Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nasty for them to exclude me?

360 replies

Korbah · 02/11/2021 09:21

Last Christmas DH and I decided not to mix. I’m CEV and was due to be vaccinated in January, I didn’t want to risk my life at the last minute after I’d shielded for months. But his family were making plans including us, and I was worried it would get to the point where they’d say it’s too late to drop out, and I’d get pressured into it. DH said I’ll tell them but not right now... because he knew MIL would take a hissy fit and wanted to postpone it. I told DH I was finding it stressful and feeling like I was going to be pressured into something unsafe for my health, so he needed to tell them within 7 days or I’d tell them myself. He didn’t tell them - so I did. As nicely as possible.

MIL immediately left the group chat and blocked me. Apparently she cried for weeks because of not having her family Christmas. Nobody posted in the group chat ever again. I’ve seen MIL and the rest of DH’s family a couple of times since then and have chatted politely. So I figured MIL’s tantrum was forgotten.

Yesterday I saw DH texting in a new “Bloggs Family” chat. Looks like they’ve set up a new family chat with everyone except me. I got really annoyed and said it’s nasty to exclude me. DH said no no, it isn’t a new family chat... we were just texting each other. Well that is a new family chat then!

AIBU to just refuse to have anything to do with any of them ever again? They’ve purposely excluded me and I think it’s nasty, I don’t see how I’m supposed to see them and just ignore it.

OP posts:
RealBecca · 02/11/2021 13:07

Yanbu.

Your husband sounds like he panders to her so id let him get on with it and step back. Need a card picking up for MIL? No I'm inot part of the family. Cook lunch for them. No, not part of the family. Go for te? No, not part of the family. Make it hos problem to solve if he wants to, otherwise e joy your new easier life. oh, and dont get drawn into a row with him. Its no different to what they are doing.

irene9 · 02/11/2021 13:06

Texting her in a group chat would have been taken pretty badly. She may have experienced that as her getting shamed in front of the group. Your DH is a wimp when it comes to his mother. It seems they are all afraid of her and she thinks her family is the main family with her as the head and other families are lesser and are her 'children' whom she is still entitled to control.

You are better off not being on the group chat. I asked to be removed from a chat set up by an inlaw because it was so pressurising. If it wasn't competitive photos of other people's kids amazing achievements it was in-laws inviting themselves over for visits where you could not politely decline without it seeming like you were binning someone off.
Really you are better off. Think of how your head would be wrecked every time your phone pings.

SaySomethingMan · 02/11/2021 13:03

@Korbah

Yes it was mean for them to all leave the group and set up a new one without you, but do you really want to be involved? They’re all communicating regularly about their lives and I’m the only one who’s excluded. I didn’t receive the photos of my SIL’s graduation. Or my nephew’s first day at school. Or my niece’s exam results. Or the twins in their Halloween costumes for their school disco. DH showed me some photos and I thought they must have been sent to him directly, but it turns out they were put in the family chat so everyone saw them except me. I’m basically excluded from everything they share.
Are you close to your DH’s family at all? Because although you’re not part of the group, if your relationship was a good one, they’ve have sent it to you anyway. Or actually raise the issue of you not being part of the group.
flatclearancehelp · 02/11/2021 13:01

MiL sounds batshit but perhaps she has 'issues' / MH problems and the family tip-toe around her so she gets away with the bullshit behaviour. I'd stay out of it and let them got on with their chatter.

Perhaps your husband will 'share' newsy items with you so you can respond privately to the family member with congratulations etc and keep in touch with them on an ad hoc basis. That way they'll know you're still interested in the goings on and you can continue a relationship with the rest of the family.

Hadjab · 02/11/2021 13:00

Here’s my take on the situation. Your MIL clearly has issues. Her reaction to you’re not coming to Christmas shows that. The fact that your DH put off telling her of your non-attendance, leads me to believe that the family will do anything for a quiet life so as not to tip her over the edge, rightly or wrongly. Yes, your DH should have your back, but I can see why he wouldn’t if he’s, assumingly, had to put up with a lifetime of this behaviour. The past 18 months have been a complete mind fuck for all of us - you haven’t said if she has form for this type of behaviour, but I’d be inclined to cut MIL some slack on that basis alone.

