Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Primary school seems obsessed with covid

259 replies

Lightswitch123 · 02/11/2021 10:27

My children's primary seem obsessed with covid.

We had a few cases in school before half term (??20 positive tests in the whole of the school?)

Now we are back, because 2 parents emailed the head over half term to say their child had a also had a positive result, the school have cancelled all in person events, after school clubs, parents not allowed in playground, reintroduced bubbles, staggering drop offs, minimising lunch and play times, kids not allowed to use class pens or pencils, no water provided etc

We get at least 1 parentmail a day "updating" us on the situation.

This is in spite of no one actually being unwell- just positive lateral flow / pcr results off the back of being named contacts. And we've all been off for ages for half term as well.

It all seems so bloody punative and OTT.

I'm beginning to think I'd rather the kids went elsewhere or just stayed at home away from this crazy.

Aibu?

YABU - School response sounds reasonable

YANBU - School is OTT

Also any advice as to how to tackle this with the school? It's doing my head in.

OP posts:
ADreadedSunnyDay · 02/11/2021 13:22

Well in Scotland we still have staggered start and finish times at primary, bubbles were reintroduced when we had Covid cases, and after schools club and football was cancelled. It was really really difficult, not helped by the absolute hysteria of some parents. I cannot speak about this IRL any longer and the sooner Covid is treated like any other illness ie no lateral flow testing, off school if you are ill and for 48 hours after recovery, the better.

Stela40 · 02/11/2021 13:18

"The vaccine was sold to the public as a way out of this mess and yet here we are with the vast majority vaccinated yet still nothing has changed...."

"The vast majority" of children are NOT vaccinated and the issue raised by OP was about the impact of Covid measures being implemented in schools where all of the unvaccinated children go!
How can you say that nothing has changed as a result of vaccinations? I would argue that hospital admissions being way down and many Covid related deaths being prevented is a massive change for the better.

PurpleDaisies · 02/11/2021 13:17

The school my children go to seems to manage to stay open despite the odd infection too.

It isn’t the odd infection here.

PurpleDaisies · 02/11/2021 13:17

Why would all the staff be off? I have a business that has not been closed at all. We are mixing with 100's of customers on a daily basis but funnily enough, even though some staff and customers had Covid we have never had to have 'all' our staff off.

Here in the local schools, so many teachers are off that bubbles and year groups are about to be closed. We can’t get enough supply to make it work. It’s a nightmare for those people who aren’t off…yet.

carrythecan · 02/11/2021 13:15

@PurpleDaisies

You are quite right OP, we need to keep our children in school.

With all the staff off?

Why would all the staff be off? I have a business that has not been closed at all. We are mixing with 100's of customers on a daily basis but funnily enough, even though some staff and customers had Covid we have never had to have 'all' our staff off.

The school my children go to seems to manage to stay open despite the odd infection too.

MatildaJayne · 02/11/2021 13:14

@Lightswitch123

Errr cases are falling!
Cases have fallen a little over half term because the kids weren't at school. They'll start rising again now kids are back mixing in school, unless there are some mitigating measures taken. Better those than more onerous measures having to taken in the new year, surely?
Primary school seems obsessed with covid
BluebellsGreenbells · 02/11/2021 13:13

Schools are full of adults as well as children.

If you don’t want the information opt out

seb342 · 02/11/2021 13:10

I agree with you OP. The vaccine was sold to the public as a way out of this mess and yet here we are with the vast majority vaccinated yet still nothing has changed and now the booster jab is the way out.

Kids have been massively hit by the disruption since it started and I feel for them missing out on so much, especially things like prom etc that they won't get the chance to do in the future.

I know people will say X amount have died but young children don't understand this and don't understand what is happening when they can go to an theme park or on holiday as normal yet are still under restrictions in school.

