Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you live rurally....do you enjoy it?

251 replies

PottererCrouch · 01/11/2021 12:47

As title really, I live rurally and really enjoy it, but I was at a party on Saturday night and got talking to a friend of the host, they asked where I live and when I said where it was, pretty much gasped and said 'good lord, however do you cope living there? It's the middle of nowhere, no, I couldn't be doing with that. I always wonder why people want to live rurally, just doesn't appeal at all to me. Do you actually enjoy it?!'

They were very drunk but I couldn't help but feel a bit offended Hmm for a start, it IS a small village (300 houses) but it does have a pub and primary school and we're only 6 miles to the nearest town so not completely 'isolated.'

I see a lot of people on here warning others off living rurally as it isn't good for kids and they regret it etc.

If you live rurally, do you enjoy it and why?

OP posts:
LittleDandelionClock · 02/11/2021 22:23

@PottererCrouch

The 'I couldn't be doing with that' brigade are jealous. All my life growing up in a big Midlands town, full of council estates, industrial estates, and shopping centres, and very little green space, or nice walks etc, I dreamed of living in the countryside. My whole life I dreamed of it.

Me and DH used to drive to other towns and cities, and passed through a few villages on the way, and could see signs on the B road we were on, saying 'this village 2 miles' and 'that village 1.5 miles. And I used to think 'awww, how lovely it would be to live up there..' Same when driving through mid/north Wales too. I thought 'aww how nice would it be to live in a little hamlet/village up here...'

I used to go for drives with my dad too when I was in my early teens, and we would go for picnics to Church Stretton, Ludlow, and places in Herefordshire, Shropshire, and mid Wales, and I LONGED to live somewhere like that.

DD left home 9 years ago (for uni) and me and DH (who had always lived in the middle of town, or in the suburbs since we started living together) decided to take the plunge, and sold our 3 bed 1980s house, and bought a little 3 bed cottage (with a BIG garden,) in a small village, 20 miles away miles. 2 miles from the nearest B road, and 4 miles from a little market town. Nearest city is about 12 miles.

Yeah we have to drive everywhere, but we had to do that quite a bit when we lived in a suburb of a town. DD's senior school and college were 3 miles, and 8 miles away, and took her 1 hour, and 1 hour and three quarters to get to by bus. So we drove her there and picked her up. We were able to, and it saved her a LOT of time, as the trips were 8 minutes and 15 minutes by car.

DH had to drive to work too, as he worked 10 miles away and worked funny shifts. Half the time he could not get there by public transport. And if we needed to go to hospital or any specialists - they were an hour to an hour and a half by bus, but 15-20 minutes drive. So a car was an absolute must.

Some appointments and things we had to do - including stuff with DD after school and at weekends, and things we had to do for our parents (if they needed taking somewhere,) needed a car, as public transport was simply not an option.

So, we need a car now? No biggie as we have pretty much always needed one!

As pps have said, I (and DH) absolutely LOVE it here, and will never EVER move. 5 minutes walk to woodlands,10 minutes walk to the canal, 15 minutes walk to the river, and multiple rolling fields and meadows. Some fields belong to farmers, but they let people walk around the edges, and they have little stiles to climb over, to enable you to go from one field to another, and through the woodland, and around the little meres and waterways...

The village has a strong community spirit too, a lovely Church, a little parish hall, a little primary school with 40-ish children, a tiny village shop, open 5 hours a day, (9am til 12 midday, then 1pm til 3pm,) and a pub where they have pub-quiz nights every week, and darts and a pool table, and a jukebox, and a little bowling green at the back of the parish hall!

Our cottage is in a little road with 14 other properties, all spaced quite far apart, and the neighbours are lovely. Everywhere me and DH and DD ever lived before (council estate/suburb/flat in a private block,) most people were OK, but a few were dickheads. Either nuisance neighbours or just aloof and rude. Even the ones who were OK however, kept themselves to themselves, and rarely spoke. There was NO community.

Out here, it's a different mindset and mentality. No-one tries to outdo anyone, no-one cares if they drive an old car, people wear 'scruffs' about the village and don't dress up, and no-one judges people. The suburbs were awful for this, with some awful people... Trying to keep up with the Joness, and constantly bitching and gossiping.

I love it so much here, and feel blessed every day I am here. There's not a single sound at night, not a car, or a person's voice, or loud music, or yobbos, or anything. Just a few distant sheep/cow sounds and a distant cockerel at around 7am. They don't wake you, but you hear them if you're already awake IYSWIM.

I would definitely recommend living rural/in a village. As I said, I will never EVER live anywhere but a village as long as I live.

MrsDThomas · 02/11/2021 22:20

Rural here. Next village a mile away. No direct neighbours, no pub, no shop, no school. Woodland, quarries, lakes, and not to far from the beach as i can see it from the kitchen window. Very unique place to be with all that.

I could never live in a town. Going to tesco is enough for me.

SirB0bby · 02/11/2021 22:17

@GoodnightGrandma

I do, but when my kids became teenagers they hated it.
Same here.
DarlingFell · 02/11/2021 22:00

Love rurally and BLOODY LOVE IT!

The peace and quiet, the beauty, even on a rainy, grey day, the countryside is stunning. I lived in Central London for years and always felt a bit glum when it rained, urban environments are very drab in dreary weather. Here, I don't care, we just get our wet weather gear out and go walking, its invigorating, uplifting, food for the soul. In London when it rained, we would have stayed in feeling fed up.

We aren't meant to live in urban environments. Modern human has been on earth for some 300,000 years living among nature, while the first cities were built around 8,000 years ago, a minute amount of time comparatively. This is why city dwellers often feel so relaxed when they holiday in a bucolic environment. They are back to where nature intended them to exist.

I'm 8 miles from our nearest town but would happily live somewhere much more remote. Being surrounded by beauty and wildlife inspires me and enriches my life so so much.

TheNinny · 02/11/2021 21:18

I’m 7 miles to my nearest pint of milk. In a village of less than 200 people. I love the beauty and scenery. I’m a 40 min drive to work and nursery though. There is a village primary school but too small I think. Probably 5 children in the entire school. There is a larger village school nearby where DD could go to but there is no wrap around care. So likely I’ll drive her in to town where I work to attend there. She already attends nursery there. I’m near the coast and a 2 miles from nature reserve. I liked it better here before having DD and now things are a bit annoying in terms of driving. But we are near family who help with childcare and half way between two bigger towns of the area which means best of both worlds when it comes to jobs/activities etc. I miss the bustle of a city but when I lived in one all I wanted was to live rurally 😂

OrangeBananaFish · 02/11/2021 21:05

About 10 years ago I made a post on MN about living in the countryside and what it was like as we were considering moving from the edge (20 min walk) of a city to a very small village.

I was told that it was perfect and I'll never look back. Or wonder why we didn't do it sooner. All I can say now is that those comments were right.

I asked on MN because I knew I'd get the truth. I knew I'd be told about the good and the bad. OK so its a faff to pop out for a pint of milk and do I really want to drag myself out for an hour just because I'm craving some chocolate? Obviously not. Yes I am aware that teenagers (or at least NT ones - DS is autistic so has no social life and he's happy that way, while DD1 is always out) need lifts, but we said that we'd be fine with that.

However, we're not all that rural. Our village has a little over 100 houses. We now have a shop (didn't when we first moved), we have a post office on a Monday in the village hall and 3 buses a day (2 in one direction, 1 in the other). The GP is 2.5 miles away in another equally small village and the nearest pub is a mile away in a different village. Oh and we have half a school (It joined up with another and pre-school and reception are in our village, years 1-6 get bussed to the other school, but when we moved it was reception to year 6 with 25 children in the whole school.

