Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Step sister and Christmas presents

116 replies

Penguinday · 02/11/2021 14:44

I have wanted to stop exchanging presents with my step sister for a couple of years now. She decided we would buy for each other’s children when we both had our first kids the same year. They’re 6 now. She suggested £50 budget which I thought was too much. (To spend that at Christmas and for birthdays) She made a big thing of it so stupidly, I ended up agreeing to it.

However, she blatantly did not spend that on my child the first year. £20 at very most. Then every birthday and Christmas since she has bought my child clothing from the M&S 3for2. Our oldest children are same age so she is likely buying 2 things for her DC and then giving the free one to mine! She sometimes even leaves the sticker on.

I have tried to bring this up yet her and other family members make out that I’m being greedy and/or ungrateful! It’s not even about the money now, it’s the feeling of being made a fool of.

I’m not rich either, if anything her and her boyfriend have more money than us.

Any advice on how to approach it please and actually stop exchanging presents.

OP posts:
JamOrMarmaladeOnToast · 02/11/2021 20:41

** COP26 !!

sorry wrong year!! Grin

JamOrMarmaladeOnToast · 02/11/2021 20:38

www.olasoceantribe.com/blogs/plastic-crisis/top-5-charities-that-are-fighting-to-protect-our-worlds-oceans-how-you-can-get-involved

Dear Stepsister and wider family, I've set up a standing order for £50 every December in all our childrens' name as part of COP21 aim to reduce plastic tat. It's for all our children's future so that they feel loved. Plastic is not just for Christmas it's for life. I just know you'll understand

Wink
NanooCov · 02/11/2021 20:32

Buy her kids something to the same value as the gifts she buys your kids. Stop caring about what she or other family members might say - they obviously think very little of your feelings so don't worry so much about theirs.

Kiduknot · 02/11/2021 20:31

I’d just say you’ve already bought something for them, you are sure they’ll love.

Cattitudes · 02/11/2021 20:27

If you want to continue the gift giving maybe suggest that the cousins choose something instead Max spend £10.

Hydrate · 02/11/2021 20:10

Your sil is not the boss of you.
Usually a price suggestion means do not spend more than X price.
Gift suggestions are not rules you need to blindly obey.
Choose gifts based on what you can afford, and what you feel ok in giving. A fun gift the DC will enjoy.
Do not mention anything about your dissatisfaction with what you or your DC recieved.
Remember what the season is about, and only think about what the step nephew would enjoy. ( I doubt it is clothing, ha ha.)

I think you should consider a Hungry Hungry Hippo game. DC will love it. adults, not so much! Grin

LoveGoldberg · 02/11/2021 20:05

We buy our own gifts and label it from the other and just grab it when doing our own Christmas shopping. That way they only get what you know they will play with and it feels less hassle. So I will send a pic what I’ve got my daughter and send it to my sister to see and then put her name on it. Then it doesn’t matter how much we spent

Chloemol · 02/11/2021 20:04

And if your mother kicks off tell her you can’t afford it, does she want to give you the difference

Chloemol · 02/11/2021 20:04

As others have said when she sends you a link just say sorry I have already bought something

Then get what you want for what you can afford. If she says anything then be honest and say you can’t afford expensive toys, and it would appear she cant as well judging by what she has bought your child

Then say maybe we cut it down to £10 for Xmas and £10 for birthday

Allthegearnoideas · 02/11/2021 19:52

Why don’t you when you get the request for whatever toy it is, say great idea, mine would love one of those too. Then suggest you buy one yourselves each and just exchange tags. Your kids get nice gifts, you don’t need to tag it f you don’t want to. if her kids don’t get the nice gift it’s on her.

MissAmbrosia · 02/11/2021 19:26

Yes. Stop engaging with all of them and just buy something you like/can afford.

JamOrMarmaladeOnToast · 02/11/2021 19:22

@Beautiful3

Just message back, "Hi, we have decided not to buy presents for extended family, for Christmas and birthdays. Please don't buy anything for x. We will continue to send cards. Thank you." That's what we did around 5 years ago!!! It was the best thing we ever did!. No more crap and I could buy better presents for my children and I got something too, for a change!
^^ this.

