Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if 15 mins is enough lunch time for kids?

61 replies

GottaGoCYa · 02/11/2021 18:06

My DC is in year 4. Another mum mentioned to me before the holidays that the children only have 15 minutes to sit and eat their lunch, her son hardly ever finishes his and therefore she is switching to home dinners. I had no idea as it's not been mentioned! When I asked DC I was told that yes, they only have 15 minutes to eat and DC said it's not enough as eating fast makes their tummy hurt. I cant imagine many of the children manage to eat properly?

First day back today and I queried this with class teacher. I was told that's how long each year group has (year 3 onwards), and it cannot be changed due to the rota. Not to do with Covid she said. But she admitted she was shocked at the change and feels many children do struggle to eat so quickly. I asked about packed lunch and they also get the same amount of time. I work and therefore can't bring DC home but I'm surprised more parents haven't picked up on this? Many primary aged kids are really slow eaters, the ones I know are anyway. Should I speak to the headteacher?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
woodhill · 03/11/2021 17:25

@XelaM

That's awful. My daughter is in Year 7 and gets 1.25 hours for lunch. They can sit in the hall or eat it outside (the school has very nice grounds)
Is that a private school Xenia, they usually have longer lunch times?

School day is usually longer possibly?

Verfremdungseffekt · 03/11/2021 10:02

@Crumblinginside

Our son rarely eats his packed lunch due to time constraints. I tend to give him porridge and two slices of toast each morning with a multivitamin.
Same here. He’s 9, a slow eater anyway, and unwilling to waste his precious free time on sandwiches when he could be playing with his friends. I feed him a substantial breakfast and a good snack with some protein in it when he gets home.
libertyfarmboots · 03/11/2021 09:59

30 minutes in total to eat and play isn’t long enough imo.

TempsPerdu · 02/11/2021 23:52

That all sounds terrible OP, but it’s really depressingly common at both primary and secondary level now - lunch breaks are getting shorter and shorter for a variety of reasons, whether Covid-related, logistical (lack of dining space, inadequate staffing levels) or behavioural.

Wolfing down a sandwich while literally being timed to the minute by a frazzled MSA is really not conducive to instilling a healthy relationship with food into our kids. So different from the more enlightened attitude in many other parts of Europe, where food is enjoyed and savoured and a sociable, convivial approach to mealtimes is promoted.

XelaM · 02/11/2021 23:39

That's awful. My daughter is in Year 7 and gets 1.25 hours for lunch. They can sit in the hall or eat it outside (the school has very nice grounds)

DroopyClematis · 02/11/2021 20:41

Many , many children just don't get that they're meant to eat their lunch. Too much talking and eat so very slowly.

Just to illustrate... children (Yr1) would go out to play at 11.45. Brought back into dinner hall at 12.
Back into class at 12.30.

Some children still eating at 12.50, 20 minutes into science or geography.
Still had complaints from parents that their children didn't have enough time to eat!

Meredusoleil · 02/11/2021 20:33

My school have 45 minutes for lunch from Reception-Year 6 and its still staggered! This doesn't include hand washing time, but does include lining up and then playtime outside. It's roughly split 20 minutes eating and 25 minutes play, but staff manage the children in small groups as and when they finish their food so they don't have fixed times.

Before covid, lunch times used to be 1 hour for all (staff included). Then they got rid of all the MMS so the TAs and SLT man the dinner hall and playground now, whilst is teachers grab a bite to eat and catch up on the morning marking 👍

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2021 20:20

@Iggly

I’m sure that’s why but it will be counter productive, especially for the ones who don’t eat that fast *@Pumperthepumper*

And the lack of play time is disgraceful.

It won’t be why, it’ll be because of staffing, if its true. I suspect that 15 missing minutes will be used for play because the staff will also be missing 15mins if their break.
PurBal · 02/11/2021 20:17

I can’t eat lunch in 15 minutes… god help a child.

Lancrelady80 · 02/11/2021 20:14

15 mins once all ch are sitting at tables with food in front of them is fine. But far too short if it also includes handwashing, lining up for food, saying grace etc.

KS2 teacher here and ours have 30 mins to eat (includes all the above) and 20 mins to play after. But tbh, 30 mins is way too long. All but the faffiest children (and I'm sure ds is one of those in his school!) are done by 20 past 12. So 20-25 mins seems about right.

Check on timings though...one school I worked at shortened the lunch hour to 45 mins to cut down on playground issues, but had to put in an additional afternoon break otherwise it was too much teaching time for the ch. (Several years ago though, so things might have changed.)

TuftyMarmoset · 02/11/2021 20:12

I think the sense of feeling rushed is worse than the actual time limit. I’ve just eaten my dinner (dal and chapatti) while browsing MN and it didn’t take more than about 10 minutes and I wasn’t rushing.

Iggly · 02/11/2021 20:12

I’m sure that’s why but it will be counter productive, especially for the ones who don’t eat that fast @Pumperthepumper

And the lack of play time is disgraceful.

iwishiwasafish · 02/11/2021 20:04

I think this a so sad. Why has the time been shortened? School isn’t supposed to be just about the classroom. They need time to eat, having a health relationship with food, and to play with time to run around properly. It should be an hour for lunch, to include food and play.

Pumperthepumper · 02/11/2021 20:03

@Iggly

I would email the headteacher and ask to explain why they think reducing their time to eat and play is considered appropriate.

Email Is better as it is harder to ignore.

I despair at the thoughtlessness towards children in schools, I really do

To give them more time in class?
Sally872 · 02/11/2021 20:01

Ours get 45 mins for lunch and due to covid rota in dinner hall has meant they have to leave dinner hall quicker. But my children always used to rush lunch as fast as possible so they could get out to play, seemed to be what most of them did. Suppose rushing to get out is different to being rushed though.

Iggly · 02/11/2021 19:59

I would email the headteacher and ask to explain why they think reducing their time to eat and play is considered appropriate.

Email Is better as it is harder to ignore.

I despair at the thoughtlessness towards children in schools, I really do

womaninatightspot · 02/11/2021 19:57

It's the same in our school as the next lot have to eat. The queuing system is quick though. As each class has a five minute slot. Lunchbreak is still an hour long they get to go outside and play for the rest of it. Younger kids get 3 breaks so I send 3 snacks. Normally an apple/ flapjack or muesli bar / banana. Sometimes they come home depending on how nice/ filling lunch was.

PaperMonster · 02/11/2021 19:57

Ours get thirty minutes in the dining hall - most have eaten in 15-20 mins and then there’s clearing away, lining up etc then they’re outside for thirty minutes whilst the other half of the school who have been outside for 30 minutes go inside to eat.

Plotato · 02/11/2021 19:47

Teaching in KS2, most children have finished eating in about 10 mins. I don't thinks it's way off to be honest.

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 02/11/2021 19:46

Yup, sounds about right to me. Was in a school working last week and it really upset me watching 5yr olds trying to gobble their food. Not so bad for kids with packed lunch but trying to eat burger and chips in that time is horrible.

iolaus · 02/11/2021 19:45

Do you mean it's 15 minutes to eat and then a period of time where they are expected to play

That I don't mind (any time queuing for food shouldn't be included)

If the entire break is 15 minutes thats wrong

switswoo81 · 02/11/2021 19:43

Not in UK but my reception aged class eat for ten mins then ten mins play (all packed lunches in classroom) at break then another ten mins to finish packed lunch and twenty mins play for lunchtime . They do however go home at 1:30.

I find that plenty of time even for the chatty ones, which my own child is.!

woodhill · 02/11/2021 19:38

@MilduraS

Why on Earth would they encourage children to eat as quickly as possible?? I could eat my lunch in less than 15 minutes but it's not a good thing. I have a history of being overweight and eating beyond the point of being full. A big part of losing weight was eating more mindfully and enjoying the food rather than rushing to eat as much as possible.
Exactly and causing indigestion

It's nice for the dc to socialise and have some downtown

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 02/11/2021 19:37

15minutes sat down at the table would likely be tight but doable.

15 minutes to line up, get served, find your seat and eat... the last ones in line will have no time.

At DDs school they have 30mons in the hall and 30 minutes outside.

One of their previous schools it was 30minutes, but it was a large snack rather than a meal as school finished at 1 after starting atv7.30.

MilduraS · 02/11/2021 19:35

Why on Earth would they encourage children to eat as quickly as possible?? I could eat my lunch in less than 15 minutes but it's not a good thing. I have a history of being overweight and eating beyond the point of being full. A big part of losing weight was eating more mindfully and enjoying the food rather than rushing to eat as much as possible.