I love it here. Going for a run on a Sunday and hearing a tractor in the distance. Saying morning to the man walking his dog even though neither of you have any idea who each other are. The views are amazing too (even though it did get a bit boring after running the same few routes during lockdown)

Flutteringbyagain · 02/11/2021 20:46

I think what some people would class as rural or isolated, others certainly wouldn't! I couldn't live too far from some sort of civilisation I.e more than 6/7 miles from a small town.

I lived rurally for 25 years (adulthood) and most isolated was a house on a forest track, 7 miles from town! DC were tiny then. That was quite tough but I loved the peace and quiet. A 5 mile drive to a baby group was a busy day!

Moved around a bit since then but stayed rural. Only had neighbours once (village of 10 houses) and hated it but was good for DC growing up. Now no neighbours again (yay), but only 1 mile from biggish town. For me personally I'd prefer to be further from civilisation (3-4 miles from town ish) but DC are teens and so better for them being closer.

ChristmasCrafter · 02/11/2021 20:45

I live rurally and love it. 1 mile from the closest village and 3 miles from the closest shop. I love the space and how quiet it is. Our road is so quiet, it is not uncommon to have rabbits, birds and deer just chilling out spring sun on the road outside my house.
I spent the first decade of my life in central London and I do remember living there but I much prefer it in the countryside. I spent my teen years cycling to the closest village to meet up with friends and working in the local pub as a waitress which doubled up as a good social life.
The only downside where I live is being tied to the car to get anywhere but I can live with that.
I now have a dd myself and I have no intention of ever moving closer to anybody else.

MsTSwift · 02/11/2021 20:35

Over my dead body would my 13 year old be quad biking in the dark to her friends house. That’s really a thing? Sounds super dangerous. Every school year where I lived we lost someone to a car accident - 17 year olds driving parents powerful cars down country lanes they feel familiar with is literally a recipe for disaster.

Stompythedinosaur · 02/11/2021 18:03

I suppose there are advantages and disadvantages everywhere. My dc can't get to a coffee shop, but they hang out with their friends daily (admittedly at our house or theirs, or at the local busy youth club).

The loss of coffee shop access can be measured against the massive freedom of being somewhere very safe, and the free access to quad bikes, horse riding etc.

I think mn can be a bit unfair about families who live rurally - failing to meet your dc's needs is cruel anywhere, but rural families aren't necessarily failing to meet teens needs.

AlphabetAerobics · 02/11/2021 17:55

The teens round here have quad bikes to travel around.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 02/11/2021 17:37

@MsTSwift

My girls can so easily hang out with pals after school or at the weekend with zero impact on us. Not just worthy activities but coffee shop after school etc. I hated bring a rural teen utterly reliant on whims of parent as to whether they could be arsed to drive you.
Exactly what I babbled on for multiple paragraphs, trying to say, @MsTSwift - only clear and succinct.
MsTSwift · 02/11/2021 17:36

My girls can so easily hang out with pals after school or at the weekend with zero impact on us. Not just worthy activities but coffee shop after school etc. I hated bring a rural teen utterly reliant on whims of parent as to whether they could be arsed to drive you.

Champagneforeveryone · 02/11/2021 17:34

We live rurally and love it, you soon get used to not running out of milk etc!

It's been tough once DS was a teen and needed the taxi of mum and dad to get about, though lockdown curtailed that greatly and he's passed his driving test now so all is good.

We are looking to move in the new year and will ideally move slightly less rurally as I don't want to move again ever and extreme rural living is not great for the elderly when things start to drop off go wrong.

julieca · 02/11/2021 17:22

The problem with that is there are relatively few teenagers to socialise with. It is fine if you are the kind of teen who easily makes friends. It is tough if you don't and none of the small group of local teenagers you really get on with.

Stompythedinosaur · 02/11/2021 17:19

@MsTSwift

I think unless you have very resilient independent teens who aren’t bothered about socialising or who love country pursuits living very remotely with teens isn’t fair.
Surely this depends a bit on your situation?

Totally isolated with parents not willing or able to facilitate a social life or activities is not great.

We are very rural, but there are 40 houses in the valley, and a group of similar age dc who get on. I spend half my life driving dc to activities - horse riding, cheerleading, music lessons, youth club, theatre group. Yes, they probably spent longer in a car than other dc because of the distances involved, but I don't think they are hugely missing out.

Tbh the fact that most of their friends live on farms leads to having lots of space for get together, the dc both have excellent social lives.

Shmithecat2 · 02/11/2021 17:18

@MsTSwift

I think unless you have very resilient independent teens who aren’t bothered about socialising or who love country pursuits living very remotely with teens isn’t fair.
It's only 'unfair' if you're not prepared for the logistics of it all. Dh and I know we'll be taxi of mum and dad for the next 10/11 years, and we're quite prepared for that.
MsTSwift · 02/11/2021 14:28

I think unless you have very resilient independent teens who aren’t bothered about socialising or who love country pursuits living very remotely with teens isn’t fair.

Walkingwounded · 02/11/2021 12:54

As pps have said, it's great until the teen years.

Lived on a really isolated rural farm for 13 years. DCs born there. Hard work but nice until they were about 12 - and then they started getting left out socially because so much of teen life is organised at the last minute ('meet you at the shops in 10 mins') and if you can't come, you start to get isolated.

I moved out - split not caused by location - and moved to the town where they go to school. Both DCs much much happier, good friends, have a social life etc. I like being near amenities too.

Chasingaftermidnight · 02/11/2021 12:49

I don’t live rurally (although I live on the rural edge of a town and can walk to open countryside in 5 minutes). I’ve always dreamt of living rurally.

That said, I think when people talk about living rurally they mean a big spectrum of different things. A village with a pub and a school and 6 miles to the nearest town sounds lovely to me but it doesn’t sound that rural really. I’m not sure if I’d like being completely in the middle of nowhere with no neighbours at all and a long drive to the nearest shops/GPs/hospital/etc.

TeaSoakedDisasterMagnet · 02/11/2021 12:41

@StaplesCorner

Also does anyone else find it claustrophobic at night? Like a blanket of darkness; or do I sound like I’ve been on the gin before lunch? 🤔
I found it the other way round. Living in the city felt claustrophobic, there was noise and mess and other people there just all the time, there was no getting away from it. We don’t live really rurally now, but on the rural edge of a town and it’s heaven.
Megan2018 · 02/11/2021 12:40

I live in a small rural hamlet, less than 100 houses. No pub, no shop, no facilities really. It’s beautiful, quiet and peaceful.
I have lived in towns and cities before including London and I loathe it. I like my horse and my hens and fresh air. I don’t need anything else.

I do work in a city twice a week and we have 2 small market towns within 15 mins or so for shops.
I’d love to get takeaways delivered but it’s probably good that I can’t!

thebakeoffwasntasgoodthisyear · 02/11/2021 12:33

YANBU to be annoyed at the comments though - it sounded like she was being unpleasant about your choices. I know many people who love living in the countryside, including 2 of my siblings and their children.

thebakeoffwasntasgoodthisyear · 02/11/2021 12:26

I lived rurally until 3 years ago - DH loved it due to the scenery and peacefulness, but I hated it - nearest bus stop was 2 miles away, our road was too dangerous to go for a walk, and we had to drive everywhere, even for a pint of milk as we lived outside the village. My DC loved it until the teen years - then hated it due to a lack of friends nearby and lack of independence eg relying on me for lifts.

We live 1.5 miles from our nearest city centre now and it suits us better. We can walk into town, and we also live 10 minutes walk from various parks, a small forest and the towpath. I attend various baby groups as I have young DC as well, and I honestly find the mums a lot friendlier in our city. I realise the latter was maybe just down to luck though.

Mintine · 02/11/2021 12:10

I don’t think it was rude either, I certainly wouldn’t have been offended.
It sounds great where you live, but I do like to be able to walk everywhere, hate driving, so it wouldn’t suit me I don’t think