JustLyra · 02/11/2021 13:08

@Lightswitch123

But all the points everyone is making to keep restrictions going could be applied to other illnesses . Vaccine efficacy / feeling unwell etc etc

Flu being the easiest parallel. Feel rubbish. May need a couple of weeks off.

School doesn't shut down because of it though.

2020 - yes was proportional

Coming into 2022 - no. It's not proportional. It's just the easy argument as you dont need to weigh up the other harder / impossible to measure costs and impacts . You just need to shout "but you don't care if someone dies!"

Flu is a shit comparison. It kills an average of 650,000 people a year. Covid has killed more than that in the US alone.

Flu killed less than 30,000 people in England and Wales in 2018, less than 27,000 on 2019. Covid has killed over 140,000 in England in less than two years.

Things are being done differently because covid isn’t flu.

Grumpster21 · 02/11/2021 13:07

@carrythecan You are quite right OP, we need to keep our children in school

Where is anyone saying otherwise?! The whole point is the schools (advised by the health security agency or whatever succeeded PHE) are trying to manage the situation to keep as many children onsite learning as possible while there is still a great deal of Covid circulating in the community.

PurpleDaisies · 02/11/2021 13:06

I appreciate some people are still scared and have sympathy, but a middle ground needs to be sought.

Who is scared? I’m so unwell I couldn’t get off the sofa to teach a class if I tried.

Totallydefeated · 02/11/2021 13:04

OP I agree, stopping all clubs etc is way OTT now.

There’s a middle ground of following requirements to test where symptomatic, isolating when positive etc, without operating as though it’s summer 2020. There’s now no need in general and we have to weigh up the detriment to children, whose interests were largely sacrificed for the greater good for the better part of 18 months. We now have vaccines and better treatment. We can’t afford to suspend normal life indefinitely. I appreciate some people are still scared and have sympathy, but a middle ground needs to be sought.

allupsidedown · 02/11/2021 13:04

The way to keep the children in school is by ensuring the safety of the staff. If there are no mitigations to protect the staff then the staff could become ill and then the school shuts.

blameitonthecaffeine · 02/11/2021 13:03

To me, the problem now is the inconsistency or what people are experiencing. When it was everyone then fair enough. But now it's just children and it's not all children. Adults can attend theatres and concerts packed with 1000s of mask free people. But some schools are cancelling their nativity in the school hall for a couple of hundred?!

And because it's Local Authority guidance schools a) have no choice and b) aren't all ending up with the same restrictions. I teach in a private school so we don't have to follow LA guidance. We do have to follow PHE guidance. So, when we had a cluster of cases before half term, we stopped whole school gatherings and asked the older children to wear masks in the corridors. Now we've had half term and currently only have a couple of children off with it, those restrictions have stopped and we're back to normal. We're able to have all our productions, concerts, matches, clubs, practical lessons etc. But schools that have to follow the LA directives can't do that. Even though I bet most of them want to.

I don't blame the schools for doing what they have to do but it isn't fair or porportionate to the risk. I don't think YABU at all.

PurpleDaisies · 02/11/2021 13:03

You are quite right OP, we need to keep our children in school.

With all the staff off?

Grumpster21 · 02/11/2021 13:03

@Lightswitch123 you are getting a bit ahead of yourself in your timeframe - it's not been 2 years since March 2020 (counting from then its only been 18months of a novel virus circulating in the community) and we have two months to go until the end of 2021. I know it feels longer! This is the first winter we have to get through (with the protection of vaccines) but a high rate of community infection that inevitably will still cause disruption this year as more of the population are exposed to it.

@SachaStark2 By mid-December, the majority of our staff will be over six months since their vaccine, so will no longer have protection The medics have said protection will not drop off a cliff edge but will gradually wane so thankfully will still prevent most hospitalisations and deaths.

Totallydefeated · 02/11/2021 13:01

Today 10:48 BiscoffAddict

@coffeerevelsrock indeed. How many times do we have to point out that school isn’t childcare?

Until such time as there are adequate levels of feasible and affordable wraparound childcare across all schools in the country, I imagine.

