Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step sister and Christmas presents

116 replies

Penguinday · 02/11/2021 14:44

I have wanted to stop exchanging presents with my step sister for a couple of years now. She decided we would buy for each other’s children when we both had our first kids the same year. They’re 6 now. She suggested £50 budget which I thought was too much. (To spend that at Christmas and for birthdays) She made a big thing of it so stupidly, I ended up agreeing to it.

However, she blatantly did not spend that on my child the first year. £20 at very most. Then every birthday and Christmas since she has bought my child clothing from the M&S 3for2. Our oldest children are same age so she is likely buying 2 things for her DC and then giving the free one to mine! She sometimes even leaves the sticker on.

I have tried to bring this up yet her and other family members make out that I’m being greedy and/or ungrateful! It’s not even about the money now, it’s the feeling of being made a fool of.

I’m not rich either, if anything her and her boyfriend have more money than us.

Any advice on how to approach it please and actually stop exchanging presents.

OP posts:
HouseOfFire · 02/11/2021 16:23

@SpiderinaWingMirror

Only 2 answers, Buy cheaper Stop altogether

I had similar with my sister who seems sensible in every other regard and not short of cash. She would say "how much should we spend at Xmas? And ask for a voucher for that amount. Then buy mine a gift for obviously less. It took me years to work out that actually she was dividing 40 quid between my 3.
I judged then and still do now. I knocked it on the head pronto once I twigged and just ceased buying her kids anything!

was she buying for 3 but had 1 ? was the same amount spent on each family?
Cocomarine · 02/11/2021 16:23

Right, but how does that family dynamic even occur?

If you say to her, “I’m not doing £50”, what happens - she runs to her dad and your mum and cries?

And then you say, “she’s being ridiculous, her £50 present last year was an £8 dress” (you sound petty if you get into the 3for2)

What happens then?

Honestly, if that doesn’t make the STFU, I would distance myself from the lot of them. Let your mum be scared of upsetting you for a change.

Practise saying, “this is fucking ridiculous and none of your business” in the mirror, ready to say it to your mum or stepdad.

You will feel SO much better when you don’t let her pull you into this crap!

AryaStarkWolf · 02/11/2021 16:22

Tell her you're not buying anymore now the kids are older and leave it at that

SpiderinaWingMirror · 02/11/2021 16:22

Only 2 answers,
Buy cheaper
Stop altogether

I had similar with my sister who seems sensible in every other regard and not short of cash. She would say "how much should we spend at Xmas? And ask for a voucher for that amount. Then buy mine a gift for obviously less. It took me years to work out that actually she was dividing 40 quid between my 3.
I judged then and still do now. I knocked it on the head pronto once I twigged and just ceased buying her kids anything!

Penguinday · 02/11/2021 16:22

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll Grin I wish I could be brave enough to send that!

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 16:16

Text her back with even more expensive gifts you want for your kids

"My DC have really set their hearts on one of these each - I've checked prices and, luckily for us, it's just in budget! I'll tell them that their favourite DA will be getting it for them, thanks so much."

Step sister and Christmas presents
Penguinday · 02/11/2021 16:13

Hi, thank you for your advice everyone.

The family dynamic is that I will end up in the wrong if I say something.

Mum won’t say anything to her. She is happy to criticise me but won’t criticise her. She did used to, but my Sisters response was either tears and how hard she’s finding everything or just stop talking to the family. Then it gets brushed under the carpet eventually. But over the years Mum now seems almost scared of upsetting her. And obviously her Dad Will side with her. Even though surely everyone can see it isn’t fair.

The jumper was £8 at M&S, which is obviously way under the £50. And if you spread the cost over 3 items then it wouldn’t have even been £6. It’s ridiculous. And no my DC wouldn’t be fussed about clothes for Christmas. And annoys me even more that I get sent fancy wooden toys to buy.

OP posts:
RudestLittleMadam · 02/11/2021 16:09

Just stop spending that much money?! I get that some people have “strong personalities” (pushy arseholes) but people who don’t respect their own limits on this kind of thing just get walked over all the time. Not having a go at you but even if I’d been brow beaten into the 50 quid limit initially, like fuck it would have happened again after the first time. They’d be getting whatever my limit was from then on, if they were lucky. And
Bugger all if they weren’t.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 16:09

"I really don't want to embarrass her by spending a lot more than she does, once she realises afterwards how much more the gifts on her DC's list have ended up costing; so I deliberately buy gifts to the same budget that she usually does."

Say the same directly to her (with adjusted pronouns), if she's brazen enough to complain that her cushy 'deal' has come to an end.

I really cannot see how any family member can possibly justify expecting you to routinely spend a lot more than she does - especially when they're better off than you are.

Beautiful3 · 02/11/2021 16:08

Just message back, "Hi, we have decided not to buy presents for extended family, for Christmas and birthdays. Please don't buy anything for x. We will continue to send cards. Thank you." That's what we did around 5 years ago!!! It was the best thing we ever did!. No more crap and I could buy better presents for my children and I got something too, for a change!

Evelyn52 · 02/11/2021 16:07

@Penguinday

Thank you for your replies.