Fantastic. Common sense. No drama and realistic enjoyment of Christmas. No one gets grabby hurt

beautifulview · 02/11/2021 19:20

Do it. Message her now. Go on. Tell her what’s what. Own your life

beautifulview · 02/11/2021 19:19

Take back power here. Just stop. Message her now “just to let you know I’m not buying you or your kids xmas presents this year. We’re cutting back. Happy to still do cards and maybe a joint trip to see a panto or something but we’re not spending money on stuff nobody needs anymore”
Be blunt. It’s liberating. If she or anyone kicks off, call them on it. To her you would say “I’m sorry you feel that way but we’re not made of money. No more gifts. See you soon” and to others “I’m surprised you care enough about this to message me. It’s our decision what money we can or can’t afford and to be honest we’re a bit pissed off with all of this. Our finances are our private business. Don’t message me about this again”
Fuck all of them

WickedWitchOfTheTrent · 02/11/2021 19:14

She can't make you spend a certain amount, she can request toys, but simply buy what you want to. I honestly can't believe someone would be so grabby to comment on how much a present cost. If however she does comment simply say it's the thought that counts. If she kicks off ignore her. The best way to stop playing this tug of war with her is to drop the rope. Just stop engaging. If she cries ignore her, if she shouts at you walk away. She can't force you to do anything you don't want to do

DontWiltMySpinachPlease · 02/11/2021 19:12

Just dont offer an explanation or open it up to conversation just a simple "hi, circumstances are charged blah blah blah, we're not buying for anyone outside of our immediate family (eg, DH and kids) please don't buy our children gifts as we won't be reciprocating"

SalmonEile · 02/11/2021 19:09

What happens if you send her something your DD would like? Does she just ignore it ?

BananaPB · 02/11/2021 19:00

You need to stop worrying what others think about you or tell your sis that you've bought a £10 gift so please don't spend more than that on your child. You're an adult woman- channel your cf stepsister and do it

paisley256 · 02/11/2021 18:03

Just reply that you already have your Christmas shopping done and spend whatever you want to then pay it no mind.
You're allowing them to walk all over you it's time to put a stop to it.

starskey80 · 02/11/2021 17:47

You couod say that you're so relieved she's lowered the cost going by the present she got your child last year, but you must have missed the text, so it's 10 quid per child yea?!?.... And big thumbs up.

happydramatic · 02/11/2021 17:41

You're being bullied into spending money on her child. Has she ever written you a thank you card?

Anyway. Obviously a number of ways to deal with it. A non-confrontational reply would be:

"That's a lovely toy! I'd love to get that for your dd. You buy it from us, and I'll spend the same on my DD's present from you. She would like XXX which is a little more than our £50 budget, but I'm happy to make up the difference for you. SmileSee you at Christmas!"

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 02/11/2021 17:38

Seriously. Don’t say / tell / text anything.

Just do. What you want. Within your means.

Problem solved.

Notaroadrunner · 02/11/2021 17:37

[quote Penguinday]@Cocomarine No with this type of situation she’d probably just kick off and not talk to me for a while. Or them as well if she thinks they aren’t sticking up for her.

I’ve talked to DM about it. The first time she said I was being petty and greedy. Then when I brought it up after a different occasion she said it wasn’t nice talking like that about step sister and she would have spent time choosing a nice present.[/quote]
Just stop. You can't do right for doing wrong so stop giving a fuck what any of them think about you. They are not privy to your finances so can't dictate how much you spend. Send a message tonight stating that "I just want to let you know that we will no longer be exchanging Christmas gifts so please don't buy for my dc". And that's it done - if she texts giving out just ignore her and ignore anyone else who tries to make it their business. It's nobody's business but yours and you are adult enough to decide what your money is spent on.

FatCatThinCat · 02/11/2021 17:36

Buy her a tube of jellytots and be done with it. She's taking the piss but only because you're letting her.

Ourlady · 02/11/2021 17:35

I would tell her you are cutting down on gifts this year due to environmental issue in the world. You will be spending £20 on her kids and would like her to do the same. Then give her a specific toy to buy for your child.