When do you think parents will have viable alternatives to relying on after school clubs as they try to meet their employment obligations?

You can’t blame parents for wanting to make use of what’s available. And generally quite a lot of schools are mindful that parents rely on clubs for childcare and try their best not to disrupt the provision. Doesn’t yours?

carrythecan · 02/11/2021 13:00

@SachaStark2

Also, vaccine efficacy is seriously dwindling amongst most of the teaching populace, as booster vaccines are slow to come about at the moment.

My mid-December, the majority of our staff will be over six months since their vaccine, so will no longer have protection.

That is not what the data shows. The protection offered by vaccines does not just 'switch off' after 6 months.

You are quite right OP, we need to keep our children in school.

allupsidedown · 02/11/2021 12:54

@salviapages

I'm disgusted by this post and the selfish attitude of OP and those that agree with her. A teacher's job involves being around hundreds of children from all different households, their job inherently holds more risk of COVID. Teachers didn't get to work from home during lockdown, they went in and taught children of key workers and vulnerable children. They haven't had the luxury of staying safe by staying at home. Schools wanting to protect their staff by putting in COVID measures is completely reasonable and I'm disgusted anyone thinks otherwise.

I trained to teach during COVID. A teacher at my school caught COVID and was incapacitated for months. She has finally returned to work but her health will never be the same.

I'm not saying teachers are heroes or trying to put them on a pedestal. But the job has inherently more of a COVID risk than many other jobs and teachers shouldn't be criticised for wanting to protect themselves from it. If they don't and they catch COVID you won't like it when your kid is stuck with a rotation of supply teachers! Plus they were well aware of the impact this has all had on children's mental health and I see teachers trying so hard to mitigate this and ensure children in their class are happy. They care about your children but they have to balance their own safety. I'm truly disgusted by the attitude of the OP

Completely agree. The OP seems to feel that schools are not putting the children first. Of course we are. However, if the teachers are all off sick then the children will be much more adversely affected than they are by not having indoor events. Our parent interviews are still happening but online instead. We did a Carol concert outside last year. Schools are trying to be creative to make things better for kids whilst at the same time have been massively unskilled to be able to teach remotely if we have to. Teachers feel like lambs to the slaughter. Not just undervalued as professional but that our lives have no value.
MrsWhites · 02/11/2021 12:53

The virus is still spreading in schools (in our school more so than last year) so I don’t see the difference between 2020 and 2021.

Would you have schools remove all precautionary measures and let it run riot through our children and those teaching/supporting them through their education? How irresponsible and selfish would that be!

Grumpster21 · 02/11/2021 12:53

@FallonBeesley

I agree with you OP, the vaccine was our way out, we just need to live with it now. The things my DS has missed out on are ridiculous, I want a normal happy life for him not this awful half life that our children are experiencing right now. It’s not fair on them and will be affecting them mentally far more than this virus.
@FallonBeesley go on then tell us what the awful half life that our children are experiencing right now is?

January-March 2020 - they were not in school, not going to sports, clubs, parties, into other families homes
Autumn 2021 - my DC are in school today, tennis tonight, going to a party and an activity at the weekend, attending brownies, family visited and stayed over for Halloween. Admittedly parents evenings are now online & the Christmas activies will be in school without parents attending but streamed to watch.

But I think you are being quite melodramatic to claim they are NOW living a half life...

MrsColon · 02/11/2021 12:51

Re: introducing bubbles - close contacts of affected children DO NOT need to isolate. If the school are doing this, then please report to the DfE, as it puts their funding at risk.

Hankunamatata · 02/11/2021 12:49

Kids don't get ill except those with asthma who can end up in hospital but as long as your kids dont miss out on their afterschool activities Hmm

Hankunamatata · 02/11/2021 12:47

Our school never stopped those measures. Most schools here are insisting on 10 days off school if close contact as so many are testing postive on day 8