Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not realise people can steal houses?

163 replies

radiatorsz · 02/11/2021 07:39

Read this story

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-59069662.amp

wtf!!!

How can this happen and how is it a civil matter? How can you stop this happening?

OP posts:
janj2301 · 03/11/2021 19:27

One article I read said the Land Registry pay out hundreds of thousands of pounds a year compensation due to fraudulant activity, so this isn't as rare as you'd like to think

MrsPinkCock · 03/11/2021 19:15

@user1471447863

It think the one most at fault here is the solicitors handling the sale. They failed to spot a doctored ID photo, that the DOB on the ID didn't match the perceived age of the person in front of them, that the ethnicity of the person didn't fit well with the extremely Anglo Saxon name. Coupled with a significantly below market value sale, without an estate agent involved and not between family. There couldn't have been more red flags could there?
But the ID in this case wasn’t doctored - it was genuine (or rather had been procured unlawfully from the DVLA).

The DOB could have been similar to the client and if the only difference is ethnicity based on a name, that would be relatively difficult to question!

But I agree that the sale price should have been picked up.

Interestingly enough, at our firm our staff are all trained on spotting false ID. We also have a second check system where client details are added and checked for authenticity… but this checks things like whether they are on the electoral roll or a politically exposed person… only if the person came back as being virtually non existent would this trigger further checks. And if the name matches the address, which matches the electoral roll (as it would in this case) it just wouldn’t get flagged up.

It’s down to human error somewhere - conveyancers are incredibly busy so very easy to fool them as they don’t have time to do such thorough checks!

ColinTheKoala · 03/11/2021 18:14

I'll bet, if there were care home costs potentially involved (or even if the owner was simply above a certain age), questions would be asked if a house was sold at less than 50% of the expected market value for the area and type of house

Probably with a house. But not with a retirement flat (though maybe they don't get sold fraudulently because they are a mare to get rid of again). But when my father went into a care home I would have sold his flat significantly undervalue to get rid of it and get the cash for the fees. Not 50% but it was valued at £120 and I would have sold it for £100K. However, he died fairly quickly so in the end I got a bit more.

Lemonsyellow · 03/11/2021 18:03

@tryinghardnottocry

They did use a solicitor. That’s the point of this thread. The house was also sold well below market value.

tryinghardnottocry · 03/11/2021 17:56

The property would not I suspect been offered through an estate agent

I would also suspect that the vendor would not have instructed a solicitor and would have acted for themselves

I would imagine a great deal of pressure was required to get the deal done quickly. The Revd was using the property

I would be surprised if the purchaser obtained a mortgage - takes too long and the property needs to be sold very quickly

I suspect the price of the property was very much below market value

Would love to hear from the purchasers as to what happened

Leftbutcameback · 03/11/2021 17:36

I think the Land Registry alert is particularly useful if it picks up a priority search. This is a search that you carry out when you're conveyancing which effectively stops other entries going onto the title (bit more complicated than that in reality). It effectively gives the purchaser priority to have their transaction registered. If you got noticed of such an entry being made on your title, and you weren't aware of any transaction taking place, that would give you notice to contact the solicitors who have lodged the application together with the land registry and the police that a potentially fraudulent activity was taking place. That's the most useful thing I can think of.

For those above who have mentioned putting a a restriction on the title which means that you would have to effectively consent to the transaction and provide some ID, it's a good idea though I've never heard of it before. The land registry are quite keen to ensure people can can put make applications themselves without having to use a conveyancer and will be helpful if you ask. I did the removal of a restriction last year and it was straightforward or though took nearly a year to be completed because of the backlog.

user1471447863 · 03/11/2021 16:18

It think the one most at fault here is the solicitors handling the sale.
They failed to spot a doctored ID photo, that the DOB on the ID didn't match the perceived age of the person in front of them, that the ethnicity of the person didn't fit well with the extremely Anglo Saxon name. Coupled with a significantly below market value sale, without an estate agent involved and not between family.
There couldn't have been more red flags could there?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 03/11/2021 10:06

Unfortunately the whole banking system is still pathetically useless at actually following where money goes so scammers still get away with their money.

Mad, isn't it? The banks will successfully pick up on and grill you if you have a weekly takeaway habit and are applying for a remortgage that will cost you less than the existing one you've constantly paid on time for years, but something like this can happen - with so many stages of checks somehow passed - and the crooks get clean away with it.

That large amount of money passed through the system electronically, so how can they possibly not know where it went? It's not even like you could launder it across in lots of small, unremarkable amounts, as it's the single lump sum conveyed across as payment for a property.

I can only assume that this bank doesn't actually understand what identity theft is - and as the fraudster has ticked their boxes to 'prove' who he supposedly is, as far as they're concerned, he IS Rev Hall, all sorted, case closed. I'd be very interested to see if they'd wash their hands of the matter so quickly if it had been their CEO who was the victim....

user1471447863 · 02/11/2021 22:41

Ultimately the sale money was paid into a bank account (probably the one the fraudsters set up as soon as they got the faked real I'd), but that money has to be transferred out so that it can ultimately be used, which is where you think the whole thing would come unstuck. Unfortunately the whole banking system is still pathetically useless at actually following where money goes so scammers still get away with their money.
Having had experience of previous owners not updating contact addresses with banks they owe money to (and paying so little towards what they owe that they will never pay it off) it is next to impossible to get a bank to understand that their customer no longer lives here - and oh no they don't have a process for dealing with that, it is no wonder banks don't have a handle on where money goes.

I've too recently sold a house - for the I'd check the solicitors wanted me to send them a photo of me holding my ID next to my face Hmm
I'd kind of hope for these sort of ID checks they'd have access to the DVLA/passport office electronic copy of the photos to catch out this very thing of a doctored real driving license

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 21:32

I've signed up for the alert but not totally sure what you'd then do if there was strange activity?

No, it's not especially obvious to know the next step, really, is it?

Plus, what kind of searches and activity flag up, I wonder - is it just if somebody does a search for your deeds and/or to find out the owner? That could just be somebody hoping to (legally) buy your house from you (or maybe part of your land), if you're in a position to consider it, and wanting to find whom to contact to approach.

Also, what about if you live in a house of great historical importance or particular local interest, and lots of history buffs or genealogists are looking for what is, after all, a public document - just for innocent research purposes? Would it alert you every time this happened?

Weredone · 02/11/2021 21:23

This happened to a family friend of ours with a house worth over 2 million. Except they were the ones who bought the house that had been stolen by someone fraudulently pretending to be the owner. The court case took years and they’ve only just been reimbursed their money.

Longdistance · 02/11/2021 21:16

@Boomquiffa thanks for the link. I’ve added a few properties to the list, mine and my immediate family who don’t use the internet.

Flubbah · 02/11/2021 17:23

Ok so the original homeowner gets compensation... but that doesn’t compensate him for all his personal property and sentimental items that the scammer has binned when they cleared the house. It also ignores the fact that people have sentimental attachment to houses. I know my parents would be devastated to lose our family home, and so would I because I grew up there and intend to move back there with my DC if/when I inherit it.

Sexnotgender · 02/11/2021 16:26

@AshGirl

I work in the property sector and this is more common than you think. The fraudsters are very organised and sophisticated. Land Registry have put a lot of measures in place to try to combat frauds but if you have a property which is empty or let out, is mortgage free and relatively valuable you should absolutely sign up for the Land Registry alerts as soon as possible.
I’ve worked in mortgage fraud for a big bank. It’s fascinating!
HotChoc10 · 02/11/2021 16:23

I've signed up for the alert but not totally sure what you'd then do if there was strange activity?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 16:23

Or if you are older you could do an equity release scheme. A proportion of your house will then belong to the equity release company.

That would lead to far fewer tears than a percentage-based charity bequest, which I most certainly wouldn't recommend. I doubt you'd find an ER company willing to lend you a tenner, just for admin purposes, though!

foxy86 · 02/11/2021 16:04

This is a mistake in the solicitors part and they should be held accountable. I remember selling our house we had to provide ID in person so they could verify us along with picture ID. Unless the ID was fake. Sounds scary. Reminds me of those that leave properties empty for years and come back to find squatters have moved in. If you are leaving your property empty for weeks or months on end make sure you have someone available to keep doing checks to ensure your property is safe.

CounsellorTroi · 02/11/2021 15:27

Or if you are older you could do an equity release scheme. A proportion of your house will then belong to the equity release company.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 15:16

Another rather extreme way to potentially protect yourself against this happening and likely leave you with lots of other irritating and challenging circumstances further down the line would be to leave a small percent of your house's value to a charity in your will. Once you're on their books, they put it on their watch list and would almost certainly monitor any sale and prices thereof.

Obviously, if you haven't died, they don't get to cash in yet - but it's in their explicit interests to track you and your property wealth, once they have that bequest in their balance sheet, and I wouldn't put it past them to get in touch and query it with you; after all, if you sell your current house for less than half its value, you'll have a lot less with which to buy any future houses, including your last one before you die, on which they stand to gain X%.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 15:10

What valuer? I suspect it was bought for cash. No valuer.

A house generally only gets valued by the mortgage lender. If it was bought cash then there wouldn't have been a valuation.

That's a good point, actually; but I would still expect the conveyancing solicitor to ask the question as part of their lengthy due diligence checks. Apart from anything else, they are required to cover the possibility of money laundering - which a house sold to a non-family-member for less than half-price could well be a contender for - and also potential tax implications.

The buyer may have been a FTB, but they still have to verify for stamp duty liability, even if it turns out to be zero that's due. Even as a non-legal person, my instant thought would be to wonder if they were paying half the price through the official channels and the other half in a brown envelope.

What's the point of the lengthy conveyancing process for a property in the first place if rudimentary checks and questions aren't asked? I find it amazing that somebody in the business of conveyancing never even thought to question the price of a house that the man or woman in the street would instantly think seemed suspiciously low.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 02/11/2021 14:59

Who judges if a house is significantly below market value, though? Who judges its value? My house may appear to be worth ££ on first glance, but I know it doesn’t have building regs approval or planning permission for all sorts, plus it has rising damp, ancient electrics etc.

True - there's a decent margin for concerns like that, but surely not 50%? Bearing in mind that the biggest part of a property's value is the bare land itself.

I'll bet, if there were care home costs potentially involved (or even if the owner was simply above a certain age), questions would be asked if a house was sold at less than 50% of the expected market value for the area and type of house.

Ozanj · 02/11/2021 14:39

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

If a fraudulent purchase doesn’t go through a solicitor buyers can and do lose the properties. This particular purchase went through a solicitor and it is their failings that caused the original owner to lose their property - they will be compensated.

Well, in that case, I think the solicitors should be investigated by the police for the reasons that I gave.

If we're going down the road of saying 'compensation due: end of matter', what's to stop any thief/fraudster/act of gross professional misconduct from trying their luck, with no repercussions other than having to pay back what they stole/mishandled on the occasions when they get caught?

Would it not ring a big bell flashing a sign saying 'GUILTY' if they have to pay compensation equivalent to the true value of the house? If they insist that the sale price was a realistic market value - and thus that's all the compo they expect to pay - they're just condemning themselves for their incompetence (assuming they weren't in on the fraud in the first place). Never mind compensation for all of his possessions and priceless sentimental things that can't be replaced, and his own mental suffering from all this.

At the very least, I would expect the valuer and anybody else along the line who should have queried the price and circumstances but didn't to be publicly named and exposed - and ideally struck off.

I also still think that, regardless of the solicitors' shocking misconduct, the buyer should be made to answer why they believed it all above-board and not at all fishy to be paying half the market value for a house that was never marketed. I cannot see how they are a completely innocent party in this.

I know that plenty of people do agree sales without ever marketing the property, but they would invariably get independent professional advise as to a fair price, and only severely reduce this if selling to a family member or similar. Even these 'buy your house instantly' companies, who profit from desperate people, wouldn't expect to pay less than 50% of the value.

If the purchasers are / have colluded with the fraudster and it can be proven as a criminal offence then the original owner will get the property back plus compensation from the solicitor plus compensation from Land Registry.

But as this was published in the media then criminal involvement on the new owners’ part isn’t suspected. So it is probably a fundamental failing with the solicitor and land registry & the original owner will probably get back the true market cost of the property (not the price the new owners paid) + compensation.

I know several people to whom this happened. It’s not that unusual in London where properties are unoccupied (one was even mortgaged) and half got their properties back while the other half received the equiv of 150% of true market value + compensation. In one case my friend got both. So the legal system does take this type of crime seriously.

Lemonsyellow · 02/11/2021 14:03

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel

It certainly does seem like an awful lot of holes lined up, ie a lot of people must have been careless for this to come off. I wonder how many of these people were paid to look the other way. Seems to me you might come up with some scheme like this precisely because you had contacts in say, the DVLA, so you could be certain of some of the stages going smoothly.
I disagree. I think it’s just a mix of laxness and general carelessness alongside a fraud. Many organisations can be just a bit incompetent too. It may be that the fraudster had tried to do the same method with other properties that didn’t come off.
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 02/11/2021 13:43

It certainly does seem like an awful lot of holes lined up, ie a lot of people must have been careless for this to come off. I wonder how many of these people were paid to look the other way. Seems to me you might come up with some scheme like this precisely because you had contacts in say, the DVLA, so you could be certain of some of the stages going smoothly.

NotDavidTennant · 02/11/2021 13:40

At the very least, I would expect the valuer and anybody else along the line who should have queried the price and circumstances but didn't to be publicly named and exposed - and ideally struck off.

A house generally only gets valued by the mortgage lender. If it was bought cash then there wouldn't have been a valuation.