Your DH does need to stand up to her, but again, if this is her standard behaviour, then it’s easier said than done. He’s in a difficult position here. Does he cut off contact with the family, because of a group chat, when by your own admission, they’ve been civil to you face to face, or does he ruin relations with you because he wants maintain his family ties, when he should have had your back?

I would suggest you let this go, for your own sanity. Exclusion isn’t nice, but just as we teach our kids not to exclude others, don’t we also teach our kids that those who exclude them have issues, and it’s for them to work on? It’s hurtful behaviour, but leave them to it. I would also echo other posters in creating your own channels for family updates - if they don’t want to post info twice, then fine, let it go, but at least you’ve tried to maintain a relationship and been the bigger and better person.

Allsorts1 · 02/11/2021 12:55

Yes you would be unreasonable to cut out your in laws for good because they had a WhatsApp chat group without you in it.

Blueberryflavour · 02/11/2021 12:53

I would be more upset with my DH’s lack of support than I would be angry at my in-laws. He had the opportunity to explain to his mum about why you couldn’t come last Christmas, presumably he knew on this occasion that there was no “ good way” to tell your MIL so just bottled it. He made you be the bad guy so that he can be the good son ( I would be so interested in knowing if there was chat as in poor Bob married to OP who wouldn’t let him come last Christmas). I would be honest with my DH and say this is all on him and that if you do go for Christmas you’ll tell them all that he was in agreement not to come last year. Actually I wouldn’t if it were me because I wouldn’t go at all, let DH do what he wants and make my own plans. Even for me who is very family orientated and sucks up a lot to keep the peace and who loves Christmas I couldn’t go and be pleasant and smiley with people who have made it perfectly clear I am not part of their family.

AndTime · 02/11/2021 12:53

I think it is mean of them to exclude you HOWEVER - you weren't bothered enough about being disconnected to reach out individually, you are only complaining now because you know about the group chat.

So you aren't actually bothered about those things, you are just sulking because you have been left out.

BadNomad · 02/11/2021 12:52

Wow they're nasty and your husband is a dick. Can you go to your own family this Christmas seeing as you are not part of the Bloggs family anymore? Fuck them.

thevassal · 02/11/2021 12:45

Don't know why all the posters are saying you are unreasonable. Yes people are allowed to have different group chats with different people but you've made it very clear that this is the main chat with everyone except you and was set up as a direct result of the issues last year.

The fact that your dh is refusing to add you because mil will leave again is pathetic. He shouldn't be using you as a scape goat and letting his family exclude you and his mum needs to get a grip! If she left that chat you should have all carried on in the main chat without her not made a new one to pacify her and deliberately exclude you. It's blatant bullying. Loads of people were disappointed about Christmas last year but they just acted like adults about it.

Mind you this is an amazing excuse to never spend another Christmas with them so at least there's that.

Notonthestairs · 02/11/2021 12:42

Lots of people missing the point.

The chat was set up to exclude - that has longer term issues than just not having to read family news. It means every single member of DH's family - including her husband - are ok with isolating the Op.

It's a horrible way to treat a family member.

And if you are bored with family chats you can just mute - I do if I'm overwhelmed with other crap. But it's always nice to have the option to congratulate someone on a new job/school/achievement or share a bit of positive news yourself.

Chimley · 02/11/2021 12:41

I think it's safe to say you have a DH problem. The question is what do you want to do about that?

2bazookas · 02/11/2021 12:37

We have various family whatsapp groups depending on who we want to share which info/chat with. This is because of the varying level of daily contact/personal visits/ personal liking/ different interests.

We ALL do this and it's perfectly open above board and OK with all of us. Nobody feels excluded or bursts into tears.

