Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wanting someone you love to die - sensitive trigger warning dementia and quality of life

128 replies

BewaretheIckabog · 01/11/2021 19:57

Today my mum has had a bad turn.

She has advanced dementia but we have been relatively lucky so far, she recognised us, was pleased to see us, lost in her own world, wandering physically and mentally but generally comfortable, well-cared for without pain and rarely stressed or agitated.

She is declining and today I said out loud that I would rather her die than her condition deteriorate further and her suffer anguish. I have seen dementia where people become really distressed. There is no hope of cure or improvement.

My AIBU is whether it is unnatural to admit it and to feel guilty for feeling this way. I know many on here say they would support a dignified death but the idea of choosing that for someone other than oneself feels off kilter.

OP posts:
scarpa · 01/11/2021 21:11

You don't need to feel guilty at all. ❤

It's a peculiarly horrible way to experience grief, in tiny bits every single day, sometimes for years before they actually die. Until you've already said goodbye in a hundred different ways - the last time they say your name, the last time they recognise you at all, the last time they even acknowledge another person is in the room.

All that, and then they die, and you have to try and grieve it again when by then, it often feels like relief, so you get a hefty dose of shame with it too.

It's awful. I've done it 3 times now with my grandparents, including being a carer for one of them, (my chances of making it to old age without dementia are, apparently, genetically "yeah, no chance") and it is fucking horrible and exhausting and it can make you so angry and bitter.

My heart goes out to you. Give yourself a break, literally and metaphorically - you're grieving all the time, so be gentle with yourself. And when she isn't here any more, allow yourself to be relieved - for her and for you. That's okay. You don't need permission. Nobody would choose that for someone they love, nor would they choose to witness it themselves, and relief is normal. Flowers

Scarby9 · 01/11/2021 21:10

I have literally just come off the phone from a friend telling me her mum had died.
When I said how sorry I was, she said 'Yes, well...' and we both agreed that her dying peacefully in her sleep was actually a positive as she too had advanced dementia.

My mum also has dementia, although she is still at the stage of knowing she isn't right and being very distressed about it. The only way is downhill from here, and I would give anything for her not to suffer any longer than necessary - to suffer any more at all, to be frank.

YANBU. It is an awful disease I would not wish on anyone.

lollipoprainbow · 01/11/2021 21:10

I strongly believe that if an illness is terminal and there is no hope then why prolong the agony. Why can't we do for our loved ones what we do for our beloved pets when there is no hope.

Kuachui · 01/11/2021 21:09

my husband hopefully has a long way to go but i hope he dies before he ever gets too ill, especially forgetting me or our kids even just a little bit.. it would truly painful.

i also hope i die before i have to suffer with anything

1969angel · 01/11/2021 21:08

YANBU My mum hasn't remembered me for years its a cruel disease you take care and look after yourself xxxx a lot of posters going through the same thing so we are always here to chat xxx

Nidan2Sandan · 01/11/2021 21:06

My beloved Nan has dementia and it's so sad.

She now lives in a world where she is always scared, always paranoid and always angry. It's not her. She lives in fear of the mundane, like using the bathroom. She thinks she is being watched and followed and is permanently frightened.

It's no life. She's well into her 90s with no enjoyment anymore. It feels like punshiment her still being here. She isnt happy. Its heart breaking

lollipoprainbow · 01/11/2021 21:04

My mum also has advanced dementia, she sleeps most of the day and when I go to see her she is barely awake, I don't think she recognises me anymore. I desperately want her to be at peace she doesn't deserve this indignity, she was such a vibrant, strong woman. Now she is tiny and frail. She was my rock, my best friend. You are definitely not being unreasonable.

BewaretheIckabog · 01/11/2021 21:03

Even three months ago whilst she was doubly incontinent and had to be washed and dressed and supervised to eat I would have hesitated to say this. I suspect she would have disagreed.

She still got excited by a piece of cake or a flower in the garden and laughed and smiled.

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 01/11/2021 21:03

@ParkheadParadise

My mum had dementia. It was fucking heartbreaking for her and us. She used to stand at the door of the care home asking everyone who entered if they had seen her mammy. I remember the doctor telling us when my mum was diagnosed Mum has been diagnosed with dementia but it's the family who will live with it If I every take it I'm killing myself, I couldn't have DH and DD watch me lose myself. I fucking hate what dementia did to my mum and family. My mum died peacefully with her 6 children at her bedside with a massive smile on her face after telling us her Mammy was there. It was a relief to know she wasn't suffering anymore.
There was a poor soul in my grandparents home who sometimes used to wander up and down the corridors crying for her mum. It was god awful to see, and no matter what anyone tried to do for her she just wanted her mum. It used to break my heart. Knowing that in her mind at that point she was a child desperate to find her mum was just awful.
Justlovedogs · 01/11/2021 21:03

You are not wrong and don't feel guilty, OP.
I lost both DF (4 years ago) and DM (8 months ago), both had dementia. I am forever grateful that neither lasted long past diagnosis and both still recognised me and both my sisters right up to the last. Like your DM, lost in their own world and space in time but without significant pain or discomfort. It's hard, but there were many times I felt I had put one of my dogs to sleep for less and how unfair it was. Thinking of you Flowers

EbbandTheWanderingHearts · 01/11/2021 21:00

I totally get where you're coming from. I was a care worker for 5 years and the majority of my customers had dementia. I lost count of how many of them asked me to end it for them. Sad It was utterly heart breaking. Watching families being destroyed by dementia, slowly losing the people they loved so dearly. Many of the relatives said it was a relief when they finally died. They grieved while they were still living but knowing they were finally at peace was a relief.

