the circumstances behind your father's life and - ultimately - death, but it is baffling that so many people in Britain are obsessed with living like Victorians in Victorian period properties. Life expectancy at birth in 1850 was 40 years for men and 42 for women; by the end of the Victorian period it had risen to the dizzying heights of 45 and 50 years respectively.

No-one in 2021 would seriously claim that this is desirable, but plenty think that the conditions which drove those statistics are worthy of perpetuating or returning to. It's nonsense.

As an aside, how many of the people on here who think sitting around in thermals, indoors, under a shared family blanket, warming your hands on a mug of tea to save on the heating is normal are the same people who leave the airconditioning running all day in your Spanish holiday villa, even when you go to the beach, because you 'can't cope with the heat?"

theDudesmummy · 03/11/2021 23:04

No heaters on at night, that would be a total deal breaker for me!

theDudesmummy · 03/11/2021 23:03

22! I would leave home and never return!

Mrsbrownsbuoys · 03/11/2021 22:55

My thermostat is set to 17, occasionally I turn it up to 18, when it gets really cold I might turn it up to 20, but only if it's freezing. I do always have a blanket on the sofa to put over me though. My mum's is set to 21°. I'm just stingy! Blush

Ibizafun · 03/11/2021 22:43

It’s 24 here in winter with underfloor heating. 25 if I can get away with itGrin

VetOnCall · 03/11/2021 22:20

Houses in Canada are extremely well insulated and warm. We have forced air heating, through vents in the floor. It's 14 degrees (outside!) here this afternoon but it's forecast to hit a 'high' of 1 and low of -6 by this day next week. Our thermostat is generally set around 21-22 but I'll bump it up and down as necessary. It's very efficient so we don't need to have it on all the time at the moment but I cannot stand cold houses and generally my Canadian DP and friends are baffled by the idea that anyone would voluntarily be cold in their own home. Being cold indoors makes me utterly miserable - having no choice is one thing and is awful, but just the thought of willingly sitting bundled up like the Michelin Man or shivering under piles of blankets with a dripping nose to watch a bit of TV in the evening or getting out of bed/showering etc. in freezing rooms gives me the horrors, I'd be so unhappy.

AnwenDolly · 03/11/2021 22:06

If you feel cold, you're cold. So you are not being unreasonable.

However, if you share space with others it's reasonable to find a way to make sure everyone is comfortable.

My husband and I are quite happy at 17°C, but when we have visitors, we usually turn the heating up a bit higher than we know we are unusually tolerant of being cold.

Cameleongirl · 03/11/2021 21:20

I checked our thermostat earlier today it said 16. We were both WFH and DH was complaining that he was cold but I wasn't...could be my age. Grin I was also wearing a jumper and a big cardy over the top.

I gave him some soup, a hot water bottle and a blanket....he could've turned the heating up but he didn't mention it. I think he enjoyed being fussed over by me!

GlitteryUnicornSparkles · 03/11/2021 21:09

17 is warm if you’re running about doing chores but sitting still it feels quite cold. My son moans about being to warm all the time so I try to suck it up at about 17 / 18 but I think 21 / 22 is comfortable for resting without a nice thick blanket.

Youmeanyouvelostyourkey · 03/11/2021 20:45

17 degrees here too. I don't usually sleep under the duvet either. If we had the heating up to 20+, I'd have to open the windows. I bought myself an Oodie but not sure how often I'll wear it

tomorrowalready · 03/11/2021 20:19

"The public health guidance is for a minimum indoor temperature of 18 degrees for healthy people suitably dressed but sedentary. It's at that level for a reason backed up by actual evidence: any less and you open yourself to increased risk of heart attack, stroke, flu and other respiratory diseases, and so on. Whilst it says lower indoor temperatures might be tolerable for healthy people who are active, it also suggests that anyone with COPD should spend at least nine hours a day at 21 degrees." This is quite depressing to read , Otherpeoplesteens, as it maybe contributed to my father's death as he had lived all his life in cold houses with just a coal fire in living room. All other rooms including the toilet and bathroom were like fridges and may as well have been outside. He had emphysema and 2 strokes when he died and that was in the coldest time of February 30 years ago. That's why I appreciate so much being warm now and having hot water for baths etc. and why I have a warm duvet and plenty of warm night clothes. All my memories of chidhood were of being bloody cold all the time. Great for those few hot weeks of summer to have a cool house but otherwise just miserable and, as you say, actually harmful to health.

tomorrowalready · 03/11/2021 20:05

I was going to start a thread about being grateful for small mechanical mercies as I realised this evening that my heating was operating on the timer not on the thermostat as I thought. The last 2 nights I have felt cold early evening and turned it up high and checked the handbook and pressure bar as nothing was happening at even 25C until after 8pm. The heating did start early morning and woke me up as too hot with winter duvet. So I checked again this evening and realised the engineer had set the timer in the summer when there had been a leaking pipe. As the clocks have gone back , it was on the wrong times for me. It's back on the thermostat control now as I do not know how to set the timer. I am in a converted Victorian flat with big rooms and high ceilings, am also a chilly person and wear 2/3 layers even in bed so usually have temp on about 19/20 degrees in evening. Also thanks to Sky for sorting out their timing problem.

bumbleymummy · 03/11/2021 19:38
  1. I would be so cold at some of the temperatures people are suggesting here!
User3579 · 03/11/2021 19:23

YANBU 20C as a minimum for me and that’s not warm, just bearable with a jumper. Used to run at 22C but have dropped to save money

BatshitCrazyWoman · 03/11/2021 19:14

About 19 is fine for me if I'm just sitting around. Heating is very definitely OFF at night, and the window slightly open, it makes me feel ill to sleep in a warm room.

BarkminsterBlue · 03/11/2021 19:07

@Bluntness100

Mines about 23-24. I don’t like a cold house and am fortunate enough to not to have to endure it

Seventeen can be warm outside in spring and summer, but on a cold autumnal night houses feel very cold inside at that temperature and most humans would find it uncomfortable.

“Most humans” Grin
kowari · 03/11/2021 18:52

@Bluntness100

Mines about 23-24. I don’t like a cold house and am fortunate enough to not to have to endure it

Seventeen can be warm outside in spring and summer, but on a cold autumnal night houses feel very cold inside at that temperature and most humans would find it uncomfortable.

23 to 24 is lovely outside in summer but I would feel uncomfortably warm if my house was that temperature on an autumn or winter night. It feels completely different without fresh air. also love to feel cosy with a hoodie around the house and blanket on the sofa. If it was that hot in my house I'd have to sit in a tshirt then layer up everytime I wanted to leave the house! 17 is just right for us.
ichundich · 03/11/2021 14:09

[quote ivykaty44]@ichundich get one that is remote and you can take from room to room - its not difficult for a plumber to do and wouldn't cost to much.

Better to have the thermostat in the room you are in or use most - then you can take hot bed with you and set lower - though obviously don't have in the bedroom if you sleep with the window open[/quote]
It's fine at the moment. We have thermostat valves on each radiator, so we just turn these up / down in the rooms that we want warm (downstairs and bathroom).

ivykaty44 · 03/11/2021 13:44

@ichundich get one that is remote and you can take from room to room - its not difficult for a plumber to do and wouldn't cost to much.

Better to have the thermostat in the room you are in or use most - then you can take hot bed with you and set lower - though obviously don't have in the bedroom if you sleep with the window open

Porseb · 03/11/2021 12:43

@Avarua

I work in a tropical country. If we put it lower than 24 Celcius people complain.
In the tropics, the lower you set the air conditioning temperature, the more energy you use and contribute to greenhouse gases so air conditioning thermostats should be set at 26C or 27C Wink
Otherpeoplesteens · 03/11/2021 12:06

We set the temperature for 21.5 downstairs and 22 upstairs for the morning, and once the heating goes off it drifts down slowly until the heating comes back on in the late afternoon/evening. It rarely falls below 20 and if it does the heating will come back on automatically. Personally I'd rather be warmer but paying and polluting more just to not have to wear an undershirt and a sweater seems like a stupid and somewhat antisocial idea.

However, I struggle with anything lower than 20 celsius. There's nothing heroic or noble about not being able to chop vegetables safely because you can't grip a knife with your numb hands, or watching your baby visibly recoil when ice cold hands change her nappy.

The public health guidance is for a minimum indoor temperature of 18 degrees for healthy people suitably dressed but sedentary. It's at that level for a reason backed up by actual evidence: any less and you open yourself to increased risk of heart attack, stroke, flu and other respiratory diseases, and so on. Whilst it says lower indoor temperatures might be tolerable for healthy people who are active, it also suggests that anyone with COPD should spend at least nine hours a day at 21 degrees.

EmotionalSupportBear · 03/11/2021 11:06

our house is kept at about 19/20. 17 is cold.

marykitty · 03/11/2021 11:04

I love 19 to 21 degrees.
17 is too cold for me, we were in the 16-17.5 range for a while at the beginning of the autumn because we did not want to turn on the heating (it felt too early) and it was not very pleasant for our 2yo toddler