The problem I have is that she messages me with specific toys that she wants me to buy. And I’m worried if I obviously spend less then the rest of the family will say I’m in the wrong.

Text her back with even more expensive gifts you want for your kids 😜
Cocomarine · 02/11/2021 16:04

How are you bringing it up?
If her suggestion was a maximum of £50, and all your family are hearing is you complaining about an M&S dress under £50 with the price still on - then yes, you would sound greedy and ungrateful.
It’s only in the context of her requesting a specific £50 toy that it is rude of her.

How are other family members getting their beaks in? It all sounds rather odd.
Don’t make any excuses - just say, “£50 is too much for me, my budget is £x.” Say it directly to her. Anyone else putting their nose in, “yes, I suggested we reduce it to £x. I can’t afford £50.”

Chocolatewheatos · 02/11/2021 16:01

Just don't buy the thing she tells you to buy. Buy her something cheap.

Cocomarine · 02/11/2021 15:58

With the exception of a winter coat, is it even possible to spend £50 on a single clothing item for a 6yo in M&S? Seems a bit high to me. I don’t think it matters if it’s the “free” item from a 3 for 2 - that’s her business.

Honestly - don’t be so wet.

I’d understand fear of family upset if she was paying £50 and you couldn’t afford that. But she isn’t.

Either tell her you’re not doing presents - just tell her. Or, send what you want to, and if she has the cheek to say, “that’s not £50” then tell her that you both stopped doing that years ago - and wave her M&S item in her face 🤷🏻‍♀️

Come on, you’re an adult. Just do it.

QueeniesCroft · 02/11/2021 15:56

You have two choices; either you say that you don't want to give presents to each other's kids from now on, or you carry on as you are and feel more and more resentful about it.

You could either ignore her requests or suggest a lower limit, of course, but I reckon that putting a stop to it will be cleaner and less stressful in the long run.

I also wonder about the family dynamic here, is there a history of her being the favoured child? Is there realistically a chance of you being pushed out if you don't pander to her?

Unfortunately, this is one of those sticking plaster moments, when you have to take a deep breath and feel some pain for a short time, if you want to get the problem sorted.

HouseOfFire · 02/11/2021 15:55

@Penguinday

Thank you for your replies.

The problem I have is that she messages me with specific toys that she wants me to buy. And I’m worried if I obviously spend less then the rest of the family will say I’m in the wrong.

So - dont buy them, buy what you want to - if she doesnt follow the rules, then for fucks sake dont be so wet and buy something for the amount you want to - or make a donation in her childs name
Sparkletastic · 02/11/2021 15:55

Tell her you don't want to exchange gifts this year as hers are always disappointing crap

Goawaymorningsickeness · 02/11/2021 15:51

@Penguinday

Thank you for your replies.

The problem I have is that she messages me with specific toys that she wants me to buy. And I’m worried if I obviously spend less then the rest of the family will say I’m in the wrong.

Stop worrying what other members of the family think. Buy her a sale item but take the sale tag off. It’s ridiculous to tell people how much to spend anyway, especially when one person has more disposable income.
JustLyra · 02/11/2021 15:50

@Penguinday

Thank you for your replies.

The problem I have is that she messages me with specific toys that she wants me to buy. And I’m worried if I obviously spend less then the rest of the family will say I’m in the wrong.

Then you either say “I’ve always sorted presents thanks”

Or “that’s great. My DC wants X.” (Ideal if it’s something almost exactly the same because then she cannot wriggle out of it - she’ll probably suggest the smaller presents next year)

TrulyPistoff · 02/11/2021 15:50

You honestly need to learn to stand up for yourself. Why do you let your sister and family bully you?! They do it because you let them. Either just tell her you’ve decided no more gifts, gifts for a lower sum, send her a link for a specific £50 item just line she does or buy the same 3 for 2 clothing and keep two. You just have to decide which one and then stick to it, no explanation needed from your side other than it works for you!

mewkins · 02/11/2021 15:49

What are you concerned about? Do you generally feel like everyone in your family is on her side for most things? Do you feel like an outsider?

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/11/2021 15:47

@Justcallmebebes

"The problem I have is that she messages me with specific toys that she wants me to buy. And I’m worried if I obviously spend less then the rest of the family will say I’m in the wrong."

When she texts just reply, "thanks" and completely ignore her and buy a gift of your choosing. What's the worst that can happen??

stop being a doormat OP for the love of god and do this
TwinsandTrifle · 02/11/2021 15:34

"Hi, we've decided to cut back a bit this Christmas. Now the children are older and receive so much from all of the family, we think a £20 limit is better as a budget for our gifts for "child" and "niece". Could you let me know what they'd like, or if you're happy for me to choose? X"

elbea · 02/11/2021 15:33

Give her something from the Boots 3 for 2 and leave the sticker on, keep the other two for yourself. I’m sure she’ll get the messagw

redbullandsherrytrifle · 02/11/2021 15:31

I would say that you feel your child gets too much at christmas and to receive a £50 gift from her feels excessive and that going forward you suggest you just buy a token gift (£10 limit) for each other's children.