A previous poster is correct that you wouldn't leave a dog to suffer as we expect our elderly to. Surely our elderly deserve dignity and the right to have a peaceful, pain free death?

Thinking of you. Flowers

ItsDinah · 01/11/2021 21:00

In the past, it was common to refer to the death of someone who was suffering a lengthy and terrible illness as "a blessed release".

Thatsplentyjack · 01/11/2021 20:59

Yes, 2 of my grandparents ended up with dementia. My gran couldn't talk for the last 3 years of her life. By the end both couldn't get out of bed, they were completely gone mentally and they were emaciated because they hardly ate and what they did eat their body didn't process properly. I won't go into anymore detail but it was extremely difficult and we all wished their lives had ended a lot sooner than they did. Sorry OP, its so tough.

ParkheadParadise · 01/11/2021 20:58

My mum had dementia. It was fucking heartbreaking for her and us.
She used to stand at the door of the care home asking everyone who entered if they had seen her mammy.
I remember the doctor telling us when my mum was diagnosed
Mum has been diagnosed with dementia but it's the family who will live with it
If I every take it I'm killing myself, I couldn't have DH and DD watch me lose myself.
I fucking hate what dementia did to my mum and family.
My mum died peacefully with her 6 children at her bedside with a massive smile on her face after telling us her Mammy was there.
It was a relief to know she wasn't suffering anymore.

Redyellowblue34 · 01/11/2021 20:58

@AllThingsServeTheBeam - this is my Dad. He has survived Covid probably but has no physical ability, has to be fed; too fragile to be moved out of bed. I don’t think he has mental capacity, and I get really distressed thinking he may have locked in syndrome. I am now reconciled he may be like this for years and it’s writing a chunk of my life off too.

saleorbouy · 01/11/2021 20:54

No you are not wrong at all to think like this. It is extremely hard to see someone you love who was strong and nurtured you to adulthood regress back to an almost infant childlike state in their strength, fragile mental state and dependency to something you no longer recognise as your parent and who doesn't see you as their child.

BettyBooper · 01/11/2021 20:54

My FIL decided on assisted suicide in California when terminally ill with a neurological disease. Although hard, we were able to be together as a family and support him through the last days and hours that were of his choosing, at home with the people he loved. We made his favourite meals, played games and reminisced. It was a time of sadness but there was also lots of laughter and joy. It was calm and he could be in control throughout, while he was still able to do so. I honestly am so thankful that he was able to do this and that we could say goodbye in the way he wanted, with us with him. I look back at the time positively. I am certain that it was how he wanted and I know I would want the same for myself in a similar situation. I think of the alternative, which in his mind was to starve himself to death rather than live with the rapidly and massively debilitating disease, and feel horrendous for those who don't have this choice. Flowers to those going through this. You have my absolute sympathies.

PlantDoctor · 01/11/2021 20:53

It is awful to go through this. Flowers there can be ups and downs with it though, so just because your mum is having a bad day today she might be more like her usual self tomorrow. I completely sympathise though and you are not being unreasonable. It is just so terribly sad. Flowers

MissDollyMix · 01/11/2021 20:50

Yes. I totally understand this. I watched first my darling grandmother, and then my father deteriorate into husks of their former selves. Towards the end their lives were utter misery. I never want anyone to suffer like that.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 01/11/2021 20:50

I understand OP. I feel the same about my dear nan. She hasn't been really awake for 6 years. Completely bed bound. She cannot speak or eat herself. Utterly terrible existence that she would not want.

Summerfun54321 · 01/11/2021 20:49

It’s perfectly natural to want the pain and suffering to stop in someone you love. And if there’s no treatment or cure for their suffering, wishing them a peaceful end is all you can do. Flowers

PermanentTemporary · 01/11/2021 20:49

My mum isn't suffering exactly - no pain, still knows people, still likes food and chats - but most things she enjoys in life have gone forever, there is no chance of her recovering. Of course I want her life to be over. Why on earth would I want anything else? I find it completely bizarre when people insist that those they love should lose every single tiny scrap of meaningful life before anyone can consider whether active treatment is really in their best interests. It would have been better if she'd died 3 years ago.

RiderGirl · 01/11/2021 20:48

Oh OP. I work in the NHS and saw patients again and again with dementia (among other illnesses - late stage cancers etc etc) in their final stages and it was heartbreaking for their families to watch them suffer.

I say this loud and I say it clear and people may not agree, but you wouldn't do it to your dog. We've got it all wrong and we are in a position to give our beloved pets a dignified and painless end when they've had enough and there's no coming back, however our beloved family members aren't afforded the relief of an "early" death even when it's plain to see they are suffering. It is grim. I will welcome a change in assisted dying laws, and I'm sure they will come.

FlowersFlowersFlowers for you and for your lovely mum.

Bluebird797 · 01/11/2021 20:48

My grandfather had vascular dementia and both my mother and I said the same thing many times.
Dementia is beyond horrid. You grieve for the person they were when they're still alive.
Sending you lots of love Op

BewaretheIckabog · 01/11/2021 20:46

@Gumbo Sorry for your loss.

My dad passed two years’s ago - he had been active but severely disabled for 50 years. Despite his substantial physical disabilities and even his loss of independence I hoped he would live.

I mourned the mum I had known when my dad passed. She wasn’t well enough to understand (small blessing as she never really had to deal with losing him).

Dementia is horrible and I don’t want her to be sad or distressed.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread