Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not realise people can steal houses?

163 replies

radiatorsz · 02/11/2021 07:39

Read this story

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-59069662.amp

wtf!!!

How can this happen and how is it a civil matter? How can you stop this happening?

OP posts:
Lemonsyellow · 02/11/2021 13:35

At the very least, I would expect the valuer and anybody else along the line who should have queried the price

What valuer? I suspect it was bought for cash. No valuer.

Hoppinggreen · 02/11/2021 13:33

@Bluntness100

Remember we don’t know the full story and it could be the owner is actually the one who commuted the fraud,or more to the story that is known to the public.
I imagine Radio 4 did their due diligence
Lemonsyellow · 02/11/2021 13:31

Maybe if you're selling to family or a very close friend, you might give them a hefty discount (although, ironically, the authorities will still ask questions and query suspected stamp duty/other tax avoidance with a significantly below-market value price); but if actually buying from a stranger/mild acquaintance?

Who judges if a house is significantly below market value, though? Who judges its value? My house may appear to be worth ££ on first glance, but I know it doesn’t have building regs approval or planning permission for all sorts, plus it has rising damp, ancient electrics etc.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 13:27

It was the neighbours who reported it as soon as they saw someone in the house.

The neighbours seem like nice ones. It's not always easy to get the balance between being a good neighbour and being a nosey, interfering busybody. For all they knew, he could have put it on Air BnB whilst he was away and anybody entering the house was a legitimate short-term tenant.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 13:24

If a fraudulent purchase doesn’t go through a solicitor buyers can and do lose the properties. This particular purchase went through a solicitor and it is their failings that caused the original owner to lose their property - they will be compensated.

Well, in that case, I think the solicitors should be investigated by the police for the reasons that I gave.

If we're going down the road of saying 'compensation due: end of matter', what's to stop any thief/fraudster/act of gross professional misconduct from trying their luck, with no repercussions other than having to pay back what they stole/mishandled on the occasions when they get caught?

Would it not ring a big bell flashing a sign saying 'GUILTY' if they have to pay compensation equivalent to the true value of the house? If they insist that the sale price was a realistic market value - and thus that's all the compo they expect to pay - they're just condemning themselves for their incompetence (assuming they weren't in on the fraud in the first place). Never mind compensation for all of his possessions and priceless sentimental things that can't be replaced, and his own mental suffering from all this.

At the very least, I would expect the valuer and anybody else along the line who should have queried the price and circumstances but didn't to be publicly named and exposed - and ideally struck off.

I also still think that, regardless of the solicitors' shocking misconduct, the buyer should be made to answer why they believed it all above-board and not at all fishy to be paying half the market value for a house that was never marketed. I cannot see how they are a completely innocent party in this.

I know that plenty of people do agree sales without ever marketing the property, but they would invariably get independent professional advise as to a fair price, and only severely reduce this if selling to a family member or similar. Even these 'buy your house instantly' companies, who profit from desperate people, wouldn't expect to pay less than 50% of the value.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 02/11/2021 13:21

Has it only just happened? Before the pandemic some streets were often quite dead during the day with everyone at work (as per Mumsnet threads you used to get regularly where the sahm or wfh op is moaning about having to take in parcels for half the street because all her neighbours are out all day).

Lemonsyellow · 02/11/2021 13:19

@CounsellorTroi

Am I the only one wondering why the neighbours didn’t see/hear anything odd going on, given it was a terraced house. I feel so sorry for this man.
It was the neighbours who reported it as soon as they saw someone in the house.
CounsellorTroi · 02/11/2021 13:16

Am I the only one wondering why the neighbours didn’t see/hear anything odd going on, given it was a terraced house. I feel so sorry for this man.

amillionrosepetals · 02/11/2021 13:13

@Cattenberg

Sorry, I should have read your post properly, *@amillionrosepetals*.
Not to worry. That was my point actually (sorry if I wasn't clear). I can't see how this could have been a normal at-arms-length type of transaction i.e openly advertise property for sale and conduct viewings. Some level of collusion between fraudster and purchaser is one explanation.
AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 02/11/2021 13:01

I've just registered with the Land Registry for alerts, thanks to this thread. MN at its best!

cooroocoocoo · 02/11/2021 12:56

I believe that this scam is only possible for properties that are fully paid/not mortgaged as when there is a mortgage, the owner is the Bank.

So worth keeping a low mortgage on the house, or not telling anyone you have paid off the mortgage!

Ozanj · 02/11/2021 12:55

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

And if you are aware of the fact that you still get to keep the property while the real owner gets paid compensation - well you might be tempted.

It really shouldn't be allowed to be that simple, especially in this case: the buyer needs to be interviewed by the police and forced to explain why they thought the house price was in any way not highly suspicious.

Maybe if you're selling to family or a very close friend, you might give them a hefty discount (although, ironically, the authorities will still ask questions and query suspected stamp duty/other tax avoidance with a significantly below-market value price); but if actually buying from a stranger/mild acquaintance?

If nothing else, I'd be very wary that, even if the seller is the rightful owner, the buyer might be taking huge advantage of somebody with dementia or learning difficulties - or even threatening/gaslighting them - especially as the house never made it to being advertised on the open market.

If a fraudulent purchase doesn’t go through a solicitor buyers can and do lose the properties. This particular purchase went through a solicitor and it is their failings that caused the original owner to lose their property - they will be compensated.
Cattenberg · 02/11/2021 12:51

Sorry, I should have read your post properly, @amillionrosepetals.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 12:50

And if you are aware of the fact that you still get to keep the property while the real owner gets paid compensation - well you might be tempted.

It really shouldn't be allowed to be that simple, especially in this case: the buyer needs to be interviewed by the police and forced to explain why they thought the house price was in any way not highly suspicious.

Maybe if you're selling to family or a very close friend, you might give them a hefty discount (although, ironically, the authorities will still ask questions and query suspected stamp duty/other tax avoidance with a significantly below-market value price); but if actually buying from a stranger/mild acquaintance?

If nothing else, I'd be very wary that, even if the seller is the rightful owner, the buyer might be taking huge advantage of somebody with dementia or learning difficulties - or even threatening/gaslighting them - especially as the house never made it to being advertised on the open market.

Cattenberg · 02/11/2021 12:49

I find it even more difficult to believe that the fraudster conducted viewings without the neighbours noticing - a property at that kind of bargain price would have had people queuing round the block to view it.

Maybe it wasn’t advertised and no estate agent was involved. We don’t even know that the buyer viewed it.

amillionrosepetals · 02/11/2021 12:20

@Korbah

I honestly think that the buyer was involved in the process There’s definitely something very dodgy. Who pays £131k for a house worth about £265k, not auctioned or advertised on Rightmove, rushed through and completed quickly, and doesn’t realise something isn’t right?
My thoughts too. From a picture I've seen of the property it looked like a pavement mid-terrace. I find it difficult to believe that the fraudster changed the locks without the neighbours noticing (neighbours who rang the real owner when they saw the new owner in the property). I find it even more difficult to believe that the fraudster conducted viewings without the neighbours noticing - a property at that kind of bargain price would have had people queuing round the block to view it. And if you are aware of the fact that you still get to keep the property while the real owner gets paid compensation - well you might be tempted.
godmum56 · 02/11/2021 11:35

@DGRossetti

In some ways, I'm surprised this hasn't happened in the past

What makes you think it didn't ?

it has, see my link further up the thread
godmum56 · 02/11/2021 11:33

@Bluntness100

Remember we don’t know the full story and it could be the owner is actually the one who commuted the fraud,or more to the story that is known to the public.
It happened to Penny hastings too, see my link.
sausageflowers · 02/11/2021 11:09

@Bluntness100 they could be, but given they're a reverend and they drove down in the middle of the night after a neighbour spotted the lights on in the property it doesn't sound likely!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 11:05

Yet if someone sells a car they are still paying for, the new owner gets it seized back, don't they? How very odd.

My exact thought, too. It's tough for the unsuspecting buyer (assuming they aren't in on it), but surely it's very basic law (and common sense) that you cannot become the owner of something by buying it from somebody who doesn't own it or have any right to sell it to you.

We're currently involved in a house sale and the conveyancing 'journey' is long and drawn out - as I expected - for precisely the reason that lots of checks have to be made to ensure that everybody involved is above board and legally allowed to buy/sell the property.

There are various stages that are so involved that the legitimate person can easily get paranoid and hope that they don't somehow mistakenly 'fail' the checks - like on gameshows, where you can tell that the contestant is 100% certain of quite an obvious answer, but is nevertheless still crossing their fingers and biting their lip.

There was a very good Mitchell & Webb sketch relating to this principle, where a man's bank was trying to tell him that he'd lost his money because he was a victim of 'identity theft'. He countered that his identity hadn't been stolen, because, erm, he still had it. He tenaciously managed to get the bank to admit that they had given away their money to somebody, who had apparently defrauded them by citing this man's name; but that, as he hadn't had any involvement in it, his own money was, of course, still safely in their care, as it had been all along.

Definitely something fishy about paying half the market value of the house, unless it was a crumbling ruin.

JohnRokesmith · 02/11/2021 10:56

@nestoftables

The land registry thing doesn't seem to work for Scotland...
Scotland being a different country to England, has a different registrar (Registers of Scotland). You will have to see what services they offer for protection of property.
Cattenberg · 02/11/2021 10:48

Yes, I hope he didn’t lose anything irreplaceable, such as family letters and photos.

I understand that the property was vacant as the vicar who owned it was working in Wales. Vicars tend to get moved to a new parish every few years and they’re not allowed to retire in the parish they last served (not sure about the previous parishes). So, if a vicar does own a property, it can be a long way from where they work.

I’m surprised the low sale price of the property didn’t ring alarm bells - unless one of the professionals involved was somehow in on the whole scam.

nestoftables · 02/11/2021 10:43

The land registry thing doesn't seem to work for Scotland...

storkstalk · 02/11/2021 10:41

Does the alert service tell you if someone does one of those £3 title register searches? And if it does, does it tell you who the person is?

Leftbutcameback · 02/11/2021 10:35

The whole thing is so so sad, especially having all his stuff thrown away. Presumably the thief just got a house clearance company in to do that. Awful.