Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the obsession with ‘hot meals’?

191 replies

LastToBePicked · 01/11/2021 19:38

As in “kids need to have a hot meal”, “They haven’t had a hot meal today” etc

Is it just short-hand for a more substantial meal or do people think there is some magic about food being hot that makes it more nutritious?

Is, for instance, a tuna pasta bake superior to a tuna sandwich? Or sausage and mash better than ham salad?

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 01/11/2021 20:30

In general I just prefer hot food. I have toast and coffee every morning. I prefer a toasties/panini/something cooked to a sandwich. I'm not a fan of slabs unless it's a side salad. Unless it's from the roll shop in the next town, they are generally boring as fuck bit the salads from the roll shop must be at lease 800 calories so not really that healthy.

LessthanJurassicPark · 01/11/2021 20:29

But salads are cold, raw and delicious.

OP you are right. I’ve never thought about it. I don’t really like hot food but always feel like I should have it.

You may have changed my life Grin

Justgettingbye · 01/11/2021 20:29

I don't get it either. Mine has school dinners because she is in reception and it's free and I cba to add another task in the morning of making her a packed lunch but I would still give her a hot dinner in the evening if she wanted it. But tbh she's happy with the dreaded beige foods crackers, toast, bagels, fruit and yoghurt

OhWhyNot · 01/11/2021 20:28

I can’t think of any cold meals that are as satisfying when the weather is cold

I love cold lasagne but with hot chips on the side

In really hot countries you still often have a hot meal often twice a day (I’ve struggled with this)

Pigeontown · 01/11/2021 20:28

If you are cold and tired hot food just makes you feel better. I'm sure there is science behind that. In the past lots of men (and women) did very manual jobs and homes had no central heating. If you work physically hard you crave substantial food. Builder's Breakfast? Cold food doesn't really fit into that. Also the range of food most children and in fact most adults will eat increases when hot cooked food is added to list. So very few children and adults will eat raw veg like brocoli or cauliflower but will eat it cooked. Food ranges/variety didn't used to be as great. Cold food was pretty limited in 70s/80s even 90s. My ds's range is not huge and would be reduced further if hot food not regularly in that. Both my dc don't like breakfast cereal and are lukewarm about sandwiches, as am I. We are also vegetarian. We often have hot all 3 meals. How hard is eggs on toast, soup or microwaved left overs for lunch and a basic hot dinner with carbs. Older people living on own get malnourished and do suffer without hot meals so there must be evidence. Im sure a quick Google would find it.
If you dont like hot food then of course you can do what you want. No one will die if they don't have a hot meal on any given day. Although when young I knew a couple of colleagues get malnourished from not eating properly living the young life and then needing various injections like B12 and iron. I know my dc would moan a lot if I didn't make substantial meals for them. I'll be surprised if you are British and don't understand how we crave hot meals on cold days. And LOTS of cuppas.

NoYOUbekind · 01/11/2021 20:27

There's lots of cultural and anthropological stuff wrapped up in 'a hot meal' though.

Humans only became successful as humans when we learned to harness fire to cook food. Before then it was incredibly hard to get enough calories to survive and all our time was spent in gathering those categories. We were only able to turn our collective attention to other things when we were able to access protein through cooking raw food.

Note too that almost all the food you mention was hot once: tuna pasta salad has been cooked then reassembled. Bread is baked. Ham in a sandwich has been cooked and cured. So most of your cold food was hot once.

Then there's things like the middle class ideal of the mother at home producing the delicious home cooked meal. Not being able to cook food because you don't have access to an oven or can't afford fuel is a huge marker for poverty so people idealise 'hot' over cold.

It's complex stuff.

speakout · 01/11/2021 20:27

A ham sandwich is not particularly healthy anyway- it will be 75% bread, ham ( a bad protein source) a tiny bit of salad or whatever.

speakout · 01/11/2021 20:25

I think you can pack a great deal more nutrition into a cooked meal rather than a sandwich.

A stew or casserole is likely to contain a bigger variety of trace mineral, micronutrients etc.
Will often contain root veg, garlic olive oil, spices, tomato, perhaps pulses and usually served with a bigger helping of veg.
Even my bolognese will contain upwards of 10 ingredients, curry even more.
I think a hot home cooked meal has more nutrition, is more comforting and filling on a cold day.

Snowisfallinghere · 01/11/2021 20:24

It's not about the temperature of the food per se, but hot meals are generally more likely to be varied and nutritious. Whereas for most people, a cold meal is most likely some variation of a sandwich.

Summerfun54321 · 01/11/2021 20:24

I expect before central heating a hot meal would have meant a lot more to us than it does now when we have many ways to keep warm. I’ve done a lot of camping and hiking for long periods and a hot meal is more morale boosting than nutritious.

maddiemookins16mum · 01/11/2021 20:23

I think it means a full, substantial meal (most likely cooked, so therefore hot) as opposed to a ham and coleslaw wrap with a munch bunch yoghurt.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 01/11/2021 20:22

@baroqueandblue

It’s a plot to keep us women in the kitchen.

Yes, like all dads never cook for their kids Hmm

The phrase "a hot meal", perhaps depending on your background, can imply that care and time has gone into preparing a decent meal with overtones of 'warmth' for those you're cooking for.

Or those of us who are single don't know how to cook for themselves.
5thnonblonde · 01/11/2021 20:20

Wtaf is the tuna obsession on this thread?!!

SuperbFoolish · 01/11/2021 20:19

Because creating a nutritious meal from unprocessed ingredients is easier when cooking a hot meal. Sandwiches tend to be full of processed stuff. Also a hot meal makes you feel good.

limitedperiodonly · 01/11/2021 20:19

@LastToBePicked do you really not understand? But it's true I'd rather have a tuna sandwich than a tuna pasta bake. I eat almost anything but would rather go to bed hungry than face warmed up tinned tuna with melted cheese.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/11/2021 20:18

Don’t much mind in summer but a hot meal is a lot more comforting at the end of a cold, wet, dark afternoon than a tuna sandwich, felt much more so when I was a child.

Sunflowerfieldsofgold · 01/11/2021 20:18

@Roselilly36

I wouldn’t say it’s an obsession Op, but when it’s cold a hot meal is much nicer than a cold salad/meal IMHO.
I never eat cold food or have cold drinks in the winter months. Lovely warm soup,bakes, casserole is so much nicer than cold sandwiches and salads-meh
TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 01/11/2021 20:18

Golly gosh, Look at me!
I always thought it related to ensuring that there was a phall curry waiting for them when they got home from school!
🤭

DroopyClematis · 01/11/2021 20:17

As long as your child gets all of their nutrients then it doesn't matter.

Give them raw vegetables, cheese , and a raw potato. (Actually don't!!!)
Many raw veg are unpalatable and can't be absorbed by the body, either physically or nutritionally.
A pork chop is better than ham ( which is mechanically reclaimed bits of cured pork , mashed together.)
But no rice, pasta or potato is quite limiting.

So yeah, a cheese and lettuce sandwich is perfect! 🤔

baroqueandblue · 01/11/2021 20:17

@seventyminutes kind of cross-posted, but you said it much better than I did!

Opalfeet · 01/11/2021 20:17

Because a hot meal is usually more nutritious with more variety and lots of hot cookedveggies

LividLaVidaLoca · 01/11/2021 20:16

Does my tits in. It’s bizarre.

DH can’t cope if he eats a hot lunch and gets all squinchy about dinner. But if we’re having a cold dinner for whatever reason he’d want a hot lunch, which is complicated because lunch for him is a synonym for “sad cheese sandwich”.

baroqueandblue · 01/11/2021 20:15

It’s a plot to keep us women in the kitchen.

Yes, like all dads never cook for their kids Hmm

The phrase "a hot meal", perhaps depending on your background, can imply that care and time has gone into preparing a decent meal with overtones of 'warmth' for those you're cooking for.

seventyminutes · 01/11/2021 20:14

I don't know if this is anything to go on but I feel it's less about the nutritional value and more of the comfort/looking after yourself.

I remember someone once saying to treat yourself the way you would a friend and that included meals - we are on the go a lot and if you think about how often we rush our breakfasts or skip them, lunch is always something thrown together or a premise sandwich often eaten in a canteen/office desk.

I was rushing around so often at night too that I forgot to switch off and would either eat standing up or pick at whatever I was cooking for my own child. Would I have made a friend eat stood over a kitchen counter? No I would have served something warm, with love and made time for it. Maybe pour a nice drink and really take the effort to enjoy the meal.

Meal times go back a very very long way and it has been a time of getting together and sharing, think the Christmas and thanksgiving meal traditions as well as banquets for the upper class and the royal feasts you read of in history documents and fairy tales. I don't feel that having something cold is less nutritious like a salad or a sandwich myself but do feel there is something in the concept of a hot nutritious meal served with love Smile

LastToBePicked · 01/11/2021 20:14

I totally appreciate hot food is often tastier/nicer, especially going into winter (in fact one of my main bugbears is my family faffing around while their hot dinner goes cold).

What I was getting at was the sense of “hot meal = good, cold meal = bad” that I often hear around. Lots of “Johnny just has toast of tea because he has a hot meal at school”. When the hot meal was probably jacket potato and cheese, or pizza, or fish fingers and chips.

OP posts: