Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not get why I'm being turned down for rental properties?

129 replies

Fpbww · 02/11/2021 10:27

In our town (don't know if this is common in other areas) the process for renting is - view house you are interested in, submit a detailed application form (the longest has been 8 pages long) confirming employers, income, bank details, addresses and so on. Sometimes providing ID, bank statements, wage slips, you name it.

The landlord then has a look at the applications and decides who he/ she likes the look of best. And if you get to that stage, THEN they do any referencing, credit checks etc.

We've applied for 5 houses in the last month. We were offered one (having passed stage 1 we were invited to agree referencing/ checks), but decided due to some concerns over maintenance (a couple of damp patches which the LL tried to say were not actually damp!) we decided not to proceed.

With the other 4, we've been rejected at the first stage.

All different estate agents (there are about 20 locally) so it's not that

I can't see why on paper we are not attractive to a LL?
We're both in our 40s, no children at home, non smokers, no pets. We both work from home. We're looking to rent for up to 2 years.
Our joint salary is 3x the affordability criteria. DP is a director of his own small business, which I know is not always attractive to landlords, but his earnings are 50% of mine, so even if you didn't include his salary I could more than afford the place on my own.

Am I missing something? We needed to give notice this week but now are holding off as there doesn't seem much chance of finding something else quickly.

OP posts:
Horst · 02/11/2021 17:55

Renting has gone crazy the house next door to be has just gone up for rent at nearly double the price of mine. I’m sure there will be people snapping the landlords hand off but it’s so so sad as the house hell the area really isn’t worth it.

The agent will be picking not the landlord as he is very hands off abs the agent is well known for placing terrible tenants in that house too.

dangermouseisace · 02/11/2021 17:52

Round our way people are being ridiculous with rentals. Offering over the asking rent, paying 6 months/a year in advance....that kind of thing. It is ridiculously competitive so don't take it personally.

elbea · 02/11/2021 17:49

@dreamingbohemian that isn’t what I said. People earning well over the affordability criteria are much more likely to be renting as a short term solution before buying. Country estates don’t as a rule sell their houses. The landowners and charities I worked for owned multiple villages with current and retired staff and private tenants, it was in their benefit to look for long term tenants who would contribute to a community, not people passing through as a stop gap.

In return tenants got fair rents, could decorate the house as they liked and had the security of knowing their home wasn’t going to be sold from under them.

HeartvsBrain · 02/11/2021 17:34

If it was a renters market OP I think you would have been snapped up by the first place you offered on. However, as it isn't at the moment, I would see from your application forms that you had lived seperately up to now, and that would concern me that your relationship might not be as secure as other longer term partners - which to be fair seems to be the case, as you say (very sensibly) that you wouldn't buy a property with your partner immediately, presumably because you want to know first that you are compatible when living together full-time - so you could actually want to give up the tenancy far sooner than you suggest on your application form. Are neither of your and your partner's present rentals suitable for one of you to move in with the other?

IncessantNameChanger · 02/11/2021 17:01

As a landlord going via a agency I personally never got involved with who got the house. The agent did all of that and told me who they wanted. Normally it was one of the quickest to view. I think the agency built up a relationship with people who had possibly been looking and viewing before but I cant say for sure. If you pass the credit check I dont really care.

However saying that a two year let isnt always ideal. I would be wondering if I needed to red carpet and redecorate in two years. Five years it's less of a concern as everything would be getting tired anyway

meganorks · 02/11/2021 16:59

I'm guessing they want good, reliable, long term tenants. And on paper you look like you will be buying somewhere soon. Even 2 years isn't that long. So if they have others who look more like long term renters they will take them.

dreamingbohemian · 02/11/2021 16:53

@elbea

Having managed large country estates with hundreds of rental properties, we never accepted anybody that offered rent up front.

As you earn 3x the affordability criteria it would also be considered that you wouldn’t be long term.

So you can't possibly rent if you don't earn 3X the rent

If you do earn 3X the rent, then it's suspicious and you still won't be able to rent

Bonkers

Lulu1919 · 02/11/2021 16:13

[quote MidnightMeltdown]@Lulu1919

£1000 isn't a lot when split between two people. When I was renting, I paid almost that much on my own, plus all bills, and still saved a deposit. If they aren't on low wages then it sounds like they aren't making the necessary sacrifices to save.[/quote]
Really !?!?
It would take years to save £35000 deposit
Renting can be a choice

MidnightMeltdown · 02/11/2021 16:04

@Lulu1919

£1000 isn't a lot when split between two people. When I was renting, I paid almost that much on my own, plus all bills, and still saved a deposit. If they aren't on low wages then it sounds like they aren't making the necessary sacrifices to save.

Fpbww · 02/11/2021 15:59

On the 'why don't we buy' point:

Firstly this is our first time living together - buying a house together is a massive commitment, I wouldn't do that without living with someone first.

Also, although I am in a position to buy, DP is not. In 2-3 years hopefully he will be. If not, we might well keep on renting for another couple of years until he is.

Our salaries fwiw are decent but not enormous, I'm lucky to earn above the average at £58k, however DP only receives £22k from the business. The places we're looking at are £800-900 pm - DP currently pays £600 on his own place.

OP posts:
Bell25 · 02/11/2021 15:57

Landlord here - working at home wouldn’t/hasn’t put me off, if anything people have more time to clean and stay on top of things.
Depending on the property type you may not be allowed to ‘do business’ from the property , mainly with leasehold properties so it could be that.
Also in regards to minimum income for affordability, the estate agent i use has this set at 20k however I always have applicants earning between 50-100k applying.
I usually accept the highest income as there really is no other way to differentiate. There might be other applicants with higher incomes although on papers yours is more than yours.
If you can offer upfront payment or a slightly higher rental income this would make you more attractive to the landlord.

Lulu1919 · 02/11/2021 15:45

@LittleDandelionClock

Maybe if you earn 3 X more than the renting criteria, and your DH is a 'director of a business' they think you can afford to buy, and are letting people rent who don't earn such humungous salaries as you and your DH.

They are probably mystified as to why you want to rent for 2 years or more with such an ample income, and as I said, they are letting people who genuinely cannot afford to buy rent the properties.

Often it's not the mortgage payments it's the deposit My daughter and husband work hard and earn quite well....but renting a small two bed flat is costing them a £1000 a month ....they can't afford to save for a deposit of £35000 so that what they rent !!!
TractorAndHeadphones · 02/11/2021 15:36

Which is why i dont think housing should be a private market but not relevatn to this thread

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/11/2021 15:34

@MidnightMeltdown

Wow, some of reasons given on here for rejecting potential tenants are unbelievable. If it's this difficult for good tenants to rent somewhere, then I dread to think what it's like for the truly less desirable tenants.

I think the issue is probably that the pandemic has changed the type of property that people want (gardens, extra bedrooms for wfh etc). People with kids who need the extra bedrooms are now finding themselves competing with singles or couples who just want the luxury of a spare room for wfh etc, but may previously have been happy without it.

Can't blame LL's for rejecting tenants with 'frivolous' reasons. Only one can have the house and they have to make a choice.

The second part is true though. One bed flats/properties are going for dirt cheap... even value has dropped like a stone.

DCINightingale · 02/11/2021 15:31

I am a landlord. I would be put off by you saying you only wanted to rent for 2 years. If there is another applicant who is looking for longer term that will always win out. Even though they could move out after a year, the goal for a lot of landlords is to get a tenant who will be settled for a good number of years. It saves the hassle of resetting, and redecorating between tenancies.

elbea · 02/11/2021 15:29

Having managed large country estates with hundreds of rental properties, we never accepted anybody that offered rent up front.

As you earn 3x the affordability criteria it would also be considered that you wouldn’t be long term.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 02/11/2021 15:24

I am a landlord and there's nothing wrong with you, the market is just crazy, I put mine up for renewal and it was gone 6 weeks before the tenants moved out, only required one Sat morning showing, lots of interest, you can't have everyone.

All those theorizing as to why, normally a dual professional couple without kids are the preferred tenants!

Ultimately this is a supply and demand issue, I've been a renter and I started to dread having to find a new property for this reason, it was highly competitive and just awful.

Keep trying!

Thesearmsofmine · 02/11/2021 15:19

It’s really difficult, I’m dreading the time when our LL sells because I know we are probably less desirable tenants(3dc, home ed) despite having lived in our current home for 9 years with no issues.

MidnightMeltdown · 02/11/2021 15:12

We have looked on Open Rent and similar but in our area it seems to be mostly landlords with 1 bed/ studio type places who use it.

This is what I mean. I think that people who were previously renting studios and 1 beds are now looking for more space which is what has caused the problem.

Just had a quick look on rightmove in my local area. There are currently 20 properties available. However, if you want 3 bedrooms then there are only 2. If you want a garden also, then there's only 1 property available.

I don't think that there's a shortage of properties as such, it's just that there's been a shift in the type of property that people want since spending more time at home.

It's not that your doing anything wrong, it's just too much demand for certain types of properties.

MsMoody · 02/11/2021 15:02

OP, I think demand is just through the roof at the moment. Keep at it and try to get in there first. Friend of mine had to try for 3 months before managing to secure a rental.

It is worrying that demand for property both to rent AND to buy is so high in this country at the moment.

Fpbww · 02/11/2021 14:58

@showmethegin what would a work reference say? I work for a very large law firm who are highly reluctant to provide reference type info other than to prospective employers and even then disclosure is minimal; at best I'd be able to get something that confirmed my start date and current salary, and I'm not even sure if they'd be willing to provide that.

DP obviously can't get a work reference for himself because he is the company director.

OP posts:
Fpbww · 02/11/2021 14:54

i can see how someone who's a director could be seen as risky, however his income is less than half mine, so our ability to pay would not be dependent on that - having said that, he's been paying himself a similar amount for 6 years and has rented houses throughout that time, and never had any rent arrears or issues as previous letting agents would confirm - as said, he's been in his current place for over 2 years. His income is pretty reliable as he contracts out his services, he's never without a contract except through choice.

We can't change the fact I WFH, although I can avoid mentioning it (there's nothing on the forms about it, so that's easy enough).

We have looked on Open Rent and similar but in our area it seems to be mostly landlords with 1 bed/ studio type places who use it, everyone else goes via an agent.

OP posts:
showmethegin · 02/11/2021 14:49

Do you have to say how long you want to stay?

We've won every rental we've applied for by attaching work and personal references to the back of the application before they've asked for it. Think it gave us an edge when comparing applicants

Notonthenewrug · 02/11/2021 14:47

It's a tough one, I think at the moment there is so much demand for properties. Also, it can depend on what the LL is looking for and it's not always the obvious. When we moved into our last property, there were 9 applicants. They chose us because we were a family and they wanted the home to go to a family. I was 8 months pregnant at the time and we also had a dog. However they chose us over single people and couples that would have created less wear and tear.

Whingasaurus · 02/11/2021 14:40

As a Ll I'd assume you wouldn't be long term so pick someone else plus and I avoid wfh where possible. More wear and tear/no break for neighbours /endless talking in the garden whilst complaining about the neighbours normal daytime noise etc etc.