Lesserspottedmama · 02/11/2021 12:36

Why would you even want to be on their boring old chat? I’m very glad not to be on my DH family WhatsApp. I think DH wishes he didn’t have to be on it either! You won’t be missing out on anything remotely interesting OP, surely you have better things to do then scroll through their inane chit chat?

2Hot2Handle · 02/11/2021 12:33

Or soul even!

2Hot2Handle · 02/11/2021 12:32

@LadyTiredWinterBottom2, this isn’t something that has happened and OP is refusing to get over it. This is something that is continuing to happen. She is being excluded continuously from the WhatsApp group. Her husband participates in the group, knowing that she’s deliberately being left out. This is ongoing. The OP is now being expected to attend family events, knowing that she is being the only one being excluded and doesn’t have a single sole willing to stand up for her, including her DH.

Hankunamatata · 02/11/2021 12:31

Its annoying but I'd let them get on with it. You said you don't have much to do with them anymore so why would you want to be on chat with them. I can see why your hurt but also its impossible for your dh - he leaves chat then doesnt have contact with family or he insists you are added and another fall out happens. Let them get kn with their drama

Jasmine11 · 02/11/2021 12:28

Sounds like it might only be your MiL and DH who are excluding you - chances are no-one else has checked the participants list closely and assumes that you are on it - or if they have noticed they probably would assume that you didn't want to be.

Hankunamatata · 02/11/2021 12:28

I'm guessing the chat that was set up immediately after fall out was to discuss the Christmas situation - they couldn't do that with you on there. 🤷‍♀️

Movingsoon21 · 02/11/2021 12:28

OP I’m sure you know you have a DH problem here. Yes his mum is a massive drama Queen and it’s horrible they’ve been messaging each other behind your back, but he is the one person who should always have your back and prevent situations like this arising.
Time for a serious chat with him. This situation is entirely his fault - if he had spoken to your mum separately to explain then they wouldn’t just have gone nuclear at you. If he had insisted you were added to the new group you wouldn’t now be feeling crap.

He needs to understand he has let you down hugely and really damaged the relationship between you and his family, so a family Christmas won’t be possible this year. He needs to make it up to you and heal the rift he has caused.

HeadNorth · 02/11/2021 12:28

OP - there is no way on this planet I would be going to my MIL's for xmas dinner under the circumstances you describe. Which means DH wil,l have to pick a team. Easy for me, my DH would never have allowed my exclusion in the first place. Your DH needs to grow a pair - would he really choose to spend xmas without his wife to please his mummy? I would hope not.

KatherineJaneway · 02/11/2021 12:26

As the saying goes this is a DH issue, not an MIL issue.

He should have told her you both would not attend the first time the topic was raised. Instead he chickened out and let her go on and on making her reaction much worse than it probably would have been if he hadn't let her hopes be raised.

He also should insist that you are added to the chat or he will leave it.

I couldn't be married to someone who so obviously didn't have my back just for a quiet life.

caketiger · 02/11/2021 12:22

Fellow CEV here, we are still shielding and planning on doing so through winter. Sending you support :-)

girlmom21 · 02/11/2021 12:21

@LadyTiredWinterBottom2

It sounds like your mil was being dramatic

It now sounds like you are being dramatic

I'm not in my DH family chat and quite frankly l'm glad not to he disturbed by their inane drivel

Stop creating unnecessary drama

The difference is you don't want to be involved.
TractorAndHeadphones · 02/11/2021 12:20

@Jumpingintochristmas

Your Mil is vile and someone should have stood up for you. Your DH is spineless and happy to hurt you over his mother, regardless of the fact you did absolutely nothing wrong. That’s deeply hurtful.

Moving forward I would personally struggle with DH’s betrayal. On a practical note I would be polite to in laws but very aware of this, it would make me anxious in their company - I would absolutely avoid wine with my Christmas lunch incase I said something Xmas Blush.

I'd just not be in their company. H can go alone