Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nasty for them to exclude me?

360 replies

Korbah · 02/11/2021 09:21

Last Christmas DH and I decided not to mix. I’m CEV and was due to be vaccinated in January, I didn’t want to risk my life at the last minute after I’d shielded for months. But his family were making plans including us, and I was worried it would get to the point where they’d say it’s too late to drop out, and I’d get pressured into it. DH said I’ll tell them but not right now... because he knew MIL would take a hissy fit and wanted to postpone it. I told DH I was finding it stressful and feeling like I was going to be pressured into something unsafe for my health, so he needed to tell them within 7 days or I’d tell them myself. He didn’t tell them - so I did. As nicely as possible.

MIL immediately left the group chat and blocked me. Apparently she cried for weeks because of not having her family Christmas. Nobody posted in the group chat ever again. I’ve seen MIL and the rest of DH’s family a couple of times since then and have chatted politely. So I figured MIL’s tantrum was forgotten.

Yesterday I saw DH texting in a new “Bloggs Family” chat. Looks like they’ve set up a new family chat with everyone except me. I got really annoyed and said it’s nasty to exclude me. DH said no no, it isn’t a new family chat... we were just texting each other. Well that is a new family chat then!

AIBU to just refuse to have anything to do with any of them ever again? They’ve purposely excluded me and I think it’s nasty, I don’t see how I’m supposed to see them and just ignore it.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 02/11/2021 10:11

You keep saying "everyone except me" but we don't know who that is. Can you clarify?

Korbah · 02/11/2021 10:10

So for 6 years you were part of the family chat, you decline Christmas invitation and then are dropped from the group? Yes that's intended to upset you
Yes exactly. For six years everyone was included in the group chat. Now it’s everyone except me. I’ve asked to be added and DH said no. Because he said if he adds me then MIL will leave the group chat again and they’ll just set up a new group chat without me again.

OP posts:
Charlene1971 · 02/11/2021 10:10

@TheKeatingFive

They're allowed to set up a group without you. I don't see what's unreasonable about that.
You don't see what's unreasonable about purposely excluding a person? Seriously? Hmm
Notonthestairs · 02/11/2021 10:09

They stopped using a group because the Op declined Christmas - how ridiculous.

Charlene1971 · 02/11/2021 10:09

@Korbah

Is it just him and his immediate family (e.g. parents and siblings), or are his siblings partners in the group as well? Everyone. Except me.
So, your siblings other partners have been added, but not you?
LittleDandelionClock · 02/11/2021 10:09

@LindaEllen

For everyone saying it's normal to have a group chat without partners - it is, but the point is they stopped posting in the old one and specifically made a new one without her in it. I think I'd be a bit upset at that, too.
This. I am shocked at the responses on here, and think the OP's husband is behaving in a sneaky, conniving manner. And HE sounds much like his mother, the OP doesn't! @Korbah YANBU at all.^ They all sound like a bunch of self-centred boors.

As for the MIL 'crying for weeks' because she couldn't have the family for Christmas! How pathetic. Is she 5? Hmm

Newsflash lady ; NO-ONE HAD THEIR FAMILY FOR CHRISTMAS LAST YEAR, BECAUSE WE WERE IN A LOCKDOWN. Some people were fortunate enough to see a couple of people, but no-one saw their whole family.

Horrible behaviour like this would have me questioning my marriage tbh. Your DH is no better than his mother.

As for the people deriding you, ignore them. There's no way in HELL that anyone on this thread would be happy with what has happened. Not the fact that your DH has a separate chat with his family that excludes you, but the fact that his MIL and family has got the hump with you, and your DH has started this chat behind your back, and you are being purposely excluded.

TheKeatingFive · 02/11/2021 10:08

They're allowed to set up a group without you. I don't see what's unreasonable about that.

Korbah · 02/11/2021 10:07

Is it just him and his immediate family (e.g. parents and siblings), or are his siblings partners in the group as well?
Everyone. Except me.

OP posts:
Notonthestairs · 02/11/2021 10:07

So for 6 years you were part of the family chat, you decline Christmas invitation and then are dropped from the group?

Yes that's intended to upset you.

I'd ignore.

Charlene1971 · 02/11/2021 10:06

@Polmuggle

We have a family chat just my brother, me and parents, which excludes sister in law. We have another one with her in but it's hardly used.

Is that nasty?

No, it's not nasty. You have every right to do this. In fact, we used to have a family chat with just my siblings in it, then my sister made one with all of our partners in them, pissed me off 😂

But OP might be the only in-law not in the new group chat, we don't know the fill story?

Korbah · 02/11/2021 10:06

But you don't know that it's a new group chat.
It’s a new chat with everyone who was on the original group chat except me. I don’t know what else you’d call it.

OP posts:
Korbah · 02/11/2021 10:04

The new one has been set up almost a year later!
Apparently it was set up last year shortly after they stopped posting in the old group chat. They’ve been using it for a year without my knowledge. I’ve seen them since and they all knew they had joined a new group chat behind my back, which included everyone except me, and nobody said anything.

OP posts:
Notonthestairs · 02/11/2021 10:04

I think it's unpleasant to drop a group chat and then begin a new one W/o one person. It's pointed and deliberately meant to exclude the Op.

Over what exactly? Not wanting to come to Christmas? It's pathetic.

And I'm not sure why it's controlling to ask DH to let MIL know in good time and then do it when he doesn't.

I have multiple WhatsApp groups 1-2-1 (mainly birthday gift ideas) but we always have done - I'd never exclude any family member from group chats though.

Lasair · 02/11/2021 10:03

Yeah that’s unfair but also I can see your husband is in a hard position.

Yogity · 02/11/2021 10:02

I would wonder when the new group chat was set up - was it January after MIL fortnight of sorrow or was it October 2021 for example. I'd be less annoyed at the latter.

I do sympathise OP. My DM is one who loses the plot if her Christmas isn't an annual identikit affair and its a lot of pressure to maintain when it often doesn't suit. I would be upset that your DH didn't step up, at the very least in the aftermath.

I also somewhat wonder how you phrased your message declining the invite. Texts are easy to misread but it sounds like more than just MIL took exception if no one else in the group chat posted ever again.

Polmuggle · 02/11/2021 10:02

We have a family chat just my brother, me and parents, which excludes sister in law. We have another one with her in but it's hardly used.

Is that nasty?

Nyxs · 02/11/2021 10:01

@Korbah

I would be perfectly happy if I’d never been included in the group chat at all from the beginning. I’m upset because I was in the group chat for six years and now they’ve excluded me. By switching to a new group chat that includes everyone except me.
So what's the issue?

You were in a group chat, you didn't want to be. That one stopped being used. Another one at some point has been set up and you are not in it. Which is fine because you didn't want to be in the first one.

Your mil maybe hard work, but you are too.

Charlene1971 · 02/11/2021 10:00

I'm confused. Is it just him and his immediate family (e.g. parents and siblings), or are his siblings partners in the group as well?

Need more info

Korbah · 02/11/2021 09:59

I would be perfectly happy if I’d never been included in the group chat at all from the beginning. I’m upset because I was in the group chat for six years and now they’ve excluded me. By switching to a new group chat that includes everyone except me.

OP posts:
MordredsOrrery · 02/11/2021 09:58

Have you tried starting up a conversation in the family chat? What happens if you do?

At the moment I think YABU but if you've tried to start conversations and nobody responded then that's a different thing.

DH's family have multiple chat groups with various members, I'm in some and not others (and mostly mute the whole family one because it's just tedious). My family don't have any chat groups, we just call each other if we want to chat. Everyone's different.

Itsnotgreatlike · 02/11/2021 09:57

But you don't know that it's a new group chat. They could simultaneously have had a different group chat at the same time as the family group chat and have been using it all along. I have all sorts of groups like that. One that just has my sisters, one that just has my brother and one other sibling, one that has all my adult nieces, one that has brothers in law and sisters in law etc. Loads of them. We can be chatting in all sorts of groups more or less simultaneously. We're not cruelly leaving other people out, we're just tailoring each group to what is most relevant.

Nyxs · 02/11/2021 09:57

@Korbah

Why is it nasty for him to have a conversation with his family? It’s nasty to stop using a chat that includes one person, and set up a new chat that includes everyone except that person.
Its really not.

You don't have to Include every person ever who has been in a previous group chat.

Group chats are set up for different reasons and different purposes. Being in one doesn't mean you would automatically be in another.v

MindatWork · 02/11/2021 09:56

Did you post about this in the run up to Christmas last year op? It sounds familiar...

nokidshere · 02/11/2021 09:54

We have lots of family chats. We have one for us sisters only, one which includes mum, one which includes nieces/nephews and wider family. I also have a group chat with me and both my sons, and an individual chat group with each of them.

DH isn't on any of them because he doesn't use social media at all. If he wants to know anything he has to get the news second hand from me. And he has no family other than me and the boys.

girlmom21 · 02/11/2021 09:54

Are other in-laws of your DH's involved in the chat? If so, it's exclusion. If not, it's not.